23 ms·
I was wrong, we need crypto
- deeviant 5y agoUsing crypto to fund illegal activities is already well explored and I don't think your post has much to add to the pitch for crypto.
- WaxedChewbacca 5y ago
- thomassmith65 5y agoIt is one thing whether or not the Canadian government should seize funds from people who support the "convoy" movement. It is a different thing whether or not the Canadian government should lose the ability to seize funds, in general, from its citizens. This article conflates the two.
- csee 5y agoI read the article as connecting (not conflating) the two. He's saying that the government can no longer be trusted with this power, as evidenced by this particular misuse, and they therefore should lose that ability.
- Comevius 5y ago[flagged]
- csee 5y agoWhy must we choose between doing nothing on the one hand and freezing assets without due process on the other? Why can't we just have a functioning liberal democracy that arrests the purported criminals quickly, charges them with a crime, and tries them in a court under the full scrutiny of the voting public?
- Comevius 5y agoCanada only enacted the Emergencies Act when things got out of hand. This was separatist group that for a time took control over the border, threatened and blockaded critical infrastructure and committed thousands of crimes (bribery, threats, assault, setting a fire in a building). The criminal investigations are ongoing. Due process will be had.
- csee 5y agoThen arrest the people who are breaking the laws and blockading critical infrastructure, and charge them with a criminal offence. The BLM protests also saw many criminal elements that did looting and assaults. None of this is a valid argument for freezing accounts of people "involved" without due process.
- Comevius 5y agoThe Emergencies Act is specifically for when there is an urgent and critical public order emergency. It's invocation is going to be ratified by the Parlaiment today. The police unfortunately dropped the ball, they tried that option too. But just arresting specific people also wasn't enough. Polling shows that the majority of Canadians supported the use of the act.
- csee 5y agoI don't accept that this wasn't resolvable by normal police action. https://www.ctvnews.ca/canada/191-arrests-later-ottawa-police-remove-remaining-freedom-convoy-vehicles-1.5788869 https://www.ctvnews.ca/canada/191-arrests-later-ottawa-polic... Maybe freezing accounts contributed to this particular outcome, but I don't accept that it was necessary.
- lowkey 5y agoNotably, the War Measures Act - which is the original act that was rebranded as the Emergencies Act in 1988 - has only ever been put into effect 3 times in history. 1. WWI 2. WWII 3. FLQ Crisis - an incident that included the kidnapping of federal ministers by a terrorist organization By contrast, this protest has been incredibly peaceful when compared to other similar protests or occupations. There is a debate happening in parliament right now on whether or not to extend the Emergency powers now that the government has successfully cleared the protestors and taken back control of downtown Ottawa. I personally don't believe this incident warranted the suspension of civil liberties. It isn't clear to me that the government did what they could to apply the existing laws on the books. If anything the biggest issue was that the Ottawa police appeared reluctant to enforce existing laws on the protestors. That is a different issue and does not justify the imposition of the Emergency act.
- CodeGlitch 5y ago> and the majority don't want these Nazi flag waving idiots distrupting their lives. Slightly off topic but the inconsistent treatment/reporting of these protestors and BLM is what gets me. BLM protestors flying "antifa" flags (let's be honest Marxists) are just as bad as Nazis in my book - seriously misled people with unworkable ideas about how the world should be run. Anyway if you're coming down hard on protestors who are causing disruption but not to protestors who are setting fire to buildings then there's something seriously wrong.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- feoren 5y ago> BLM protestors flying "antifa" flags ... are just as bad as Nazis Let's be clear about what you're saying: people who are vehemently opposed to Nazis are just as bad as Nazis. This is the definition of "fake centrism" or (sarcastically) "enlightened centrism". You're really saying that a new flag created to express opposition to Nazis, fascism, authoritarianism, and genocide is as bad as a flag that has been used for almost a century to represent those exact things? They're just as bad as each other? Are there good and bad people "on both sides", too? You need to seriously take a hard look at yourself in a mirror if you believe this. One group is expressly saying "we should subjugate and genocide non-whites" and the other group is expressly saying "we should not tolerate genocide and subjugation" and they are just as bad in your eyes!?
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoPeople vehemently opposed to Nazis can be exactly as bad as Nazis. It's not the flag; it's not even really the ideology; it's the actions. If your actions are as bad as the actions of Nazis, then you are as bad as Nazis. You and CodeGlitch can argue whether that applies in this situation. But the idea itself is perfectly reasonable.
- feoren 5y agoI'm not claiming nobody is as bad as the Nazis. I am claiming that the core belief of "Antifa", represented by both its name and its flag, is "anti-fascism", which is nearly synonymous with being "anti-Nazi". I am also claiming that people who wave the Nazi flag in modern times are explicitly calling for the genocide of other human beings. Finally, I am claiming that being against genocide and being for genocide are not somehow automatically equal, like two poles of some spectrum; rather, that such a belief is a well-known false equivalency known as "enlightened centrism" that is commonly used by people who actually just outright sympathize with Nazis and just don't want to admit it. None of these claims should be controversial in any way whatsoever. So I don't really understand what you're trying to rebut here.
- lowkey 5y agoPlease note that the Canadian government has, in the past, on multiple occasions [0], used agents provocateurs to falsely smear a protest movement by planting their own agents who attempt to inflame a situation. For example, trying to turn peaceful protests violent. To my knowledge, there was a singular incident of Nazi flag on the very first day of a 25 day protest. There is also some evidence that it may have actually been the PM's personal photographer who took the photos of the Nazi flag [1]. It is also a curious fact that this flag incident took place at the Fairmont Chateau Laurier, a $300/night luxury hotel in the heart of Ottawa, known for hosting foreign dignitaries and heads of state, that now curiously houses a large contingent of police from all over Canada [2]. It seems suspect to think that truckers and racists would choose such an iconic and expensive venue to display this symbol of hate. Given that most of us never expected the severe curtailing of civil liberties by a liberal democracy such as Canada, I think it is prudent for us all to be skeptical about the facts on the ground in this incident as it almost appear engineered to sow the seeds of hate against the protesters in this case. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agent_provocateur#Canada https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agent_provocateur#Canada [1] https://twitter.com/McloughlinGuy/status/1489468112009408514/photo/1 https://twitter.com/McloughlinGuy/status/1489468112009408514... [2] https://twitter.com/GuitarBill609/status/1495447010291372034/photo/1 https://twitter.com/GuitarBill609/status/1495447010291372034...
