8 ms·
> Cotten possessed the only key to the online vaults where his customers’ investments were supposedly stored. This is very important. Due to strong cryptograph
by matheusmoreira 5y ago
> Cotten possessed the only key to the online vaults where his customers’ investments were supposedly stored.
This is very important. Due to strong cryptography it's safe to assume the cryptocurrencies can't be moved without the secret key. What happens if the owner of the key dies? My father asked me about this once and I had no answer. Something to really think about.
We currently think of secret keys as expendable. Compromised or lost? Just make a new one. Nobody shares or inherits keys, everyone has their own set. The dead won't be encrypting or signing any messages and there is generally no reason for anyone to retain the ability to impersonate them.
Traditional key discipline relies on the assumption keys are worth nothing. All this goes out the window when these are the keys to assets worth thousands, millions. A new key discipline needs to be developed.
- maerF0x0 5y agoThere are also key escrow solutions like https://keys.casa/ https://keys.casa/ (i'm sure there are many many others, please add yours as a reply!)
- nathias 5y agoyou make a paper wallet and you can pass it on as inheritance
- scotty79 5y agoOn the other hand ... What's wrong, if your wealth distilled to the limits of abstraction dies with you? If you haven't shared it with anyone, why would anyone get it? If you didn't trust anyone with the keys to it while you were alive, why should anyone have it?
- zwirbl 5y agoMost people don't trust their adult children with access to their wealth, and yet they leave it as an inheritance to them when they die. Often even accompanied by a will
- snek_case 5y agoPeople sometimes die pretty suddenly, with no planning for what should happen after.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tshaddox 5y agoI mean, another way to look at this is that wealth, assuming it’s reasonably liquid, can be exchanged for other goods (that is, after all, the only real point of wealth in the first place). Surely you wouldn’t think it’s absurd to expect that if someone dies with some extra food, that other people ought to make use of that food, even if they hadn’t made a formal last will.
- brigandish 5y agoOn the other hand, if money is destroyed and not replaced that then makes everyone else's money more valuable as no one else's wealth (and hence overall wealth) has been affected.
- tshaddox 5y agoI doubt that’s true in any meaningful sense. You could say the same thing for food: if you make it more scarce at some point you will probably observe an increase in price of existing food. And yet you could have eaten the food instead of destroyed it.
- neilknowsbest 5y agoI believe the parent here is making a distinction between "capital" and "money"; "money" being a claim against real physical "capital". When a pile of "capital" is destroyed (i.e. a bushel of wheat spoils, or a factory burns to the ground, or the lyrics to Bohemian Rhapsody are somehow lost forever) then this is a loss to society in general and to the owner of that "capital" in particular. If a pile of "money" is destroyed (i.e. Pablo Escobar burns $2MM in currency, private key to crypto wallet is lost) there is no corresponding loss of real physical "capital". There is simply a reduction in aggregate outstanding claims against the unchanged real physical "capital". So the unaffected holders of the other claims see their purchasing power increase, i.e. they no longer have to outbid the person whose "money" was destroyed, they have now "cut out" the loser from claims against "capital".
- 5y ago
- pjc50 5y agoIn this case, it wasn't his money! It was the Quadriga customer wallet! Besides, "how do I ensure my wife and/or children get my wealth when I die" is a question humans have been addressing for thousands of years. Only a bitcoiner could be so nihilist to not care.
- wbobeirne 5y ago> Only a bitcoiner could be so nihilist to not care. I feel like the people I know who are most enthusiastic about Bitcoin are the ones who care most about generational wealth and the long-term mindset. There are tons of ways to establish backups for family members (multi signature wallets, time locked wallets.)
- scotty79 5y ago> Besides, "how do I ensure my wife and/or children get my wealth when I die" ... ... but can't rip me off a second earlier.
