5 ms·
Sven was my friend. I knew him well. He was one of the first people in the tech scene I met when I first came to Berlin in 2007. I don't think we should be h
by sneak 5y ago
Sven was my friend. I knew him well. He was one of the first people in the tech scene I met when I first came to Berlin in 2007.
I don't think we should be honoring him, though, because he was, despite being my friend, not a very good person:
https://twitter.com/deborianerin/status/1495636848722513920 https://twitter.com/deborianerin/status/1495636848722513920
https://twitter.com/deborianerin/status/1495645190832463872 https://twitter.com/deborianerin/status/1495645190832463872
https://twitter.com/twena/status/1495537875651371012 https://twitter.com/twena/status/1495537875651371012
https://twitter.com/deborianerin/status/1495673397296218113 https://twitter.com/deborianerin/status/1495673397296218113
These tweets were posted today, but those of us that knew him well have known of these issues for years.
I have as a point of pride many "problematic" friends; my friendship with someone is not approval of every (or even any) action they undertake in life.
I do not approve of this dedication, as Sven was a good example of the kind of people who make the f/oss community worse, not better. We as a community can do much better than explicitly endorsing those who would cause our scene to be unsafe and unwelcoming to young women.
- btittelbach 5y agoSven was always welcome in our hackerspace. We never had any reason to find fault with him. Having known him, I can certainly imagine him hurting for companionship and being awkward about it. Surprise, Sven was an imperfect human, just like everybody else. Personally though I've NEVER observed him behaving in this way and being on the watch for such things, I would surely have talked to him about it. Despite the problems he had to deal with (or choose to ignore ;->) (not talking about the stuff above), he dedicated his life to improve things around him the best way he could see fit. If you had a problem with Sven and were happy enough to not speak up when he was alive, why raise this issue only now that he is dead? We are honouring Sven's contributions so others are inspired to be similarly helpful. It truth this is somewhat independent of Sven as a whole. But by dragging the person he was through the mud, you are not helping anybody or achieving anything for society.
- warmwaffles 5y ago> Sven was my friend. I knew him well. You are a wonderful friend.
- twh270 5y agoI don't know the first thing about him, but maybe we could honor his contributions while not giving a blanket approval of everything he ever said and did? Or is that, like, too subtle and nuanced a concept nowadays.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- xionon 5y agoHow do you celebrate one’s accomplishments while ignoring one’s behavior in the process of making those accomplishments? Or rather, is it actually too nuanced to think the ends don’t justify the means?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- BeetleB 5y agoOne can also highlight both the good and the bad. Although my experiences with him were not as extreme as these examples, I did stop using Mutt a decade ago partially because of his behavior - he had been a liability to Mutt development for years at that point.
- atommclain 5y agoIn situations like this, I think of the sentiment: "May the good he created stretch on, and the evil be buried with him."
- allarm 5y agoAnd maybe there should be something more than a couple of tweets from random persons without ANY proofs? That’s just so wrong.
- BeetleB 5y agoThe commenter knew him personally, and is attesting to his behavior.
- freedomben 5y agoYou have as a point of pride many problematic friends (which I think is great), but you shit on their memory online the day after they die? I'm very much with you that just because someone has died doesn't mean we should whitewash their flaws and pretend they don't exist, but you've really caused me to face the full force of that opinion today :-)
- sneak 5y agoIf I am shitting on anything, it is the decision by people currently alive to explicitly endorse his presence in the f/oss community, which is a very poor decision in my view, given Sven's conduct within it. Telling the truth is always appropriate. TFA claims that "He was a good person." I do not believe that to be accurate.
- serf 5y ago>Telling the truth is always appropriate. the truth is that Sven was a prolific foss contributor with a complicated history with regards to other people. you can acknowledge both contributions & faults, erasing his history of foss contributions wouldn't be the truth -- much like labeling him as nothing more than a predator wouldn't be the truth, either. I'm not sure what you're advocating in this memoriam thread, to be honest -- total erasure of person and non-response from the projects they were involved with? Isn't that a similar kind of non-whole truth that you're railing against all together?
