7 ms·
That’s an attempt to inject an urbanist hobby horse into a discussion of poverty. The vast majority of poor Americans have a car. It gives people tremendous fle
by rayiner 5y ago
That’s an attempt to inject an urbanist hobby horse into a discussion of poverty. The vast majority of poor Americans have a car. It gives people tremendous flexibility in taking advantage of different employment and housing opportunities.
If anything I’d argue that transit puts poor people at a disadvantage. My wife’s family comes from rural poverty (like reliant on hunting for meat). Access to cars is never the problem. And cars mean that if someone loses their job or their housing, they can pick up and move to a different town where there might be opportunities.
The transit-dependent urban poor are completely dependent on what opportunities might exist near the transit lines. That also makes them tremendously reliant on the city central planners, who are often incompetent.
- DoreenMichele 5y agoIn some cases, it's the hobby horse of people with barriers to driving who have studied the space and wish the US was more like it used to be and more like some other countries still are.
- geodel 5y agoYeah, what are those countries which are geographically vast, diverse and rich and rely on transit system for daily commute needs?
- DoreenMichele 5y agoI don't use public transit much -- I mostly walk everywhere -- and the OP only said The fact someone needs a car is itself a failure. There's no mention of public transit as a proposed solution.
- geodel 5y agoWell anything could be called failure if alternatives and their pros/cons not discussed. Good that you could walk everywhere. I can't, my knees hurt walking more than a mile or so. If I have no car and can't afford cab for everything, not sure how I would be better off.
- DoreenMichele 5y agoI'm not asking you to give up your car. I'm only asking for a world that isn't so openly hostile to pedestrians and cyclists.
- hattmall 5y agoPedestrians are fine, cyclists have to admit they are doing it for their own personal pleasure at the time and expense of everyone else 99% of the time. I commuted by bicycle for many years because I lived somewhere that it was convenient and appropriate. I didn't impede traffic and delay other people. Cheap motorbikes need to be more widely available and utilized by any one who is cycling out of necessity in areas not intended for it. Bicycles should absolute be relegated to specialized infrastructure of which we should build more, but cyclists within regular vehicle traffic is mostly done for enjoyment and only inspires hatred and annoyance at bicycles in general which creates a feedback loop resulting in less support for bicycle infrastructure. Having to slow down traffic and wait to pass a bicycle only to have them filter back to the front at the next red light and make everyone slow down and pass them again repeatedly is a real contributor to gridlock.
- zozbot234 5y agoA bicycle takes up a lot less road space than a car, especially when it can smoothly filter through lanes. You know what contributes to gridlock? Too many cars on the road, that's what. Bicycles are not making traffic any worse.
- Mikeb85 5y agoI mentioned infrastructure. Public transit is infrastructure. It's implied and should be obvious.
- DoreenMichele 5y agoAt one time, I wanted to be an urban planner. Public transit is only one piece of infrastructure. Zoning and land use significantly impact how people and goods get around.
- guerrilla 5y agoSweden. I've never needed a car and live 50km from a city. The only people that need cars are those that literally live in the middle of the forest or need them for work.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- geodel 5y agoWell in New York people commute this much distance. And even I lived about 25-30 miles from Washington DC without car. Is it applicable to whole USA that's the point.
- guerrilla 5y agoSorry, when I said city, I meant one with 60,000 people. The nearest city of the kind you're thinking is 5-6 hours away.
- eckesicle 5y agoThat's certainly NOT generalisable to Sweden as a whole. Rural Sweden is definitely not accessible by public transport as a whole.
- guerrilla 5y agoHas never been a problem in either Blekinge or Kalmar... almost every village has a bus line. I specifically excluded "literally living in the woods" though.
- ionicgiraffe 5y agoBut what about the time an planning of using public transport vs car?
- guerrilla 5y ago
- rayiner 5y agoPoor people in the country back then we’re very bad off. The mobility from cars enabled real improvements for them.
- DoreenMichele 5y agoI'm not claiming it didn't. Poor people historically were worse off in myriad ways. Wanting options for people is trying to throw out the bathwater, not the baby. I'm not looking to take cars away from anyone. I'm just looking to restore access to some essentials that I grew up with and that I know can be real, even with cars remaining popular and common. I'm not some extremist looking to eliminate cars. I'm not trying to insist that anyone who can drive and prefers to drive be denied that possibility.
- zozbot234 5y agoCars have a way of breaking down and causing unpredictable expenses that can push the poor into hardship. The choice between car culture and well-developed mass transit comes down to density. I might believe that even many "urban areas" in the US are still too sprawlish and low-density for mass transit to be genuinely effective, but this is not uniformly true.
