4 ms·
> Unlike traditional religion technology is not subject to the same constraints as stone churches, dusty books and preachers. Because technology can take physi
by paulryanrogers 5y ago
> Unlike traditional religion technology is not subject to the same constraints as stone churches, dusty books and preachers.
Because technology can take physical form like robots and cars?
IMO religion has done so much damage in the form of wars, torture, and (mass and individual) mental illness that I imagine modern technology has a long way to go before it t can be considered as worrisome as religion and its memes.
- nonrandomstring 5y ago@paul > Because technology can take physical form like robots and cars? Not so much that, no. Quite the opposite, because it's non-physical. Physical technology has already taken on worrying forms, like atomic weapons and gasoline automobiles. We've managed those admirably I think [1] - even though it may seem otherwise at times. Physical has inbuilt limitations. Consider Google Glass and the near unanimous societal rejection of "glassholes". I am just recycling Mumford, Ellul and Postman here, but digital technology is different as it can produce near instantaneous change on global culture. > IMO religion has done so much damage in the form of wars, torture, and (mass and individual) mental illness that I imagine modern technology has a long way to go before it t can be considered as worrisome as religion and its memes. You're right, religion has and still does yield these consequences. BTW I am not rejecting _all_ of religion, it has many good sides too. But religion took thousands of years for its damaging effects to happen. Much of what we blame 'religion' for is really a parochial perspective on history (the view from now) and the playing out of human evolutionary affairs through it. The same will be true of technology . What we must be mindful of is that they are (1) essentially the same phenomenon, and (2) that digital technology will produce effects much, much faster than religion. It;s really only been 50 years, which is nothing in historical terms. [1] That might seem like a disingenuous thing to say within a context that feels so cynical, and we don't get to run control groups on history, but I like to think that we're on course to correct for climate change and that the game-theoretical MAD aspect to nukes has proven somewhat correct so far and we will reach a future time of disarmament. In that sense I have faith in science and people.
- _xnmw 5y ago> IMO religion has done so much damage Actually the worst wars and killing events in history (WWI and WWII) were secular, technology driven. And religion has cured far more than it caused. The statistics are pretty damn clear: religious people are happier, live longer, have bigger families, and score better on almost every measure of wellbeing.
- ithkuil 5y ago"With or without religion, good people can behave well and bad people can do evil; but for good people to do evil - that takes religion." -- Steven Weinberg
- netmonk 5y ago
- disgruntledphd2 5y agos/religion/ideology.
- ithkuil 5y agoYou could say that a religion is a special case of an ideology.
- disgruntledphd2 5y agoYeah basically. Personally I think religion is useful, but it's definitely a kind of ideology.
- roughly 5y agoThe Spanish Catholics wiped out the entire culture of the Maya and the Inca. Four copies of the Maya codexes remain because the church destroyed the rest. The Inca quipu were destroyed en masse - we’re just now re-learning that they were more than just accounting. Both the Spanish and American churches committed cultural genocide against American Indians on an enormous scale. The destruction wrought by the church on the world includes the intentional wholesale destruction of the indigenous culture and history of the entire Western Hemisphere, and that’s just part of the blood ledger for one particular sect of Christianity.