- kingofpandora 5y agoThere is no evidence it was "Trudeau's personal photographer" that took the picture in question. Zero.
- lowkey 5y agoI apologize. I overstepped and will correct my previous comment with a note. I do find it suspect that this all went down at the Fairmont Chateau Laurier which is a hotel most well known for hosting foreign dignitaries and heads of state, as well as more recently large numbers of police brought in from around the country. This single nazi flag incident has been repeated by the government and it's proponent so many times now to paint this entire movement as racist which is do feel is an unfair characterization of the protesters, most of whom were simply Canadians who felt the need to be heard.
- gorwell 5y agoOne idiot or provocateur in a sea of tens of thousands does not override the 99%. That's an absurd, lazy smear. What this episode makes clear is that many people actually love authoritarianism as long as the actions of the state in the moment appear to align with their own ideology. Next time it won't, which is why it must be resisted on a principled basis. This precedent being set is a dictator's dream come true and you will have no leg to stand on as someone that cheered on the tools of oppression.
- wwweston 5y ago> One idiot or provocateur in a sea of tens of thousands does not override the 99%. When the blockade is significantly funded from outside the country the policies are supposed to be about [0], when effective mechanics of the protest aren't merely speech but crippling trade, when the stated substance is basically claiming the privilege of unrestrained motion across international borders without regard to vaccination status, even if it were true that "one idiot or provocateur in a sea of tens of thousands" were engaging in fundamentally unacceptable (e.g. nazi) performance, there's still be plenty of reasons for sensible and restrained government authorities to intervene. > This precedent being set is a dictator's dream Which precedent? That authorities might use authority to stop trade disruption? Seizure of property from people involved in that disruption? Bigger and far more routine problems in terms of civil forfeiture. Needing to be vaccinated to cross a border? You may want to look at precedents established over the last century or two and ask yourself why the totalitarian catastrophe you seem to be imagining has only crossed some kind of threshold now, almost as if it isn't coming. [0] https://talkingpointsmemo.com/edblog/where-things-stand-majority-of-anti-vax-trucker-protest-funds-were-donated-by-americans https://talkingpointsmemo.com/edblog/where-things-stand-majo...
- Elinvynia 5y ago> One idiot or provocateur in a sea of tens of thousands does not override the 99%. That's an absurd, lazy smear. Do you feel the same about the BLM protests?
- colpabar 5y agoThis is a really lazy whataboutism. Let's assume that both the blm protests and the convoy both had "a few idiots or provocateurs in a sea of tens of thousands." Now compare the media coverage and government handling of the two things, and compare how those idiots are portrayed compared to the tens of thousands. Do you see a difference? It seems to me that all blm-related events are generally considered peaceful protests (even the ones where buildings are burned down), while the convoy is nothing but a big nazi flag waving party. Did any blm related entity have their bank accounts frozen?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- waterlaw 5y agoThis comment reminds me of Carl Schmitt's observation that nothing in a Liberal Democracy prevents it from becoming totalitarian (or otherwise.) His books are more relevant today, as the state is re-establishing its authority to define "friend" and "enemy". "Good" and "evil". Tolerating the "other" side's views is no longer acceptable. The state is re-establishing its authority (and monopoly?) to determine public "friend" and "enemy".
- yuvadam 5y agoThe Canadian government can still seize crypto funds from citizens, it just requires them to actually go through a due process, and perhaps get a court order or warrant. What's going on in Canada right now is a disgrace that perfectly exemplifies why the legacy financial system is morally - and quite literally - bankrupt.
- anonporridge 5y agoThe key point is that seizing someone's property needs to be costly. It's immensely problematic when violating someone's individual rights is not costly, and you can seize the money of tens of thousands of people with the stroke of a pen and the push of a button. The same argument applies to surveillance. If the FBI has reason to suspect a person of a crime, then they have the right to set up some surveillance apparatus to gather evidence against that person. But this is a costly endeavor and requires many manhours of work. But, if you can automatically surveil every person in the country, and run it all through machine learning to constantly monitor every single person, then that becomes an extremely dangerous slippery slope into an inescapable authoritarian state.
- bryanlarsen 5y ago> get a court order or warrant. Already done: https://www.thestar.com/news/canada/2022/02/17/citizens-group-wins-court-ordered-freeze-of-freedom-convoy-accounts-cryptocurrency.html https://www.thestar.com/news/canada/2022/02/17/citizens-grou...