- 0xB31B1B 5y agoCar ownership is highly correlated with income, people in the bottom 10%ile of income are much less likely to have a car than people of higher income. If you look at modeshare for people in the bottom 10% it’s a much much larger share of biking, public transit, walking, and carpooling than others. Cars are one of the top sources of bankruptcy for people in the bottom 10% of income (car repairs, car accidents, making car payments). Car dependent life is a huge stressor to people in the bottom 10% of income
- kodah 5y agoThat is only in cities. Across the majority of the US your statement is not true. Poor people across the Midwest and South need a car because walking, biking, bussing, and trains are not available to them.
- Retric 5y agoPoor across the Midwest and south want a car but often live without. The difference is simply how important people consider cars and how expensive they are to keep. Being able to park for free makes a huge difference at the edge.
- kodah 5y agoThat's not true to my experience at all. We usually budgeted for a car first and a house second. Mass transit in most forms isn't cost efficient below a certain density, so at most you'll have a light bus system or rail system available to you. In regards to your "often live without" statement, I met very few people in the South who didn't have cars. For the reasons I stated above, they're practically a necessity. Data also doesn't indicate that people are often going without cars except in major, wealthy cities: https://www.governing.com/archive/car-ownership-numbers-of-vehicles-by-city-map.html https://www.governing.com/archive/car-ownership-numbers-of-v...
- Retric 5y agoFrom your 2015 data: Miami, Florida has 19.9% of households without cars, New Orleans, Louisiana at 18.8%. Even Birmingham, Alabama is at 15.8% and Atlanta, Georgia has 15.2% of households without cars. That’s much higher than say Arlington, Virginia at 13.4% which is connected to one of the best public transportation networks in the US. A handful of places on that list sat at 2% without cars, but most of the south was over 5% without cars largely due to poverty. PS: Not that I think the data is very accurate Murrieta, California seemingly went from 3.5% (2015) down to 0.7% (2016) which seems extremely unlikely for a single year. The poor are often missed in official statistics like census unless significant effort is used to track them.
- throwawaynay 5y ago
- nickpeterson 5y agoYou realize that New York to Los Angeles is like 4800km right?
- Mikeb85 5y agoAirplanes exist. The network of infrastructure in Europe isn't just trains... Part of the problem in North America is that there's not adequate public transportation from airports to city centres (whether it's a train terminal or frequent buses), not enough trains from city centres to suburbs/outskirts and not enough buses in between or from town to town. I recently went from Paris -> Prague as an example. So I walked from the hotel in St. Germain to a metro station, took the metro to the airport, hopped on a plane, landed in Prague, then took a bus to a metro terminal and the metro to downtown Prague. That's what it looks like. You could have the same in the US... I haven't spend a ton of time there but the airport I'm familiar with in Canada, YYC (Calgary) has terrible access to/from the airport. The cab industry basically has convinced the city to not run a train line to the airport, nor to have a proper bus schedule. You need a taxi or ride for no good reason.
- hattmall 5y agoYou can do that in the US, you can't do it everywhere, but for the cities on the level of Prague and Paris you certainly can. Most of the major cities on the east coast and West Coast that's applicable and for Chicago. Philly, DC, NYC, Atlanta, Boston, Chicago, South Florida, LA, and the Bay area I've done entirely public transit trips many times to the major areas and that's covering a population larger than any EU country.
- throwawaynay 5y agoThat doesn't change the fact that trains and public transportation in the US are crap. In the US, can you travel +1000km for next to nothing at +300km/h in an environmentally friendly way?(in most cases you can arrive up to 5 minutes before the train leaves btw, no waiting) It's easier to travel through Europe than through the US and we're like 40 different countries....
- Mikeb85 5y ago>The transit-dependent urban poor are completely dependent on what opportunities might exist near the transit lines Yes, they are, which is why you build more infrastructure...
- jacobolus 5y agoCar-centered suburban development puts anyone who is not a healthy financially stable adult at a huge disadvantage. It is terrible for not only the poor and working class, but also children, families with children, the elderly, the disabled, the sick, tourists arriving by plane/train/bus/boat, etc. And it is even terrible for well-off healthy adults whenever something happens to their car (say, engine trouble). Not to mention, car accidents are a significant cause of injury and death, and being habitually sedentary leaves a high proportion of people in horrible physical shape and is a leading cause of ballooning healthcare costs, poor quality of life, and preventable deaths. It is a tremendously exclusionary, resource inefficient, fragile, and environmentally destructive form of transportation and social organization.
