7 ms·
Will Robots Steal Your Job?
- hefangdotcom 15y agoI have no worries... My job is show respects to my boss.
- jleyank 15y agoNot until they figure out how robots can program. As we're not sure WE know how to program (or program correctly), it looks to be a meta-problem right now. Or, has there been AI advances that the blogs haven't talked about. Others have pointed out that foreign workers are cheaper than robots. Perhaps this will change when oil prices go through the roof, but for now biologicals are the preferred choice.
- ebiester 15y agoWe're still fine. We're probably fine for the next twenty or fifty years. Manufacturing jobs are not fine, and they haven't been fine for a while. That's not just China -- the manufacturing that is done in this country (and Germany, and China) has become increasingly automated. They're working on Agriculture, and as computer vision improves (as it's doing now) the agricultural jobs are going to fall through the floor. First, it will be robots that pick the easiest fruit, and humans finish the job. Then, the robots will get better and better, and eventually the humans will be too expensive to get the remnants. The hidden piece to the law puzzle is that lawyers are becoming increasingly efficient. Why do we need pharmacy techs anymore? Just design the pharmacy to auto-dispense the drugs, and have the pharmacist there to answer questions and give the directions. As it is, technology is reducing the number of people who work in grocery stores. I'm sure that Walmart will figure out a way to automate stocking in the next ten years. How close are we to machine learning and Radiology? Someone has to be working on a "See chart. See expert radiologist opinion. Give computer percentage and expert recommendation side by side. Put results afterward into computer to help train machine." workflow? How long, after that, is the machine learning better than the radiologist, who concentrates on a smaller and smaller number of hard cases? How long after that, is a robot woodworker better than a human one? The robotic one can choose to leave human-like imperfections or not. Now, which of these seem unlikely, given what we know about machine learning and computer vision algorithms? It's not that the problem is hard as much as the computing power/$ isn't there. Yet.
- Uhhrrr 15y agoWoodworking knowledge actually goes pretty deep. If you don't have a feel for each piece, it's easy to break blades, cause fires, or have bits go flying. It's achievable, but I agree with your putting it after radiology.
- kiba 15y agoQuestion: how will the unemployed find the money to purchase said good dispensed by machines? Machines need markets to sustain their existence or else their owners abandon them or turn them into scrap parts.
- doyoulikeworms 15y agoThis has happened a lot in history, but I'm no historian. The way I understand it, the automation (or technological improvement) of an industry lowers prices, and therefore helps another industry. Consumers to pay less for products, so extra funds directly (purchases) or indirectly (savings, investment) flow into new industries. In the short term, workers displaced by automation are unemployed, but in the long term, they have growing employment opportunities elsewhere (or even in the same industry, later). What's more, I feel like once automation takes hold in an industry, efficiency gains must accelerate relative to human laborers-- helping everyone. Sure, greater education and methodological improvements help humans to produce more for cheaper, but Moore's Law is a hell of an ally. IANAE(conomist), but I couldn't explain why the world didn't disintegrate after the Industrial Revolution(s) any other way.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoIt's likely that a small number of high skilled humans (read: AI programmers, artists, and a few others) will have a functioning market among themselves. The remainder of humanity will subsist on some flavor of socialism. Most likely they will have a higher standard of living than the middle class today, but inequality will be dramatically higher.
- intended 15y agoAt some point though, the ones subsidizing the others will say no.
- fleitz 15y agoYou may want to look into compilers, barely anyone programs computers anymore.
- wladimir 15y agoGood point, and frequently overlooked. Higher-level languages are already increasing programming productivity. And this is only the beginning. Combined with automated testing/fuzzing and verification and code generation from high-level models, this could increase even more. No strong AI required. It's just that so much programming work is required that we don't notice it in terms of less programming jobs. Of course, there's no saying what will happen in 25,50,100 years...
- ryandvm 15y agoI hope so. The decades between when the robots start doing all our jobs and when they rise up against us are going to be easy street.
