11 ms·
Grocery delivery “dark stores” in Amsterdam
- bobcostas55 5y agoIs there any evidence that dark stores are more disruptive than...normal stores? A regular supermarket gets tons of traffic, trucks unloading goods, etc. What's the difference?
- astura 5y agoI suppose you could operate a dark store in a residential neighborhood where it would be impractical to impossible to operate a regular store. Or maybe it's a fluke in zoning laws where they can legally operate a dark store but not a regular store.
- jazzyjackson 5y agoBrings to mind the FreshDirect trucks squatting in the streets of NYC, acting as a mini-warehouse for the bike couriers; its literally free real estate: https://www.reddit.com/r/NYCbike/comments/n6oi0v/a_freshdirect_truck_has_been_squatting_on/ https://www.reddit.com/r/NYCbike/comments/n6oi0v/a_freshdire...
- bogomipz 5y agoAnecdotal and personal observations: Regular grocery stores have dedicated service entrances for deliveries. These dark grocery stores are often just using whatever repurposed single door retail space they could get, i.e places that were built for regular foot traffic retail. Also the amount of ebikes and delivery scooters coming and going on the sidewalks in front of these places, as well as blocking them, has become something a nuisance for pedestrians. While not necessarily "disruptive" but certainly somewhat dystopian feeling - these dark grocery stores just put up paper over the windows. Not transitionally but permanently. It's really not any kind of an improvement over the blight of an empty storefront.
- himlion 5y agoThese shops in Amsterdam are even using converted residential apartments.
- fock 5y agothe normal supermarket (or any non-gig-business) here in Germany has to provide: - parking (bikes/cars/none if only pedestrians are there) - some rest/change area for employees These things cost quite a bit of money. Now, as with most gig-economy "startups" (or should you call them moneybaths?), the "dark stores" require these things too, but at least with the locations I saw, they don't really do that. Essentially their fronts look like a branded homeless-camp. No thanks. Also: can someone explain to me, how this concept will (like that of any other gig-economy company) be realized in any semi-equal society (aka no slavers state). Essentially you'd probably need 2/100 people working for that, nonstop. These people will basically do something which nowadays everyone but the richest people have heavily optimized already, just that it's not supposed to be optimized, because I don't think the idea is a soviet-style "hey, I bring you your allocated food, once a week". The explicit promise is that whoever can afford this, can just call these services on a whim, meaning this is super-inefficient from a societal view (how do you optimize 10min delivery time?). Then, just letting the price decide and having all of services structured that way, you'll essentially get the slavers state, neolib. edition™. Because a lot of people working in these sectors will then be forced to choose the soviet-style solution outlined above (and you already see this!), just without being allowed a say in that matter, because that's how the system is supposed to be, no? What a brave new world!
- Nextgrid 5y ago> how this concept will (like that of any other gig-economy company) be realized in any semi-equal society (aka no slavers state). Essentially you'd probably need 2/100 people working for that, nonstop It can work, just not in a way that Silicon Valley VC bros want it to. Most countries already have a legacy version of this system in place: the post office, as well as a few private courier companies. Those systems' "tick rates" are typically one day - packages are collected at depots/sorting offices early in the morning, assigned to couriers who then spend the rest of the day delivering them. Increasing the tick rate of such a system is possible especially with smaller goods as well as being able to take advantage of more "depots" (for grocery deliveries, supermarkets are essentially the depots) - the costs will obviously be higher, but not prohibitively so. The problem with the current delivery services is that it's fragmented - every company has their own couriers, restaurants/supermarkets, etc where not only is the supply & demand unbalanced, leading to situations where one company's couriers may be sitting idle wasting time loitering (leading to potential antisocial behavior) where anothers' might be overloaded and delivering a poor customer experience with regards to wait times. The system also has the overheads of people staying idle which is currently subsidized by treating these workers like shit and denying them employment rights/benefits. A single marketplace providing an API for moving goods from point A to point B priced by weight, special requirements (refrigerated transport, etc), timeliness and the current state of the market (dynamic pricing) could work. This will allow the system to maximize the efficiency of the people on the ground, being able to consolidate deliveries and reduce waste (bikes or vehicles sitting idle, couriers loitering around, etc). This could be operated by the existing postal system and even use this same infrastructure for mail/package delivery. The above system would undeniably cost more than the current VC-subsidized services which also underpay their workers and treat them like shit in general, but not by an exorbitant amount. Its costs overheads would scale linearly though which is a bad fit for VCs looking to monopolize the world, however as a public service similar to the post office it should be viable.
