8 ms·
Solar is awesome in that yield scales with load peaks. The problem with nuclear is an example of why deregulation was stupid. As a society of electricity consu
by Spooky23 5y ago
Solar is awesome in that yield scales with load peaks.
The problem with nuclear is an example of why deregulation was stupid. As a society of electricity consumers, we are sitting on lawn chairs on a railroad track with an electric train approaching us. It's obvious to anyone with a pulse that electric cars are ramping up and will displace the current fleet, and equally obvious that that operating model (plug in your car at night) will increase base load requirements.
So because we've detached planning from electrical generation and distribution, we have 50 different sets of cartels optimizing for short term returns on the spot market. The various electrical shit-shows in California and Texas are like failed-state levels of dysfunction. North of NYC, electrical supply rates are up 50% because we turned off a massive reactor complex and replaced it with volatile natural gas. We're decommissioning nuclear at a point in time just before we need it, environmentalists were bought by gas extraction people and Wall St. accounting is very bad at dealing with capital assets with 50-100 year lifecycles.
If you think about it the "energy storage" problem is absurd. Installing millions of inefficient distributed battery cells in potentially millions of buildings, for want of adequate electrical generation is beyond dumb, and the scale of waste and wasted value is staggering. It is solely a byproduct of a market designed to maximize producer profit.
- KptMarchewa 5y ago> Solar is awesome in that yield scales with load peaks. This might be true in California but peak in Poland and many other places is after sun sets.
- spywaregorilla 5y agoAnd in some places in winter. And in some places in summer. Sometimes by HUGE multiples that operate inversely with the availability of solar power. For long periods that batteries struggle store power for.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- _ea1k 5y agoIts a problem here in the US too, though probably to a lesser degree. South facing solar is the most efficient in total energy produced, but it starts to drop off just as A/C loads start to accelerate toward their peak. West facing panels help, but the ROI isn't as good without variable energy pricing.
- bottled_poe 5y ago> We're decommissioning nuclear at a point in time just before we need it, environmentalists were bought by gas extraction people and Wall St. It’s insane that the environmentalist movement is inadvertently supporting the fossil fuel industry due to their traditional stance on nuclear. Modern civilisation requires reliable base load and nuclear seems like the only viable option which satisfies both the reliability and globally accepted environmentally sustainable goals.
- charcircuit 5y ago>nuclear seems like the only viable option which satisfies both the reliability and globally accepted environmentally sustainable goals. Hydro?
- bottled_poe 5y agoHydro is great, but is very limited in terms of viable locations.
- jimmydorry 5y agoHydro causes massive environment destruction, takes up a large amount of area (typically the most agriculturally productive area at that), and can't just be thrown down anywhere.
- willcipriano 5y agoThe environmental movement is 9/10ths feelings, and 1/10th science. A lot of environmentalists just don't like rural people so they do things like rail on and on about pickup trucks whilest on a plane bound for a European vacation. That three eyed fish on the Simpsons probably resulted in thousands of deaths due to the environmental folks choosing coal over nuclear. The goal is good vibes, not results.
- sofixa 5y ago> A lot of environmentalists just don't like rural people so they do things like rail on and on about pickup trucks What? I don't think there are many environmentalists who "don't like rural people" and have a problem with pickup trucks used where they're appropriate ( like on a farm). In a country like the US, they're often abused as a suburban vehicle, which is a preposterous waste which deserves railing on against.
- mlindner 5y ago> The problem with nuclear is an example of why deregulation was stupid. There was never a deregulation that happened. In fact deregulation is what's needed to revive nuclear power. Competition in the power market is illegal in most states.
- briffle 5y agoI think the residents of texas that had no power for days, or $15k residential bills would disagree with you. In fact, my co-worker in MN had their natural gas rates go up a very noticable jump this year due to losses the company had in texas (and having to buy gas at super inflated peak rates when many texas pumping stations had to power down, since they weren't winterized to save some money.)
- godelski 5y agoThe parent you are responding to is talking about deregulation in a different context and with a different purpose. Regulation and deregulation are both broad terms and talking about one does not requisite jumping to a different topic. Doing so just means we'll fight all day because you can find examples on both sides where they had disastrous effects. We need to be more nuanced than this. I'll also argue that the parent should be more specific to avoid these types of responses too.