- ChrisNorstrom 15y agoI find this ASTRONOMICALLY interesting! I wonder what will happen to us... In the past, JOBS were a way to redistribute money and keep the money cycle flowing. The rich who owned companies are rich because the average consumer pays for their products and services. The rich then hire workers and pass money down to them, as well as spend money on other products made by other workers. But as unemployment reaches 20% then 30% then 40% over the next 50-100 years. We'll have to readjust the way we redistribute money in order to keep the money cycle going. Otherwise the rich will get richer and the poor will get poorer, to a point, then the whole system will collapse because who will have the money to buy your products. If the middle and lower class don't have any money to spend on the products that the company using robots makes... Product creators will effective kill off their own wealth machine. Decades ago 80%+ of everything we bought was made in our own country, now that number has dwindled down to, 20% was it? It was some terrible small number. Outsourcing to China was good in the short term (cheaper more affordable products) and terribly destructive in the long term (disrupting the money cycle and destroying jobs). Now everyone in the US is pissed off about unemployment, we're passing all sorts of job bills and stimuliouses, while we're all ignoring the giant elephant in the room. We pissed our jobs away in the name of cheaper products (consumers are just as guilty as shareholders). Look at what outsourcing to China has done. Rich get richer, poor got poorer, then the economy tanked because consumers don't have money to spend on the products the rich make. Now imagine what automation is going to do... Driverless buses and subways (already in testing / already in use) that don't go on strike, robots that fix robots (almost there) and never ask for a raise. Robot pharmacists that don't make mistakes (already in testing). Robotic construction workers that don't join unions. The people who own these businesses that employ robots over humans will make tremendous profits and save lives and do a better, faster job too. But they will HAVE to redistribute their money using a new method. Socialism? Who knows. I'm not afraid of this future where robots take over. In fact I'm looking forward to it. I'm just afraid of our refusal to adjust to it.
- eugenejen 15y agoI think if labor is completely replaced by robots, then society has to choose socialization of all means of productions in order to maintain political stability.
- 15y ago
- georgieporgie 15y agoIn the next decade, we'll see machines barge into areas of the economy that we'd never suspected possible—they'll be diagnosing your diseases, dispensing your medicine, handling your lawsuits, making fundamental scientific discoveries, and even writing stories just like this one. That's really, really optimistic. The only one which seems plausible (and probably a great idea in terms of eliminating human error) in the reasonably near term is dispensing medicine. As in taking a clearly encoded prescription from a verified doctor and dispensing precisely the drug indicated. That still, though, won't eliminate the pharmacist, just a few of the technicians. As for diagnosing diseases, they were working on expert systems to do that since the 70's. It has hope to be a great tool, but the doctor is still responsible for interpreting the statements of the patient, recognizing symptoms, and feeding the correct data into the system. I don't see skilled knowledge workers being threatened for quite awhile. If I were going to spread FUD about automation, I would be pointing at RedBox and saying that it's paving the way toward automating low-end service jobs.
- baddox 15y agoAs I understand it, expert system can be quite accurate and effective in diagnosis (if fed accurate input of symptoms, which would still require a physician or at least a trained technician). The problem is always public perception and liability. Medicine is as much about instilling people with confidence as it is with actually healing them. Some (most?) people would shy away from the idea of an automated diagnosis. Also, a bad diagnosis (even if it was caused by improper input into the expert system) introduces a quagmire of liability.
- spc476 15y agoOdd, the results of MYCIN (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mycin http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mycin) were more accurate than doctors, and that was with 70s computer technology. And while not as nearly entertaining to watch as House, MYCIN was probably much easier to get along with.
- georgieporgie 15y agoMYCIN diagnoses only infectious diseases, and does so only with a considerable amount of human input. IMO that doesn't really constitute replacing people. It's basically an interactive book of diseases combined with a statistical analysis expert.
- troymc 15y agoSome fiction exploring this idea (and more): * Manna, by Marshall Brain, http://marshallbrain.com/manna1.htm http://marshallbrain.com/manna1.htm * Accelerando, by Charles Stross (goes way farther than Slate.com will ever go), http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accelerando_%28novel%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accelerando_%28novel%29 --- note that you can download the full text for free (licensed CC-BY-NC-ND).
