2 ms·
why can't the metric eliminate outlier students? This is what they do in competitive sports that require judges like ice-skating or diving; you remove the top a
by chii 5y ago
why can't the metric eliminate outlier students? This is what they do in competitive sports that require judges like ice-skating or diving; you remove the top and bottom score, and average the rest.
A school should not be judged on the best students they have, nor the worst. They ought to be judged on the most prominent outcomes for students - the middle.
A school could get a higher score, even if they take in bad students or ESL students, or disabled students. The metric for measurement should remove those students' contributions (as they are likely the ones dragging down the metric), unless those students reach some middling score (in which case, they don't affect the over all metric much). Ditto with the super-genius students.
- singron 5y agoStudent performance doesn't entirely depend on individual circumstances, it depends on the environment and the other students around them. The special ed students require more resources. E.g. they usually have more staff, sometimes 1:1 aides, dedicated rooms, special classes. Beyond the resources explicitly allocated for them, they also take up common resources. E.g. if they are mixed into a normal class, the teacher usually has to spend disproportionately more time on them, either 1:1 in the classroom or in prep for customized learning plans. Informally bad students are worse in some ways since they don't necessarily get additional resource allocation (like an ESL or special ed student would), but will distract the rest of the classroom. It would only make sense if they completely segregated those students, which (AFAIK) is very bad for those students.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoSome schools are dominated by outlier students. What do you when you have a school of 500 students in a blighted community and the average GPA is less than 0.15? >https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/baltimore-school-report-failing-students-promoted https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/baltimore-school-rep...
- hiptobecubic 5y agoThen they aren't "outliers" are they?
- s1artibartfast 5y agoFor the school, no. For the general population, yes.