3 ms·
>At some point the FDA didn't exist and we decided to create it to regulate an industry. FDA, youtube edition: alphabet is the only company approved to host vi
by gruez 5y ago
>At some point the FDA didn't exist and we decided to create it to regulate an industry.
FDA, youtube edition: alphabet is the only company approved to host videos for public consumption, because they're the only one that has an approved copyright/hate speech filter (regulated for safety, efficacy, ADA compliance, and to be non-discriminatory). All other sites are prohibited from operating unless they spend $5B to get their systems approved.
- belter 5y agoYou raise a very important point, that I have seen at work in the Finance industry. It goes like this: Large consulting companies are structurally incompetent and keep running to the ground financial and government IT projects. After starting to see their lunch taken by small specialized and competent small operations, a underground operation starts to require the regulator to force companies working in the space to get certified as "Financial Services Provider". Regulations will make sure the number of required certified professionals, minimum capital etc...Are of a nature to drive out the competent small boutiques. Projects are of course still done, by forcing the small companies to subcontract on a 2nd and 3nd level via the now certified ( but still incompetent) large consulting companies.
- doctor_eval 5y agoI saw the end result of this, after working on a proposal for a large Australian city council. After the presentation, I was told that while our ideas were awesome, unfortunately we were too small (ca. 15 people). We would have to have partnered with a large consultant (IBM was mentioned), or we would not be invited to continue our work. We were told explicitly that this was because council needed someone big enough to sue. To this day it makes no sense to me. But that’s how it was.
- Daishiman 5y agoSure it does; your 15 person company can go out of existence just by a fight between founders. Lead engineer gets run over by a bus and didn't document his work? You're done. Lose your other customer out of the 2 that were keeping you alive? You have to fire half of your staff. Whether the reason was made to justify the existence of some parasites doesn't change the fact that it's a real reason. A company that's been in business for over a century isn't going to go out in a year, and worst case someone will have the knowledge and certs to keep the ship running.
- doctor_eval 5y agoIt’s fair to say that working with smaller companies has different risks, but that doesn’t mean that working with large companies reduces project risk. It’s just trading one set of risks for another. I have personally seen one of the big consultants change entire project methodologies twice - at the customer’s expense - within 6 months, in the same project. This is leaning more into the big business revolving door problem - but in any case, I don’t think it’s widely accepted that the big consultants reduce project risks in any meaningful way. And quite frankly, if your strategy is to sue a company if things go pear shaped, why in gods name would you choose IBM as your partner?
- jiggawatts 5y agoThis is an absurd argument trotted out by people who -- to be blunt -- have absolutely no idea what really goes on. Lawsuits by government agencies against suppliers are rare, and likely to result in a loss if attempted against large corporations. Companies like Microsoft or Oracle have armies of the best lawyers on retainer. Government agencies can only afford the ones that have sensible shoes and patches on their jacket elbows. A recent case in point: The NSW Transport department had a legal spat with a huge contracting company Acciona, and ended up losing the court case to the tune of over half a billion dollars! That specific case made me laugh out loud because the company I worked for had signed a very similar contract with the same department. I remember looking at it and thinking it was some sort of joke that nobody in their right mind would sign (on the government side). It included none of the "hard but essential" bits, and all of the easy fluffy bits. They signed it. They argued with us over non-delivery. We pointed at the contract and made them pay us 5x more than the original amount to do the actual, hard work. The real reason that government agencies like big contractors is because they are reassuringly expensive. They're the "big name" that looks good in reports. They're chosen by people with unlimited funding, no profit motive, and the power to choose a vendor with the sole motivation of covering their ass. That's it. No need to be "efficient", or "fit for purpose", or any such thing. These decisions are all made by a small number of people acting in individual self-interest. Optimising for their own continued employment. They're trading your taxes so that in the event of a failure they can point at the name on the report memo and say: "See! Not even Big Name Vendor could implement this! It's not my fault!" I once got "fired" from a consulting gigs where things went wrong and I took it very hard. A salesman explained that our purpose is to be easily fire-able so that the manager at the customer can keep his job. That's why he paid us triple rates compared to a direct contractor. I was back on that site 12 months later, once everybody forgot who I was. TL;DR: Organisations that mis-allocate punishment and reward force their internal middle-managers to protect themselves at the expense of the organisation. Big consulting firms exist to milk these inefficient organisations, and this has nothing to do with lawsuits.
- elyobo 5y agoHave heard the "big enough to sue" which is also "big enough to afford the indemnity insurance in case they're sued" is a common problem in Australian government contracting.
- camkego 5y agoThis is exactly why Facebook has so many video ads promoting new regulations. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kur94OyXf3U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kur94OyXf3U
- ComradePhil 5y agoThe video has no information about what they want the government to regulate. It links to this page: https://about.fb.com/regulations/ https://about.fb.com/regulations/ Which then links to this page: https://about.fb.com/news/2019/03/four-ideas-regulate-internet/ https://about.fb.com/news/2019/03/four-ideas-regulate-intern... Basically, what I gathered is that they want to create a high barrier to entry for their potential competitors, as one would expect. There is nothing useful to people in those regulations.
- mitchdoogle 5y agoI don't think regulating access to online accounts has to include anything about video hosting specifically. We need more of an "online bill of rights", which includes a right to download any data you've created before an account is closed. We could also throw in a right to privacy. The bill of rights in the Constitution doesn't prohibit people from opening businesses - I don't see why an online bill of rights would do so