3 ms·
How would that keep the company in business to provide support? Seems like the same outcome, to me.
by sneak 5y ago
How would that keep the company in business to provide support? Seems like the same outcome, to me.
- kadoban 5y agoThey should be forced to fund a trust that can support all users for their lifetime.
- subroutine 5y agoHow much do you reckon that would cost per user?
- kadoban 5y agoA fairly large amount, even for minimal support. If it's prohibitive to create cool medical devices due to this, the government can assist (guaranteed loans against future profit? whatever, I'm sure there's a bunch of ways to structure it). Maybe it will push these companies to make support easier as well, and Open Source parts of it where it makes sense to.
- victorronin 5y agoI am torn. On one hand, this is great idea (exactly for such cases). I feel unbelievably bad for users. On another hand. Lifetime support of technology (say 50 years) is damn expensive. Let say you need a dozen of engineers (hardware + software) + doctors to keep it going. It's 12 people * 200k salary (if you don't like this number, pick your own) * 50 years = $120M. I think you can potentially argue that you don't need a dozen people to support this. However, I think it's a fair number to support aging hardware + software. Unfortunately, such things work only with a scale. You need 10 people to support 100 customers, 20 people to support 1000 customers and 40 people to support 10000. If they got to 10000 customers, I could see them getting enough money to fund such trust. Having just 300 customers won't be enough. Looking at the crunchbase (https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/second-sight https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/second-sight). They whole funding was $130M.
- staticautomatic 5y agoPerhaps this could be accomplished by making them front or insure the cost of the expected liability — being at least the cost of removing unsupported devices.
- theossuary 5y agoIt wouldn't necessarily, but it'd allow others to fill the niche should the company stop filling it themselves. My understanding is that copyright law is meant to allow a company to profit off its ideas for a set period of time, in order to recoup R&D costs. Then, if the company no longer has the means to profit off the IP, and won't sell it to another who wishes to make the IP available, the IP should become public domain.