7 ms·
White House Petition to End Software Patents Is a Hit
- vadiml 15y agoI wonder i somebody took a time to really read what the petition says. The title is anti-sofware patents but the body is more complicated: "The patent office's original interpretation of software as language and therefor patentable is much closer to reality and more productive for innovation than it's current practice of issuing software patents with no understanding of the patents being issued". I think it should read: "The patent office's original interpretation of software as language and therefor not patentable is much closer to reality and more productive for innovation than it's current practice of issuing software patents with no understanding of the patents being issued." Or am I missing something?
- nextparadigms 15y agoI wonder if the creator of the petition even noticed the mistake, or he can't edit it anymore. Would that be a real problem giving the title and some of the body are clearly anti-software patents?
- Lost_BiomedE 15y agoYes, the creator posted in another thread that that they wont let him edit it. He also said it was accidentally sent prematurely before a good proof-read, due to the system not being intuitive to him at the moment.
- shareme 15y agoNo that is generally how the whitehouse miss-writes laws issued..just wait for the over-correction being worse than the original
- alain94040 15y agoExactly. I didn't sign it because I read the text, had no clue what it meant, so I refused to sign, despite the name. And I wrote patents and experienced firsthand the fun of patent litigation. My position is closer to Jonathan Abrams' tweet: tell the USPTO to stop issuing obvious patents, no matter what form.
- grannyg00se 15y agoFor me the problem is that there is frequently "no understanding of the patents being issued". Aside from that, if you are attempting to patent an idea or process I don't see why software should be treated differently than hardware.
- TruthElixirX 15y agoBecause software can already be copyrighted.
- hugh3 15y agoSurely software copyright prevents reusing of the same source code, but not a different implementation of the same algorithm?
- thehotdon 15y agoYes, and that's how it should be. Mathematics, including algorithms, is not patentable.
- grannyg00se 15y agoWhy shouldn't they be patentable. If your company spends money and time comig up with a novel way to sort or search or compress information, why should you not be afforded the same protections as a company that came up with a novel way to store energy, or convert energy?
- slowpoke 15y agoThe "time and money" argument (financial incentive to innovate) is as old as it is irrelevant. Frankly, I don't care if you can't make money off the monopoly rents of an abstract concept (and I'm offended that you think I should). What I care about is you thinking you are entitled to halt progress for your own selfish goals. Besides, it's fallacious to imply that people need "incentives" to innovate. I'd wager there are much more people who are hindered by the patent system than there are people who would stop innovating just because there's no more monopoly to be had by being the first to apply for some legalese nonsense. It's utterly absurd to imply any sort of ownership or rights to an abstract concept. The very notion of it should be grounds for attesting insanity. Instead, we should focus on free flow and exchange of ideas, tight cooperation and incremental development off each others' discoveries. So no, they shouldn't be patentable. Nothing should be.
- delinka 15y agoIf by "hit" you mean "we still need many signatures," then OK. Just that it's the most popular petition amongst a few hundred people who have signed petitions at all does not smack of "hit material" to me.
- AshleysBrain 15y agoWell, it's soared past the 5000 requirement to 6500+ at time of writing now!
- delinka 15y agoYou are correct. I did not clearly state that my complaint is specifically about the article as written rather than the petition itself.
- hugh3 15y agoThe only thing less useful than an internet petition is... actually I can't finish that sentence because I can't think of anything less useful than an internet petition. But I'm sure the White House had a fun time harvesting all those email addresses to spam throughout the coming fourteen months of election season!
- ugh 15y agoWhy do you think that is going to happen? Their privacy policy doesn't seem to allow email addresses to be used for that purpose. I do not think the Obama campaign could take this lightly, and not only because of the privacy policy. Use of government resources for an election campaing is another issue, one more than just privacy activists care about.
- burgerbrain 15y ago"I do not think the Obama campaign could take this lightly" Taking what people think lightly is a skill practiced by all politicians. They are very good at it.
- hugh3 15y agoWhy do you think that is going to happen? Because harvesting email addresses is pretty much the ultimate purpose of all online petitions. Their privacy policy doesn't seem to allow email addresses to be used for that purpose Which part excludes it? Use of government resources for an election campaing is another issue, one more than just privacy activists care about. In a world where the President can take Air Force One to go to a campaign fundraiser, I don't think that this is taken all that seriously any more. There are certain rules regarding what's "politics" and what's "government", but if the White House has your email address you're certainly gonna be getting a lot of emails going "Gosh, what a good job I'm doing as President. What a pity those darn Republicans are to blame for everything that's going wrong" et cetera.
- icebraining 15y ago>Because harvesting email addresses is pretty much the ultimate purpose of all online petitions. Says who? I've been registered on more than one petition websites for years using an email just for them ([name-of-site]@mydomain.com) and I haven't ever got a spam email. In a world where the President can take Air Force One to go to a campaign fundraiser, I don't think that this is taken all that seriously any more. There are certain rules regarding what's "politics" and what's "government", but if the White House has your email address you're certainly gonna be getting a lot of emails going "Gosh, what a good job I'm doing as President. What a pity those darn Republicans are to blame for everything that's going wrong" et cetera. Do you have an evidence of this ever happening, or are you just defaming?
