15 ms·
NFT marketplace shuts, citing 'rampant' fakes, plagiarism problem
- benburleson 5y agoWait, NFT creators never considered the fact that others could create NFTs from an identical digital source?
- rchaud 5y agoCreators did. NFT shovel sellers, aka the marketplace builders, didn't care.
- Closi 5y agoBlockchain is magic, didn't you know?
- wpietri 5y agoExactly. There are strong selection pressures against anybody who thinks about anything too much here. In the POSIWID sense, the purpose of NFTs is obviously not to provide a reliable market for digital goods. It's just the next in a long series of things one can hype (bitcoin, blockchain technology, ICOs, DAOs) such that money comes in and the promoters and speculators can divert some of that money flow into their own pockets. It doesn't have to actually work. It just has to sound good enough that suckers buy in. It's all magic beans.
- miracle2k 5y agoThere is no way for a blockchain to magically know how owns the copyright to a work. Multi-year court proceedings are sometimes necessary and people still don't agree. It is shallow criticism that often amounts to no less than "blockchain bad because it can't do that magical thing". NFTs cannot solve this, and therefore don't want to. Once you accept that, they work perfectly fine for their actually intended purpose!
- wpietri 5y agoExactly my point. Blockchain technology is useless here; it's a bad match for the problem of ownership. I agree with you that NFTs work perfectly fine for their true purpose. In the same way that Bitcoin, a complete failure for its stated purpose, works great for its current purpose: enabling grifts, scams, frauds, and assorted light financial crime.
- alpaca128 5y agoOh, the creators did. The suckers who bought the NFTs didn't because they had sufficiently little understanding of the tech to fall for it.
- Ekaros 5y agoThat would violate NAP, so why would anyone do that?
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y ago[dead]
- Bancakes 5y agoIt doesn't because it's already in my RAM. Or swap. If you're OK with it being in swap, you gotta be OK with me saving it to disk manually.
- dwb 5y agoI’m sorry but this is a consequence of the current nature of NFTs in this space that should have been obvious to any technologist. It’s just baffling to me that this stuff has got this far.
- zitsarethecure 5y agoEvery generation thinks they are too smart to fall for scams, and every generation is wrong.
- friedturkey 5y agoI'm not really surprised. Every time there's an unregulated market with the potential for loads of cash, people rush in to scrape up every cent before either it gets regulated or everyone else runs out with the money.
- croes 5y agoWho says it's not exactly as they wanted it to be. It's about profit. Things like proof of ownership means more complexity and reduces profit.
- dwb 5y agoDoubtless there are a lot of cynical actors around all this, but when making frustrated generalisations I prefer to apply Hanlon’s Razor!
- dale_glass 5y agoConfusingly, it seems there really are people out there who believe rules and laws are only created because somebody is power hungry, and not because they're actually useful. Yeah, if you're 5 idealists with the same dream you probably won't screw over each other too much, and whoever tries to set rules for everyone else probably will turn out to have some unpleasant ulterior motives for it. But large groups are very different from small groups, the dynamics are very different, and far more structure is needed for things to actually function. Some people just have to learn that the hard way I suppose.
- huitzitziltzin 5y agoWhat does “fake” even mean in this context? I can recognize your claim to the “original” digital image I right clicked and saved. The version I’m selling isn’t that one, it’s this one. I’m not selling your copy. I’m selling my copy. Look - I even point to a different location on the blockchain where ownership will be recorded. An alternative approach - I can right click, save, and then change the color of one pixel by 1%. That’s a different image! Is it also a fake?
- cygx 5y agoWhat does “fake” even mean in this context? An NFT minted by someone who doesn't hold the rights to the digital asset it is supposed to represent. NFTs were advertised as a way for creators of digital content to monetize their work, but without some authority that verifies that the seller owns the copyright, the system cannot work...
- LightG 5y agoThat last point seems to be overriding problem with anything in this space beyond basic bitcoin. I keep coming back to it with anything to do with smart contracts. Can someone explain at least what the theoretical solution to this is? Otherwise the whole thing just sounds like a scam.
- rmah 5y agoThere is no theoretical (technical) solution. Ownership is a legal construct, not a natural phenomenon. To wit, someone only owns something because a legal jurisdiction is willing to recognize that he does. No blockchain tech can surmount this.