- jacquesm 5y agoI think we have diverging definitions of what the word 'friend' means. It's possible to be someone's friend, acknowledge their wrongs and not draw attention to those wrongs in their obituary. It's one of those things that have historically been agreed upon as the proper way, in dutch we've formalized it in a proverb "Over de doden niets dan goeds.". "Nothing but good about the dead.". Simply because it is bad form to shit all over someone who isn't there to defend themselves (especially when you call them a friend) and because you never know who is going to read your writings, they might already be having a very hard day. I realize that this is too much to ask for some, but his friends should know better.
- d_tr 5y ago
- rectang 5y agoLet's not underestimate the impact that certain kinds of being "inappropriate" can have on people — the sense of powerlessness it instills, especially when the offense is dismissed and minimized by elements of the wider society. It's sad but not surprising to see this sort of response (EDIT: her response).
- d_tr 5y agoYour reply is not very relevant to my comment though. Also I might be much more sensitive than you think and you are sad and unsurprised for nothing. EDIT: I' m sorry, I misunderstood you.
- rectang 5y agoI'm at fault for a lack of clarity. This is a difficult and unfortunate discussion, and let's try to appreciate all of us as whole people today in the fullness of all our experiences and lives lived.
- Tomte 5y ago> happy that the person died That's simply a lie. Her words support that she is happy about him not harassing anyone anymore, but not about his death per se. Which she explicitly emphasizes down the thread again.
- vimacs2 5y agoCurious if the same people getting upset about her words were similarly upset when Richard Stallman said after hearing of Steve Job's death "I'm not glad he's dead but I'm glad he's gone".
- wyldfire 5y agoCan you share a translation for the first two - auf Englisch?
- stereo 5y agoDeborah's first tweet: He only harassed me inappropriately, via text and a few times physically, many years ago in #CCCB Glad that won't happen again. Reply: Sven Guckes was one of the great evangelists of the German open source scene. During his lifetime, there were good reasons why people wanted to dislike, shun or sometimes kick him out, but he really didn't deserve such a reaction to the obituary tweet. Take care, Sven. Her reply: but I deserved to be harassed as a woman, by a +20 years older guy in whom I NEVER showed interest...? To just sit on my legs at the movie Sunday, to force cuddling, although I had ignored [his] advances for months - BÄH how disgusting.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwaway984393 5y agoObits are not meant to be honest. They are meant solely to make the people that are still alive feel better. If we had to stop and think about death, we would have to consider our own mortality. If we had to stop and think about the poor life choices of a dead person, we would have to stop and think about our own poor life choices. We might have to consider whether we owe some kind of penance; whether our own misdeeds outweigh our good; whether someone might dig up our own past when we pass. And that's terrifying. So obits must only say good things about the dead. We mustn't consider the true nature of a life filled with bad and good and in-between. We must instead shroud ourselves in the comforting blanket of pure nostalgia. This way we don't have to face pain, or truth, or conflict, and we can just feel a benign sad pleasure, to more easily slip back into comforting ignorance. As an aside: Twitter is a hellscape of negativity. It could be that he also saved drowning toddlers from a river or some shit, but that isn't going to make it through the typical barrage of snide tweets. So just as much as we should consider the negative, we should consider that there's also positive. The fact that all humans are fundamentally flawed does not invalidate their good deeds, nor validate the bad. And if we try really hard, we might conclude that there is no such thing as a "good" or "bad" person, but just "a person", the culmination of which cannot be put neatly into a box. Maybe then we could stop reacting so strongly to discovering that humans are indeed flawed, and that there is no shame in considering all of one's deeds, for that's where the truth of life lies.
- jpgvm 5y agoNot condoning his behavior if these tweets are true but I think acknowledging his contributions to VIM is entirely orthogonal. Some will think this is the same as "making it OK to be a harasser if you are l33t/important/rich/etc" but it's really not. VIM is a community project that he dedicated significant time and effort to at his own expense. It's just like a rich donor to some hospital and getting a wing named after them, it doesn't erase their sins but it acknowledges the good that person has done in that act. A person is more than their faults and trying to take everything good away from their memory after their death because of those faults doesn't sit right with me.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]