13 ms·
>The article doesn’t say much about what would help. Jobs that pay well, and don't require the poor to fuck their work/life balance or drive them to neglect/fe
by coldtea 5y ago
>The article doesn’t say much about what would help.
Jobs that pay well, and don't require the poor to fuck their work/life balance or drive them to neglect/feel their kids as a burden.
Inflation-adjusted minimum wage imposed to all businesses/states. If they can't afford, they can go bust, like with any other cost of doing business.
Cheap rents and affordable housing.
Protective nets for periods of illness/unemployment/etc.
School districts equally equipped, with good teachers.
Free (or very affordable, no-loan-based) college education if their kid passes a hard tamper-proof exam.
Taxes on outsourcing work outside the country.
- Skunkleton 5y agoAs an engineer, I have many privileges. Two that stand out here are salary, and the power dynamic I enjoy with my employer. I am well paid, enough said. I also am not beholden to the whims of my management. I can take time off, they need me to be happy, I can effect change on my management as they can effect change on their subordinates. High pay is great, but to a point, I place a higher value on the dignity that I enjoy in my employment. > Inflation-adjusted minimum wage imposed to all businesses/states. I can't say I have a better idea here, but the whole concept of a minimum wage seems like a problem. It strongly implies that there are a large class of jobs where the employer has all of the power, and does not have to compete to attract employees. Also strongly implied is that minimum wage workers do not have an alternative means of supporting themselves. Practically speaking, raising minimum wage regularly should help keep workers out of poverty. Still, these people will still have to contend with employers that treat them like commodities, with no real alternative way to support themselves.
- e40 5y agoYour two points are so incredibly key. I've felt and known this for a long time. The last 5-6 years has made me thing so much of _why_ this is the case is rooted in: 1. Race and how people are perceived--the rise of race issues in the referenced period is so confusing to me, as I thought we were getting past them, but it is very clear that a huge percentage of the US population is still have 19th century views on race. 2. Certain companies (like Amazon) who few low-skilled workers as machines to use up and throw away. As for the "inflation-adjusted minimum wage" ... the argument used to be "small businesses will suffer" but strangely I haven't heard that in a long time. In fact, I don't hear anyone refuting the idea of IAMW. It's so insane to me that we don't do this. Maybe that would give politicians an incentive to keep inflation low? (Because they want to keep the minimum wage as low as possible?)
- faangiq 5y ago> 2. Certain companies (like Amazon) who few low-skilled workers as machines to use up and throw away. Don’t worry, these companies view high-skilled workers the same way.
- coldtea 5y agoYes, but they get a lot more out of this...
- pirate787 5y agoThe big problem with the minimum wage is that, if higher than the market-clearing price, it takes away the lowest rung of the opportunity ladder for the least skilled.
- ddingus 5y agoThat's not true. Fact is, labor costs money for the laborer to exist and show up for work. No matter what, that money is paid, or the labor does not exist and or show up for work. Your argument is one of merit, skill and market value. This is exactly the wrong way to look at things. If we start from the cost of labor, and it does have a cost as I put above, whether to fund the labor boils down to the value said labor has for others, and that value can be traded on accordingly. Fact is we need basic labors. Anyone can do them. There should be no shame in this work, and it should be valued as the massive time and effort savings to others that it really is. And automation holds few answers right now, and I would argue for a considerable time yet. People will be doing those labors. Question really is how much does it cost people, who hold other positions in life, to perform basic labors themselves? And the answer is expensive!! That difference in value can very easily fund labors then. It's a perfectly acceptable basis, and it means we value labor differently and it means we recognize that guy digging the ditch, or making our shit disappear, or any number of basic things has the same waking hours any of us do, same basic needs any of us do, and may have a family as any of us do. This idea of people being inherently worthless is very highly toxic and is doing a great harm to all of us. It's completely unacceptable given the quite obvious value even basic labors actually do have for us overall.
- Consultant32452 5y agoThe CPI is already corrupted and consistently below real COL increases because it’s tied to entitlements and taxes. It’s used as a tool to steal from the poor. Further tying it to minimum wage will only add more pressure to politicize and corrupt the CPI calculation. That is the failure point in all similar ideas.
