4 ms·
I grew up in Africa. We had snakes going through our yard, every day, that would make you brownulate your jodhpurs. We had bugs that, when they bit you, hurt f
by ChrisMarshallNY 5y ago
I grew up in Africa.
We had snakes going through our yard, every day, that would make you brownulate your jodhpurs. We had bugs that, when they bit you, hurt for a month.
My favorite toys were these painted sheet-metal cars and spaceships, with flints and sanding wheels. They would spit out showers of sparks.
I survived.
But ask any parent that has lost a child. It's absolutely devastating. I know a number of them. I never, ever want to tell them that their child's life is worth less than my freedom from inconvenience.
It's really not a black/white issue, and I have no answers.
- donw 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- monitron 5y ago
- malwarebytess 5y ago> having a capacity to move one to either compassionate or contemptuous pity > marked by sorrow or melancholy > pitifully inferior or inadequate > absurd, laughable seems accurate enough a word to describe the emotional argument.
- kingcharles 5y ago> I think that if your manner of speech makes you sound like a B-movie villain I imagined the poster above you having his five-year-old child come home from school with a fresh painting of Mommy and Daddy and the poster snatching it out of their hands, "PATHETIC!" rips up painting
- donw 5y agoNo, you save that for the essays they write throughout high school. Joking aside, children are not tiny adults, and how you deal with them changes over time. A five-year-old gets rewarded for just doing work, because that's the baseline. A fifteen-year-old must demonstrate some degree of competence. They are not developmentally identical. A grown adult obsessed with safety over all other concerns is childish, pathetic, and ironically, dangerous as all hell to others. Those that prioritize safety above other concerns are the first to use violence against any and all perceived threats to that "safety".
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoI'm not too bothered by the reaction, but I don't know if it's actually useful. My childhood gave me great things. I have a worldview that is highly unusual in my peer group, and was directly useful in my career, as I'm a xenophile. I'm not sorry I went through what I went through, but I had to add some loc-tite, later in life, to tighten a few loose screws, from my childhood experiences. But I am serious. Because of the extracurricular work I do, I am in daily contact with many parents of deceased children (and relatives of other deceased people). Many of the deceased got there through misadventure, suicide, or even murder. It's really hard to encounter these folks, and not understand that there are depths of feeling, that we can't understand. I would submit that dismissing these feelings that others experience; simply because they don't fit our own worldview, makes our own lives (and the lives around us) darker. It certainly doesn't help us to become better people.
- donw 5y ago> Many of the deceased got there through misadventure, suicide, or even murder. I have likely spent more time around people like this than you. > I would submit that dismissing these feelings that others experience; simply because they don't fit our own worldview, makes our own lives darker. Your feelings do not give you the right to deprive others' children of the adversity they need to grow into adulthood. That's my point.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y ago> I have likely spent more time around people like this than you. It’s been over 41 years, for me. Wanna bet? It’s not my feelings at all. I never said it was. We’re done here. Have a great day!
- dang 5y agoPlease don't take threads further into flamewar, regardless of how bad another comment is or you feel it is. It only makes everything worse. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- ip26 5y agoI will not have my children deprived of their right to grow into adulthood If you don't shield them from simple dangers they cannot understand, then that is exactly what you may deprive them of. A two year old is not ready to contend with rattlesnakes, mountain lions, electrical sockets, etc.
- donw 5y agoInvariably, any criticism of safety obsession is met with something along the lines of "so you're saying we should fill playgrounds with active landmines and light machine guns?" Danger needs to scale with a child's ability to handle it, and which is likely higher than the average American parents' tolerance. A two-year-old isn't ready to contend with rattlesnakes. A sixteen-year-old absolutely is. Somewhere in that timeline, there's a stair-step in the danger function, and that's just part of life. Safety-obsessed Americans would ensure that the rattlesnake stays behind glass forver.
- lern_too_spel 5y agoWhat is gained by selling rattlesnakes to children in stores? The harms outweigh the benefits. People who need to study rattlesnakes have ample opportunity. Similarly, chemicals that are extremely risky to handle should not be sold to children but introduced in a classroom. (OP's example is different because the chemistry sets he complains about not being available actually are available to children today.) It's not like there isn't plenty of other chemistry to learn about, and this setup makes it more likely that more children will survive as chemists to make important discoveries. (See the David Hahn story.)
- joe_the_user 5y agoIt's not a black/white issue and I don't think it has to be handled like one. It's possible to that allow serious exploration without exposing children to toxic chemicals. I think you can let children walk by themselves and play by themselves without discarding any worry about child safety. Etc. The OP is what my younger friends would call a "boomer rant". And despite being a "boomer" myself I no sympathy for a "the problem today is people are too worried about safety" viewpoint. Today's world is complex combination of good trends and bad trends, not merely a matter of "now lawyers run everything".
- int_19h 5y agoIt doesn't have to be the problem to be a problem. As for the labels, I'm late genX / early millennial, but I broadly agree with the premise that safety concerns are excessive in modern society, and that causes adverse social effects that are often unaccounted for.
- Aerroon 5y ago>But ask any parent that has lost a child. It's absolutely devastating. I know a number of them. I never, ever want to tell them that their child's life is worth less than my freedom from inconvenience. Sure, but when safety is the primary concern then nothing gets done. Too many car accidents? Just ban cars. You can't have a car accident if there are no cars. If safety is your primary goal, then surely something small like "getting from A to B faster" is a small price to pay for the life of a child! But this isn't feasible. You can't run a society based on this concern. Everything we do carries risks. Some are more hidden, others are more accepted and for some reason we single out specific risks and become unreasonable about them. We selectively pick and choose what we're outraged about in the name of safety.
- awb 5y ago> Sure, but when safety is the primary concern then nothing gets done. Too many car accidents? Just ban cars. You can't have a car accident if there are no cars. I think you’re missing the part of these debates that is an honest conversation about utility and how to balance the needs of the group vs. the needs of the individual. That’s why we both care about car safety and don’t ban cars. It doesn’t have to be as extreme as either A) No safety rules, maximum freedom. Or B) Maximum safety, no freedom. The middle option is what you see a lot: some safety, some freedom. That’s why you have cars with airbags and kid’s chemistry sets without hazardous materials. Some safety, some freedom. You can debate about the utility, but I doubt anyone in the pro-50s chemistry kit camp would be OK with including radioactive isotopes or deadly viruses. At some point the learning experience isn’t worth the risk at which point you’ve gone through the exact same thought process: how much safety do I want vs. how much freedom? So I think we all agree there needs to be some safety concerns, the question is where and that will always be a grey area with no right or wrong answer. Everyone’s utility will be slightly different. But just questioning safety as a goal itself doesn’t make much sense IMO. We all want safety and we all want freedom, just different amounts of each.
- elil17 5y agoI mean, cars are the most dangerous way to travel. I think it would be better if we could build cities that didn't have cars.
- wyager 5y ago> I never, ever want to tell them that their child's life is worth less than my freedom from inconvenience. This is why a healthy society needs social institutions which insulate people from having to constantly defend freedoms and other pro-social behaviors from emotional appeals. The fact that we are so vulnerable to such appeals causes scaling problems in societies as large as ours today.