4 ms·
The Rule of 72 (2007)
- arjvik 5y agoI love the rule of 72, but my calculus class affectionately called it the rule of 69.pi (69.314). More accurate (you can round to 72 in your head anyway) and so much more fun to remember.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bonzini 5y agoIt's not necessarily more accurate to use 69.3. If you expand the Taylor series to two terms you get an even better formula, 69.3/x+0.34. Write it as (69.3+0.34x)/x and it shows how, as the interest rate grows, using a dividend in the 70–72 range is more precise than 69.3. [That's another way to write the paragraph "A note on accuracy" from the article]
- outside1234 5y agoThis is one of the most powerful rules in finance
- boffinism 5y agoRelevant XKCD: https://xkcd.com/947/ https://xkcd.com/947/
- Ruecker 5y ago[dead]
- kqr 5y agoHere's what I don't understand about this: you won't do the long division in your head, so clearly, you'll have to memorise, for common interest rates, that 72/2 = 36, 72/3 = 24, 72/4 = 19, 72/5 = 15, and so on. At that point, why wouldn't you just remember that "at 2 %, compounding doubles in 36 periods" and so on? Why the indirection through 72? (Obviously, if you need a more accurate calculation or you don't remember the division, you'll probably use an electronic calculator, and then you might as well compute the compounding directly. The only exception I can think of is if you don't have access to an electronic calculator but do have a slide rule at hand. This is very rare these days.)
- dskloet 5y ago72 = 2*2*2*3*3 so if the divisor is a multiple of those factors, the result is too. This makes the division quite easy in many cases. It's also why I immediately realized your typo in 72/4=19.
- iratewizard 5y agoAnother way to say it is 3*4*6. Divide by those numbers by taking one of them out of the multiplication
- Veserv 5y agoMany people do actually do the division in their head, I certainly do and not just for the trivial divisors either. In fact, I would find it odd if any of my mathematically, scientifically, or financially inclined friends did not do it in their heads, at least for quick calculations, to the point where I actually find your position that people would just memorize it instead of calculating it kind of shocking. It is truly amazing how people can have such different life experiences.
- kqr 5y agoNo, I get it. It might just be that mental division is a weakness of mine that I should brush up on.
- nosianu 5y agoI usually do it by approximation most of the time. I estimate and then I multiply to see how close I got. Multiplication is easier. 720 / 13 for this example and 1.3% looks pretty easy this way IMO, you just need a few iterations. I immediately know the result of using 10, so I'm already down to 720/130, or 72/13. Which shows me I did something stupid because I could have started that way and not forgotten what "%" means in the first place... Anyway, using 5 as a very lazy first estimate gives me 5 * 13=65 - certainly manageable in most heads. Trying 6 gives me 78. Looking at both results, which have about the same distance from the target value, next I'll try 5.5 and that's 5 * 13 + a half of 13, still easy, 71.5. Close enough. Multiply by ten to compensate for the initial simplification, I get 55. That's really close to the result (~53.7, using the rule of 72 it is ~55.4). I try to segment such calculations into simpler ones, instead of doing one algorithm, and finding shortcuts. For the 5.5 I use the shortcut that it's half of ten which always is easy, and that I can split it into two easy parts. To me it's more fun that way, even if I could also do the algorithm. It's supposed to be fun and being lazy is my goal. For division you can often find shortcuts as well. Dividing by two, and powers of two subsequently, is simple enough. Any number you can divide by makes the number you have left easier. If you start from two you get prime factorization. You just have to remember a few numbers to put them together again (i.e. multiply) afterwards. Or any number less than ten really. Here too I would try to decompose. To me merely applying the algorithm is just work and maybe counts as mental exercise, but the decomposition and finding of little shortcuts is more fun and an exercise too.
- dang 5y agoRelated past: The Rule of 72 (2007) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11959230 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11959230 - June 2016 (92 comments) The Rule of 72 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3699782 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3699782 - March 2012 (1 comment)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- names_are_hard 5y agoOne thing I don't see mentioned in TFA (I quickly skimmed it) is the relationship of the rule to continuous compounding. The article does say that it works better for "small R", after all - if interest rates where 100%, it should obviously take a year to double, not .72 years, right? Well...no. Theoretically, if interest is 100% paid continuously throughout the year, you'll double your money in about .72 years. The issue is that we generally quote interest rates as annualized rates _after_ taking into account the compounding frequency (this is the difference between "APY" and "APR"), so the rule is usually applied to annualized rates, in which case it's correct to say that the error increases as the rates increase. But suppose rates were actually quoted as the annual rate before compounding frequency is accounted for. With monthly compounding, your return is > (1 + r/12)^(12n) where r is the annual rate and n is the number of years. With weekly compounding, your return is > (1 + r/52)^(52n) Daily: > (1 + r/365.25) ^ (365.25n) More generally, if p is the number of interest periods in the year > (1 + r/p) ^ pn Taking the limit of p as it tends to infinity (ie "continuous compounding) it can be shown than the rate is > e^rn Some text books write this as "Pe^rt", where P is your starting principle and t is the number of years. Same same. Anyway... To double your money, solve the following for n: > e^rn = 2 > n = ln(2) / r > n = ~.69 / r Thus the rule of ln(2) is actually perfectly accurate if you're looking at an annual interest rate that is paid continuously, or close to it. Round ln(2) to 72 for simplicity and it's still pretty close. The big error bar comes from the lack of continuous compounding, which is what forces the hand-waving in the articles derivation ("for small R..."). P.S. Written off-the-cuff, it's been years since I looked at the math for this and I might be totally way off. This is not investment advice, this is hacker news and I'm positive some kind soul will correct my mistakes. After all, the best way to get correct information on the internet is to post something wrong on a forum of smart pedantics.
- nly 5y agoNothing in finance is really continuous though. Most banks will calculate interest daily. On a related note, I recently took the time to learn some financial Excel functions to create a Rent vs Buy spreadsheet. It's worth anyone who ever keeps track of their finances using a spreadsheet to learn the FV function: https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/office/fv-function-2eef9f44-a084-4c61-bdd8-4fe4bb1b71b3 https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/office/fv-function-2eef9... And the PMT function, which is useful for mortgage calculations: https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/office/pmt-function-0214da64-9a63-4996-bc20-214433fa6441 https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/office/pmt-function-0214...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- amelius 5y agoIt doesn't account for inflation, though.
- aperson_hello 5y agoSure it does, if you make it do so. Use net real rather than nominal returns as the input to the equation
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]