- helen___keller 5y ago> If you didn't trust anyone with the keys to it while you were alive, why should anyone have it? Wills and inheritance have been a part of human society since the beginning of civilization, I think it’s more likely we will need to find a way to make new technology adapt to society and not the other way around
- slyrus 5y agoThen again maybe this addresses the inheritance tax issue. Instead of debating how much money goes to heirs vs the state, folks net worth could just "evaporate" on death, thereby slightly (presumably) reducing the supply of whatever currency was held at the time of death.
- carlob 5y agoYeah, but inheritance law has changed a lot over the centuries: before the French revolution only the first child (possibly son, I don't recall right now) could inherit, then the revolutionary government made a big deal of splitting properties equally among siblings in order to break up large estates. After WWII most Western countries had very punishing inheritance taxes, and that's been dialed back in the 70s. Some economists (Piketty and co) make a big deal of bringing back high inheritance taxes and using them to finance a universal basic capital to be disbursed at a young age. In a sense, due to the deflationary nature of most crypto, dying without telling anyone what the key to your wallet is, is equivalent to redistributing all your funds to everyone in a way that is proportional to the amount everybody already owns. So it's kinda regressive, which seems to align well with the current crypto political climate...
- maerF0x0 5y ago> If you haven't shared it with anyone, why would anyone get it? This is the wrong model, technically it causes micro deflation that would be similar to distributing it to everyone weighted by their current amount. The rich get richer-er (in an absolute sense, but not in a proportional sense). The effect is probably minuscule on a case by case basis, but if it were happening on nation scale it might make a difference.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> What's wrong, if your wealth distilled to the limits of abstraction dies with you? What do you mean, what's wrong? Everything is wrong. If I have children, I absolutely want them to inherit everything I own when I die. I want them to use it all to reach even further than I have and be more successful and richer than I was. This is how wealth is built across generations. I don't want my money to be forever lost in the unimaginably large cryptographic search space. I certainly don't want my money to go to anyone other than my children, especially the government.
- scotty79 5y agoWhy don't you give them your stuff now?
- whywhywhywhy 5y agoMany do but even then you have to drip feed it extremely slowly.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoI don't have children yet.
- wbobeirne 5y agoTaxes.
- gbasin 5y agoYou need social key recovery or multi-sig with other trusted parties (lawyers, business partners, etc)
- vvpan 5y agoYeah only reasonable UX options. Saw somebody praise the wonders of seed phrase wallets on Twitter and could not believe my eyes.
- lordnacho 5y agoSmart contract with a dead man switch?
- PowerfulWizard 5y agoOne solution is to have the key on paper in a safe, and then let the lawyer know the key is in the safe. If you die they can drill the safe. The nature of the private key makes digital solutions possible, but they aren't necessary. It doesn't have to be handled differently from any highly valuable small object.
- kkielhofner 5y agoOr (somewhat ironically) a bank safe deposit box.
- dylan604 5y agoThis isn't that ironic, as there are often safe deposit boxes with contents more valuable than the cash on hand of the bank branch itself. Yes, ironic that digital currency is being protected by physical bank, but that's really stretching for something to be haha. It's SOP for banks really.
- kkielhofner 5y agoI was more referring to the (somewhat fair) crusade against big banks in the crypto community in general. Tweeting against banks all day and talking about "code is law" while paying a safe deposit box fee and leaning on the traditional legal system (wills, etc) and banks (the box) scales somewhere from ironic to hypocritical.
