5 ms·
West Virginia wants to ban sending OTA updates to customer cars
- josephcsible 5y agoTo be clear, this has nothing to do with security or any other legitimate concern. The point of it is to give dealers more business and to harm automakers that don't have dealers.
- hulitu 5y agoIt has to do with security. OTA are an atacker's wet dream. And the potential to do harm is big. It's not that cars run obscure OSs. With the ARMification of devices you have a global platform opened to global threats.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoAn Oklahoma state rep is currently pushing to ban Tesla from the state (although Tesla could move to tribal lands to avoid such actions if necessary) through House Bill 3994 [1]. They also manage family owned legacy automaker dealerships (per LinkedIn [2]). Lots of bad faith efforts going to occur on the path to clean mobility due to entrenched interests. [1] https://engage.tesla.com/articles/1134-oklahoma-oppose-hb-3994 https://engage.tesla.com/articles/1134-oklahoma-oppose-hb-39... [2] https://i.imgur.com/oGCg1Yv.jpg https://i.imgur.com/oGCg1Yv.jpg
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwaway894345 5y agoSimilarly, Biden is trying to pass EV subsidies for non-Tesla auto manufacturers, and then there was the amusing couple of weeks where he would praise GM and Ford (but not Tesla) for paving the way in EV (Tesla sold 350K EVs in the US while GM and Ford collectively sold fewer than 60K). Moreover, it feels like there's been a surge in anti-Tesla automotive reporting recently (e.g., Roadshow omitting any Tesla cars from its 2022 list of best EVs lol). One definitely gets the impression that the legacy auto industry is scared shitless and spending out its ass on politicians and media.
- KerrAvon 5y agoI dunno about the Biden admin’s attitude toward Tesla, but some of the other stuff is Tesla reaping what it sows by not having a press office. There’s a reason corporations have press offices! If you don’t engage with the media on their terms, you’re at their mercy. In this sense, the continuous attacks by the Tesla stan army are actually not helpful to Tesla’s long term cause.
- josephcsible 5y agoThat sounds an awful lot like saying a business destroyed by the Mafia reaped what it sowed for refusing to pay them for "protection".
- KerrAvon 5y agoIf I’m an auto journalist and can’t get a press car, and all of the other manufacturers from Rolls Royce and Porsche on down give me press cars, I’m gonna have some natural bias. This is human nature, not racketeering.
- ehvatum 5y agoYour journalism only extends to investigating what companies deliver to your driveway, and not one millimeter further? That’s a racket, buddy.
- throwaway894345 5y agoWhat's Biden's excuse? What about the politicians from Oklahoma and West Virginia?
- ehvatum 5y agoPolitical Clientelism. It’s not an excuse, but it’s the reason.
- throwaway894345 5y ago
- aaaaaaaaata 5y agoand yet, I still want them to do it, because I think people should have the option of not needing to guess if their car has a new janky update before heading off in the morning.
- Karunamon 5y agoAt least in the case of Tesla, you have to approve updates since installing one makes the car unusable for 20 minutes to an hour.
- josephcsible 5y agoIf you don't like OTA updates, why not just buy a car from a manufacturer that doesn't do them? Why make it so that even people who do like them can't have them?
- whoknew1122 5y agoBecause, once you're on the road, your car affects everyone else around you. Have automatic updates for your personal machine. If Windows pushes out a patch that bricks your computer, I'm not impacted. If Tesla pushes out an OTA that is buggy and causes accidents, I'm affected.
- throwaway894345 5y agoIf an update "is buggy and causes accidents", why does it matter whether it was delivered OTA or not?
- juancampa 5y agoHaving the option is different from banning it completely. If you have a Tesla, you can opt-out from automatic OTA updates [0]. 0: https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/threads/opt-out-on-updates.173301/ https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/threads/opt-out-on-updates.1...
- whoknew1122 5y agoIf it keeps Teslas with 'aggressive' autopilot from doing illegal and dangerous things like rolling stops, I don't care what concern it stems from. Anything to stop bad companies from sending out half-baked patches is a net good. I don't care if you have to roll back an update on your SaaS site. Sucks, but we'll move on. But continuous integration should stay far away from what amount to missiles that weigh tons and go in excess of 60 miles.
- josephcsible 5y ago> If it keeps Teslas with 'aggressive' autopilot from doing illegal and dangerous things like rolling stops It doesn't do that. Tesla would still be able to push out whatever updates it wants. Drivers would just have to either go to a service center or leave the state to install them.
- whoknew1122 5y agoThe more structural obstacles there are to pushing out patches, the fewer patches will be pushed out. The company would have an incentive to rigorously test the patches before sending them out. Currently, with OTA patches, you can throw out any patch you want because it's self-serve. But if customers were inconvenienced by having to go to a service center for an update, Tesla would have a larger incentive to get things right the first time. It would damage their brand reputation if a customer had to go to a service center for a patch and then turn around and schedule two more appointments to download bugfix patches.