- mtgentry 15y agoFor those of you who have your doubts, this is the bottom line for me: Corporate America is raking in the cash even though the economy is lousy. They don't NEED to hire new workers. They're doing fine without them, that's the thing no one in DC will talk about. Small businesses will rescue the country you say? I'm not so sure. I own a reusable water bottle company. All of my warehousing and shipping needs are done by a fulfillment house (which does the same thing for other small businesses). Our shipping and warehousing needs are shared. And most of my marketing can be done through MailChimp,Twitter etc. I don't need to hire any workers either. Worse still, let's say my competition has 5-10 employees. All things being equal, I can undercut them ruthlessly if I wanted to because I have lower overhead. I think an easy way to keep tabs on all of this is to simply look at unemployment. If it stays around 10% for another few years, it seems like we have a STRUCTURAL unemployment problem on our hands. And one of the causes is surely automation.
- WalterBright 15y ago>And one of the causes is surely automation. People have been saying that since the first mechanised loom machines appeared 200 years ago.
- mtgentry 15y agoTotally agree, but that was one sector. Automation is disrupting every industry it can. Economists say those disrupted workers will adjust and learn new skills, but Martin Ford and many others think their numbers will be too vast and the available positions will be too few.
- bermanoid 15y agoAnd they were just as right back then as they are now about the fundamental problem: fewer and fewer humans, over time, have anything of value to contribute to the economy. Come strong AI, and that number will rapidly drop to zero, and even the people that specialize in AI will quickly become useless in comparison to their creations... People may disagree about exactly when that will happen, but 20 years is probably a good inside guess computationally speaking, and anything much past 40 would mean that we really dropped the ball on AI software research (which is definitely possible, to be fair), so I'm not really so hot on the idea of writing off these concerns as overly premature or ill conceived. People were way off 200 years ago, but these days the literal end of human usefulness is visible on a very real horizon, possibly within our lifetimes.
- jjmaxwell4 15y agoPG brought the most important defense against this argument the last time an article like this got posted. Why this time? Technology, including automation, has been around for the past 60 years, but we have only gotten richer. When the declaration of independence was signed, it took 19 out of every 20 people to feed America and provide and surplus for export. Today it takes 1 out of every 20 people to do the same thing. Did jobs disappear? Did we have unemployment at 10%? No. People adapted, and got jobs doing things that were useful and beneficial to the economy. Robots will take revolutionize many industries, just like software is right now, but it won't mean the demise of the economy. In fact it will be a huge boon, and we will continue to advance as we have been for the past 500 years. By nearly any measure possible, we are better off today then 50 years ago. Technology is no small part of that.
- mynameishere 15y agoOf course, this is not a question of GDP, but of employment, or idleness. Machines are beautiful creatures, (as long as they don't involve deflagrants or explosives) and they make everyone richer. But people are people, and the differences between a stupid employed person, and a stupid unemployed person are tremendous. Even when their bellies are equally full. The unemployment rate of post-graduate-degree holders is about 2 percent, and the rate among high school dropouts is almost 20 percent. This will not change. It will get worse. There is an aristocracy emerging of the intelligent/educated and the rest. It will get worse and worse, until you have 80 percent, then 85 percent, then 90 percent of the population economically useless. These predictions have been going on for decades (see "Player Piano" by Vonnegut). They are just now coming true.
- astrofinch 15y ago"Why this time?" Why not this time? Arguing from historical trends is a weak form of argument, especially when we are discussing something as complicated as the human economy (humans are complicated enough, it's hard to say much for certain about their economy). Anyway there's data suggesting this transformation is already happening: http://www.bing.com/search?q=median+wages+adjusted+for+inflation http://www.bing.com/search?q=median+wages+adjusted+for+infla... I'm tentatively in favor of this change – I don't see how having efficient, intelligent, cheap means of production can hurt human civilization in the long run, so long as we can work out resource allocation challenges.
- zeteo 15y ago> robotic lawyers will bring cheap legal services to the masses who can't afford lawyers today. Just what in the world is a robotic lawyer good for?! It's hard to imagine a profession in which a weird corporeal presence might actually be less useful. Yes, databases and expert systems are taking up a lot of the work that fresh law school graduates were doing a few decades ago. So the poor humans these days need to spend more time with badly paid and unexciting activities, like confronting hostile witnesses and persuading juries...