- anticristi 5y agoBasically it all comes back to monopoly on violence. If you steal my painting, police will crack open your home and take it back.
- isoprophlex 5y agoBut... but... wasn't all this web3 tech supposed to solve this?! I was promised non-fungible monkey jpgs! How could I have seen this coming?!
- chrisco255 5y agoOh no, how will we ever solve decentralized reputation systems, it's an NP hard problem! Literally impossible. We really painted ourselves into a corner this time. Oh well, we tried. Back to your scrollfeed, serf.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoI feel like PVP got it in one: http://pvponline.com/comic/2022-01-31 http://pvponline.com/comic/2022-01-31
- throw3838 5y agoNFT are really just used for tax evasion and money laundering, similar to physical art scene. There is not real NFT market!
- enkid 5y agoDon't forget pump and dump schemes.
- Lucasoato 5y agoI really hope that the disappointment the market will have after realizing that NFTs are just being used as a Ponzi scheme right now won't be an obstacle to other more appropriate uses. Imagine the revolution they can bring to other old school ledger system for houses, cars, licenses...
- dustymcp 5y agoThey would have the same central authority problem, the real issue is to get evereyone to agree to using a system like that..
- PebblesHD 5y agoThis is the part of NFTs and crypto more broadly that I struggle to understand. What exactly about car registrations or licenses needs improving and how does a crypto token do that? A drivers license is already relatively difficult to forge, and for verification there is already a central registry of them, so where does the token come in?
- seba_dos1 5y agoIt doesn't. If you really need a blockchain, an old-school permissioned one will do the job cheaper, more reliable, and, paradoxically, often even in more decentralized fashion. NFTs don't bring anything to the table, other than being a cute and wasteful collectible card equivalent that's perfect for money washing and scamming clueless people.
- after_care 5y ago> crypto more broadly Think about all of the licensing, money printing, and registration agencies to ever exist. What percentage of them have significant corruption? Blockchains provides a lot of stability in a way more traditional human organizations fail to.
- adhesive_wombat 5y agoAt the end of the day, the vehicle registration agency still needs to issue the license, so what's the benefit of a blockchain here? You do not need a blockchain to, say, cryptographically sign something such that it can be verified as a genuine item. And blockchain won't stop corrupt minting of licenses by the agency. And even if you did need a blockchain, the ledger wouldn't be public because the data on it is private. So now it's just a database with a ton of extra steps, complexity and kneecapped performance.
- robrorcroptrer 5y agoHow much does it cost to store the actual asset only within the actual blockchain, for the most popular chains?
- hobo_mark 5y agoDid not do the math myself, but apparently: https://twitter.com/dominic_w/status/1490349135249035264 https://twitter.com/dominic_w/status/1490349135249035264 "Cost of storing 1 phone photo (3.3MB) on the blockchain" ICP 1.6 cents - Solana ~$2,500 - Ethereum ~$1M
- ramchip 5y agoICP looks pretty dodgy from some quick googling. The number might still be true, I have no idea... https://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrency/comments/pg3nuf/was_icp_a_scam_coin/ https://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrency/comments/pg3nuf/was_...
- Lapsa 5y agoi see pee is actually good at something?
- tromp 5y agoOn the order of $1 per KB for Bitcoin IF it allowed transactions to embed arbitrary data, which it doesn't. Spreading bits of data over many transactions is MUCH more expensive.
- seba_dos1 5y agoA fortune. Plus once it's on a public blockchain, everyone can copy it, so not sure what does "only" mean in your question.
- numpad0 5y agoI've heard lots of NFTs are just links to links that starts with "https://s3.us-east-1 https://s3.us-east-1". It makes some sense to make it any ways but not like that.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mattdesl 5y agoNot the first NFT marketplace to shut down; and won't be the last. Depending on the implementation, this may or may not have much of an impact on the assets being distributed and/or traded on the platform.[1] I suspect most marketplaces that take a completely open and decentralized approach will struggle against spam, plagiarism, and regulation. [1] - https://mattdesl.substack.com/p/hicetnunc-and-the-merits-of-web3 https://mattdesl.substack.com/p/hicetnunc-and-the-merits-of-...
- stjohnswarts 5y agoGet in, get rich, don't get greedy, get out
- tommiegannert 5y agoI was wondering why they shut down instead of solving the problem... The original (or current) title is "suspends," which makes more sense.
