7 ms·
> As a 20-something-year-old tech bro Not to blatantly "pick the most controversial part of the article", but this explains a lot. Being analytical and having
by zozbot234 5y ago
> As a 20-something-year-old tech bro
Not to blatantly "pick the most controversial part of the article", but this explains a lot. Being analytical and having a skeptical attitude about things is not "toxic". But doing the same things and being insufferably rude about it can often be. The rest is just a matter of how you fix that state of things. Once you are so far gone as to even wear the "techbro" moniker as a badge of honor, I'd kinda suggest that you might want to change that attitude.
- abernard1 5y agoOne of my favorite genres of HN posts is the "hey I'm 25 and got into a FAANG, lemme tell ya about life" posts. It's second only to my all time favorite of "I left a company, and here's a blog post about why you should care" post. Only in this industry can people lack the self-awareness and realization that nobody cares.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 5y agoThere are plenty of other industries where lack of the realization that nobody cares is front and center.
- coldtea 5y agoI came to write something similar, about the influencers, fashion, and celebrity gossip industries... but then it occured to me that there, people, sadly, do care...
- WJW 5y agoDo they though? In most of those scenes 99% of the audience is other, less-famous starlets who want to improve their status by being seen in connection <big shot name in the respective industry>. They don't care at all about what the big shot is actually doing or saying.
- coldtea 5y agoHuh? You must have some other case in mind. The audience for "celebrity gossip" is billions of people. The audience for fashion (and related magazines) too. And the audience for influencers is tons of people who are not influencers and rarely any "less-famous starlets".
- BoysenberryPi 5y ago> It's second only to my all time favorite of "I left a company, and here's a blog post about why you should care" post. As a counterpoint, one of my genuinely favorite post is Michael Lynchs "Why I left Google" post and his yearly solo developer updates. A lot of people simply blog as a way to organize their thoughts, not because they believe people care and need to hear what they have to say.
- abernard1 5y agoWell, he's definitely one of the people then. "Why I left Google" quoted returns 7790 results. It conveys nothing of status and says more about the environment of the person who thinks it does. I might as well read "Why I left Wal-Mart," except that I expect those articles, were they ever to be written, would show a wide latitude of interesting personal experiences, and not the self-promoting pablum that particular genre of LinkedIn fluff provides.
- causi 5y agoPersonally I love the bouquet of a nice "One of my twitter posts was popular for two days, now let me spend ten pages telling you about the revelation that internet fame isn't that great".
- coldtea 5y agoAll 3 of those posts? Your comments is written as those were somehow a trope...
- causi 5y agoI feel like I see one on the HN front page at least once a month, but your mileage may vary.
- coldtea 5y agoDunno, I fell like I've ever read 2 or 3 of those in years of HN. And those I remember were mostly about the issues with hosting something popular and getting hit on HN or virality (e.g. the guy who made the "is it stuck yet" about the ship in the Souez canal).
- coldtea 5y ago>Only in this industry can people lack the self-awareness and realization that nobody cares. Don't look into the Influencer industry then... (Though, there, the audience DOES care!)
- rhacker 5y agoHe may not know you don't want to be a "tech bro"
- BoysenberryPi 5y agoPersonally I would say most people here and in tech communities in general are insufferably rude but YMMV.
- ratsmack 5y agoIs there a possibility that some people are unusually sensitive or have a persecution complex causing them to perceive the slightest push back as a personal attack?
- BoysenberryPi 5y agoSure it's possible.
- czbond 5y agoI disagree. My experience with many engineers - suggest there are different engineering types. There are the exacting, detailed oriented, pedantic, focused engineers who just cannot think big picture. They're great at rules based / systems following work - and love picking apart anything not based in 'immediate reality' There are the strategic, forward thinking, open minded who cannot execute a project to save their life. There are the directive, steam rollers who bully a team - but great at getting stuff done. Etc. Etc. Other types, but for brevity I cut it short.
