3 ms·
> If you can save 200 hours of work per paper, you can put another paper out. I guess that's an opportunity for those countries to focus on research quality in
by marcosdumay 5y ago
> If you can save 200 hours of work per paper, you can put another paper out.
I guess that's an opportunity for those countries to focus on research quality instead of publication volume and sidetrack the entire issue.
But, well, they are not doing this. That's too bad.
- bee_rider 5y agoThis could be nice, as long as universities correspondingly stopped using paper counts as a measure of researcher productivity when doing hiring or tenure decisions.
- marcosdumay 5y agoNot only university hiring, but grant analysis also needs to change. This is something done top-down, not bottom-up. I guess that's why nobody is doing it.
- MichaelZuo 5y agoUniversities only use those metrics in lieu of actual proven results. A genius with demonstrated novel, reproducible, experimental results in any of the hard sciences or engineering will likely not encounter much difficulty getting a tenure track position at even the most selective schools. The really interesting question is why do so few researchers have novel, reproducible, experimental results?
- ebiester 5y agoHowever, having an editor that will engage with your work and provide expert feedback will make your work better, as well as save overall time. It's not quality versus quantity - it's paying for expert assistance. This isn't cheating, mind you - it's something every one of us will do, given the option. However, wealthy institutions can pay for it, and other institutions cannot - that leaves the academic to either pay out of their own pocket (say, if they have a partner who is in our industry and can afford to), or go without.
- marcosdumay 5y ago> However, having an editor that will engage with your work and provide expert feedback will make your work better, as well as save overall time. You mean something like peer review before submission, or you mean a formal editor? A formal editor will only add value to that document. You may communicate things better, but it won't improve what things you communicate.