7 ms·
How a Book Is Made – Ink, Paper and a 200k-Pound Printer
- jvandonsel 5y agoContrast that with this old-school book printing process from 1947. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w3rlsj-KEZE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w3rlsj-KEZE
- Thorham 5y agoNow compare that to the early days of printing. That difference is much larger.
- amelius 5y agoWhy isn't more of this process automated?
- Geonode 5y agoI'm sure it is, I doubt for example all the print on demand paperbacks are done like this. So I assume the machines are still used simply because they still work. Maybe the quality is better, but for each of these machines that get replaced I'm sure a minority are replaced with like equipment.
- extrapickles 5y agoIt's likely cheaper to have people that to automate further. One problem with automation is that if you are making bespoke products, engineering and capital costs for the automation cost more than a person. A printing press operator costs ~$67k/year ($45k salary + benefits + etc). Automating a step can easily cost $100-200k, plus 10-20% of that in yearly maintenance, so if the task being performed is changing more than once every few years its cheaper for a person to do it. Humans are very good at tasks involving hand-eye coordination and machines are good at extremely repetitive tasks. Most of the people in the article seemed to be doing tasks that automation is not yet good at. The book cover had standard CMYK printing plus some special inks to help it stand out. Automation could easily check the CMYK inks, but not the special inks, as they likely fall out of the sRGB color range that off the shelf cameras are able to sense (you likely would have to use several BW cameras with special filters).
- alexchamberlain 5y agoThe automated version doesn’t have a human in the loop that can spot problems, errors etc either.
- Finnucane 5y agoAutomation and digital processes have removed a lot of labor in the past few decades. Traditional prepress is history, and makereadies go much faster because of computer controls and scanning systems on press.
- rs999gti 5y agoWhy does this process exist anymore? Book binding might as well go the way of vinyl records. The digital product is just as good if not better. The future of printed books may be just curios that very few people collect, to have a physical product in their hands and for nostalgia.
- dreamcompiler 5y agoDigital books (on e-paper anyway) cannot yet handle the range of colors paper can. OLED can do this much better than paper but it also requires much more energy than e-paper. Long term I wonder how long digital books will last. After the apocalypse paper books will still be readable but will we have the devices, the batteries, the Internet-connected DRM systems etc to read digital books? All that said I still buy mostly e-books when color doesn't matter. I used to own a printing business, so I feel some nostalgia about paper books, but the sheer tonnage of paper books in my house is threatening to condense into a mini black hole, so e-books it is for me from now on.
- gscott 5y agoVinyl records are popular again.
- jdkee 5y agoHave you heard about the resurgence in vinyl record sales? https://www.tennessean.com/story/entertainment/music/2022/01/12/vinyl-music-sales-grow-2021/9168973002/ https://www.tennessean.com/story/entertainment/music/2022/01...
- neonate 5y agohttps://archive.is/DDeA1 https://archive.is/DDeA1
- TuLithu 5y agoWhile I appreciate you sharing this article, my free reads on New York Times have long been used up, and I don't plan to buy a subscription. But I've been to a book "factory" at Anadolu University in Eskisehir, Turkey. The printers ARE huge!
- elorant 5y agoJust delete the cookies
- dylan604 5y agoshhh, it's a secret!!!
- jason-phillips 5y ago...or browse in private mode
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoIt's leet hacking in Missouri.
- dylan604 5y agoI'm beginning to think that owning a browser is hacking in Missouri
- TuLithu 5y agoWhat are cookies? Just kidding. I always forget stuff like that. Thanks for the "Pro Tip"
- gordon_freeman 5y agocheck out if your local library allows a 1 or 3-day passes of NYTimes digital, for example LAPL [1] and Berkley PL [2] allows something like this: [1] https://www.lapl.org/new-york-times-digital https://www.lapl.org/new-york-times-digital [2] https://www.berkeleypubliclibrary.org/explore/elibrary/new-york-times-digital-edition https://www.berkeleypubliclibrary.org/explore/elibrary/new-y...
- russellbeattie 5y agoHeh. In the early 90s I studied journalism and graphic design at college, and interned at a small town newspaper in the summers. It was a great learning opportunity - I did everything from writing stories to selling ads to helping run the giant press, including plating, inking and manhandling the 800lb rolls of newsprint onto the machine. Then I went into tech, specifically the web, and literally haven't seen a press in person or stepped into a newsroom since then. If I could, I would go back in time and transfer to UIUC in 1992 instead and go help Marc and Eric develop Mosaic, but what can you do? Anyways, as someone who has done the dirty job (The ink! The ink! Everywhere!) of printing, I really have no illusions about the long lost art of book making going away. It's an inefficient, dirty, dangerous, wasteful business that is, honestly at this point, simply making more landfill.
- mastazi 5y ago> wasteful business that is, honestly at this point, simply making more landfill. I'm pretty sure that, on average, web pages rot much faster than the time it takes a book to reach the landfill. I have lots of books that I got used, many of them for free. There is probably a book exchange in your city as well, look it up.
- russellbeattie 5y agoSo clueless. Have you ever worked at book store? Do you know what happens to unsold inventory? Why don't you look it up? Just because you have a precious book or two you love so much and will cherish forever (well, until you die and your family throws them all away), it doesn't mean that particular book is special in any way. In order for your own copy to get into your grubby little hands, at least a dozen more were printed and destroyed. Something like 77 million unsold books destroyed per year. The waste is mind boggling and in today's world, completely unnecessary. Personally, I like my text on a screen and my trees in the ground as living plants, not landfill.