- BoysenberryPi 5y agoWhat does this have to do with people in tech communities being rude?
- czbond 5y agoI'm suggesting not all are rude; I see many uplifting comments. A number are rude - and maybe those who are pre-oriented to replying in text on a partially anonymous board with a pedantic nature are pre-inclined to be more rude. Engineers by design are used to problem solving or working through the problem solving. If they're not solving the problem - then they would be in "what's wrong with this approach" mode and some may see it as rude.
- memetomancer 5y agoDid you just relentlessly pick apart OPs post over the incidentals, apparently in order to sideline the message "be more nice"? You are very smart, that is a clever way to illustrate the point.
- zozbot234 5y agoI actually agree with the message. I'm just saying that there's more than one way to pursue niceness (or, if not 'niceness' however defined, at least proper respect, empathy and decorum), and expecting people to be less analytical (which quite literally means to "pick shit apart") might not be the best.
- bobthechef 5y ago
- ordu 5y agoI studied psychology after I studied math, and the most funny thing that happened to me after the second: I become less concerned about truths and more about people, about what they say and why they say it. There are two examples in the article. The first one is about nurses and masks, when author's girlfriend evidently tried to convey her compassion to nurses who need to wear masks all the day long, but the author didn't pick this message, he stumbled over untruth and was unable to just let it be. The second example is about his father, who probably tried to ask for help nicely, to ask in a way that doesn't feel obligatory to conform. But unfortunately the author saw an untruth in a message and was unable to resist an urge to start a holy war against falsehoods, so he missed an opportunity to help without realizing it. The second example is illuminating: he missed an opportunity. Maybe he was not interested in it, in this case he lost nothing. But maybe he was interested (or rather would be interested if he picked it from conversation), and in this case his loss was very real. It is not about niceness per se, it is about seeing world around you as it is. You can be nice then, or to be not nice at all, but if you do not see where are opportunities to be nice, you are losing an opportunity to choose. If being more analytical leads to the less understanding of the world around you, and therefore you are missing opportunities, than maybe an analytical approach is overrated? Though I feel very empathic to STEM majors who was trained to fight a holy war against untruths and cannot resist it even when this holy war sidetracks them from the core of a conversation. It is not easy to overcome this training and moreover it may be not just training, but a natural disposition too: maybe people who are less concerned about people are attracted to (or pushed into) STEM carrier paths. I do not see their behavior as toxic, one just needs to clarify his/her message when STEM major stumbled over an untruth. It is just like talking with kids, they also tend to react to a wrong part of a message.
- j1elo 5y agoAs an ex-20-something-year-old human, it comes a day when you look back at when you were 20-something and invariably think "oh boy I was just a grown-up child back then". But 20-somethings haven't yet got there and sometimes think they are in the top of their maturity and wisdom. I guess it's life. One day they might look back and cringe on the idea of calling themselves "techbro" like if it was cool or something. And might say "what was I thinking?" Oh well :-)
- nlowell 5y agoCalling yourself a tech bro is intentional ironic humor. Guys doing this are likely aware of the negative connotations but also the fact that if you are a young man in tech, other people will label you a tech bro regardless. It's just a harmless joke imo.
- maximus-decimus 5y agoMaybe tech bros lose their sense of humor when they hit a certain age and become tech boomers.
- polka_haunts_us 5y agoI believe the accepted term of art is "Dinobabies".
- rootsudo 5y agoAge, comes experience. But, I was surprised that techbro has such a negative image too and used as an attack. Only found that out when I moved to Seattle. Sometimes it helps to adapt it, because for sure the community/locals on some level really do push it to a label. Meanwhile, across the country in Florida - everyone encourages everyone to do what you want, learn, succeed and it wasn't rare that in university, outside university events IT/coders/artists and such all hung out together. But, certain environments affect the meaning and acceptance of words. I still am flabbergasted that my experience in Seattle is still like that and that I was "shamed" for doing what I love. Seattle was the only place also that people in tech would also omit they work in tech and do anything, everything else.
