7 ms·
Basically, the Investment Act of 1934 says: 1. You have to file a prospectus (an S-1) before collecting money. 2. You have to disclose a lot of stuff, like wh
by Animats 5y ago
Basically, the Investment Act of 1934 says:
1. You have to file a prospectus (an S-1) before collecting money.
2. You have to disclose a lot of stuff, like who's really behind this, where the money goes, what the risks are, what's happened so far, and what the business plan is.
3. Lying in an S-1 is a crime.
Crypto schemes tend to violate 1), because 2) would show that their scheme is a scam, and if they tried to cover that up, 3) would put them in jail.
There's grumbling about "paperwork", but that's just an excuse. It's the part about having to disclose all that stuff under penalty of perjury that scammers hate.
- nikanj 5y agoLuckily they can run the whole scheme from Elbonia, and people are more than happy to send over cryptos from the US.
- numtel 5y agoWell, there is Nexo which is basically the same but headquartered in Bulgaria.
- cuteboy19 5y agoThat's almost exactly how Tether (USDT) works. Except instead of Elbonia we have the Caymans
- altairprime 5y agoNote that Tether moving to the Caymans inspired the UK finregs to investigate the UK accounting company that’s now running Tether’s books, so I wouldn’t consider the Caymans to be a successful escape yet: https://www.ft.com/content/e86f8d72-918c-4a80-a4bf-de3110316076 https://www.ft.com/content/e86f8d72-918c-4a80-a4bf-de3110316...
- thebean11 5y agoIs BlockFi a scam though? Fraud is not what they are getting fined for, and it sounds like they can continue to operate if they meet these reporting requirements, and that the company intends to do that.
- Animats 5y agoThey misrepresented how their assets were collateralized, creating a false impression of safety. That's fraud.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sbierwagen 5y agoCheck out the interest rates on their crypto accounts: https://blockfi.com/rates/ https://blockfi.com/rates/ A guaranteed 9.25% APY on crypto deposits when US dollar savings accounts at FDIC banks do 0.50% is odd. Where is the extra money coming from?
- ar_lan 5y agoIf you check DeFi rates, 9.25% is fairly low currently.
- joelbondurant1 5y ago
- thebean11 5y agoAccording to them they lend the money out to institutions and traders. Margin rates can be pretty high.
- AlexandrB 5y agoThat's how banks make money too. However, banks must also consider the risk of their debtors defaulting on their loans. They pass those risks on to you in the form of very low interests rates on money deposited, while keeping your deposit "safe". It seems like BlockFi was passing the risk on in the form of an undisclosed risk of losing all your money. That's the part the SEC seems to have a problem with: > The order also finds that BlockFi made a false and misleading statement for more than two years on its website concerning the level of risk in its loan portfolio and lending activity. The point is there's no free lunch. If you're making 9+% on your deposit don't be surprised if your account is wiped out when BlockFi's debtors fail to pay.
- z16a 5y agoPlease clearly articulate how Blockfi is a scheme or a scam.
- altairprime 5y ago> BlockFi made a false and misleading statement for more than two years on its website concerning the level of risk in its loan portfolio and lending activity. As the order linked above indicates, BlockFi knowingly deceived investors. In the financial/investing context of this discussion, “to scheme” is to plan and execute deception, with intent of personal gain. Thus, my attempt to reword using your provided language rather than the order’s: > BlockFi’s scheming led investors to believe that BlockFi was a lower-risk investment than it was in reality. Note that any errors in translation from SEC wording to your provided terminology are my own, and that I’m making a good-faith effort to help build a verbal bridge from your confusion to an example of specific language in the order that addresses it. If my verbal bridge is insufficient, then please accept my apologies and I hope you’re able to find the answers you seek from others, or in the order itself. (I am not your lawyer, this is not legal advice.)
- AlexandrB 5y agoIt's in the article: > The order also finds that BlockFi made a false and misleading statement for more than two years on its website concerning the level of risk in its loan portfolio and lending activity. Just because a scam hasn't imploded yet, doesn't mean it's not a scam.
- ryanSrich 5y agoConflating anything related to crypto as a scam is just lazy and anti-intellectual. This is one of HN's weakest traits IMO. I find great value in following topics and threads on HN, but it's unrelenting hate for crypto and crypto adjacent topics is unfounded.
- NelsonMinar 5y agoWe are literally discussing a company being found by the SEC to have sold an investment asset without appropriate disclosure and that asset being closed to American investors. This is not the example to make your case with.
- ryanSrich 5y agoWhy not? I could find countless SEC violations that are far worse than this from banking institutions that I guarantee you use on a weekly or monthly basis. Are those scams?
- NelsonMinar 5y agoYes, yes they often are. But I think you'll be hard-pressed to find many examples of legitimate banks having their primary customer offering being declared illegal and forced to stop operation immediately.
- omeze 5y agoErm, from recent memory: Wells Fargo (3rd largest US bank) had a nice 185 million fine for checking account fraud… https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wells_Fargo_account_fraud_scandal https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wells_Fargo_account_fraud_sc... Not saying this justifies BlockFi’s behavior but the incentives for any bank is there!
- NelsonMinar 5y agoYes, that was a fraud. I was personally a victim of it. I will never do business with Wells Fargo again in my lifetime. That doesn't mean I think all banks are fraudulent. In particular I appreciate that there was a regulatory mechanism in place to protect consumers from that fraud.