12 ms·
Long ago I worked tech support for a company that supported some mainframe equipment. Eventually after some incidents they introduced “special instructions” fo
by duxup 5y ago
Long ago I worked tech support for a company that supported some mainframe equipment.
Eventually after some incidents they introduced “special instructions” for customers who we had to gather extra troubleshooting data for because of some complex issues they had.
Then a few more customers had special instructions… and a few more.
Eventually these involved things like “Send the account manager an email for each call, this customer is very sensitive.”
After just a year EVERY account had special instructions.
Many people oriented instructions were impossible to follow “Page Jim.” Jim didn’t carry a pager anymore and when he did he would never respond so you couldn’t do step 2.
Some involved gathering loads of memory dumps for issues long solved. Others would have you follow program pointers to memory that didn’t exist so you would start over and over until you gave up and decided failing to do your job was preferable to losing your mind at 4am….
Some instructions were multi page word documents expected to be read every time the customer called. After reading it a dozen times a week it almost became impossible to notice if it had a slight change or not.
One clever account manager trying to make sure tech support “noticed” his special instructions tried using a <blink> tag… entirely ignoring the issue that upon noticing the instructions they would be hard to read. Thankfully the tag failed to work.
As you can imagine eventually there were exasperated executive meetings about how nobody follows the special instructions.
This is the world of protecting against corner cases.
- Carioca 5y agoHuman systems are not computer systems. In computer systems, edge cases are usually worthy of investigation and rethinking. In human systems, edge cases are to be dealt with when they appear
- dredmorbius 5y agoThose disagreeing with your comment might want to consider that it's very close in spirit and meaning to what JKM wrote in TFA: Computers don’t have emotions; I don’t need to worry insulting the vast majority of S3 objects when I defensively check integrity every time. But humans are different; when we design a human system around uncommon cases, we do need to consider the ramifications on the majority.
- tchalla 5y ago> JKM wrote in TFA As a human, can you please tell all of us what these abbreviations are?!
- 3np 5y agoJKM: Jacob Kaplan-Moss, the name of he author, featured in header and footer of... ...TFA: The Featured Article a.k.a. (also known as) OP (original post(er))
- Mezzie 5y agoFor some reason I'd always been under the impression that the 'F' in 'TFA' was a different word. This makes so many exchanges less hostile in retrospect. Oops.
- ankitpati 5y agoThis, right here, is why I never use acronyms with the sixth letter of the English alphabet anywhere in them. Heck, as you might already have noticed, I don’t use said letter at all, unless it is part of a word. This is one “human corner case” I have no shame working around. Wouldn’t want to convey hostility where none exists.
- stronglikedan 5y agoThe F-word (I'll spare your virgin eyes), or even the letter F, is not capable of conveying hostility on it's own, so there is no sense in omitting it.
- marcosdumay 5y agoThe acronym was coined with the non "fine" meaning for that letter. It was much later that internet culture got more polite and people retroactively replaced the meaning on RTFM and RTFA.
- krupan 5y ago
- Helmut10001 5y agoRe: "Edge cases" - Reminds me of where today's legal systems appear to be directed.
- arcticbull 5y agoWhich is why crypto cannot work for the general public. It pretends otherwise in spite of overwhelming evidence.
- yuvadam 5y agoI'm curious to understand what exactly you mean by that statement
- thematrixturtle 5y agoI presume they mean that out in the real world, there are lots of edge cases where reversing a transaction is a better outcome than chest-thumping about "Code is Law".
- Tabular-Iceberg 5y agoThat was a solved problem long before computers came about. If a transaction is wrong, don’t change it, add another that compensates for the error. The real problem with crypto is that usually what is asked for is a ledger, and the crypto and distributed parts are just bloat.
- duxup 5y agoYeah and the way I described it every "skeptical instructions" was a catch ... that triggered on every call. Unlike code that triggers (hopefully) only when something weird happens, the cost of the special instructions and the dysfunction that followed was ultra high.
- Ansil849 5y agoSeriously...what? This sounds insane and I genuinely don't understand why anyone would work here or put up with this. I understand the main point, I think, of 'make sure that people read instructions instead of ignoring them', but this is taken to bizarro levels which I don't understand why anyone would tolerate. The 'account managers' designing these 'special instructions' are either sadists or just assholes, and if management is not willing to protect its own staff from this bullshit, I see no reason for anyone to continue to work there. I don't really understand people staying in abusive job situations like this. There are many other job opportunities out there.
- Mezzie 5y ago> I don't really understand people staying in abusive job situations like this. I'm working to get out of a job that turned into this once our (lovely) manager bailed and exposed our team to the incompetence of our current leadership. I'm having to HEAVILY fight my gut instinct by leaving, because I was raised in poverty and grew up as a disabled lesbian back when those things created more issues than they do now. I'm also from a rural area and neither of my parents have college degrees. I may logically know that I (as someone with credentials and a decent skill set) have every right to leave and it's in my best interest to do so, but it conflicts with literally decades of messaging I've got telling me I'm lucky to be allowed where I am at all and seeing those around me be punished for standing up for themselves. I was also abused by my parents, and that's another angle: People who are used to abuse don't think it's that bad, and I'd wager there's a fair number of people who have just never had a decent work situation. If you're going to be abused, at least pick an abuser you know and can work around. Humans are pattern recognition/social machines, and if you only expose humans to dysfunctional patterns, they'll assume the problem is them. If you design a society, it's pretty easy to get yourself a group of people who are open to being exploited.
- michaelbarton 5y agoI can relate to this. Neither of my parents have college degrees and we were poor growing up. For a while they just pushed me to get any job I could. I worked in a call centre (horrible), door to door sales (more horrible), a butcher in supermarket (slightly horrible), working in the NHS (terrible pay, lovely people). I've had a lot problems myself struggling around guilt about the pay and general lifestyle in tech. But I'm now working in a tech company with lovely people, doing interesting work. For what it's worth from a stranger: I wish you luck in overcoming your inner critic and that you are worthy and deserving to get a job with people you like at a job you enjoy.
- choeger 5y agoOuch. That's the worst example of "Befehlstaktik" I've read so far. Try Auftragstaktik instead: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mission-type_tactics https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mission-type_tactics
- beaconstudios 5y agosounds like the difference between utilitarianism and deontology - focused on outcome versus focused on process.
- sidpatil 5y agoReminds me of "declarative" versus "imperative".
- BlameKaneda 5y agoLearned some interesting words today, thanks.