- wladimir 15y agoA lot of lawyer work consists of document analysis, which could be done by a advanced IBM-watson-like systems. The point is not that it will replace all lawyers, but all-in-all, they have less work, so less people can be employed full time (same with doctors, and maybe even programmers, don't think we're safe ;) ).
- ajuc 15y agoAlready happening - for now in the small niches - like systems that allow lay man to search law (less demand for lawyers), or systems that handle routine cases leaving judges only checking documents and signing them (see my previous comment). There won't be a C3PO walking awkwardly into court room, but some day most of the cases will be handled in the software, leaving controversial matters and appelations to humans.
- mildweed 15y agoAt some point, when all the means of production and deduction are automated, capitalism will likely collapse. My input to society as an individual will come from my human qualities, not from my labor or reasoning qualities. Star Trek TNG's society seems more prophetic every day.
- natmaster 15y agoThese luddites completely understand the situation. Software will simply replace the menial parts of jobs, leaving only the more interesting parts left to humans. In other words, you'll be able to do more with what you have, and you won't be bored out of your mind doing repetitive tasks. In math: The Boyer-Moore theorem solver. This completely replaces a mathematicians job of proving theorems, right? Wrong. It replaces the menial task of connecting the steps, and making sure the proof is correct. Mathematicians can now focus on the bigger picture, more complicated proofs, instead of wasting time verifying the correctness of their proof. In law: I'm not familiar with the exact system name, but there are systems that make retrieving huge legal databases to find relevant cases much much easier. This replaces the menial legal-aide jobs, but not the creative aspect of figuring out how to tie past cases together, present your case in court, etc. (I'm not super familiar with a lawyer's job, but you get the point.) In art: Photoshop makes effects take much less work. I could go on all day. Technology is what creates growth, and those who refuse to learn the new technology deserve to be left behind.
- avdempsey 15y ago"Technology is what creates growth, and those who refuse to learn the new technology deserve to be left behind." You might be right, but it doesn't matter what people deserve. Unfortunately, you may find that those that are left behind will cause untenable social unrest. If job automation outpaces re-training by too great a rate you can kiss civil society goodbye. No one can hold automation back, but we can work to smooth out the anticipated pain. No matter how optimistic you are about growth, we need this spaceship to hold together!
- intended 15y agoAn interesting case may be when technological growth outpaces societies ability to absorb it. Perhaps this is a case of one gear (tech progress) going faster than the others (humanity). Plus I would have to bring in another aspect - the fact that humans age, while machines/tech wont. When you/people grow older, its quite possible that they wont be nimble enough to jump and twist fast enough onto new platforms. In which case you/they are screwed. You can't assume that everyone is going to invest and save away and have perfect retirements/medical situations in their old age either.
- ajuc 15y agoThere are already systems for handling routine court cases (mostly all about "letters before debt recover action" and managing when these payments are due). One in my city - in 2011 it handled almost 1000000 cases already (it employs 102 "judging" persons - 4 judges and 98 "junior judges"). So it is 1000000/(270*102)=36 cases per day per person (not counting free days). Human input is very limited in such systems, and throughput is huge - freeing humans to do more creative work. I can only imagine it getting more automatic every year and handling greater varety of cases. Article about it (in Polish - sorry) - http://wiadomosci.gazeta.pl/Wiadomosci/1,80273,10326080,Jedyny_w_Polsce_e_sad_tonie__Jeszcze_nie_bylo_tak.html http://wiadomosci.gazeta.pl/Wiadomosci/1,80273,10326080,Jedy... I believe AI will be stealing our jobs long before robots will be stealing jobs of cleaners or builders. That's because we are much better at scaling software than hardware. Write program once and it can handle any amount of information given enough processor time. And processor time is commodity now. And special purpose AI is getting better all the time.
- ck2 15y agoTo further the irony, the robots won't even be made in your country but a design outsourced overseas. In about a decade only fundamental services that cannot be automated will be left.