- defaultname 5y ago"In just three weeks of honking, blocked streets and bridges, bouncy castles and flag waving, this peaceful protest" Aside from a billion dollars+ in trade blocked when the protest -- having achieved nothing terrorizing the residents of Ottawa and blasting horns/setting off fireworks around the clock -- branched out to trying to block international borders, they harassed schools, healthcare workers, anyone wearing a mask, and attacked reporters from venues they don't like. The vast majority of businesses in the affected zone shut down entirely because the lawless, selfish crowd at this rally proved such a massive liability that simply closing was a better option. But they set up a bouncy castle and brought children as shields (stated tactical plan of the group), so I guess that is okay. They fawned over a Fox News reporter, and then spit on and slurred an MSNBC reporter. You might notice a correlation with another group South of the border, and that isn't accidental. Just as it shouldn't surprise that the main "stage" of this operation's daily speeches were chock full of QAnon gibberish (utterly indisputable -- the crowd cheers as conspiracies about the WEF, the Rothschilds, Bill Gates, 5G, and so on were given the daily reading). Appearances by "Canada First" flags, Red Ensign flags (an old Canadian flag repurposed by white supremacist), and more unfortunate correlations. This isn't accidental. Livestreams and discussions with many of the protestors betrayed just a cosmically misinformed, ignorant group, and it's a perilous demonstration of the future we all face as groups fracture off, conveniently declare anything but a few grifting sources "fake news", and then feed off of each other. To call this an anti-mandate protest is to seriously miss the plot. If it was -- if it hadn't constructed noise-terrorism devices that saw people measuring 100db+ in their apartment -- and actually saved the "Fuck Trudeau" signs and QAnon conspiracies, or that whole seditious "we're not leaving until the government resigns and the Governor General declares us the new government" bit of nonsense, they could have inspired sympathy. Instead it was simply political terrorism, and is grotesquely anti-democratic. 93% of Canadians wanted this shut down weeks ago. "Martial law"? After three weeks, weeks past being declared an illegal occupation, they were sent home in the gentlest way possible. After weeks of warnings, then days of warning of an action, the police did their job. The only thing above and beyond normal policing they did was that the Emergency Act allowed other regions to add to the police force without the whole normal process. Calling this Martial Law is *gross* and makes DHH look like a clown, though the entire piece manages that so it's consistent. It should offend anyone with any functioning reason. "First the Ottawa police department got GoFundMe to confiscate donations with the intention of redirecting them to other causes" GFM was made aware the cause was being used to fund literal crime breaking (indisputable), so they cancelled it. Good for them. And if someone crowdfunded to have crimes committed against DHH or his property, I hope they would be even quicker (but hey, at least his detractors will have crypto, right?). What GFM decided to do then was entirely on GFM's side. Now the government wants crowdfunding with targets or sources in Canada to report large or suspicious transactions to FINTRAC, given that currently it is a gap in the financial system. There is nothing surprising or bizarre in that. And before someone cites BLM or "ANTIFA" thinking that's some sort of "haha got you leftist" retort, a lot of us -- those of us who don't frame everything as "right" or "left", and have remotely consistent values -- are against unlawful blockades and occupations fullstop. "CHOP" areas -- terrible, shut them down. Railway blockades -- terrible, shut them down. Bridge blockade -- terrible, shut them down. City blockade and criminal harassment for three weeks -- terrible, shut it down. Trying to undermine or usurp a democracy through criminal action -- terrible, shut it down. I am embarrassed for DHH. Another hot take bit of nonsense filled with clear lies, all so he could claim that crypto could be the answer? And this trash will see upvotes by crypto enthusiasts who don't realize it's yet another American giving their unwanted, unneeded, ignorant hot takes about a situation about which they are grossly misinformed (or they're just a liar and don't care, because again they know they're talking to an audience that will eat it up). As one aside, he tries to shame someone who called for them to lose their commercial license, commercial insurance, etc. Imagine if you will that a pilot at JFK airport didn't like....who cares, something, anything...so they taxied their A360 out to an active runway and then shut it down and locked the doors. Until they were satisfied with whatever their cause was, they weren't moving. Now tell me what you think the chances are that this person would maintain their pilot license, employment, or would ever fly a plane again?
- rglover 5y ago> And that it was the Canadians who brought this on? You might as well have told me that it was really the Care Bears who ran Abu Ghraib. > Especially since I had some sympathy with fears projected by the US progressive left who spent four years fretting Trump might pull stunts like these. Then it turns out that the worries of an authoritarian overreach would be fulfilled by Trudeu to the North instead? Who's writing this script? M. Night Shyamalan? The kumbaya "we're all in this together" thing only works until one of the other apes becomes self-aware and remembers we're still living in the jungle. More often than not in history, the person pushing that message knows exactly what they're doing and has designs on doing exactly what Trudeau has done. None of this is a surprise.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jqpabc123 5y ago... we need crypto Did someone say otherwise? Crypto is an attempt to fulfill a broad yearning for financial freedom. The problem is, as it currently exists --- it just doesn't deliver. Crypto doesn't displace trust, it misplaces it. Instead of trusting government and regulated banks, you end up trusting the unregulated gatekeepers to the block chain --- the exchanges. Who is making sure these gatekeepers are not self serving scammers and con artists? Why no one really. In other words, block chain automates the accounting but it does nothing to eliminate *trust* as a central aspect of the monetary system. So the question simply becomes, who are you going to trust? If government suddenly ceased to exist, the first thing people would do is re-invent it. Because left to their own devices, people are not trustworthy.
- dylkil 5y ago>you end up trusting the unregulated gatekeepers to the block chain --- the exchanges. how exactly are exchanges gatekeepers? blockchains would function completely fine without exchanges. In fact, on chain exchanges like uniswap and 0x require zero trust whatsoever.
- jqpabc123 5y agoIn fact, on chain exchanges like uniswap and 0x require zero trust whatsoever. Who determines how much your crypto is worth? Does uniswap do this? No, not on their own. They can't --- their daily trading volume is too small. They are literally forced to follow the "marketplace". The 800lb gorillas that make up the crypto "marketplace" are the centralized exchanges --- Binance and others. They set the price using whatever method they choose. And they can easily influence the price by buying and selling themselves. Binance has access to unlimited funds to do so --- by simply minting more Tethers --- which they have done repeatedly --- and the price remains pegged at $1USD (wink, wink, nod, nod). With unlimited funds, effective control over the pricing mechanism and no regulation --- the centralized exchanges have all the ingredients for the ultimate form of insider trading fraud. If you trade crypto as it exists today, you are *trusting* the centralized exchanges who have overwhelming influence over the "marketplace". You have no other option.
