11 ms·
Some interesting historical context on construction costs: 100 years ago the cost of construction was about $45/sqft when adjusted for inflation and today it i
by s1artibartfast 5y ago
Some interesting historical context on construction costs:
100 years ago the cost of construction was about $45/sqft when adjusted for inflation and today it is closer to $220/sqft, approximately 5x the cost. Blue collar wedges are pretty similar across time, but the cost of house construction (ignoring land) is dramatically higher.
The 1914 sears Model 147 house was 900sqft and cost $872 for materials, estimated at $1,530 with labor.[1] Adjusting for inflation from 1914 to 2020, that is about $22,000 for materials and 40K with labor.
Looking at 1913 US national labor statistics, the average baker in 1913 San Francisco worked 54 hrs/wk and made $0.46 per hour for an annual wage of $1,291[2] (or 33K in 2020 dollars)
The median baker in 2020 California makes 36.5K/yr [3]. The cost of new housing construction is $220/sqft[4], or 200K for the same size house.
http://www.searsarchives.com/homes/images/1908-1914/1913_0147.jpg http://www.searsarchives.com/homes/images/1908-1914/1913_014...
https://fraser.stlouisfed.org/title/union-scale-wages-hours-labor-3912/union-scale-wages-hours-labor-may-15-1913-476866?start_page=79 https://fraser.stlouisfed.org/title/union-scale-wages-hours-...
https://www.careeronestop.org/Toolkit/Careers/Occupations/occupation-profile.aspx?keyword=Bakers&onetcode=51301100&location=94122 https://www.careeronestop.org/Toolkit/Careers/Occupations/oc...
https://ternercenter.berkeley.edu/wp-content/uploads/pdfs/Hard_Construction_Costs_March_2020.pdf https://ternercenter.berkeley.edu/wp-content/uploads/pdfs/Ha...
- chrisseaton 5y agoBaker is a strange salary to look at. Back then bakers were everywhere churning out a staple food by hand. Today a baker is likely to be an artisan of some kind, with a specialist product.
- whoisburbansky 5y agoIt's odd, don't you think, that an "artisan" of some kind, with a "specialist" product, would only make about 10% more per annum, adjusted for inflation, than a generalist churning out a staple food by hand?
- ghaff 5y agoI expect that most "bakers" in the US today work for grocery chains (or maybe for manufacturers of packaged bread and pastry products--not sure how precisely the category is defined). They're probably mostly not working for artisan specialty bakeries although I wouldn't be shocked if people at those places weren't exactly raking it in either.
- chrisseaton 5y agoI don't think those large industrial bakeries really have 'bakers'? They have automation engineers, food scientists, mechanics.
- ghaff 5y agoAs I say. I don't know who is counted. In any case, I certainly imagine grocery chains that bake on-premise have "bakers" and there are more of them in that type of job than working in high-end artisan bakeries.
- datadawg 5y agoJust wanted to say I've enjoyed this HN rabbithole gold, where we've gone from talking about increasing house costs to discussing the role of bakers in modern day industrial bakeries :)
- vkou 5y agoNo, those people are the specialists that come in and set things up, or design and build the machinery that gets set up. The day-to-day work is done by bakers, and much of it is not automated.
- OJFord 5y agoIt's a factory job though, their employer 'competes' for them with the other nearby factories, not the nearby independent bakeries.
- jzwinck 5y ago
- missedthecue 5y agoyes that occupation has changed considerably in the last 100 years. A "baker" today is usually the person who opens Krispy Kreme in the morning. 1914 was a decade and half before sliced bread was even invented! These days, bread is made very efficiently in massive plants (which is why it costs only $0.93 a loaf at my grocer)
- s1artibartfast 5y agoIt is just a point of comparison. You can ignore it and focus on inflation and dollar purchasing power for consumer goods, also included. Point being that house construction costs have grown on a different trajectory than dollar value and salary.
- kube-system 5y agoThe standard of construction has also changed since 1914. Not only do few people want to build a 900sqft freestanding home, if they did it today with that Sears kit, it would break nearly every building code in the book. A more equal comparison would be to a prefab or mobile home, which you can get for that inflation adjusted price.
- dzhiurgis 5y agoDid standard improve 5x tho? Probably by like 2-3x I'd guess. Or standard maybe even decreased in some ways, but we're actually paying for complexity. Also - building larger typically reduces price/sqm.
- kube-system 5y agoThere's a lot of ways that the standards have changed, it's not just one dimension. Complexity and feature set are probably the biggest. New construction single-family homes today are more likely to be customized, not kits, have way more features and way better mechanicals. That 1914 house had no kitchen appliances, no laundry appliances, no driveway, no garage, no insulation, no central HVAC, etc.
