5 ms·
I totally agree that the take away is construction costs are going up over time! This holds true even if you look at price/foot opposed to total cost. Like you
by s1artibartfast 5y ago
I totally agree that the take away is construction costs are going up over time! This holds true even if you look at price/foot opposed to total cost.
Like you said, part of this is differences in what you get, building codes, and amenities.
That said, Craftsmen homes are wonderful and in some respects have better build quality than modern homes.
- R0b0t1 5y agoJust interjecting "but building codes!" doesn't make a lot of sense. If the codes are so strict that we can't actually build houses they are failing at their purpose. I dunno if you've dug deeply into most building codes but they're almost always overly specific in pointless ways and in ways totally unrelated to safety. Getting an engineer to sign off on a design should be enough, especially for a freestanding (tiny)house.
- rootusrootus 5y agoOTOH, hiring an engineer to actually put their name on your home construction will almost certainly cost significantly more than the city inspection cost.
- R0b0t1 5y agoEvery location (in the US) I'm aware of requires houses to be signed off on by an engineer before construction. You always have to pay for it. The issue is engineers are usually obligated to enforce code, and a lot of them try to be stamp mills -- they only want to look over and assure designs that are very similar so they don't have to think about it. There's an unfortunate number of locations in the US where you must use wood frame for your house, or you must route your power in exactly this way, etc, even if it'd be equally safe or cheaper to do something else.
- rascul 5y ago> Every location (in the US) I'm aware of requires houses to be signed off on by an engineer before construction. This varies widely by state. In some states, it matters if you're in a municipality or if you're rural. Where I am, in this county, I do not require a permit or inspections or anything to build a house for myself unless I'm inside a municipality. The government doesn't care until it's time to pay taxes. I may need some sort of inspection to hook up to the electric grid though, or to get water turned on. In (edit: some) other states, you can barely build a small dog house behind your house in the country without permits, inspections, engineers, surveys, and all kinds of other stuff.
- R0b0t1 5y agoAh yeah, you're right, I confused myself.
- rootusrootus 5y agoI will admit that I don't know regulations outside of my area, and I'm guilty of assuming they are somewhat standardized across the US (and indeed, for some codes, internationally). Here we just have city inspectors to check basic code compliance. They'll take a quick look at the framing, electrical, and plumbing before the sheetrock goes up, and then they come back for a walk-through before issuing the certificate of occupation. No engineers. The biggest fees by far are the permit fees, but that's for revenue and would still exist if engineers were doing the analysis for the construction.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoIn UK you can buy a house that was built in the dark ages, before Americas were 'discovered', were declared a listed building and the owners are legally barred from making major changes. They cost like 3x what a newbuild does, this "but building codes" stuff doesnt stand up to scruitiny. You dont have to use wood, we have brick. We've had automation and 100 years of growth in productivity.
- djdjfhsje33edh 5y ago> They cost like 3x what a newbuild does, this "but building codes" stuff doesnt stand up to scruitiny. I don't think that's a fair comparison. There is a fixed supply by definition of those old buildings, so their price will be pushed up by demand with little relation to their cost to build since they can't be built anymore. A better comparison would be to look at the cost of new houses in developing places like SE Asia where there are little to no building codes.
- blitzar 5y agoThe building code certainly allows homes to be built with 3 foot brick walls, but home builder building 100 cookie cutter homes on a plot of land are in it for the money (despite saying they are in it to build peoples dreams in their ads). They build using the cheapest methods allowed by law, see the choice to build with fireproof cladding (£24 psm) vs flamable (£22 psm). Building codes are about setting a floor in the construction quality, not a ceiling (pun intended).
- OJFord 5y agoThere's a lot more than you probably imagine, other than these 3x price ones GP's thinking of - that seems pretty niche, they'd have to be exceptionally well-preserved and dripping in original features.
- kube-system 5y agoI wouldn’t exactly characterize that as “construction costs going up” though. We’re building different things. The standard of living has changed significantly. The 1910’s were a very different time. Comparing houses now to houses then is like comparing a horse to a Honda Accord. We’re not just talking luxury features here —- You can be pretty certain that a home built in 2022 has indoor plumbing, a refrigerator, and a furnace that doesn’t require shoveling fuel.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI agree that they are clearly different houses. That said, I think the difference is overstated. I have lots of friends who live in craftsmen homes. They resell at basically the same price as similar sized houses built 25 years ago (even with single pane windows ect) . If somehow you got one that wasn't upgraded since 1920, you are looking at a few tens of thousands to put in electrical, plumbing, and appliances. Still, you are right that that they are not the same. But a lot of people today would kill to own a beautiful new craftsman home for 40k! I wouldn't trade out my car for a horse, but I would trade 40k a year rent for a craftsman home! The point is that even you wanted to replicate an original craftsman home today, you wouldn't be able to do it for that price, even ignoring regulations. Labor costs have gone up, wood has gone up, minimum cost of every material used has gone up.
- learc83 5y agoThe average craftsman home built 100 years ago isn’t going for the same price as a 25 year old house. The craftsman homes that have survived for 100 years in good condition are. That’s a very different thing. Old houses also have tons of problems even when upgraded, and they just aren’t anywhere near equivalent to a modern home unless you essentially gut them and rebuild. Insulation isn’t nearly as good. Bathrooms aren’t nearly the same size. The floor plans aren’t nearly as open. This last one in particular is a big cost difference because creating large open spans is expensive. Those things might not matter as much to you, but they are big differences. >The point is that even you wanted to replicate an original craftsman home today, you wouldn't be able to do it for that price, even ignoring regulations. Labor costs have gone up, wood has gone up, minimum cost of every material used has gone up. Depends on the part of the country and whether or not you can use modern equivalent materials. Where I live, assuming pre pandemic prices, I could probably build a 900 sq ft, single story house with a wooden pier foundation, no plumbing, no electrical, no insulation (or maybe old newspapers like my great grandmothers house used for insulation), no driveway, no sod, and no inspections for $40-$50k. That would be roughly equivalent to your average house built 100 years ago.
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y agoThe average craftsman home listed for sale in CA - 80+ years old - seems substantially better than the average newly built D.R. Horton home. Maybe this is highly biased toward craftsman homes that have been well maintained due to how expensive CA housing is. But why wouldn't D.R. Horton homes also be maintained? They're theoretically equally expensive.
- learc83 5y agoThe surviving craftsman homes, which weren’t average for the time time due to survivorship bias, are more likely to be built in higher density walkable environments closer to urban cores. Real estate in those areas is more valuable in general. The average D.R. Horton home is built further out on lower density, less valuable land. There’s also an element of scarcity here. There’s a subset of people who find older homes appealing specifically because they are older. The supply of older homes can’t increase, but the supply of D.R. Horton homes can and does.