- mananaysiempre 5y agoNo it doesn’t, at least in a sensible understanding of the crusade. (I’m not sure cryptographic Byzantine consensus is the panacea it is touted to be, but agree with its proponents as to whether many of the things they call problems with the traditional system are in fact problems.) It’s nice to have a technical solution to things that do not actually need human interpretation, and it’s nice to expand the set of these things. Whether you actually want human interpretation for the act of transferring money is questionable. Fiat money is uniquely susceptible to repressive governments in a way that nothing was when people actually thought about countering those in a practical way, and bank transfers are even more so—see today’s news from Canada for an example that’s chilling whether or not you agree with the actual politics in play. That needs to be fixed, I think. It could be fixed by making money more resilient to government intervention or by making governments less likely to make malicious interventions, probably both. These approaches, and even approaches to these approaches, have different implications, so history will have to find the balance, but I’d be loath to just dismiss the former out of hand. But death is a thing that needs human interpretation, at least for the foreseeable future, and thus those arguments don’t apply here. The current banking and actuarial system isn’t that insane for the most part, for a system that has to operate under the constraint of needing human interpretation. It’s just that I refuse to stop thinking about the extent to which such a constraint is actually present in any particular situation. In strongbox rental, it is. Great! And I say that as someone with an experience of withdrawing the contents of a safe deposit box from a branch of a failing bank, on the day before the doors of said branch were locked and tagged. (Nothing about a strongbox rental business even needs to be connected with loans or securities in any way, it’s just that banks sort of organically grew both functions. No problem with that, but also no problem with somebody dissatisfied with any aspect of modern macroeconomics having no gripes against safe deposit boxes.)
- camillomiller 5y agowould it be possible to program a smart contract tied to the key owner's death in some provable way, in order to release a key retrieval mechanism to their heir?
- notreallyserio 5y agoI suppose you could surgically implant a private key inside your body that could be used to decrypt a cache of your other or private keys. It'd have to be somewhere that can't be accessed without killing you, though.
- csomar 5y agoTorture you to reveal the secret location and in the process kill you to get the private key. Nice idea.
- rwiggum 5y agosince smart contracts are turing complete, you could easily write a "dead mans switch" contract that requires check in, say, every 30 days. the contract could be written such that if two or more checkins in a row are missed, then the assets can be withdrawn by any authorized users.
- thesausageking 5y agoThis is a solved problem. Entities that have to custody large amounts of crypto use multi-sig wallets where N of M keys are needed to unlock them. The keys are given to a N people and kept in different locations. If someone dies, N of the remaining people can move the assets to a new wallet.
- jll29 5y agoThat's how Ethereum founder V. Buterin manages his online assets: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XW0QZmtbjvs&list=RDCMUCSHZKyawb77ixDdsGog4iWA&start_radio=1&rv=XW0QZmtbjvs&t=79 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XW0QZmtbjvs&list=RDCMUCSHZKy...
- janekm 5y agoThe challenges are similar to those involved in signing the root keys for DNSsec (or certificate authorities). Root signing ceremonies make for an interesting read: https://www.cloudflare.com/en-gb/dns/dnssec/root-signing-ceremony/ https://www.cloudflare.com/en-gb/dns/dnssec/root-signing-cer...
- laumars 5y agoThere’s already a practice of businesses storing a paper copy of a critical infrastructure password in a safe for emergencies. I don’t see why the same concept couldn’t be used here.
- pmlamotte 5y agoKey management is definitely difficult and is full of tradeoffs depending on the risks you want to protect against. There are some nice guides out there that go into some of the details[1][2] as well as inheritance plans, and it typically involves multisig wallets (2 of 3, 3 of 5, etc) with some of the keys stored with a lawyer or other trusted party. Some commercial solutions exist like Casa which can make it seemingly easier, but has increased risk as a result. If you don't plan ahead, it's likely gone, but the setup time/cost of these solutions really only makes sense for large amounts. I recall reading at one point about future support for time locked multisig in Bitcoin that could maybe help with that but don't know the status of that capability or how it works, or how difficult it is to set up. [1] https://github.com/fresheneesz/TordlWalletProtocols https://github.com/fresheneesz/TordlWalletProtocols [2] https://glacierprotocol.org/docs/overview/ https://glacierprotocol.org/docs/overview/
- dylan604 5y agoSo what happens to these digital coins in the face of loss of keys? Actually, what do banks do as well? If someone dies with a large sum in an account, how is it different than a digital currency at that point? There's no physical tangible good that has value. It's just a number in a digital ledger for crypto or typical bank. Is the only difference in this case the encryption, otherwise typical banking rules would apply?