- rglover 5y agoWe don't need "crypto," we need _Bitcoin_. Crypto is the scam he references here. It's clear that DHH has a very thin understanding of Bitcoin and is conflating arguments about the web3/crypto/defi/nft nonsense with it. _That_ is the psyop. If people think Bitcoin and all of the other junk (sh*tcoins) are the same thing, you're just walking into the same trap as what precipitated the nightmare in Canada. The thing to watch for is the push for CBDCs which are state-controlled cryptocurrencies which will give authoritarians perpetual hard-on levels of control. You think freezing a bank account is bad? Wait until they can make your money expire or prevent you from transacting with anyone they deem "bad actors." Recommended: https://www.amazon.com/Bitcoin-Standard-Decentralized-Alternative-Central/dp/1119473861 https://www.amazon.com/Bitcoin-Standard-Decentralized-Altern...
- rosndo 5y ago> We don't need "crypto," we need _Bitcoin_. But Monero is objectively better than Bitcoin if you just want to pay for things.
- rglover 5y agoPerhaps, but it lacks the brand recognition. Playing the technology dick measuring contest will end up confusing people and lead them right into a trap (meaning, they end up distrusting the very thing that can save them). Bitcoin has all of the necessary pieces to get the immediate problem of government overreach and currency manipulation fixed.
- anonporridge 5y agoArguable, because monero's hash power is a negligible fraction of bitcoin's AND it's ASIC resitant, so mining on CPUs is still viable. This makes it much more vulnerable to nation state 51% attack since they can just temporarily redirect fleets of CPUs (maybe even deputize AWS, Azure, GCP, etc) to attack the network. This kind of rapid response attack isn't feasible on bitcoin because SHA256 ASIC miners are incredibly hard to come by and the electricity required to pull it off would be enormously expensive.
- h2odragon 5y agoThe Canadian Gubmint is issuing orders about seizing crypto assets too. We need more economic freedom; "cryptocurrencies" are not suddenly a panacea to that end. They're still the scam riddled "but this is stupid at its very base" pyramid schemes they were all along. See the precedent set by Emperor Norton; community currencies and other alternates can work too. What's needed is a government that admits limits to its powers to interfere with its citizens ability to transact. There's no technical means to make a government live up to that promise... Short of explosives.
- LewisVerstappen 5y ago> The Canadian Gubmint is issuing orders about seizing crypto assets too. Sure, but the entire point is that they can't. If you manage your own private keys, it is significantly harder for the canadian government to seize your assets compared to the gov telling your bank to freeze your account. Crypto people need to work on UX though, so that you don't need to be technically savvy to do so.
- thesuperbigfrog 5y ago>> Sure, but the entire point is that they can't. >> If you manage your own private keys, it is significantly harder for the canadian government to seize your assets compared to the gov telling your bank to freeze your account. If they want your keys badly enough, they will get them: https://imgs.xkcd.com/comics/security.png https://imgs.xkcd.com/comics/security.png
- datadata 5y agoThere is a big and meaningful difference between being able to freeze bank accounts at scale without violence and only with the cooperation of a centralized finance institution, versus having to physically torture each account owner to get what they want one by one. A government would have to be substantially more evil and use vastly more resources to do the later. And there is a second order chilling effect in the former, where even if a government does not seize asserts, the threat of it will make citizens think about their words.
- spupe 5y agoThis is nonsense. Canada is starting to classify cryptos as assets [1], and they already are looking into some accounts related to the protests [2]. It's true that you could hide it well, but you could also do so by having gold bars in a bank vault. [1] https://fcpablog.com/2021/06/21/canadian-courts-assist-crypto-recovery/ https://fcpablog.com/2021/06/21/canadian-courts-assist-crypt... [2] https://www.coindesk.com/policy/2022/02/16/canada-sanctions-34-crypto-wallets-tied-to-trucker-freedom-convoy/ https://www.coindesk.com/policy/2022/02/16/canada-sanctions-...
- dylkil 5y agoYour comment is nonsense. They can seize your gold in a bank vault. They cannot forge a signature transferring your crypto held on your metamask. They would need first physical access to your computer and secondly your metamask password. They can classify it all they want, but it is completely outside of the control of their legacy systems.
- spupe 5y agoThey can seize the gold only if they know where it is. And to convert crypto back into Canadian dollars, you will need to go through the "legacy" banking system at any substantial amount, where it can be flagged with standard tools and you would be arrested.
- dylkil 5y ago>And to convert crypto back into Canadian dollars the ultimate goal is to never convert back
- medvezhenok 5y agoThey can also criminalize accepting Bitcoin for payment for goods, in which case you would have no choice but to convert back to dollars (and taxes will likely always be paid in dollars anyway)
- jonathan-adly 5y agoCrypto makes people so ideological and emotional. if you put down the pitchforks and think for a second. Bitcoin is just an insurance. Store cash under the mattress if you don’t like it. Just understand that the people who in it aren’t stupid or in a Ponzi scheme. Personally, living without insurance in case centralized financial instruments lock me out out is an insane risk to take.
- cuteboy19 5y agoThis is like saying that Amway is not a ponzi because you happen to like their essential oils. What makes Bitcoin a ponzi scheme is its economics and the way that it is promoted. That you find some use in the token is almost incidental
- qalmakka 5y agoThe problem with cryptocurrencies is not the _idea_ per se, it's that every current and proposed implementation is deeply flawed and utterly fails to deliver on what it promises, to the point that crypto mostly stands afloat only as a mean to enable economical speculation and to facilitate unregulated and illegal transactions. I also agree with the idea that teleportation and faster-than-light travel would be extremely beneficial if not necessary for the long term success of the human species, but that does not mean that any proposal or attempt to accomplish those should be immediately hailed as a success. Cryptocurrency is definitely a failure at being what it was supposed to be, there's very little doubt regarding that I'm afraid.