- rayiner 5y agoThat explains why NYC is full of kids multigenerational families and suburban and rural America isn’t, right?
- jacobolus 5y agoAnecdotally, both cities and rural areas are full of kids of multigenerational households (I’m having trouble tracking down a good data source; maybe you have data?). But that generally has more to do with poverty than love for a particular place. It is also more common among immigrant and minority groups. My impression is that car-centric suburbs full of wealthy white people have the fewest multigenerational households. The elderly are much less independent in a car-centric society, which makes them more likely to end up spending longer in an assisted living facility where families can afford it.
- rayiner 5y agoBut the immigrants and minorities want to get out of there. I have had several members of my extended family who have lived in NYC after immigrating from Bangladesh. They do it because there’s a large Bangladeshi community and lots of support for new immigrants. But invariably they move out to Long Island as soon as they’re able to do so. The most recent wave is going straight to places like Texas. My FB feed is full of pictures of 3BR houses in the exurbs with pools. If living in a transit-dependent city with kids and elderly people was so convenient, the immigration pipeline wouldn’t involve people moving to Texas as soon as they can. But that’s exactly what happens. New York City has a huge internal out migration—it would be shrinking without international immigration. As an aside, most suburbs aren’t full of “wealthy white people.” In the DC area, the places where you’re most likely to encounter multigenerational households is the Virginia suburbs where there are lots of Hispanics and Muslims. DC itself has some of the lowest fertility rates in the country, for both white people and Black people.
- coldtea 5y ago
- newbie789 5y ago
- II2II 5y agoI disagree with this necessarily being an attempt to inject an urban hobby horse into a discussion on poverty. I have lived in compact towns where the main reason to own a vehicle was to service neighbouring industries (agriculture, forestry, petrochemical). Everything within town was within walking distance. Contrast that to the suburbs of larger cities, where it may be difficult to find a single employer within walking distance. I recognize those towns are not universal. Then again, the situation of your wife's family is not universal either. Which is the crux of the problem with discussions such as this one: people like to reach for generalities that reflect their own life experiences or observations, when the reality is that those perspectives represents a narrow worldview. Heck, even the people who study poverty for a living cannot come up with a consistent narrative (as demonstrated by the opening paragraphs of the article) since it will be influenced by the questions they ask and how they conduct their research.
- pandemicsoul 5y agoYou're right that public transit is inefficient for people living in rural areas, but 83% of the U.S. population lives in urban areas so to simply discount public transit as an "urbanist hobby horse" seems pretty hand-wavey. You only have to look to other developed countries to see how fast, cheap, and efficient public transit is not only a major and driving force in the economy, but also a critical part of the social safety net. Just because America's public transit systems have been hobbled by the oil-industry doesn't mean we shouldn't be improving it for everyone's benefit.
- rayiner 5y agoGo look at the Census definition of “urban.” Sibley, Iowa, where my wife grew up, is classified as an “urban area.” It’s in the middle of nowhere surrounded by farmland.
- seanmcdirmid 5y ago> And cars mean that if someone loses their job or their housing, they can pick up and move to a different town where there might be opportunities. Poor people in Europe can easily hop a train to get to another town or village if needed. In the case of a really rural community, they will have buses to the nearest train station. > That also makes them tremendously reliant on the city central planners, who are often incompetent. Aka America’s self fulfilling destiny.
- inglor_cz 5y ago"Poor people in Europe can easily hop a train to get to another town or village if needed." Not completely true, there are many rural regions where the train or bus service is very irregular, if not discontinued outright. One of the reasons why the Yellow Vests in France were so forceful: French countryside is seriously underserved by public transport and living there without a car or with very expensive fuel is hard.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoThat might be true, in that they are underserved, but that is a huge difference from the USA’s non-service. My experience is in (the French speaking part of) Switzerland, where to get to a remote mountain village you must go by postal bus from the train station. The postal bus only came once every 2 hours, which was a pain, but it was very viable.
- Simon_O_Rourke 5y agoI've been to a few of those near Neuchatel, the busses may be sparse, but they're regular and reliable
- sli 5y ago> The vast majority of poor Americans have a car. Because they have no choice, and are constantly forced to dump money into it to keep it on the road. This is absolutely pertinent to this discussion. Public transit systems are restricting because they are so poorly implemented. I live in a small town, but when I was looking into taking the bus to work in the morning, it would have taken two hours each way, every day. That's extremely poor public transit and creates a huge amount of pressure to buy a car instead.