- throwaway894345 5y agoAh, the old "make it harder for customers to install safety updates" argument. > The company would have an incentive to rigorously test the patches before sending them out. This doesn't stop traditional automotive companies from releasing buggy software (they have far more recalls per unit time than Tesla), and anyway the issue you noted above wasn't a bug, it was a perfectly safe _optional_ feature that NHTSA didn't like.
- 5y ago
- nimbius 5y agodealerships exist because they comprise a nontrivial amount of state revenue and campaign contributions. they could offer negative value (which arguably, they do) and states would still refuse to deregulate. if you want them gone, in the fourth epoch of neoliberal capitalism, youll need to find an alternate source of tax revenue that not only protects corporate tax cuts but champions austerity and doesnt interfere with deficit spending at the state level.
- _8j50 5y agoEither way, it is a good idea. Prevents subscription modeled features.
- josephcsible 5y agoNo it doesn't. How would it?
- _8j50 5y agoFeatures can't be disabled OTA for non-payment.
- josephcsible 5y agoBut that's not a software update, so my understanding is that it is still allowed.
- _8j50 5y agoDepends on what an update is legally speaking. If there is a security vuln due to a config issue and an update fixes it, is it a software update?
- tyfon 5y agoJust do like toyota, have the car call home for subscription status and disable if the network etc is down [1]. [1] https://www.thedrive.com/news/43329/toyota-made-its-key-fob-remote-start-into-a-subscription-service https://www.thedrive.com/news/43329/toyota-made-its-key-fob-...
- throw0101a 5y ago> To be clear, this has nothing to do with security or any other legitimate concern. I simply want a toggle, at least software and preferably also hardware (e.g., being able to pull the SIM). The less Phone Home stuff in my car (and its black box / data recorder), the better.
- josephcsible 5y agoAnd that is a reasonable thing to want. It's just not what this law will give you.
- cout 5y agoIs it just to benefit dealers, or is there a provision in WV law for independent repairers to gain access to the ECU updates? I agree this smells of being anti-competitive against any manufacturer lacking in brick-and-mortar dealerships (e.g. Tesla).
- josephcsible 5y agoThe bill specifically uses the language "new motor vehicle dealer". So no, this isn't even a win for right-to-repair. It's just the rent-seeking dealer lobby looking to stop themselves from being cut out as the middlemen.
- jmclnx 5y agoI would think this would violate the interstate Commerce Clause of the Constitution.
- josephcsible 5y agoAll that says is that the federal government would have the authority to step in here, but if they don't, then that doesn't prohibit this.
- oneplane 5y agoBut if dealers no longer add enough value to the process of buying a car, doesn't that just mean that they either have to find new value to add or simply cease to exist because their business model is no longer viable?
- netr0ute 5y agoThat's one of the strategies behind the Tesla model.
- throwaway894345 5y agoOr lobby politicians for laws which entrench their position at the expense of wider society.
- jaywalk 5y agoIt's not even that, really. Older cars (for the most part) had nothing to update, so it's not like these updates are really taking anything away from the dealers that they were doing before. They are just mad that they aren't able to add a new revenue stream by being the only place to go to get software updates.
- Drunk_Engineer 5y agoOlder cars do have firmware, which may require updates.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- branon 5y agoWouldn't mind this. No OTA means less computers and networked junk in my car that I don't want or use anyway. By all means take the touchscreen and LTE radio out, they mean nothing to me.
- olliej 5y agoCars have had firmware that need updates for decades. This law simply means that you have to take the car in for a service, and pay for the privilege.
- nokcha 5y agoAutomatic over-the-air updates to cars do constitute a national security concern. A nation-state adversary who infiltrates the manufacturer can brick the cars, impeding the ability of essential employees to commute to work. And if the cars can be updated while on the road (either by design or by exploiting a vulnerability), it can be even worse.
- bognition 5y agoHow is this any different than everything else that is connected the grid. Sure a nation state could brick some cars or force them to drive without a driver. Shutting down critical infrastructure such as electricity generation, or water purification would do far more damage.
- vba616 5y ago>Shutting down critical infrastructure such as electricity generation, or water purification would do far more damage. I mean, this is true right now, and so those things (and hospitals and governments) are being targeted right now. Lots of stories about ransomware recently, and allegedly it's part of the hostilities in Ukraine. When there is enough centralized infrastructure controlling enough cars, then targeting it will do more damage, so it would be logical to do more of it.
- danhab99 5y agoOTA updates are important for any tech product and (hot take) electric cars have more in common with phones that gas cars. They need OTA updates. I would like to see it in law that these upgrades are not required and should be the users choice. I'm pretty sure that's what this bill was supposed to be before it got politics.
- quantified 5y agoPull model, just like phones, computers and the like. Yes.