- Khelavaster 5y agoThis link goes to an error page
- dang 5y agoLooks like a bug in our software that tries to detect canonical URLs. I'll look into it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ruuda 5y agoThere's a crackdown in Utrecht as well: https://www.duic.nl/algemeen/utrecht-legt-flitsbezorgers-aan-banden-zonder-vergunning-niet-meer-welkom-in-woon-of-winkelbuurten/ https://www.duic.nl/algemeen/utrecht-legt-flitsbezorgers-aan... (Dutch) It does feel magic to order groceries and have them at your doorstep in 10 minutes (literally). But it's rarely useful.
- agumonkey 5y agoI thought about offering something like this to neighbors (for small orders) just so they don't drive their car to the bakery (I use a bike).
- user_7832 5y ago> It does feel magic to order groceries and have them at your doorstep in 10 minutes (literally). But it's rarely useful. Please speak for yourself. It might not make much of a difference for you or perhaps many people, but a lot of people like me also find it to be highly convenient. When I'm tired and out of time instead of ordering an unhealthy meal from $FOODDELIVERYAPP$ I can (and very frequently do) buy something relatively healthier from such a site. Of course, the negatives need to be countered too, but their high popularity does indicate I'm unsurprisingly not alone.
- FpUser 5y agoI can't imagine buying produce without actually seeing it.
- user_7832 5y agoVery often the food is a factory-made package (think yogurt/milk carton rather than a broccoli), so there's absolutely no difference in that case. Personally I never buy vegetables like this.
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y agoI’ve used produce delivery services before and rarely have I received a quality that isn’t decent. These people don’t benefit by providing poor service, don’t benefit by providing poor produce.
- the_mitsuhiko 5y agoI use Flink a lot in Vienna. Largely also because shopping hours are so incredibly restrictive here that using Flink is even more convenient than elsewhere. Grocery stores are required by law to close at around 8, but Flink operates two hours longer. And having even larger orders show up within 10 minutes obviously makes this even more convenient. I'm pretty sure this type of business actually fills a niche here.
- cehrlich 5y agoI use it for the same reason. But to be honest the real solution is to expand opening hours of normal grocery stores, or to allow something similar to Off License in the UK / Späti in Germany. It doesn’t make sense that it’s cheaper to have someone bring me beer than it is to go buy it myself.
- mns 5y ago> But to be honest the real solution is to expand opening hours of normal grocery stores. Well, those hours need to be filled in by someone. Just like Uber, these services managed to drive down costs by paying some “contractors” to deliver food to mostly rich and well-off people. Maybe we should offer better working schedules for everyone, instead of exploiting some. Living in a state in Germany where stores close at 8 and on Sunday, I really got used to it and managed to adapt, and I’m sure a lot of the people working there do like the fact they don’t have to work until 10 or on Sundays. > It doesn’t make sense that it’s cheaper to have someone bring me beer than it is to go buy it myself. Yeah, because some of those costs come from the guy delivering your stuff not being an employee.
- kwhitefoot 5y ago
- jlund-molfese 5y agoAs a student, I wasn't able to work a 9-5 job, but 5PM-10PM and weekend work was a good way to make money. The alternative for many people with other obligations besides work isn't to simply work comfortable hours, it's to lose their job entirely. Also, at least in the US, you'll often see different crowds shopping at night compared to during the day. The privileged person has a flexible work situation or a partner who goes shopping during the day, but someone who has has inflexible commitments during the day appreciates the opportunity to be able to shop at irregular hours.