- anonAndOn 5y agoNo kidding. Brick foundation, exterior plumbing, knob and tube wiring with 1 electrical outlet and 1 ceiling light bulb per room, zero insulation, single pane glass windows, dirt driveway... all features of my "charming, historically accurate" previous residence.
- sokoloff 5y agoIn 1925, only half of homes in the US had electric lighting. None had air conditioning. Many would have had only steam boilers (which can function without electric pumps) fired by hand-shoveled coal. Most would have had no insulation. In 1940, half of homes had no indoor flush toilets and no hot running water. If you built a house today without electricity, with only cold water service, and an outhouse, I think you’d save a fair bit on skilled trades (and be pretty damn unhappy when you visited a neighbor and saw their utilities).
- rr808 5y agoYes its interesting example, but 1914 Sears house didn't have electricity, or hot water (was an extra), no shower, I'm guessing its single glazed and lightly insulated. Certainly I think most modern houses are too luxurious with marble and complicated accessories that aren't really needed.
- throwawaylinux 5y agoAre most modern houses really too luxurious where you're from? What I see is that they have pretty poor build quality when you look closely, and are thrown together as cheaply as possible, and are not designed all that well. Where I am, "marble" would be engineered stone (which I don't have a problem with it's functional and looks okay), but many new kitchens (and bathrooms) aren't well designed for the space they take up and come with flimsy gimmicky fittings and appliances. Where modern houses go overboard (in my opinion) is optimizing floor area per dollar and making them very large and lowering quality. Although that's also a response to buyer preferences, people like having very big houses and don't care too much about the design, the details, or efficiency.
- rr808 5y agoYes build quality is poor. "Luxurious" to me has quotes, looks pretty on the brochure but everything needs replacing after 10 years.
- dockd 5y agoDid the 1914 house have electricity? With "acetylene lighting plant" being extra, I think not. Did the 1914 house have more than one toilet? Cost per square foot doesn't cover what goes into the square foot, and fixtures cost a lot more than an empty room.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoDoes it cost 5x to add electrical wiring into a house? I would happily take a 1915 house and upgrade it. I love in a 'premium' newbuild block in a 1st world country, and the construction quality is so atrocious it would be condemned in some 2nd world countries! The builders forgot to connect the extractor fan to any ducting, it just sits inside the ceiling and makes noise, the piping of the sprinkler system in not secured to any structure and is wobbling and threatwning a flood, the guy that made a hole in the ceiling for the sprinkler missed and we have a hole in the ceiling and a sprinkler somewhere inside. Last week a hot water mains has burst creating a flood of scalding water and 13 floors had to be evacuated. We had a nice steaming waterfall down the side of the building 40 meters down. The electric meters are installed in breach of code. It's a 23 story building and elevators never work, etc. The building was completed 4 years ago, apartments sold at a premium to 'investors' based in tax heavens - not a single resident here owns the flat. Mine is based in Cayman islands.
- majormajor 5y ago> I would happily take a 1915 house and upgrade it. Why do you think it's so much easier/better to upgrade an old house than fix constructions errors with a new one? I live in an early-20th-century house with minimally-acceptable plumbing and electric (pipes not secured to the structure? welcome to the club!), no insulation, terribly cold windows, one tiny bathroom, sometimes-wobbly feeling floors, etc. "Upgrading it" would basically be "rip it down to the studs and redo it all" which is basically "everything but one of the easiest parts of new construction" anyway.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoThe idea was basically 'I would rather upgrade a well-built 1900 house than try to fix a poorly built, possibly structurally flawed modern one'. I am not sure it would be easier, but my genereal experiece is telling me the outcome is usually better. I think the new 'buy to let' phenomenom makes it possible to sell shoddy construction as premium houses to investors based in tax heavens becuase it looks shiny and htey don't give two shits.
- jjav 5y agoWhile costs have risen, it's not reasonable to compare a kit-house like the ones Sears offered, to a house built on-site. Looking for kit-houses, I found: https://rethority.com/kit-homes/ https://rethority.com/kit-homes/ Where it says "On average, expect to spend between $40 to $60 per square foot to complete your kit home build." So that's right in the ballpark of the above inflation-adjusted cost of $45/sqft a century ago.
- cma 5y agoIt seems like there should be a better metric using purchasing power parity since it is domestic labor intensive.
- WalterBright 5y agoLumber is a great way to sequester carbon. Plant more trees!
