8 ms·
The standard of construction has also changed since 1914. Not only do few people want to build a 900sqft freestanding home, if they did it today with that Sears
by kube-system 5y ago
The standard of construction has also changed since 1914. Not only do few people want to build a 900sqft freestanding home, if they did it today with that Sears kit, it would break nearly every building code in the book.
A more equal comparison would be to a prefab or mobile home, which you can get for that inflation adjusted price.
- dzhiurgis 5y agoDid standard improve 5x tho? Probably by like 2-3x I'd guess. Or standard maybe even decreased in some ways, but we're actually paying for complexity. Also - building larger typically reduces price/sqm.
- kube-system 5y agoThere's a lot of ways that the standards have changed, it's not just one dimension. Complexity and feature set are probably the biggest. New construction single-family homes today are more likely to be customized, not kits, have way more features and way better mechanicals. That 1914 house had no kitchen appliances, no laundry appliances, no driveway, no garage, no insulation, no central HVAC, etc.
- anonAndOn 5y agoNo kidding. Brick foundation, exterior plumbing, knob and tube wiring with 1 electrical outlet and 1 ceiling light bulb per room, zero insulation, single pane glass windows, dirt driveway... all features of my "charming, historically accurate" previous residence.
- sokoloff 5y agoIn 1925, only half of homes in the US had electric lighting. None had air conditioning. Many would have had only steam boilers (which can function without electric pumps) fired by hand-shoveled coal. Most would have had no insulation. In 1940, half of homes had no indoor flush toilets and no hot running water. If you built a house today without electricity, with only cold water service, and an outhouse, I think you’d save a fair bit on skilled trades (and be pretty damn unhappy when you visited a neighbor and saw their utilities).
- s1artibartfast 5y ago>In 1925, only half of homes in the US had electric lighting. None had air conditioning. Many would have had only steam boilers (which can function without electric pumps) fired by hand-shoveled coal. Most would have had no insulation. In 1940, half of homes had no indoor flush toilets and no hot running water. This is true but can be a little bit misleading. You would expect new homes built in 1925 or 1940 to have many more of these amenities than the average. (you can see the flush toilet in the Sears 1914 home). For context, The average home in the US today was built ~45 years ago.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"In 1925, only half of homes in the US had electric lighting." Surely if our goal was to compare prices of TVs over the past 20 years, and if we found that prices of TVs haven't changed, you cannot then claim 'well, old TVs were 720p and modern TVs are 4K, so actually the price of TVs dropped 4 times!' Today we have all kinds of things that increase productivity: electric power tools, prebuilt parts, laser levels and measuring tools, CAD software, flooring that interlocks, expanding foam that's easilly applied from a spray can, drywall and dozens of things I never even heard of.
- waiseristy 5y agoAs an owner of 90+ year old home. Yes. It's quite dramatic how underbuilt old homes are. 2x4 joists spanning 10+ feet was commonplace. Foundations were cinderblocks holding up whole timbers. Insulation wasn't even a thing!
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI totally agree that the take away is construction costs are going up over time! This holds true even if you look at price/foot opposed to total cost. Like you said, part of this is differences in what you get, building codes, and amenities. That said, Craftsmen homes are wonderful and in some respects have better build quality than modern homes.
- R0b0t1 5y agoJust interjecting "but building codes!" doesn't make a lot of sense. If the codes are so strict that we can't actually build houses they are failing at their purpose. I dunno if you've dug deeply into most building codes but they're almost always overly specific in pointless ways and in ways totally unrelated to safety. Getting an engineer to sign off on a design should be enough, especially for a freestanding (tiny)house.
- rootusrootus 5y agoOTOH, hiring an engineer to actually put their name on your home construction will almost certainly cost significantly more than the city inspection cost.
- R0b0t1 5y agoEvery location (in the US) I'm aware of requires houses to be signed off on by an engineer before construction. You always have to pay for it. The issue is engineers are usually obligated to enforce code, and a lot of them try to be stamp mills -- they only want to look over and assure designs that are very similar so they don't have to think about it. There's an unfortunate number of locations in the US where you must use wood frame for your house, or you must route your power in exactly this way, etc, even if it'd be equally safe or cheaper to do something else.
- rascul 5y ago> Every location (in the US) I'm aware of requires houses to be signed off on by an engineer before construction. This varies widely by state. In some states, it matters if you're in a municipality or if you're rural. Where I am, in this county, I do not require a permit or inspections or anything to build a house for myself unless I'm inside a municipality. The government doesn't care until it's time to pay taxes. I may need some sort of inspection to hook up to the electric grid though, or to get water turned on. In (edit: some) other states, you can barely build a small dog house behind your house in the country without permits, inspections, engineers, surveys, and all kinds of other stuff.
- plasticchris 5y agoHave you checked on the prices for prefab homes? Even in the Midwest 40k won’t even get you the cheapest ones unless you go with something like a used mobile home.
- kube-system 5y agoYes, I checked before I posted the comment, and I found many around the 62,000 range with delivery ($40k+22k is cited in the parent).
- plasticchris 5y agoAh, they said 40k with labor. Even so, 62k would be difficult to find in my experience. Where are you looking? I’m curious where the price is so low.