- wiradikusuma 5y agoI'm confused, isn't the neighborhood who protest about these stores are also the same neighborhood who want them (that's why the stores are there in the first place)? Or _some_ people in the neighborhood want convenience at the expense of others?
- lotsofpulp 5y agoPresumably, the problems do not affect those not in immediate vicinity of the warehouse/shipping operation. Those experiencing problems could be much fewer in number than those being able to be serviced by the warehouse while also being too far away to experience the problems. Which is a way zoning laws start to be introduced.
- jstanley 5y agoSimilarly, _some_ people in the neighbourhood want it to be quiet at the expense of others.
- Fnoord 5y agoWithin reason. I lived near a noisy neighbor (drug dealer/user etc). If you got work next day in a 9 to 5 job (like normal people) you don't want noisy drama at 3 AM.
- j4yav 5y agoThe stores have a relatively large range, but create a nuisance within a small portion. Neighbourhoods debate all kinds of things that some people want and others don’t: strip clubs, coffeeshops, prostitution. All are legal here, but have rules because even though presumably some people find them convenient, others less so. Does that help clear up the confusion?
- Scarblac 5y agoThe stores are there because some large enterprises want to turn really quick delivery of groceries into a business model, so far they are making a loss.
- spicybright 5y ago> For orders to be delivered within apps’ 10- or 20-minute targets, delivery companies need real estate within residential areas, forcing locals to live next door to the businesses. Do zoning laws not effect this?
- monocasa 5y agoThey might not. Commercial zoning around me involves a storefront or front desk. I run a startup out of my house legally because of that (which is really just my office).
- alkonaut 5y agoIf you are running a business you need permits and those permits obviously include writing about how much traffic your business can generate, noise levels at specific times, how trash is taken care of, and so on. Here it sounds like someone set up a garage business and didn’t fill out the paperwork. Either that’s illegal or the city is some kind of anarcholiberal extreme (which could well be the case in this example seeing as the Netherlands is often on the liberal side of business regulation, but it wouldn’t generalize to other cities so it wouldn’t really be noteworthy)
- j4yav 5y agoFor what it’s worth, Amsterdam doesn’t have anarcholiberal zoning rules. The article describes how the situation led to a ban that was put in place here, which presumably wouldn’t fly in an anarchist city.
- alkonaut 5y agoSounds like everything works as intended. Except that here a specific ban shouldn’t be necessary, regular rules around traffic etc should be enough.
- bogomipz 5y agoA similar article regarding the same phenomenon in both NYC and Berlin from last week: https://www.nytimes.com/2022/02/11/nyregion/gorillas-rapid-delivery-berlin-nyc.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/02/11/nyregion/gorillas-rapid-d...
- mshockwave 5y agosimilar things can also be found in Taiwan's food delivery where IIRC there is a dark store who takes orders from 5 different "restaurants" (kinda like shell companies) on major platforms, like Uber Eats.
- guruz 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghost_kitchen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghost_kitchen
- shepherdjerred 5y agoI saw restaurants like these in Seattle! There was a food truck parked by China Harbor that would serve for several restaurants on Uber Eats. I’m pretty sure Uber labels these as virtual restaurants or something.
- ewoodrich 5y agoThese became extremely common by the time I stopped doing Uber Eats in early 2021. As a driver I loved them because their business model was 100% aligned with delivery services and would always have food ready to go, be polite and responsive (unlike how many restaurants treated drivers), occasionally give a free water bottle as a thank you, etc.
- bombcar 5y agoThese are actually older than delivery foods - twenty years ago I worked at a hotel where the "cheap" restaurant and the "very fancy" restaurant had the same kitchen/cooks. The food offered was mostly different but you certainly could order the exact same meal at the fancy restaurant for almost double the cheaper one.
- Ekaros 5y agoI love how pizzeria/kebab shop me has 3 different store fronts on same service... All selling pizza... At least the other one have just two and one for wings etc. with different branding, though over double the transport cost... Go figure that mess...
- ljm 5y agoThese services have been popping up all over London too. I actually wondered if they're a front for something, because almost every other week there's a new grocery delivery service with a forgettable name.