- conductr 5y agoMechanical/appliances alone can run more than the inflation adjusted Sears house
- daniel-cussen 5y agoThey cost about the same. There's a few differences, like some better tech--also some worse tech, like preferring lasers and CPUs over older cheaper techniques that also work better[1]. There's more regulation too. And wages have swung upward and downward in the intervening time, right now we're barely past the bottom of the cycle[2] of the relationship between leaf-node employee wages and everything else. But the real difference is that official inflation is a lie. Inflation since 1970 is closer to 38x (candy-jar guessing), not 7.25x. So the costs of construction are pretty similar. [1] So once upon a time, to create a level line, and in Latin America to this day, you fill a clear hose held up in a U-shape with water up to a foot from the top on either end. Hold one waterline up to the mark that marks the height you want for the level line. Then extend the other end out to the wall you want the level line to extend to. The waterline will be at the same height on either end. Mark it. That's the endpoint of the level line. Costs like three dollars for the hose and that hose lasts indefinitely unless it is damaged, by getting stepped on pretty much not due to any other reason. Whereas apparently in USA there's laser levels that have all these buttons and a manual and a CPU and data and...yuck. And it starts at $29.99 for the basic model, of what I can tell--you can't look up prices online anymore much because they're tailor in many cases. That's what I think that crappy product costs--that's the "price point" they target. Plus there's price discrimination and rebates, points, programs, whereas with the clear hose you're clearly not getting hosed. [2] Since about the seventies--a time when I daresay managers were underpaid--there has been opposition at multiple different levels against leaf-node employee wages. From opposing the minimum wage, to promoting immigrant arrivals who rarely manage anybody when they arrive, to busting unions and strikes, to right-to-work laws, plus noncompetes for the likes of sandwich makers, plus SCOTUS making paying union dues destined for political speech optional (but no such luck for the part of the price for a good that corporations destine for political speech), to women entering the workforce (more leaf-node competition, they don't start out as management), to college becoming impossible to pay for as a leaf-node worker, then endless distortions in the housing market to make rent a third of income (this is by design, it can just as easily be a tenth), plus the erosion of safety nets...it's a subject unto itself, but leaf-node wages are heavily opposed in America. After IIRC their peak in 1978, 44 years ago, they are coming back up from the trough. Tying it back to the subject of inflation, leaf-node wages are considered inflationary in a way that other wages are not. And according to the BLS, inflation and leaf-node wages are the sameself thing. EDIT: I forgot the other main ingredients of inflation: commodities, cars and computers. Commodity prices are also strongly opposed politically, corporately, and "mediatically." Cars and computers are not politically opposed--on the contrary, they're good, that's why they're included, to make inflation look smaller, look it up on http://www.shadowstats.com http://www.shadowstats.com.
- vericiab 5y agoBy how much and why the cost of labor has changed over time is an interesting question. I'd assume that the bulk of the cost of labor is wages, but there are some other direct and indirect costs that might contribute in addition to wage related factors. Carrying workers' compensation insurance was not the norm at the turn of the 20th century; injured workers could instead sue their employer for negligence but usually lost. Legal challenges to state legislation that made participation in a workers' compensation program mandatory weren't resolved until the Supreme Court's 1917 ruling on N.Y. Central R.R. Co. v. White. In the modern day, Texas is the only state where workers' compensation insurance isn't mandatory. In a similar vein, workplace safety standards have seen a lot of change. With the exception of a few states that passed legislation sooner, workplace safety was largely unregulated until the Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970 established OSHA. I know less of the specifics but consumer protection laws have also changed. Many states now impose statutory warranties on new construction that cover construction defects for a period of time. It seems plausible that builders had less liability for such defects in 1914. Construction equipment and the cost of running and maintaining it is another thing that I would expect gets rolled into the cost of labor. I'd assume that equipment costs are usually offset by increased efficiency (paying wages for less time), so it wouldn't increase the cost of labor, but it would be interesting to see data on that. As far as wage-related factors, while blue collar wages may not have changed in general there are some exceptions. Based on the sources you provided, plumbers in 1913 San Francisco worked 44 hrs/wk and made $0.75 per hour for an annual wage of $1716 (or $44.9K in 2020 dollars). The median plumber in 2020 San Francisco makes $110.9K/yr. (Since SF might be an outlier, in St Louis in 1913 plumbers made $1515 annually, equivalent to $39.6K in 2020, and had a median annual wage of $80.6K in 2020.) It's also possible the number and types of workers required to build a home has changed. Constructing a new home might now require more "specialists" (like plumbers) who command higher wages to do work that was either not done at all or was previously done by general laborers paid lower wages. It would be interesting to see data on that as well.
- KoftaBob 5y ago> Blue collar wedges (wages?) are pretty similar across time, but the cost of house construction (ignoring land) is dramatically higher. Blue collar wages as a whole may have, but construction workers' wages since 2006 have increased 47% when adjusted for inflation. This should come as no surprise, since that field historically has strong unions. You also have more rigorous safety codes for those workers. On top of that, building codes have changed dramatically (thankfully) in those past 100 years. Whether it's structural, insulation, windows, electrical wiring and capacity, plumbing (older homes pipes were narrower, so couldn't handle things like a garbage disposal).