- dylkil 5y agoThe second problem is some of the smartest people in the world rather point out its flaws than recognise the potential and help fix the flaws
- qalmakka 5y agoImagine you woke up one day set on the intention of digging a tunnel to China in your backyard by only using cutlery. Would throwing more people in the hole armed with spoons fix the inherent issues with your project? The reason why there are lots of experts criticizing the current implementations and crypto concepts is because it's vastly easier to realize the flaws in one's idea than coming up with a new proposal. Yes, PoW works but it does not make sense, it's just a very interesting gimmick that makes cryptocurrency doable. That does not mean it actually makes sense or that it represents a stable foundation for a digital currency in practice.
- datadata 5y agoIn the digging example, the goal is to complete the tunnel. If the tunnel is not completed, the project would be a failure. You say that PoW works and makes cryptocurrency doable, yet you conclude that it is a failure. But you don't define what the goal of it is. What specific goal would you want crypto to achieve to falsify your belief that it is a failure?
- zoiul3 5y agoCanada just made the warrantless asset seizure permanent (running past the duration of the Emergencies Act). This is a warmup/trial to implement the same policies in the USA.
- someguydave 5y agono, the Canadian version is worse because I don't believe they even need to inform the court what they are doing
- StewardMcOy 5y agoI don't support these policies, but they are already well in place in the USA. They don't need Canada to perform a trial run. The US has has a long history with warrantless asset seizure, the most recent being the laws passed in the 1980s and still used today with the stated intention of curbing the illicit drug trade. In short, officers can size cash, valuables, vehicles, and property they believe might be used in a crime. Simply traveling with a few hundred dollars or more can be considered suspicious. Hundreds of millions of dollars are sized every year by police this way. The US government can also freeze bank accounts of people they believe to be involved in crimes. In all these cases, victims can go to court to reclaim what was taken from them and to get their accounts unfrozen. The same is true with what happened in Canada. There is very little difference with what is already the reality in the US.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- devops000 5y agoHow about converting BTC to USD? This will always be centralized and your bank could always block the incoming transaction.
- HL33tibCe7 5y ago> the Canadian prime minister imposed martial law on the protestors No, he didn’t.
- drewcoo 5y agoTechnically the War Measures Act, which the Emergencies Act replaced, was not considered martial law either. We can all understand what this really is in spirit, though, and I don't think anyone is claiming literally that the military is in charge.
- wobblyasp 5y agoGrifters gonna grift anyway they can. For anyone interested in knowing what the emergency act actually entails, and why it's not the war measures act, Elizabeth May has a fairly decent, if not long, speech during the debate: https://youtu.be/-iPsgfuum2c https://youtu.be/-iPsgfuum2c
- givemeethekeys 5y agoAre you saying, "no he didn't in theory" or "no he didn't in theory or in practice" ?
- arcticbull 5y agoNo he didn't either way, because that's not what the Emergencies Act is or does. [1, 2] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergencies_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergencies_Act [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-iPsgfuum2c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-iPsgfuum2c
- guilhas 5y agoSo what do you call closing people bank accounts because they donated 50$ to a protest? https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10535361/Canadian-MP-says-single-mom-bank-account-frozen-donating-50-Freedom-Convoy.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10535361/Canadian-M...
- allisdust 5y agoThe thing with democracies is, their rot and death is often not visible from within the democracy. As a sad spectator outside the North America, I can confidently predict the end of democracy in this continent is continuing at a rapid pace. Due to the nature of resentment, you can never extinguish it by more ruthless measures. Small periodic eruptions is what keeps a volcano from having a bigger bang. When you close every vent, you just create a lot more pressure inside. My prediction would be civil war in both countries in coming decades if the current schism between the left and right doesn't get filled soon. Media and politicians started this fire for their own gains and its raging in every heart without anyone in control.
- pictur 5y agoThis guy is really weird. I wanted to take the article seriously and read it, but halfway through I laughed and hung up.
- StanislavPetrov 5y agoThis whole episode is a lesson about the danger of unchecked, centralized power. Any government that has the power to act unilaterally to destroy (financially or otherwise) and imprison anyone they deem "bad" is a government that is a threat to the freedom of everyone. It doesn't matter how benevolent you think they are, or they claim to be. The existence of this power itself is the problem. That's why transparency, checks and balances are so important. Far too many people who claim to believe in freedom and civil rights are actually authoritarians who are merely content that the authoritarians in charge are currently aiming their unlimited power at people they don't like (in many cases, having been conditioned not to like by media arms of the state). It shouldn't matter how much you dislike the truckers or their cause to be aghast at the actions of the Canadian government.
- nathanaldensr 5y agoI completely agree. I never thought I'd see so many blatant authoritarian would-be tyrants coming out of the woodwork as I've seen here on HN since the protest began.
- wildrhythms 5y agoAnti-vaccine pro-crypto CEO who spends his time retweeting bored ape avatars on Twitter telling everybody about how crypto will save us. Please tell me more!
- _aleph2c_ 5y agoMike Solana calls this Trudeau's rainbow-colored iron fist: https://www.piratewires.com/p/shock-and-awe?utm_source=url https://www.piratewires.com/p/shock-and-awe?utm_source=url
- ayngg 5y agoI wonder if the chaotic noise dominates social awareness because people are simply unaware of the macro trends influencing them, or the more charitable explanation that they are aware they exist but accept they are helpless to change them. Either way, this entire ordeal has basically solidified my position that as a society we are woefully unequipped to solve any of the major problems that threaten us. People are so preoccupied with the audacity of x doing y that dominates the news cycle, but nobody seems to actually care why x is doing y. They just slap some shallow explanation like they are white supremacists, or they are mad George Floyd was killed because of police brutality and consider that level of understanding to be satisfactory while simultaneously being concerned about how increasingly divided, populist and radicalized western society is becoming.