- analog31 5y agoThey could be like the scooter rental start-ups, which seemed to have every hallmark of existing primarily to absorb venture capital.
- woudsma 5y agoAT5 (local Amsterdam news station) recently made a video about darkstores. https://youtu.be/Owf3Uo3NC8o https://youtu.be/Owf3Uo3NC8o (Dutch, but auto-translate subtitles work pretty well)
- Fnoord 5y agoOn bottom it says this is originally a Wired story [1] [1] https://www.wired.com/story/amsterdam-dark-stores/ https://www.wired.com/story/amsterdam-dark-stores/
- vondur 5y agoWow. I thought one of the cool things living in a European city was how many local stores within walking distance of most housing in urban centers.
- Vinnl 5y agoYeah, I can't imagine this ever being worth the VC money where I'm from for this reason. But who knows.
- itronitron 5y agoIn my opinion, most of these ventures will fail (or be consolidated) because they aren't charging as much as they could for the service. As a result most of their business is probably delivering pints of Ben and Jerry's to people after all of the stores have closed.
- Vinnl 5y agoHow much could they charge, and why? At least where I'm from with a supermarket always nearby, the convenience factor is going to be worth something, but they'll always have to compete with just picking things up yourself, which I'm assuming will always cost a lot less. Doesn't feel like there's room for a whole lot of margin on top of that.
- itronitron 5y agoThere are probably two main segments of customer for this service. Customer A cares about convenience, and customer B cares about saving time (also logistics). One could argue that they are the same thing, but there is a difference in degree. Customer B can arguably save an hour of their time by having a large order of groceries delivered. How much is that time worth? Ten dollars/euros is an easy minimum value to set. That will probably turn away most prospective customers but the remaining customers that do use the service will be buying a lot more groceries per trip.
- periheli0n 5y agoIsn't running noisy 24/7 businesses in residential areas and repeated threatening behaviour from riders something that the cops should be able to shut down relatively easily?
- johnnyApplePRNG 5y agoMy thoughts exactly, does amsterdam not have zoning restrictions?
- matsemann 5y agoMost cities in europe prefer mixed zoning, so one doesn't get those crazy suburbs. So it's normal to have businesses in the lowest floors with apartments around. But those are often small stores, cafés, restaurants etc, making the city feel alive and provide services to the residents. Not covered windows and buildings you cannot enter, and being a nuisance.
- Ekaros 5y agoThe amount of barbers and hairdressers here is something to behold at times. Or even offices for some types of firms. I think it is reasonable and makes lot of sense to have these types of businesses being available near where people actually live. I'm not really too keen on dark stores that aren't available for general public. I would much prefer regular store to one, even if that store would only be counter and pick-up only.
- periheli0n 5y agoBut mixed zoning usually comes with rules regarding opening hours, and a requirement to respect the neighbors' sleep. If a business repeatedly breaks those rules they get shut down. That's how in works in my city. The rules might be different in different cities/countries, but at least nightly harassment shouldn't be something that one has to tolerate.
- dan-robertson 5y ago
- noobermin 5y agoThis article is really downplaying the racial element to the stories, the complaints about "smoking, making noise, bikes blocking walkways" in a city like Amsterdam is a bit telling. Not that dark stores can be a nuisance but it's clearly a dimension in this story.
- Tade0 5y agoInteresting, could you elaborate? Is there anyone in particular they could have in mind complaining like that?
- noobermin 5y agoThe article says it towards the end. Generally immigrants are riders for these shops I'm assuming and a rider is quoted saying riders are acting defensive: >Ramzy Läbidi, a student who spent five months as a rider for Gorillas, believes some riders are responding to the “weird, racist comments” they receive as they deliver orders around the city. “Eventually, I think [some riders] get frustrated, and they go on vigilante mode and try to do something about it,” he says, adding that this might motivate some riders to pick fights.