- coldtea 5y ago>Further tying it to minimum wage will only add more pressure to politicize and corrupt the CPI calculation. That is the failure point in all similar ideas. That's not much of an issue in practice: to even get a few those ideas implemented already requires voter vigilance and strong societal push. If you have those then a reliable CPI is just another thing this vigilance/push should cover. If you don't have them, you wont get far with those proposals either. So it's not like we can get the proposals into laws, but the CPI will be the issue making them ineffective. It's all or nothing.
- Consultant32452 5y agoWe can be certain the CPI has been corrupted since at least the Boskin commission in 1996. Taxes and entitlements are tied to inflation. The Boskin commission determined if they could find the CPI was over-stated by 1.1% they could save $1 Trillion over 10 years. Magically, with no new research, they came up with a justification to lower the CPI estimate by 1.1%. Raising taxes and cutting Social Security without getting caught is the third rail of politics. The amount of pressure to find ways to do this is immense. This is the level of corruption you are dealing with. We are not even on a path from "here" to a place where the CPI is an actual fair estimation of inflation. Most people don't even know this is a problem. It's too complicated for regular folks to even deal with and all the establishment political figures are in on it, so they obviously won't draw attention to it.
- coldtea 5y ago>not have to compete to attract employees. Also strongly implied is that minimum wage workers do not have an alternative means of supporting themselves. In practice, that's the case. I think that the idea that it isn't so, and people go to this or that employer out of "free choice", stems from a religious-like belief in "free market", than from real-life empirical evaluation of how desperate and poor people pick jobs - and what options are open to then. >Still, these people will still have to contend with employers that treat them like commodities, with no real alternative way to support themselves. True. But at least they will make some more money will doing so - and might even afford to save a buck or too, and eventually look elsewhere.
- Skunkleton 5y ago> But at least they will make some more money will doing so - and might even afford to save a buck or too, and eventually look elsewhere. Yeah, I hope so. Maybe someone will come up with a better idea later.
- Atheros 5y agoReplace the minimum wage with an expanded Earned Income Tax Credit. It has the benefits of getting people enough money to live without significantly distorting the labor market. And it's more politically expedient than guaranteed minimum income.
- consp 5y ago> It strongly implies that there are a large class of jobs where the employer has all of the power, and does not have to compete to attract employees That is even true in cases where there is even balanced employment-employer availability due to other factors. My country should be more civilized by my dad got 6 years of pension payment reduced because the employer "failed to pay" but on every balance sheet his pay was added because "automatic" and nobody warned him, just the employer. Afterwards the lawyers told him to take the "I'll pay one year" deal of the employer because of the likelyhood of getting nothing due to limited liability companies protection. And this in Europe, not even the US. The balance is so far off it's not even remotely fair game.
- darawk 5y ago> Inflation-adjusted minimum wage imposed to all businesses/states. If they can't afford, they can go bust, like with any other cost of doing business. How does this help, exactly? If the businesses who can't afford to pay at the standard you want go bust, you can't just assume there will be others who can. If the unit of labor a person can provide is worth less than its state mandated cost, that unit of labor will go unemployed. People don't buy things for more than their value to them.
- ddingus 5y agoPeople cost money to exist and show up for work. A business that cannot fully fund it's labor is not a business. Who wants to pay a subsidy, which is exactly what happens when labor is underfunded, just so someone can mooch for profit? I don't. The answer to your question is we simply do that labor ourselves.
- missedthecue 5y agoOf course, by "fully fund" you mean "meet my arbitrary price floor".
- ddingus 5y agoDon't ask me. Ask the people currently failing to earn enough from their labor to exist and show up for work.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoRight. And businesses can always get creative by improving productivity (via automation) to survive with rising labor costs. Those that cannot simply cease to exist, entire industries die out all the time.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> And businesses can always get creative by improving productivity (via automation) to survive with rising labor costs. Those that cannot simply cease to exist, entire industries die out all the time. This takes commerce as a given. Another outcome is that those that cannot cease to exist and are replaced by nothing, leading to more poverty. That has been a common failure mode of that policy.