- brimble 5y agoQuality lumber is incredibly expensive now compared with 1914. I owned a 1910s-construction house for a while, and they used huge, thick wooden boards around the foundation where the structure met the stone-and-mortar basement walls, and in the floor joists (visible in the basement), and in the diagonally-run underfloor boards (used where we'd use plywood, today). Nearly knot-free, perfectly straight, that stuff would probably be put aside for high-end fine woodworking or even veneer-making, now. It was beautiful stuff and they stuck it under the floors. The ones around the walls must have been something like 8"x14" or bigger, and tens of feet long. Nearly-flawless pieces of lumber. I assume the wood used in the wall framing (some pieces likely three stories long—it was a balloon-construction house) was similarly astoundingly-good by modern standards. That stuff was, evidently, so cheap from the perspective of people in the 1910s, that they didn't think it worth any amount of effort to sub in worse wood for places where looks didn't matter. These days, some of that would be hard to find at any price, short of salvaging it from old buildings like that. And that's the "crap" they put under the nice wood they used for finishing! OTOH we do have drywall, which has got to be cheaper in pretty much every way than lathe-and-plaster.
- throwaway19423 5y agoI live in Canada, where we are swimming in lumber (in theory). I just don't understand why it is so expensive. I know the processing and treatment is very sophisticated but there is so much automation throughout the whole chain. My only explanation is that lumber is a globally traded commodity .. price isn't determined by just Canadian demand for lumber but the global demand. It makes me wonder .. if the US shutdown Canadian wood imports, would that significantly lower prices for Canadian consumers? How low would it go?
- mistrial9 5y agomy un-schooled guess is simple - the rest of the industrialized world has benefited from profit markups in real dollars of today - that fun book or skateboard was priced in modern terms.. while lumber is a commodity from the previous century or three.. their dollars and costs were low to start with, and were pressed down by commodity markets. I once asked a recent undergrad in Economics graduate, at a party, why one pound of bread costs more than one pound of meat (the inputs and processing costs are vastly different, through the life of the animal, the meat should be way, way more) but, blank stare, more beer. I for one believe that most of the markets, most of the time, make no sense at all from the perspective of the real natural inputs, and all the sense in the world from the point of view of one human group selling things to another human group, any way they can; old timber included.
- anm89 5y agoalso as someone who is working with architects and builders right now on a house, I can say the houses you are getting at the 250 /sqft range in many cases are terribly built. They are going to last a fraction of the time that that $45 / sqft house from 100 years ago lasted
- learc83 5y agoMany houses built 100 years ago were incredibly shoddily built / assembled. Have you ever looked at the foundations on old houses? Wooden piers that are lucky to last 40 years were very common. You’re seeing survivorship bias at work. Also 250/sq ft is far from cheap/shoddy quality in much of the US. And with proper maintenance just about any house built to code in most places in the US will easily last longer than the average house built 100 years ago.
- kube-system 5y agoI don’t need a house that lasts 100 years. My estate will be selling it in 50 years, if I don’t sell it in the average ownership duration of 10 years. Lasting a long time does not mean a structure is better in every way. Old housing can be a challenge in terms of safety, cohesive design, lifestyle fit, land use, environmental concerns, etc. In Japan, for instance, it is popular to frequently tear down housing rebuild it, and it works well for them. I have lived in and fixed up many old houses with strong bones. They might stand for hundreds of years but everything attached to those bones is a patchwork of afterthoughts.
- gjhh244 5y agoSo you think tearing down a house every 50 years isn't an environmental problem? It absolutely is. Concrete especially causes major Co2 emissions.
- kube-system 5y ago+1 for wooden American homes, made from naturally sequestered carbon :) I haven't done the math, but I'd bet the energy efficiency requirements would more than make up for it. Uninsulated/underinsulated homes are a huge waste of energy.
- Spooky23 5y agoThe Sears kit wasn’t unique in that regard and they were built pretty good for the time. Non kit houses were often balloon framed or featured other serious code issues. I live in a northeast city, and the average house in a ten block radius was built between 1920-1940. They seem to weather just fine and gradual retrofits to things like electric panels eventually take place. You can’t compare that meaningfully to a mobile home, which is more like a car with a 20 year lifespan. Frankly, I think the building codes are out of control in some respects and add needless cost. The standard of construction of a middle class home built in 1925 is better the 2022 on the basis of materials alone.
- joe_the_user 5y agoNot only do few people want to build a 900sqft freestanding home, if they did it today with that Sears kit, it would break nearly every building code in the book. Lots of people want to build 900 sqft homes. It's just that with land costing 100s of ks and utility hookups etc at 100k, it make no sense to build a 900 sqft house. Basically, areas with high house prices have created a situation building a little house on a bit of land is between very cost ineffective and simply impossible and then said "no one want to do this".
- bobthepanda 5y agoAlso, with min lot sizes a 900 sq ft house doesn't quite pencil out at today's land prices. Most jurisdictions would not let you buy a 900 sq ft plot of land, for example, because the size would be too small.
- selestify 5y agoWhy do those jurisdictions create min lot sizes in the first place? Surely there's a reason other than maintaining housing prices.
- bobthepanda 5y agoputting a floor on house prices is a bit of the point, to prevent "the wrong kind of people" from "destroying the neighborhood character"
- kwhitefoot 5y ago900 square feet is pretty close the the average size of a family home in the UK.
- driverdan 5y agoHow many new houses are built to that size though? The UK has a lot of very old housing stock.
- asiachick 5y ago900sqft is larger than most Japanese houses. Americans are spoiled https://graphics.reuters.com/HEALTH-CORONAVIRUS/TOKYO-HOMES/dgkvlabxpbx/ https://graphics.reuters.com/HEALTH-CORONAVIRUS/TOKYO-HOMES/...
- _uy6i 5y agoCompliance with building codes <> higher quality I grew up in a small farm house built in the 1700’s - post and beam construction, that will far outlast “code compliant” building methods of today
- kube-system 5y ago“Lasting a long time” also <> higher quality. There’s a lot of other factors that more closely contribute to making a house a nice place to live. Whether it lasts for hundreds of years after the owners death is relatively unimpactful on their quality of life.
- _uy6i 5y agoFair enough - but I’d say the quality of construction was much higher as well.