14 ms·
To be fair, multi selection is a disaster on any platform. It is a hard concept that isn't completely solved by any of the standard GUI widgets.
by marcosdumay 5y ago
To be fair, multi selection is a disaster on any platform.
It is a hard concept that isn't completely solved by any of the standard GUI widgets.
- egeozcan 5y agoThere are problems even with the single selection (searching for an option in mobile, consistent contrast, copying selected value etc.). Depending on the application, sometimes to fix such problems, you need to reimplement the component in js or you start won't fix'ing tickets. So articles like this really underestimate the problems with the existing controls and the lack of some.
- cabalamat 5y agoI would probably use a series of checkboxes for the same effect.
- com2kid 5y agoHilariously, lots of good implementations on mobile. Long tap to start, checkbox next to each item that is then selected. Confirm button when done selecting.
- Shared404 5y agoI actually really dislike this. I find that I often have half second hangups due to not remembering if in select mode or not. Much prefer the "Hold shift/ctrl" model used often in file managers.
- kreetx 5y agoParent is talking about mobile. And on Android it's working rather well I'd say. The only downside I see is that selecting longer spans (shift click) is not possible.
- Shared404 5y agoIn the context of the parents comment I thought they were comparing that model to others where multi selct exists. I don't think there is a much better model on mobile, except possibly adding a button to each item to select a longer span.
- com2kid 5y agoBrowser requires very fine degree of dexterity, and has 0 discoverability. Mobile ones often have a "start multi-select" button in the UI. Neither is an amazing experience, but IMHO the mobile one is somewhat better.
- spiralx 5y agoThere are Android apps where you can select two items in a list and then there's a button that selects all of the items between them, which is equivalent to a shift-click.
- nine_k 5y agoA separate multi-select control is just a bad idea from 1990s; it should be disused and forgotten. The proper way is a list of checkboxes. Checkboxes are easy to recognize, easy to style, and easy to navigate and operate.
- crooked-v 5y agoNow make that a set of 200 checkboxes and see how practical it is compared to one combobox-style multi-select input.
- nine_k 5y ago200 checkboxes make about as much sense as a 200-item dropdown. Neither is manageable. The multi-select dropdown is additionally hard to check for the selections made. An input box with pill-style auto-completion (see e.g. the tags control on Stackoverflow) would be a reasonable alternative. Another, larger alternative is the typical two-lists control, with selected items moved from the source list to the target list; this idiom was widely used in Windows since 1990s. It's not mobile-friendly though.
- egeozcan 5y ago> 200 checkboxes make about as much sense as a 200-item dropdown. Neither is manageable. Multi-select is okay there, apart from the problems I mentioned above: https://jsfiddle.net/z0Ltxh47/2/ https://jsfiddle.net/z0Ltxh47/2/ . I can navigate to i19 with a few key strokes. Only if it were then possible to easily select a1... > An input box with pill-style auto-completion (see e.g. the tags control on Stackoverflow) would be a reasonable alternative And we are back at implementing our custom controls again.
- nine_k 5y ago> And we are back at implementing our custom controls again. Sadly, yes. Not everything was anticipated at the times of Netscape 2. HTML5 added a number of native controls, like video players and calendars. I wish a better "native" multi-select alternative surfaced, too. OTOH I suppose that browsers are going to blur the line between "native" controls and web components and such.
- galaxyLogic 5y agoMulti-select is what you have in File Explorer. You can select multiple files and folders for copying or deletion or moving. It is not a disaster
- ehnto 5y agoThe most robust solution is to individually toggle selected state on each item, and don't unselect all on a new click. Like a checkbox. Click once for selected, once to unselect, don't unselect all on any click. A multi-select drop down is just solving the problem of a checkbox list being too long, or not what the designer wants it to look like. The most clear UI for this input type is a set of checkboxes in my opinion. Same for a single item select and radio buttons. Drop downs have a lot of caveats, and unique compositions in the wild, so many of them are inaccesible and it's essentially just because someone wanted it to look pretty. I think that is bad software.