4 ms·
An alternative title could be: "I saved a naive student from career suicide"
by coldtea 5y ago
An alternative title could be: "I saved a naive student from career suicide"
- raxxorrax 5y agoSome like to do science, some like to do a career. You are not wrong though. We should listen to the people that want to do science.
- johntdaly 5y agoYes, he definitely did that. What sucks for people like his student is that they counted as a minority and got shafted by that until they didn’t count as a minority anymore and got shafted by that too. It sucks to be an invisible minority.
- yakshaving_jgt 5y agoIn both cases, Daniel was shafted by racism, ergo, affirmative action is racist.
- johntdaly 5y agoDaniel is also a smart kid who can make his way through university without getting a leg up anywhere along the way and come out to be successful afterwards. Just calling affirmative action racist isn’t helping. Things are a bit more nuanced than that and should be treated as such so that useful conversations can happen instead of two sides just calling each other names. Besides, “affirmative action is racist” doesn’t fallow from “Daniel was shafted by racism” and is attackable based only on that point. If you want to argue against affirmative action here you could say: 1) The action is taken towards a group that is already privileged (well performing university students) and is superfluous 2) That the action is more likely to build up bad feelings towards the recipients by deserving individuals that get ignored 3) That the recipients of this action can never be as secure in their achievement and will suffer doubt from outside and inside because of it Argue your point, don’t just assert it. What be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence.
- yakshaving_jgt 5y agoI think I support your latter point more generally, but I'm not sure I need to further substantiate my comment with evidence, given that the evidence for the shafting is provided in the article. My comment doesn't provide new information — it's merely a laconic summation of arguments implicit in the article.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- thrwaway9871 5y agoAnd this is why no one listens to scientists. When it comes to actually standing up for something objectively right they fold like author and fall in line with status quo. Why do climate denial or anti-vax movements exist? Its because academia lost all integrity in the eyes of the public. You can wave all the research you want in front of their eyes but no one will listen as science is just another part of marketing nowadays. Let it sink in that speaking out the truth is career suicide and institutions publicly portrayed as sources of truth are actively pushing for it to stay that way.
- Ancapistani 5y ago> When it comes to actually standing up for something objectively right they fold like author and fall in line with status quo. Where do you get that from the article? The author’s purpose seemed to be to make sure that “Daniel” didn’t fall victim to his own naivety. His advice was based on his own judgement of Daniel’s understanding of the situation. Standing up for what you believe is right is great - if you understand what you’re doing, why you’re doing it, how likely you are to succeed, and the what the consequences are if you don’t.