- NicoJuicy 5y agoI got the "expert beginner" vibe almost immediately.
- telchior 5y agoPerhaps he's self-identifying as a tech bro defensively? That is: based on his age / appearance / employment, other people might dismiss him as just another tech bro, so he's just going ahead with a self-label to get it out of the way before moving on to his point.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ohCh6zos 5y agoWhat’s wrong with being a techbro?
- vxnul 5y ago"Bro" is a strange word, because it has gone through quite a bit of semantic shift. It used to refer to a certain type of entitled, right-wing young male associated with some college fraternities (not all frats are like that, but a lot of them are) and tech-company management. Now, "bro" has just become a synonym for "man" and doesn't really have the sting it used to have.
- clairity 5y agothen maybe you're too young to remember that for decades it was just an abbreviation for 'male sibling' mixed with a little "close male friend who's like a sibling". 'bro' has basically completely supplanted 'dude', which waxed and waned before it, and like all fashion, it too will wane.
- svnt 5y agoOh my god it isn’t ironic. These people read it and thought it was just tech and bro in the cool sense. Gather round children and let me tell you a tale about a time before it was broadly trendy and profitable to do technical work, when bros sold mortgages and stayed in sales, and we were all geeks and nerds (whether we identified as that or not).
- mgarfias 5y agoJust cuz he’s got a ‘tude, doesn’t make him wrong. HN is filled with toxicity, especially if you have a thought that runs counter to the normal accepted way.
- ReleaseCandidat 5y ago> HN is filled with toxicity, especially if you have a thought that runs counter to the normal accepted way. Compared to the real world, HN is still a bowl of cherries.
- idiotsecant 5y agoI generally find HN to have a level of civil discourse that is unheard of on most other platforms online, to the point that I sometimes find myself behaving a little better here than I would elsewhere because it's just how it's done around here. I'm curious what community you'd point to that is not toxic if HN is considered toxic.
- mgarfias 5y agoWell, for one, the corvette racer dudes I know aren't at all like what you see here with people telling you you're straight out wrong, dumb, etc. And they actively help each other when things happen. I've cut my track time short to help a dude I didnt know fix his car when it broke (we're friends now). Dude last year crashed his car and caught fire - was massively burnt to a crisp and almost died. People came together and almost $60k to help him. Then, another one of our crew had a stroke. The first guy donated to him (along with the rest of us), despite dealing with his own medical issues. so yeah, by comparison HN is rude as hell
- adventured 5y ago> HN is filled with toxicity, especially if you have a thought that runs counter to the normal accepted way. So what. The world shouldn't be gentle padded walls and protective headgear. That's part of what's wrong with US and Western European culture: extraordinary, pathetic intellectual weakness and cowardice rather than mental fortitude and strength. The West is soft and weak mentally - constantly crying like a spoiled brat to be protected from ideas, arguments, debates, anything disliked or disagreed with - and it's only getting worse.
- dang 5y agoPlease don't cross into personal attack. I'm sure you didn't mean to, but this comment is at least dipping a toe into those nasty waters. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- zozbot234 5y agoYou might well be right about this, however the OP's post is all about relating their personal experience in a way that somehow ends up painting the whole HN userbase with a very broad brush. It just does not seem very feasible to answer that in a way that's on point, without incidentally "dipping" into the same kind of attitude.
- dang 5y agoYou're probably right about the post (I haven't read it), but this is a needle we all need to learn how to thread. It's feasible, though not necessarily easy.
- zozbot234 5y ago> I haven't read it Thanks, I understand your remark better now. But I'm still not sure that the right choice is then to shy away from a mere rephrasing of things that are literally or almost-literally stated as such in the OP (and I don't just mean what I quoted, that was almost beside the point!), lest they then be perceived as a personal attack on OP themselves. That just seems like an especially insidious sort of projection.