- _aleph2c_ 5y agoI think that there are answers out there, many coming from Stephen Kotkin, a man who destroyed his eye sight studying Stalin, who is an expert on the collapse of the Soviet Union, and who is trying to reboot the American diplomatic service. He talks about how we in the west must stop demonizing each other. We have the ability to solve our problems, but our political parties make it impossible to get the right people on our ballots. (In Canada I just join all the parties and vote within them, since a vote within is worth 50 votes without). Kotkin is non-partisan, and we should all take notice of what he says. video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ul1gsIdlJFs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ul1gsIdlJFs transcripts: https://www.hoover.org/research/5-questions-stephen-kotkin-1 https://www.hoover.org/research/5-questions-stephen-kotkin-1
- Ambix 5y agoThanks for Kotkin recommendation, looks very interesting
- arcticbull 5y agoThis is full of factual errors, and garbage on the face of it. Canada is a rule-of-law, democratic society. The so-called protestors blocked off major ports of entry leading to material harm to businesses. They also violated the rights of individuals living within the downtown core (including my family) for weeks on end. They brought weapons with them, they built shanties and filled them with kerosene and propane. The plurality of Canadians voted for the government and the imposition of its lawful and constitutional restrictions in re: COVID. Were they unlawful or in violation of Charter rights, they could have used the courts but elected not to. Because they are lawful and in keeping with the Charter. Two thirds of Canadians support the use of the Emergencies Act in breakup up the unlawful protests. As the elder Trudeau said in the October Crisis re: the use of the military (which the junior Trudeau is not planning on doing): Yeah, well there's a lot of bleeding hearts around who just don't like to see people with helmets and guns. All I can say is, go on and bleed, but it's more important to keep law and order in this society than to be worried about weak-kneed people who don't like the looks of a soldier's helmet. If you want to change the Government, vote. Trudeau's Liberals are a minority government meaning they require the support of another major party to continue to be a government. If they fail to pass a confidence bill they will immediately be dissolved and face an election. The average tenure of a minority government in Canada is 1 year, 140 days. The use of Bitcoin in this manner is anti-Democratic as it seeks to overturn the lawful, constitutional decisions of the plurality - and to overturn the last election. We have ways of sorting this out in Canada. You vote. If you see yourself supporting these anti-Democratic viewpoints, ask yourselves: "Are we the baddies?" [edit] Not only did I not vote for the Liberals in the last election, I'm open to re-evaluating the COVID restrictions too. But not with a boot to the neck. The unlawful protests must end. Then we can talk.
- ComradePhil 5y agoThere's voting in Democratic Republic of Korea too. It doesn't help if anyone speaking against the mass propaganda is silenced.
- arcticbull 5y ago> There's voting in Democratic Republic of Korea too. Wow that's a really interesting fact about North Korea that has absolutely and unequivocally nothing to do with Canada. > It doesn't help if anyone speaking against the mass propaganda is silenced. Except they're not. So. After all, I can hear you now, Comrade Phil. Consider than rather than being silenced, people may just not agree with these fringe positions?
- moralestapia 5y ago
- dinkleberg 5y agoThis isn't Hey's blog, but instead his personal blog. They built a blogging platform into their product.
- BoGs83 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sneak 5y agoIn 2011 I gave a talk in Germany at the Chaos Communications Camp entitled "Financing the Revolution" which makes the argument that uncensorable payment systems are an essential prerequisite for a free society, as without them, you cannot exercise basic rights: https://media.ccc.de/v/cccamp11-4591-financing_the_revolution-en https://media.ccc.de/v/cccamp11-4591-financing_the_revolutio... I cited the banking blockade by Visa, Mastercard, and PayPal used against Wikileaks/Assange as evidence that, at the very least, publishers need to be able to send and receive payments that the state does not wish them to be able to send or receive. Last week, I wrote about how we as a society need to be prepared specifically for user-friendly, widespread unstoppable payments, as the technology now exists for actually private, uncensorable payments to reach a wide audience. https://sneak.berlin/20220213/unstoppable-payments-are-coming/ https://sneak.berlin/20220213/unstoppable-payments-are-comin...
- bryanlarsen 5y agoCanadians have a right to protest. Canadians also have a right to the enjoyment of their property. The former does not override the latter, and the latter was severely infringed upon by the occupiers. These protests caused hundreds of millions of dollars worth of damage. There is a $300M lawsuit against the occupiers in Ottawa, similar ones will happen against the occupiers of the Ambassador bridge. The bank accounts have been frozen via two different mechanisms -- by the use of the Emergency Measures Act, and by a preliminary ruling in the civil court. The freezing via the EMA would thaw after the EMA expires in a few days. The freezing by the civil court will not, and will likely result in the loss of those bank accounts.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- stunt 5y agoI think a better approach was to fine individuals for breaking the law.
- bb88 5y agoThe first option is criminal, which is fine/imprisonment or both. The second option is civil, which are lawsuits against the protesters to recoup losses by businesses. And then if crypto is a possibility, one could say you have to seize the assets now before they can be laundered, in other words, you're pre-empting the potential of illegal behavior.
- lowkey 5y ago> The freezing via the EMA would thaw after the EMA expires in a few days. The PM is on the record admitting he is considering extending the Emergency Measures Act, potentially for months. His Minister of Finance has already declared she now plans to make some of the financial controls permanent. Whether or not you believe these measures to be appropriate, it is incorrect to claim they will expire in the next few days. Question: "Hello from the CBC, the truckers could come back in 2 months, 3 months, so does that mean we would have to keep it for another 2, 3 months?" Trudeau: "Indeed. This is something we are thinking about, of course."