- barrucadu 5y agoWho could have foreseen this? Oh, wait...
- obiefernandez 5y agoOpen NFT marketplaces and free minting are a recipe for this kind of mass stupidity. I run a major music NFT marketplace and we don’t have this problem because to create content on my platform you have to be invited and go through a contract process that includes legal assurances related to rights and clearances of anything you plan to mint. Most of that content ends up being exclusive and fans love it. That people write off the entire NFT space based on the “fakes” issue are missing the point that there are people like me who believe the technology serves the people rather than vice versa.
- rasputin243 5y agoCan you share the name of your marketplace?
- obiefernandez 5y agoRCRDSHP
- theonlybutlet 5y agoLittle point in an NFT if it's the legal system protecting you, the downfall of NFT's, it serves little purpose. I mean Shutterstock has been around for ages.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoYeah, really no more valuable than a dead tree format certificate with an artists' signature of authenticity on it. Much like that not worth the paper it's printed on if so one isn't enforcing it or a very large body of people agree "that's the one"
- miracle2k 5y agoYes, its exactly like that - and that's fine. That is how they are designed and intended.
- obiefernandez 5y ago
- theknocker 5y ago
- xwdv 5y agoI can’t wait until all these NFT hustlers, Get-Rich-Quick shills, wannabe Crypto influencer billionaires get blown out of the market, and we get back to the days where the only people who held crypto were true techies and blockchain enthusiasts. Just them.
- skc 5y agoIf those end up being the only people using crypto then what would have been the point of it?
- xwdv 5y agoThe point was never to make people obscenely rich off of speculation.
- helloworld11 5y agoWhat a uptight, insular and silly comment. When the American West opened up due to railroads, gold mining and cheap/free land. Guess who some of the first people to really commercialize it and make it viable for all future growth were? Get rich quick shills, wannabes, hustlers and desperate people looking for a new frontier for wealth. It's not a pretty thing, but it's how interesting frontier territories grow and later mature into something better, be they digital or physical... The early commercial internet was also full of hucksters, shills, hustlers and so forth. What happens next is anyone's clear guess, but if you really want your precious crypto bubble to turn into something useful for the world, you might want to reconsider your notions.. What good is crypto if it stays limited to a narrow circle of naval gazers?
- lwouis 5y agoEvery week, I read some new grotesque story about NFC. Every time I'm reminded of the movie Idiocracy. We have 2 billion people in poverty. Climate change threatens our sedentary civilizations. We still have no clue what's going on in the universe and how to make sense of it. And yet somehow enough of us participate in this circus that it make the news, and I have to witness pathetic drama stories about screenshot-ing monkey drawings, people spending 250M dollars to encode a book onto a chain, NFT marketplaces centralizing into traditional model while operating on a technology that literally and non-ironically requires "gas fees" for simple transactions because of how inept the tech is. Gas fees. In the same world that holds COP events every year to try and get us to not self-extinct from our own waste products. What a sad show this is.
- jbirer 5y ago
- barneygale 5y agoCharity won't solve poverty you muppet
- jbirer 5y agoCharity can give someone the push needed to try to improve their situation, i.e giving a homeless man a 1 week airbnb and suit and clean shave could help him get a job. I shouldn't have to explain this to you like this but I also have understanding for the disabled.
- vmception 5y agoSo why did they shut down? > people selling sets of NFTs which resemble a security Okay thats a much more valid reason to shut down, because the marketplace will get curb stomped by the SEC
- dorkwood 5y agoI'm confused why they would close over this, since what they're describing is essentially their core business and shouldn't come as a surprise to them. Could it be that they're in legal trouble? One thing that seems important, but which is missing from the headline, is the fact that people were also selling bundles of existing NFTs on their platform. > Hejazi highlighted three main problems: people selling unauthorised copies of other NFTs, people making NFTs of content which does not belong to them, and people selling sets of NFTs which resemble a security.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- xyproto 5y agoRight when I was looking forward to selling my new masterpiece "Mona Lisa with 1 pixel changed".
- freitasm 5y agoI read comments thus far and seriouslly, so many ways to rationalise institutional scam.
- anotherevan 5y agoI wish I knew who originally called NFTs "Content-Free DRM" so I can give them appropriate credit. I think they nailed it.