- throwaway894345 5y agoCan you elaborate on what nuclear regulations were lifted and how that contributed to the Texas power outage? This isn't rhetorical, I'm genuinely curious.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoNuclear regulations had nothing to do with it. Texas had very few regulations for oil/gas and for power plant winter weatherization hence the grid failed. Overall the grid is fine, but it can't handle a freak winter weather event like that, and it still can't. It has handled many summer heat events just fine (I know I've lived here for almost 15 years). Regulations are the obvious factor that lead to the failure, ERCOT has been warned (and in turn warned the politicians) about the dangers multiple times and the politicians will not pass legislation and money to fix the issue.
- apex3stoker 5y ago>environmentalists were bought by gas extraction people In the US, opposition to nuclear energy is more like opposition to homeless shelters - people don't want the plants near them. I don't think environmentlists are that powerful politically as to significantly impact the trajectory of nuclear power policies in the US, otherwise, they would have the power to significantly impact climate change policies too. Besides, what I have seen is that environmentalists are pretty divided in term of nuclear energy. There are strong opponents like green peace and Sierra clubs, there are strong supporters and there are many who are ambivalent. This further reduces their political power as a group. I think nuclear energy supporters should stop blaming environmentalists as they are pretty much non-factor if they want nuclear power.
- throwaway894345 5y agoThere's tons of FUD about nuclear waste, including with respect to environmental impacts. I think environmentalists have been coming around to nuclear, but I'm pretty sure that's a more recent development. At least my perception circa 10 years ago was that environmentalists were largely (if not overwhelmingly) opposed to nuclear. Certainly for a long while, environmentalists worked (perhaps unwittingly) with the fossil fuel industry to promote personal responsibility and lifestyle campaigns ("everyone needs to go vegan", "we just need more recycling", "get rid of SUVs", etc) rather than substantial energy reforms (like nuclear or carbon tax).
- apex3stoker 5y agoI don't think nuclear waste is a key factor, but cost overrun is. Source: https://www.vox.com/2016/2/29/11132930/nuclear-power-costs-us-france-korea https://www.vox.com/2016/2/29/11132930/nuclear-power-costs-u...
- Melatonic 5y agoEnvironmentalists are not against Nuclear generally - they are just against the shitty ways governments have stored the waste in the past. When a government cheaps out and ships the waste to some far off pacific island and does not invest as much as it should building a proper containment setup and then it all leaks into the ocean it becomes a big problem for everyone and then environmentalists are of course pissed. When done properly I would guess the majority would be relatively fine with it (although they may still prefer cleaner options).
- Hammershaft 5y ago> It's obvious to anyone with a pulse that electric cars are ramping up and will displace the current fleet, and equally obvious that that operating model (plug in your car at night) will increase base load requirements. It strikes me that transitioning to electric cars could become less viable the more we rely on renewables+batteries, as grid scale battery storage could hugely exacerbate shortages of battery materials. Though on the other hand grid batteries would also spur more research into battery tech which could change the game for both grid & mobile batteries. It seems like a huge gamble commiting to grid storage in the hopes of big innovations down the road instead of doubling down on baseload nuclear.
- ncmncm 5y agoYou have identified why grid-scale storage will not depend mainly on the kind of battery technology needed for cars.
- bamboozled 5y agoWe just make it expensive to plug-in at night for the average joe so they plug-in during the day, at the office etc? If you’re a courier or something you’re exempt.
- Manuel_D 5y ago> Solar is awesome in that yield scales with load peaks. No, this is the opposite of what is true. In most places, load peaks in the evening, just as the sun sets. Looking up the data [1], the more nuanced answer is that load peaks in in the evening in the fall, winter, and spring. Only in the summer does solar energy match load. 1. https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=42915 https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=42915
- jimmydorry 5y agoIf anyone wants another example, this has data for Australia [1]. Power usage consistently peaks in the late afternoon, typically as everyone ends work for the day [2][3]. Unsurprisingly, this is also around when the price spikes. [1] https://aemo.com.au/en/energy-systems/electricity/national-electricity-market-nem/data-nem/data-dashboard-nem https://aemo.com.au/en/energy-systems/electricity/national-e... [2] https://i.imgur.com/60kGlIR.png https://i.imgur.com/60kGlIR.png [3] https://i.imgur.com/nRjBjeN.png https://i.imgur.com/nRjBjeN.png
- widdma 5y agoIt's worth pointing out AEMO's demand is for the grid, and residential solar typically does not show up on the grid. OpenNEM[1] uses estimates of residential solar to approximate the full load. [1]: https://opennem.org.au/ https://opennem.org.au/
- grapescheesee 5y agoThis is exactly what I wanted to say, and have been for the last several years. The issue is no states, cities, population want to issue permits to build them. Its political to the point no one will touch it.