- russdpale 5y ago
- bb88 5y agoMoney Laundering for Good is still money laundering. For all the good that people say it has, it is undeniable that it will enable evil when oppressive governments have new ways to project power untraceably. Whether you love or hate the CIA, the CIA will project power this way, and probably already has. And there are a lot of people who hate the CIA. But it wouldn't be that hard to expect to see black market arms deals be done over crypto. Or payment to terrorists (and their families) as well.
- Imnimo 5y agoOkay, but crypto already existed when all this transpired. If crypto is such a good idea and would prevent these problems, why didn't they just use it?
- latchkey 5y agohttps://finbold.com/canadas-truckers-turn-to-bitcoin-as-gofundme-ceases-9-million-in-donations/ https://finbold.com/canadas-truckers-turn-to-bitcoin-as-gofu...
- woodruffw 5y agoExcellent question. The post also begs the question: does DHH really think that people in Canada are performing everyday transactions in cryptocurrencies? Donations in those forms would almost certainly be liquidated immediately, into ordinary banking accounts.
- latchkey 5y ago> Donations in those forms would almost certainly be liquidated immediately, into ordinary banking accounts. Not necessarily, p2p and cash.
- woodruffw 5y agoConverting cryptocurrency into fiat outside of the financial system falls under the "don't do two crimes at once" maxim, in this situation.
- latchkey 5y agoThere is nothing illegal about converting crypto to cash in a p2p transaction. You're also US biased with your opinion.
- woodruffw 5y agoMy opinion is “US and Canadian financial law” biased, yes, since that’s the rough domain of interest in this thread. There’s nothing illegal about P2P crypto transfers, assuming that you’re not (1) circumventing currency transaction laws, and (2) paying the appropriate taxes. Since the people who might do P2P transfers in this scenario want to avoid the scrutiny of the law entirely, I think it’s safe to say that this does indeed fall under “doing two crimes at once.”
- john_moscow 5y agoAs someone who was born in the USSR and spent considerable effort trying to figure out why the West made it so much better, I think this is very superficial. Bank accounts are being frozen because currently it is an efficient way to instill fear into anyone thinking of supporting a similar protest in the future. If you eliminate the banking angle, there will be always others. In Russia, they can void your parental rights and send your kids to an orphanage where you won't ever see them. Back in the 80s USSR they could declare dissidents legally insane, forcing them to undergo "experimental treatment". Further back in the 30s, they would just send an unmarked operative car to your apartment and take you for questioning at 3am, after which you won't ever return. These are all the symptoms. The real problem is the centralization of power. Russia was formed by centrally managed conquests, while many Western countries emerged as a compromise between equally powerful entities as early as 800+ years ago [0]. There's no trick to it - people only respect law if their opponents respect it as well, both knowing that the alternative (mutual destruction or an exhausting fight) is more expensive. In the peaceful times, power is mostly an economical thing. You wield power when you own/control products that others depend upon. In a small closed community with a couple of farmers, a few local groceries, small banks, local factories, breweries, etc. the power is distributed. If Alice decides to not sell corn to Bob, he can always go buy it from Carol. This got disrupted by information technology, where Alice and Carol got outcompeted by Mike owning a grocery chain, employing minimum wage employees that decide nothing, and using the leverage to negotiate better prices with the suppliers. It also had a side effect of transferring the power from both Alice and Carol into Mike's hands. As the lower interest rates fueled more mergers, the power became consolidated in fewer and fewer hands. So currently there is a shareholder class getting their income from the capital gains, and the rank-and-file class, working the corporate jobs. There is also a dwindling small business owner class that finds it harder and harder to compete in a market where selling goods below cost fueled by endless capital is just fine. The shareholder class holds most of the power, owns most media companies, and is using it to facilitate further transfer of wealth from the employee class (e.g. the move from owning suburban houses to renting corporate-owned condos). The rank-and-file class and small business class appear to be fighting each other over invented identity issues, pushed by the corporate media, and fail to recognize how they are both being robbed by the corporate class. I don't think using distributed ledgers to hold your savings/pay for your expenses will solve the underlying problem. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magna_Carta https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magna_Carta
- bradgranath 5y agoBitcoin/Crypto does not solve any of these problems and only makes them worse.
- MichaelZuo 5y agoDiscussing the politics of a country that the vast majority of HN readers do not understand in-deth in response to a rant by someone else who also only has cursory understanding is adding useless noise to HN. Canada has never been about ‘life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness’, bar a small minority. In many areas it is closer to the EU than the U.S. In fact these rants are self-defeating as they convince ever more voting Canadians that the whole fiasco was boosted to an unnatural degree by self-interested U.S. based groups, and thus further legitimizing the crackdown.
- defaultname 5y agoIt is sobering whenever this topic appears on HN (though thankfully this time it seemed to be flagged directly off the first three pages immediately, and perhaps DHH's low quality pablum has been properly binned) because it really resets my perception of the quality of comments here. Like reading a newspaper or magazine article on a field you happen to know in detail, making you realize that what you thought were considered, informed opinions are actually just people giving uninformed, careless takes. Strongly held, highly emotional opinions that are built on a tower of, in essence, shit. It's someone telling you, with great passion and confidence, that the Linux kernel needs to be rewritten in Visual Basic because the current PHP code isn't maintainable. Throughout these comments, and in hot takes like DHH's, there are just profoundly ignorant errors that betray that the speaker doesn't have the slightest clue what they're talking about. It instantly reveals their rhetoric to be noisy garbage.
- seanp2k2 5y agoMedia these days is just about exposure to sell ad space. The only credential required to be an influencer is the ability to influence via any means.