- LaurensBER 5y agoAlthough I have no doubt that there's an element of racism in there it doesn't seem to be the root cause here. Keep in mind that Amsterdam is a very diverse city and in general racism tends to be quite low. I'm guessing (hoping) that some of the racistic comments were spoken in a moment of frustration (which given the noise and general disturbances 24/7 would create plenty of opportunities) and do not signal a changing attitude towards "foreigners" in Amsterdam.
- boh 5y agoIt's interesting that class prejudice is exclusively expressed as a racial issue these days.
- vinay427 5y agoI’m unsure how you interpreted “downplaying the racial element” and “a dimension in this story” in the GP comment to mean “exclusively.” There are numerous alternatives I can think of that the commenter could have used to indicate exclusivity, but their phrasing seems to clearly (IMO) indicate that it’s simply an element that is underplayed in this article.
- kingcharles 5y agoThere is one of these around the corner from my home in Chicago. I know what street it is on because I somehow managed to find it on the map recently. I was curious because I ordered some online groceries and less than five minutes from clicking the order button a mad guy turned up at my door, "YOU WILL REMEMBER ME! MY NAME IS IVAN! I AM RUSSIAN!", handed me the bag and sped off.
- qnsi 5y agou do remember him which made me introduce myself in this way in rhe future
- mrep 5y agoI'm in Chicago, what app are you using?
- kingcharles 5y agoIt was a GoPuff order.
- everyone 5y agoHow can you run a small warehouse in a residential street? What about zoning?
- noobermin 5y agoZoning in the netherlands is nowhere as onerous as it is in America.
- everyone 5y agoA big reason the Netherlands is such a great country is that that it's well planned out. They must have a shittone of planning rules and procedure to achieve that. They do promote mixed use development, mixing business and residential. But a warehouse is more industrial, I assume they dont want to mix residential and industrial?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- noobermin 5y agoSure, I guess I don't know whether these qualify as warehouses or shops, I suppose that's the ambiguity the start-ups are trying to exploit.
- kwhitefoot 5y ago> assume they don't want to mix residential and industrial? Why not? Residential buildings and light industry can exist in close proximity without too much trouble as long as everyone behaves properly.
- Ekaros 5y agoI think big issue is that these warehouses and dark kitchens actually take out of the retail space otherwise available, thus making the services to those in immediate vicinity worse.
- 5y ago
- analog31 5y agoI'm reminded that almost every culture has a version of a folk story such as "The goose that laid the golden egg." Someone is given a power to do something that can make them wealthy, but they lose all sense of restraint and destroy the thing that is giving them that power. When a new business idea is introduced and someone asks: "How will this be carried to its logical extreme and become a nusiance," that's dismissed as a slippery slope argument. But it's ultimately why we have things like zoning laws. My own reaction is that new things tend to arrive in my town relatively slowly, and it's good to see how they pan out elsewhere before arriving here.
- blablabla123 5y agoThe whole delivery business is becoming increasingly absurd to the point where many places are in walking distance and delivery services only deliver from close places during peak hours. A really streamlined take away option would oftentimes be much better (than waiting 15 minutes at a place and worrying whether they got the order right...)
- holografix 5y agoIt’s hard not to be cynical about business like this. I don’t think the exec team believes it to be a sustainable long term situation. The business model is avoid regulation using the latest ubiquitous tech and don’t pay for externalities. The only way to have groceries delivered in 10 minutes is to co-locate distribution points with residential areas + have access to labour willing to make an easy buck. There’s a huge supply of poorly educated, unemployed immigrants in Amsterdam and in NL. I don’t blame them for jumping on this.
- Ansil849 5y agoI'm not a fan of neigbhorhood nuisance, obviously, but I also feel like it's trendy to pick on new phenomena like 'dark stores' as opposed to established phenomena. For example, my biggest noise concerns in residential areas are: loud city service vehicles at extremely early hours in the day like rubbish collector trucks and the binmen throwing things around at 5 in the morning, or police/ambulances/fire trucks speeding through in the middle of the night, or the city doing overnight roadwork on a nonresidential street which intersects with the residential street and so basically makes sleeping impossible. Why are there no (popular) petitions or news articles about this more mundane but also much more universal noise pollution?