- ninjaa 15y agoHere's my petition to pass the StartupVisa https://wwws.whitehouse.gov/petitions#!/petition/allow-foreign-born-startup-founders-start-their-businesses-united-states-httpstartupvisacom/TCSQ4XG6 https://wwws.whitehouse.gov/petitions#!/petition/allow-forei... Please sign it if you are so inclined
- Francon 15y agoIf there arent any software patents would we see new competetion to the big giants of industry. A competetor to Google for example? (no, bing doesnt count) Seems to me that the entire reason that the internet has been so successful and innovative is that there (was) little litigious battles and it was just smart people solving problems. I'd be in favor of eliminating the anti-competetive behavior of patents.
- bane 15y agoInteresting to note that this is currently #1 with >100 points, while my link to the actual petition was flagged and is now marked dead. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3032320 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3032320 According to the guidlines "Please submit the original source. If a blog post reports on something they found on another site, submit the latter." bizarre.
- jxcole 15y agoThere is absolutely no justification for flagging this. I am disheartened that hacker news has become a place where people flag stuff they dislike rather than posting a rebuttal. I feel this is a systemic error, it is currently too easy for a few people to kill articles they don't like.
- abcd_f 15y agoFlagging is a way to sink an item from the front page. I suspect that if there were a way of doing it without killing an item (say, have a per-user 'hide' option for each item), the flagging rampage would subside.
- wavephorm 15y agoThere's no way to downvote other than to flag. Making a rebuttal doesn't make the article go away, it does the opposite.
- raldi 15y agoThe headline "White House Petition to End Software Patents Is a Hit" is slightly misleading. It makes it sound like the petition came from the White House.
- Jach 15y agoI thought that too at first. A better title would be "Petition for the White House to end ...". I haven't even heard of this petition site before, it's interesting that it hasn't been overrun by 4chan scripts inflating whatever. "We petition you to make 4chan the official capital of the internet."
- jaywhy 15y agoThis is a liitle offtopic, but I have a simply question, one that I've had for awhile but cannot find the answer to, can anyone give an example of a legitimate software patent -- a patent that beyond its superficial veneer doesn't seem utterly absurd.
- extension 15y agomp3 perhaps?
- hugh3 15y agoA sophisticated algorithm for drug design. A sophisticated algorithm for simulating turbulent flow near jet engines. A sophisticated algorithm for optimizing [some complicated industrial process]. If you want a specific example, this is just what I got from a google patent search for "rational drug design", but: http://www.google.com/patents?id=3b8kAAAAEBAJ&zoom=4&dq=rational%20drug%20design&pg=PA2#v=onepage&q&f=false http://www.google.com/patents?id=3b8kAAAAEBAJ&zoom=4&...
- l_dopa 15y agoI was under the impression that algorithms are specifically not patentable http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patentable_subject_matter#The_algorithm_exception_and_the_patent-eligibility_trilogy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patentable_subject_matter#The_a...
- iano 15y agoApplications of algorithms are patentable, not the algorithms themselves. (un-cited e.g. using machine learning for handwriting recognition)
- BrandonM 15y ago> e.g. using machine learning for handwriting recognition This is one of the problems with software patents. Using machine learning for handwriting recognition is a pretty obvious "innovation" to anyone with a little background in AI who has thought about the problem at all. If we allow people to patent "using machine learning for X" for all activities X, that blocks a lot of innovation. The field is moving so fast right now that people are thinking of new ideas all the time; we don't need patents to encourage that. There are some non-obvious algorithms that are worthy of patenting (that is, if algorithms were actually patentable). One that comes to mind is the fast inverse square root algorithm (https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Fast_inverse_square_root https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Fast_inverse_...). In our field, trade secret (e.g. compiled source code) is usually sufficient to provide protection against a competitor stealing a novel algorithm, rendering patents largely unnecessary.
- ajju 15y agoThe link from Technology review to the application is broken. If they fix it, the number will probably go up!
- guelo 15y agoIt's a shame that the petition that gained traction was so poorly written to the point of not being understandable.
- anigbrowl 15y agoYep. That pretty much assures it's a dead letter.
- extension 15y agoLook what else is a hit: https://wwws.whitehouse.gov/petitions#!/petition/formally-acknowledge-extraterrestrial-presence-engaging-human-race-disclosure/wfYDlmlG https://wwws.whitehouse.gov/petitions#!/petition/formally-ac...
- missy 15y agoI wondered if, there were no software patents would the community be better off ? Does anyone know off a statistic were there are cases where it shows that companies that sued others and won, ended up paying more in the end for breaching someone elses patent. Google bought Motorola recently and some say just to have security that android is used on the phones. They then used ,and still are, the patents as an leverage against rivals competitors. I think as indiviudal company you can gain, but with these wars the eco system is weakend and in turn everyone is worse off.