- mastazi 5y agoWhy do you have to express your opinion in the form of a personal attack? Been a long day? I hope you have a better one tomorrow.
- lai-yin 5y agoMy aunt, recently retired from the printing industry, has regaled me with many tales of the intricacies and complications she went through to print everything from Harry Potter to Jocko Willink. Kindles were also banned from entering her home.
- jason-phillips 5y agoBy all means, regale away!
- daniel-cussen 5y ago> Kindles were also banned from entering her home. There's an idea!
- raffraffraff 5y agoIs that... Kilopounds?
- frosted-flakes 5y agoKilopounds, or just 1000 pounds? K is commonly used as an abbreviation for 1000.
- raffraffraff 5y agoOh I know. I get it. It just sounds weird as F to a European. Imperial scales don't increase in nice multiples of 10/100/1000. I remember Imperial weight measurements as grain, ounce, pound, stone, quarter, hundred weight, ton. In Ireland back in the 70s/80s if you were asked your weight, you'd give it in stones, pounds and ounces (and of course, you had to remember how many of one was in the other). I don't remember "old money" but I'm old enough to remember adults talk about how much something cost "in old money" (£,S,D) and being a child of the 70s, I laughed and wondered how the hell they calculated anything back then when a shilling was 12d and there were 240d in a £. It's why I've always found it odd that the US stuck hard to measurement systems that are inherently difficult to remember and calculate because they don't use multiples of 10/100/1000, and easy type of measurement uses its own words and multiples. So kilopound... Sounds weird.
- frosted-flakes 5y agoYou might find this to be an interesting watch: [1]: https://youtube.com/watch?v=iJymKowx8cY https://youtube.com/watch?v=iJymKowx8cY / "a defense of the imperial measurement system: it's not as bad as people say it is (but it is still pretty bad)" The primary point of the Imperial "system" is that it's not a single system. The fact that there are 5280 feet in a mile might seem insane, but feet and miles are from different systems, and they are used for entirely different things. For example, when driving in a car, distances are measured in miles, and if you were to direct someone to make a turn, you would say "turn right in 0.25 mile", not "700 feet". It's a compelling argument, and it's largely tempered my opinion of the USA's systems of measurement.
- 8bitsrule 5y agoThe process that makes those 800 lb. rolls of paper is every bit as complex and interesting as the printing. I worked in a paper mill for several summers, and later on worked for a couple of years on the lumberjack end (much more fun). The paper-making machines dwarf that printing-press. There are groups of rollers that weigh more than it! (3 minute short-course: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jmgMdDH14sE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jmgMdDH14sE )
- ggm 5y agoInk is the very devil. Too much dense ink in parts of the page can make a nightmare come true. A lot of the invisible smarts are managing ink flow at every level from page layout onward.
- ggm 5y agoBack in the old days, cheap labour coloured in images by hand. Sometimes, they corrected late-stage typos and print errors by hand too. This is sort-of related to the origin story of "tuppence coloured, a penny plain" although thats about prints more than machine printing (although a printed handsheet was pretty mechanised) I've bought books which had correction slips in them (mainly textbooks)
- dreamcompiler 5y agoAnd water flow. Offset printing is lithography, and lithography is a delicate balance between oil (ink) and water.
- ggm 5y agoYea. I'd love to do that. I must think about going to a printmaking workshop and reconnecting with this stuff.
- YaBomm 5y ago
- Ansil849 5y agoI wonder what the carbon footprint of these industrial printing presses is and how it compares to crypto mining or NFTs or whatever it is that's fashionable to complain about nowadays?
- bob1029 5y agoI haven't done the actual math but I'd estimate you could print, bind, package and deliver a book using less energy than it takes to perform a single bitcoin transaction.
- Ansil849 5y agoI'd genuinely be interested in seeing the math behind that reasoning. Not because I think it's true or not true, but because I just genuinely have no idea so would like to see how this sort of comparison is calculated.
- bob1029 5y agoThe last time I actually did do the math, the base figure for completion of 1 bitcoin transaction was somewhere north of a megawatt-hour of electrical energy. To put this in perspective, you could run the "average" American home for over a month with 1 MWh. At scale, I don't think it requires the energy consumption of an entire American household over the course of a month to produce a single book.
- oxplot 5y agoAbout a year ago, I came across a book printing service [1] and didn't realize until that point, how accessible and cheap high quality book printing was. So I collected all the (poetry) content I could from my blog, had my partner take care of the drawings and published a book [2] with a proper ISBN and everything in two weeks. It was a great experience, learning about all different terminologies, layout design, color profiles, etc. The color profile thing was specially tricky. And once we started giving them away to friends and family, I realized how much more effective print media is in the world of endless online content. They all read and talked about it while the same content had been on online on my blog for the past decade or so without it receiving much attention. [1]: https://mixam.com.au/hardcoverbooks https://mixam.com.au/hardcoverbooks [2]: https://books.google.com.au/books/about/Duoverse.html?id=QconzgEACAAJ&redir_esc=y https://books.google.com.au/books/about/Duoverse.html?id=Qco...