- mardifoufs 5y agoYet Europeans and canadians are allowed to discuss American politics and even completely trash American values repeatedly. It's funny to see canadians be so defensive when someone else does it to us when we are usually extremely smug about doing exactly the same to our southern neighbors. And by the way no, sorry but that's absurd. There's a huge line between being a freedom gun loving American and being against enacting emergency measures that do away with due process because of a protest. To think canadians support this just to... own the Americans online? Is so ridiculous that it might border on satire. Remember, trudeau is still in a minority government and lost popular vote twice in a row to the conservative party. The conservative party has voted against enacting emergency measures. So you might be living in a bubble where everyone actually supports this, but it's not representative of the electorate. Trudeau is completely, completely losing it and that's coming from someone who has met him a few times when he was my MP. I also volunteered for his campaign back in 2015 and 2019. Yet to me he seems completely unhinged at this point.
- disambiguation 5y agoHas crypto solved the 51% problem yet? I like that crypto is resistant to government control, but just because its decentralized doesn't mean it can't be manipulated and used against me.
- neilk 5y agoLet’s be real here. If you’re only getting angry now, you don’t care about democracy. You care about your goddamned Bored Apes and other ways of doing end runs around financial controls. The convoy is anti-democratic. It is not a protest in the conventional sense. They are not petitioning for concerns to be heard; they are asking to be treated as if they were the real government. Many of them have bizarre legal theories and even started to swear each other in as peace officers to justify resisting with deadly force. The end goal of their actions were to get the government to declare itself illegitimate. Hey, I am often skeptical of the state too, but given the convoyers’ aims I would not expect the government to even talk to them. Be real. This was no protest, and it wasn’t even analogous to an Occupy Wall Street action. A bunch of gullible people who had their brains hollowed out by Q, Facebook and Fox, led by opportunistic white supremacists and at least one literal Nazi, descended on the capital and crucial economic chokepoints to cause mayhem. There were a shocking number of US and Trump flags. In my city, these shitheads scheduled a convoy to pass by every major hospital and disrupt access. The organizers seem to believe doctors and nurses are in on the conspiracy. The hospital workers were advised not to wear scrubs in public lest they be harassed or attacked. I’m happy that Vancouver bicyclists stepped in to block them. But they wandered aimlessly around my neighborhood, and I have friends who’ve been harassed on the street for wearing masks. It’s very tempting to let the state fuck these assholes up. But I’ve been involved in a lot of protests and I expect these emergency powers to be used against more admirable causes next. If you actually care about limiting the powers of the state, the answer is not to clutch your fucking crypto even harder. As already noted, the government can act against financial institutions and laundered coins and assets will be tracked. Do something useful like donate to civil liberties associations, such as the CCLA, which has taken a stance against abuses of emergency powers and will bring a suit against the Canadian government. https://ccla.org/press-release/ccla-calls-for-revocation-of-declaration-of-emergency/ https://ccla.org/press-release/ccla-calls-for-revocation-of-...
- ykevinator2 5y agoI love the glamor shot, get over yourself.
- alainchabat 5y agoKraken exchange's CEO said they'll comply to any juridiction decision, and recommend to get cryptos out of custodial platforms (theirs included) [1] [1] https://twitter.com/jespow/status/1494462097161220104 https://twitter.com/jespow/status/1494462097161220104
- janandonly 5y agoWe don't need "crypto" but we do need Bitcoin. From the article: > And that it was the Canadians who brought this on? You might as well have told me that it was really the Care Bears who ran Abu Ghraib. > Especially since I had some sympathy with fears projected by the US progressive left who spent four years fretting Trump might pull stunts like these. Then it turns out that the worries of an authoritarian overreach would be fulfilled by Trudeau to the North instead? Who's writing this script? M. Night Shyamalan? > Meanwhile, plenty of American commentators are cheering this on. Those terrible, horrible, no-good, very-bad truckers got what they deserved! To protest for a repeal of pandemic restrictions, so as to live the life enjoyed in Denmark by a population less vaccinated than the Canadians? That's clearly beyond the pale!
- croes 5y agoStrange that's always their freedom but not the freedom of others. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/ottawa/truck-convoy-downtown-ottawa-residents-mental-health-1.6333674 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/ottawa/truck-convoy-downtown-... Pretty egomaniac
- kaffee 5y agoThe most recent episode (#118) of Law Bytes with Michael Geist (a respected Canadian law professor) goes into the legal nitty gritty about the use of the Emergency Measures Act. Here's the link: https://tunein.com/podcasts/Technology-Podcasts/Law-Bytes-A-Podcast-With-Michael-Geist-p1214872/?topicId=170010496 https://tunein.com/podcasts/Technology-Podcasts/Law-Bytes-A-... Having just listened to it, I will say the restrictions on Canadians using the banking system to donate to the truckers sound sweeping.
- _9omd 5y agoI think a lot of people are missing the big picture here, because they're against the trucker protest. It's actually quite possible to think the trucker protest was stupid, and incredibly damaging to locals (via noise pollution and sleep deprivation), while still being pro crypto (I am). The question is not is crypto valuable because of this one protest. The question is, what happens when you DO agree with a protest against the state. In that case, wouldn't you want a censorship resistant currency as a way of fueling peaceful revolution? Crypto is no about dismantling the state. It's about the recognition that the state is no infallible, and on a long enough timeline will make decisions that are harmful to citizens. Crypto is an insurance policy against corruption and power, which can happen anywhere.
- berkes 5y agoFully agree. I too dislike the protest, the methods, the cause, the goal. Yet I see the benefit in something that operates separate from the state. To rewrite my common quote on this, using your phrase: "Crypto is not about dismantling the state. It's about decoupling from the state".
- _9omd 5y ago> "Crypto is not about dismantling the state. It's about decoupling from the state". Love it, I think I'll be using this saying from now on.