5 ms·
Smart people recognize that the base premise is simply unworkable. The idea that anyone can create money out of electrons is really no better than the idea tha
by jqpabc123 5y ago
Smart people recognize that the base premise is simply unworkable.
The idea that anyone can create money out of electrons is really no better than the idea that anyone can create money out of paper. There is no real reason to believe the first will be any more successful than the second.
There are close to 10,000 different cryptocurrencies currently in use. And the number is increasing all the time. You don't have to be really smart to see that over time, these are all likely to tend toward the same value. The essential elements that will seal their fate --- trust and consensus --- or the lack thereof.
The part of the idea that does have some merit is "digital" currency. The Fed is working on it. And when it arrives, crypto will likely vanish back into the electronic ether from whence it sprang.
- datadata 5y agoWhy do you see the large number of cryptocurrencies an argument supporting their value going to zero? This is like saying that the number of websites is still going up, therefore the value of the internet will go to zero. A more charitable analysis would look at the number of users of cryptocurrency, and especially the number of users of the most prevalent cryptocurrencies, which is indisputably rising.
- jqpabc123 5y agoWhy do you see the large number of cryptocurrencies an argument supporting theoretical value going to zero? If too many people can easily make the product, the market quickly becomes saturated and the value starts to tend toward zero and people losing interest in it. Also, in this particular case the product is defective. It doesn't actually function as stated --- as a currency that is widely accepted to buy a huge variety of things both large and small with minimal fees, high transaction volume and low wait times? These are basically just instruments for speculation and fraud. History shows that such schemes can't and won't be sustained over time.
- datadata 5y ago> If anyone can make it, the market quickly becomes saturated and the value tends toward zero and people losing interest in it. You just restated your previous claim, you still didn't give any reason why the value must go to zero-- By the same logic, the market for websites is also saturated, therefore the value of the internet is going to zero.
- jqpabc123 5y agoDon't look now but the market value of most web sites is zero. People pay nothing to use them.
- datadata 5y agoAnd stocks also? There are more than 10,000 stocks, therefore the value of stocks much also must go to zero as the market is saturated.
- jqpabc123 5y agoNow you're just making up ever more absurd analogies by ignoring most of the context. You don't have 10,000 companies all producing the same type of product. If you did, the value of most of them would go to zero really fast. Also, you can't easily clone most listed companies at no cost. There are significant barriers to entry in the stock market --- which explains why you don't have 10,000 companies all doing the same thing.
- datadata 5y agoI'm making analogies so that you have to substantiate your argument. It isn't clear that just because there is a large number of something, the entire ecosystem must be worthless, which is what you originally said. You can't clone bitcoin at no cost. To clone bitcoin you would have to invest the same amount of energy that has been expended thus far to proof of work.
- 5y ago
- _9omd 5y agoYou're missing the idea of network effects. Yes, you an easily make a clone of Bitcoin (or other cryptos), but you cannot easily clone the network effect it has. The value of a crypto is in the network, not the code, and this value grows exponentially with the number of the people using the network (Metcalf's Law[0]). Despite the increase in total number of cryptocurrencies, the number of people using the big networks (Bitcoin, Ethereum, etc.) is growing, and thus their network values are growing. This really shouldn't be surprising to anyone familiar with the growth of the web. Just like cloning a crypo, it'd be trivial to make a new Twitter, but extremely difficult to gain the same level of network effect. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metcalfe%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metcalfe%27s_law
- jqpabc123 5y agoJust like cloning a crypo, it'd be trivial to make a new Twitter, but extremely difficult to gain the same level of network effect. If Elon Musk wanted to make "MuskCoin", he could and instantly have a huge number of people jump on board. He has already proven this just by meddling in the current crypto market for his own amusement. Lots of other companies/individuals with clout and name recognition could easily do the same. The only reason they don't --- they recognize the ultimate futility of it. Musk has even poked fun at the absurdity of it all. https://futurism.com/elon-musk-mocks-dogecoin-crypto-scams https://futurism.com/elon-musk-mocks-dogecoin-crypto-scams
- _9omd 5y agoAnd likewise, if Elon Musk wanted to make a Twitter clone with better free speech he could get a lot of users. What's your point, that's literally the opposite of low barrier to entry. Being Elon Musk is NOT a low barrier to entry. Anything you say can be re-framed to the web, so if your point is valid then how can websites like Twitter be so valueable?
- jqpabc123 5y agoWhat's your point, that's literally the opposite of low barrier to entry. It's just one example of how your "network effect" could be overcome very quickly. Any individual or company with market presence and name recognition could do this if they were so inclined. You could easily have ChaseCoin, FordCoin, FidelityCoin, NFLCoin and 10,000 more if they thought it was practical and profitable and would be successful over the long term. But allowing anyone to "mint" their own money is really an argument *against* the basic concept of a "currency". The world has already been there, seen that and done that. And most "smart people" (and companies) recognize that this is not in the best long term interests of themselves or the overall economy.
- imtringued 5y agoSmart people recognize that money can never be anything but a consensual agreement between humans. How you symbolize that agreement is actually irrelevant. There is no limit to the agreements that humans can make so the idea of limiting them by decree is absurd. The most problematic part is that holding onto money is a onesided arrangement that requires no consent or agreement. You can literally leave the other party hanging. It is kinda like doing homework in a group and waiting on the results of the second guy so you can work on your part. You will eventually stop waiting and just borrow the homework from another group so you can finally get started with your damn part of the homework.
- jqpabc123 5y agoThere is no limit to the agreements that humans can make so the idea of limiting them by decree is absurd. No one is limiting the number of cryptocurrencies. If you and your friends want to make your own "CryptoNickel" currency, go for it. No one is stopping you. No one is stopping others from doing the same too --- and therein lies the problem --- the exercise is self defeating outside your unique circle of friends. Just a wild guess but you probably won't be using "CryptoNickel" to pay rent or buy groceries. Why is this? Because as I noted above, "CryptoNickel" is missing essential elements of a truly functional currency --- trust and consensus --- not just among your friends but society at large. And a distributed electronic accounting system is no substitute for these missing elements.