- egypturnash 5y agoWhat do banks do? Look up “unclaimed property”, there is a whole complicated bureaucracy dedicated to tracking this stuff and letting heirs claim it. Each state of the US has a separate web site where you can search for anything left in a dead relative’s accounts. Claiming it is easy for small values. It gets more complicated as the value rises, I have enough left in this situation from a grandparent that I am putting off getting something called a “judgement of possession” to acquire some funds. This bureaucracy does not, of course, exist for cryptobucks; creating one probably will be mandatory if it is to become an actual part of the financial system instead of a cascading pile of scams, and it will involve a whole lot of things that are anathema to the anti-government attitudes a lot of crypto true believers have.
- saalweachter 5y ago> Actually, what do banks do as well? The short answer is inheritance happens. If there's no co-signers, named beneficiaries, will or heirs, the state will eventually appoint an executor who will settle any outstanding debts of the estate against the account, and then I think the state itself is the ultimate inheritor. Most states have a notion of "unclaimed funds", and you can check to see if you have any money sitting in the state coffers from a dead relative or a settlement.
- PeterisP 5y agoI'll add to that the issue that it's extremely unlikely for there to be no heirs, as even if you made no family and your parents are dead, there's still likely to be e.g. some third-degree cousins. There are some cases (e.g. related to the Holocaust or immigrants where all the local family is dead and there are no contacts with the overseas relatives) but generally there's quite some time for distant relatives to apply until eventually the state (i.e. the general public) takes it over.
- astoor 5y agoNote that this wasn't a case of the money being lost because the key was lost when the owner died as per the initial headlines - in this case the money simply wasn't there in the first place: "Quadriga likely never invested the funds entrusted to it, according to Chainalysis, ... Either the funds were never received or quickly went missing" and "Ernst & Young found five Quadriga cold wallet addresses, but they were empty, containing no cryptocurrency since April 2018."[0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quadriga_Fintech_Solutions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quadriga_Fintech_Solutions
- throw123123123 5y agoThere are so many options! My favorite conceptually is a dead-man switch. For example, something will have a password only you have, as long as you input you are alive every x days. If you die, eventually it switches to another password someone else might have. It really is amazing to think how hard it is to keep something safe, once you are tasked with it.
- ls15 5y ago> This is very important. Due to strong cryptography it's safe to assume the cryptocurrencies can't be moved without the secret key. What happens if the owner of the key dies? My father asked me about this once and I had no answer. Something to really think about. One option would be to create a multi-signature wallet, where for example three keys exist, while two keys are needed for transactions. This would allow scenarios where the widow and the notary can access a wallet after the owner died. At the same time, no single party would be able to run with the money with only one key.
- sircastor 5y ago7 or so years ago, a friend of mine passed away. He had setup and explained a complicated encryption scheme to his wife that stored all their digital stuff. She didn't remember any of that, and then it was permanently inaccessible to her. Seeing the challenge in this, I made a note for my wife which is "All of our nerd stuff, if I die" It contains instructions on how our network works, how to handle domain names, how our backup system works, etc. Passwords and such belong to our shared BitWarden, but for all the other "What now?" stuff, I feel better having given her at least some explanation.
- louloulou 5y agoUse multisig. Just to add to this, we haven't even scratched the surface of what's possible with shared/collaborative custody and timelocks.
- plorg 5y agoI know you're facilitating a conversation about key discipline, and I don't mean to derail you from that, but it's not clear that the problem here was really an inaccessible wallet. You can read the Ontario government report on it [1]. Cotten was treating all customer deposits as ostensibly a single asset pool, paying expenses and customer withdrawals out of the same pot, using that same pot to speculate on bitcoin on external exchanges, and using fake accounts to boost volume or liquidity. When Bitcoin crashed in 2017 he had way more BTC and way less CAD than his customers were owed and had paid much more for it than he could sell it for. It was a classic Ponzi scheme. Add in all of the money he had spent on personal assets out of the same pot and there is no need to speculate about a mythical missing wallet. They found 4 paper cold wallets and all of them were empty, presumably because the contents had been sold to pay other customers. [1] https://www.osc.ca/quadrigacxreport/ https://www.osc.ca/quadrigacxreport/