- rossdavidh 5y ago"Inflation-adjusted minimum wage imposed to all businesses/states. If they can't afford, they can go bust, like with any other cost of doing business." I have no problem with a higher minimum wage, but that's rather like giving someone who has lost a lot of blood, a blood transfusion. It's good, but it's a stopgap measure that is ignoring a more fundamental problem, and if you're not stitching up the wound you're not doing much good. If jobs can be exported overseas to places with much lower wages (and lax/nonexistent environmental laws), then all a higher minimum wage (here) does is put more people out of a job. Higher minimum wage, ok, but it can't be done in isolation or you've replaced "low wages" with "no wages".
- cool_dude85 5y ago>If jobs can be exported overseas to places with much lower wages (and lax/nonexistent environmental laws), then all a higher minimum wage (here) does is put more people out of a job. As far as I know, the economic literature is pretty clear that this is not the case in the US. Even regional changes, where an employer can reasonably relocate outside the e.g. city boundary without much difficulty, don't show job losses.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoA lot of manufacturing left the USA along time ago due so I’m not sure why the economics literature says it doesn’t matter? Yes, the service jobs that now dominate in the USA are largely unaffected, but that’s more due to survivor bias than any underlying economic mechanism. Automation and self service (like in European cafeterias) is largely the response when services become too uneconomical to be done manually. Those elevator operators aren’t coming back to the USA.
- cool_dude85 5y agoBut there's no evidence I'm aware of suggesting that minimum wages were the cause of deindustrialization in the US. I suspect most of those factory jobs were far above the minimum wage. And people often wave the automation threat around - but why hasn't it happened yet? In concrete studies of minimum wage increases that actually occurred, we do not find job losses.
- truted2 5y agoI’ve seen these ideas pitched on Hacker News but is there any examples of HN users: 1. Starting a business that generally pays minimum wage and attempting to pay their employees more 2. Buying property and renting it out at below market rates 3. Supporting, training or helping people who are unemployed. 4. Going to work as teachers in underserved school districts. 5. Offering university level education for free 6. Buying USA made only Hasn’t this traditionally been the American way? People going out and trying to experiment and build the things they wish to see in the world? I think everyone wants the things you mention but for some reason we are unable to execute on them and a convenient scape goat is that the government should solve it or that “the other party” is getting in the way. Where is the “You must be the change you seek” crowd these days? Wouldn’t trying to make a small change in your community have more impact than all the comments posted in this thread?
- CPLX 5y ago> Wouldn’t trying to make a small change in your community have more impact than all the comments posted in this thread? No. Some problems are rightly solved at the government level and anything that serves to distract from that is propaganda.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bo1024 5y agoTo expand on this, there are problems solved well by competitive markets and problems that are not. If the above were in the first category people would have solved them and we wouldn’t be talking about them.
- refurb 5y agoNope. Waiting for the government to step in when you could do something right now is just hypocritical.
- tyg13 5y ago
- hattmall 5y agoI basically agree with you, but if the businesses go bust then there's no jobs at all...
- nxmnxm99 5y agoSo who exactly is going to pay for all this?
- narag 5y agoSo who exactly is going to pay for all this? Let's see (only what I have answers to): Cheap rents and affordable housing. Allow more vertical building. Protective nets for periods of illness/unemployment/etc. I and my employers pay a fund that covers it. School districts equally equipped, with good teachers. From the taxes, it's not so expensive. Free (or very affordable, no-loan-based) college education if their kid passes a hard tamper-proof exam. From the taxes, it's not so expensive if you only pay the smartest ones. Taxes on outsourcing work outside the country. Well, that's income, but I disagree. Just forbid making any business with tyrants. I know, I know...
- nxmnxm99 5y agoSo basically take all the money we have right now and somehow increase spending on all of these programs, got it.
- narag 5y agoNo, I'm from another country. From my point of view it's more like stop wasting money for other useless purposes so we can grow. If we've been able to survive, no doubt the USA can thrive.
- nxmnxm99 5y agoI'm pretty sure the USA has been thriving for a while
- narag 5y agoNot sure if you didn't understand or you're being deliberately obtuse to make another point. Of course the implication was that the USA can still thrive even spending that money, a pittance compared with public expenses in other areas. I don't share all the points of the originator of the thread (was it coldtea?), you might find interesting which ones I didn't mention, but some of them are a good idea even from the point of view of more affluent people.
- deeg 5y ago> Taxes on outsourcing work outside the country. I disagree here. Global poverty is at its lowest point in human history, in large part due to jobs being exported to poor countries.
- atoav 5y agoSo in short: humanism.