2 ms·
IBM owned 9/8 so this is a legitimate use of address space. All hosts should have globally unique addresses, even if you want to use NAT to hide various things.
by wmf 5y ago
IBM owned 9/8 so this is a legitimate use of address space. All hosts should have globally unique addresses, even if you want to use NAT to hide various things. IBM does multiple acquisitions per year. Imagine merging two corporate networks that both use 10/8; it's a nightmare.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wongarsu 5y agoThe acquisition's IPs might not conflict with IBMs, but surely they conflict with those of the other acquisitions? Is there any benefit after the first acquisition?
- wmf 5y agoMy point is that if every company uses real IPs then you can merge networks with no conflicts. 10/8 is fine for home use but not for enterprise networks.
- wongarsu 5y agoIn a word where any medium sized company could just get a /20 network and any enterprise could get a /8 I would agree, but with IPv4 we live in a world where the vast majority of companies don't have anything but 10/8 (and a couple of IPs for public facing stuff). The only real options besides 10/8 are to have been big at the advent of the internet (like IBM or Apple) or misappropriate one of those IP blocks in the hope it never becomes publicly routable.
- tpolzer 5y agoThere's a real option: IPv6 and 464XLAT
- Dylan16807 5y agoSo use no IPv4s at all? Well that still falls under "all the addresses you assign to machines are real global addresses" I'm sure it's a fine option now but that RFC is pretty new.
- jrockway 5y ago> Imagine merging two corporate networks that both use 10/8; it's a nightmare. This is a nightmare even inside companies. Two teams set up a default VPC, and one day you go to peer them and find that the IP ranges conflict. At my last job, I ended up using Netbox to manage our private IP ranges alongside our public IP ranges. (In theory, it would be nice if cloud providers offered this feature. "8 other VPCs on this account also use 10.0.0.0/8. Are you sure you want to be the 9th?")
- epc 5y agoI do not know IBM’s current practice but in the 1990s acquisitions continued to use their internal networking for quite a long time, just interconnecting the networks as necessary and announcing routes internally. 9. addresses only started being used widely inside IBM around 1992 as the internal multi protocol network rolled out (combining RSCS over SNA and TCP/IP). As APPC connected devices gave way to TCP/IP connected devices allocations shot upward, IIRC each major campus was a /16. Advantis/IBM Global Network ran the 9 network on the same physical and logical circuits as the public networks they managed, leading me to bypass the IBM firewall unintentionally multiple times as the filters they used broke. This may be one of the reasons RFC1918 addresses were discouraged (at least through 12/2001 when I left).