6 ms·
It doesn't look like, it is authoritarian response to something which should be protected. Using government power intended for things like war to suppress a pr
by colechristensen 5y ago
It doesn't look like, it is authoritarian response to something which should be protected.
Using government power intended for things like war to suppress a protest is ridiculous, if this is what being "liberal" is about, I'm out.
I hope the response is a protest escalation. Not my country, not my protest, but I know who I'm rooting for.
Contrast this to what was happening in Minneapolis a couple of summers ago... people burning down buildings, shops, and police stations and the fire and police literally afraid to go places in the city until we had armed forces marching through the streets. Those are the kind of popular uprisings that need to be dealt with, not streets being blocked by unhappy people.
- s5300 5y agoDamage in Minneapolis was mostly confined to a singular street. Singular. At no point were fire and police “afraid” to go places in the city either, though I can imagine you may have been watching certain “news” coverage that may have claimed that.
- jcadam 5y agoI don't think they were afraid. I think they were under orders not to interfere with the rioters.
- xienze 5y ago> At no point were fire and police “afraid” to go places in the city either They completely abandoned a police precinct which was promptly burned down [0]. Pretty safe to say they were afraid to stay at their own building! 0: https://www.twincities.com/2020/05/28/minneapolis-police-abandon-third-precinct-hq-as-george-floyd-protesters-pull-down-fences/amp/ https://www.twincities.com/2020/05/28/minneapolis-police-aba...
- colechristensen 5y agoI've spent more than a decade living in Minneapolis, I wasn't confused by crazy news sources. >At no point were fire and police “afraid” to go places in the city either The police abandoned the 3rd precinct station which was burned down later that night. How's that for being afraid to be in a place? There were plenty of stories of fire trucks not going places for security reasons, and eventually firemen had national guard escorts. I don't know what that is besides "being afraid" to go places in the city. >>“We were faced with these fail fail fail options,” Mr. Frey (Minneapolis mayor) said. “We were literally having to choose between preventing additional looting, protecting a precinct and providing escorts to firefighters to put out fires. There was no way we could do all three.” >Damage in Minneapolis was mostly confined to a singular street. A main street which crossed the cities, miles long. And damage wasn't at all confined there. There were several hot spots around the cities. >I can imagine you may have been watching certain “news” coverage that may have claimed that. Well, here's the New York Times backing up my claims. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/03/us/minneapolis-government-george-floyd.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/03/us/minneapolis-government...
- s5300 5y agoOh yes, the glorious New York Times. Well known to not be biased towards police propaganda in the slightest.
- thorncorona 5y agoIs this sarcasm? The NYT is quite liberal.
- seanmcdirmid 5y ago"Liberal" can mean both "pro police" and "anti police" at the same time. It really depends on what police behavior you are against.
- thebigman433 5y agoLiberals are major police supporters, and the NYT is just that. They have run a ton of pro-police propaganda using police officers as their sources.
- kennywinker 5y agoI hope you’re just as outraged by the removal of first nations protesters blockading pipelines last year - because those were more peaceful than the trucker stuff and they were crushed with pretty extreme force by the rcmp
- skrbjc 5y agoAre you as outraged by this as that?
- worik 5y agoHell no! Comparing privileged truckers to Canadian indigenous people is chalk and cheese.
- TexanFeller 5y agoTruckers as a group are not what most people would call privileged! Hard work, long hours away from their family, and not great pay. Most of them aren’t very educated and came from humble homes.
- moistly 5y agoThe protesters are, by and large, not truckers. There are some 300000 truckers (most of them vaccinated) in Canada. A few hundred of them are involved in the protests. It is not a truckers protest, it’s a people in pickups and passenger cars protest. As for pay, I’m seeing wages of $85K + bennies advertised around here. That’s not a bad wage.
- chernevik 5y agoIt takes a lot of ideology to think of truckers as "privileged".
- worik 5y agoNot compared to Canadian Indians! Very privileged.
- ff317 5y agoSerious question though, which applies to both the Canadian truckers case and the Minneapolis example above - does a right to protest an issue also include a right to inflict economic harm (on broader society, in poorly-targeted fashion) in order to raise awareness? Is the amount of economic harm (say, %GDP of the town, region, or country) or how broadly it's targeted ("random retail stores"? "Anything that relies on ground-based trade between Canada and the US"?) a factor in how allowable it is? Where does one draw a line of reasonability here?
- skrbjc 5y agoAll protests cause economic harm. How many businesses were closed and looted during the protests for BLM? What is the correct amount of economic harm in your view? What are the terms under which a protest should be allowed by a government?
- colechristensen 5y ago"Economic harm" is a really weak criterion all around for restricting protest rights and one ripe for abuse. I'm not sure if this is the only impact that a line should be drawn at all. "Public safety" is a good one, you're free to protest but there has to be adequate access for emergency services to get to people in need. "No significant destruction" is a good one, not just making a mess in the streets but when your movement starts actively destroying property, looting, etc. If you keep doing economic harm, your movement will tend to get pretty unpopular pretty quickly and the social pressure instead of government force will likely get to you in the end. Lots of people walking of the job will do significant amounts of economic harm, I don't want people in certain jobs to become effective slaves because their job is important to the economy. And also a general strike is a very powerful action which should be done from time to time, explicitly very economically powerful and definitely should be protected.
- sangnoir 5y ago> No significant destruction" is a good one, not just making a mess in the streets but when your movement starts actively destroying property, looting, etc This one is also ripe for abuse - outside forces have been using agents provocateurs for centuries, often undercover cops.
- defaultname 5y ago"Using government power intended for things like war" This isn't the war measures act. It is a response specifically targeted to situations like this. "I hope the response is a protest escalation" That's neat. I hope that every protester that misused a privilege of their CDL lose their truck license, lose insurance, have their bank accounts locked, and face enormous fines. I guess we have differing hopes. Sign petitions. Make a new political party. Lobby. Do a campaign. But if you try to force your political will through force -- which parking large trucks throughout cities and on border crossings is -- you have crossed a line and need to be reigned in. "Not my country" Oh gosh, what a surprise... And then, of course, a comparison with completely irrelevant other events that most of us also found reprehensible. I hate when the protests appear on HN because it makes me realize how terrible "right wing" so many on here are (not conservative -- I'm conservative -- but rather a particularly...stupid and angry version that now parades as right wing in the US), and how absolutely reprehensible opinions are. A sort of "look someone previously in a different country and a completely different event tore stuff down so let them go wild in another country to own the libs". Just garbage takes that should be embarrassing to the speaker.
- tdfx 5y ago> But if you try to force your political will through force [...] you have crossed a line and need to be reigned in Like forcing people out of their job for refusing a vaccine? Disclaimer: I'm vaccinated and I encourage everyone to do it. But no one should have to under threat to their livelihood, especially given the absurd logical inconsistencies of the mandate rules.
- defaultname 5y ago> Like forcing people out of their job for refusing a vaccine? Before vaccination was politicized in the US (bizarrely, I must say, through mechanisms that I find absolutely baffling), many jobs had mandatory vaccinations. Most healthcare setting have mandatory yearly flu vaccinations, for instance. The military has a whole plethora of mandatory vaccinations, including some pretty crazy ones. And of course schools, daycare, etc have forced vaccinations. Suddenly it's a big issue. Ask yourself why. And for what it's worth, I've been against mandates since omicron made it evident that they were no longer useful. I have zero tolerance for these protests, though, and would like to see them absolutely stomped.