3 ms·
I still fail to understand how the smart contract metaphor of "here is some obfuscated code from a third party, please give it access to all your money, kthx" h
by ajross 5y ago
I still fail to understand how the smart contract metaphor of "here is some obfuscated code from a third party, please give it access to all your money, kthx" has managed to survive at all. I mean, really, no one saw this coming?
It's just the Trust Problem all over again. Decentralized reliance on automatic software still requires trust that the authors of the software won't scam you. It all comes down to trust. And I trust banks, mostly. Who in their right mind trusts contracts someone sends you on Discord? And yet...
- muh_gradle 5y ago> Who in their right mind trusts contracts someone sends you on Discord? Exactly. That's where the gullibility is really visible... This is basically a steroid version of "I am Nigerian royalty and I need you to give me money" emails. Your first instinct should always be skepticism.
- chrisco255 5y agoI don't trust them. Just last week, GoFundMe rugged a bunch of funds sent for a legitimate political protest. They can snap their fingers and freeze your funds and hold it indefinitely, without a warrant. I admit that the Approval UX for wallets and tokens needs to be improved. Unlimited spend approvals should always be flagged in the UX. And approvals should be atomic (single transaction only, with a clearly listed cap, by default). There are some EIP proposals addressing this, but they will be a ways off from standardization.
- leshow 5y ago> Just last week, GoFundMe rugged a bunch of funds sent for a legitimate political protest. The protest is illegally blocking much of downtown Ottawa, as a result GoFundMe decided to refund the donors. That's far from a "rug"
- matkoniecz 5y agoNote that GoFundMe decision to refund is a change from its previous one that happened only after outcry.
- chrisco255 5y agoA private company intervened in the sending of money between private individuals. You can arbitrate that all you want, but it doesn't change the fact that they shouldn't have that power in the first place. GoFundMe is not politically neutral.
- PretzelPirate 5y ago> Who in their right mind trusts contracts someone sends you on Discord? No one. > It's just the Trust Problem all over again. Decentralized reliance on automatic software still requires trust that the authors of the software won't scam you. It all comes down to trust. It does, but you get to decide who you trust rather than being forced to trust one of a small number of large institutions. If you want, you can delegate your trust to a third party who will be responsible for vetting anything you interact with. You can also choose to trust yourself or other members of your community. This person shouldn’t trust themselves since they are too willing to go along with people who say positive things about them.
- ajross 5y ago> but you get to decide who you trust And if you trust the wrong people? Per the linked twitter thread, the author trusted the scammers! They only avoided the scam because they were competent to read the contract code for themselves. Is that the standard you want applied to all transactions? Does that seem likely to lead to good outcomes?
- lanstin 5y agoYeah it isn’t trusting people so much as trusting code written by people. Generally something you want to do only very carefully and when you have no other choice. Or have some proper centralized framework of safety engineering to make mistakes harder.
- lanstin 5y agoTo be honest i don’t really trust banks to value my economic well-being so I have almost all my money in a credit union. But as a software engineer I really don’t see how you can trust code, even stuff developed under NASA style care has bugs. Especially where the framework isn’t doing any rate limiting or safety checks.
- kevinventullo 5y agoTotally agree. I heard recently discussion of putting deeds to homes on the blockchain, but having recently purchased my first home, I am 1000% okay with the paperwork and oversight and honestly friction that goes into it. The amount of regulation seems to make it very difficult to get totally ripped off, which is great since so much of the process was so opaque to me.