9 ms·
Turbine “torture” for Greek islanders as wind farms proliferate
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mdp2021 5y ago> Agii Apostoli was a picturesque seaside village ... Now it is ringed by towering wind turbines whose night lights and whirring sounds are tantamount to daily "torture", locals say. ... "Wind turbines have been installed on mountain peaks, in forests, near archaeological sites, on islands, in protected habitats" ... "This is torture, we can no longer sleep for the noise" It is called, in some regions, a "silver bullet", a solution that may look plausible (or is presented as such), but that upon actual consideration involves difficulties, tradeoffs, and feasibility constraints which may be initially hidden. The noise pollution involved by wind turbines is not into everyone's awareness. It may be a minor inconvenience for those who live in some metropolitan areas («Noise is so pervasive here that even sirens are set twice as loud», or «I am looking for good noise protecting earmuffs for my newborn for when I will take her around outside» - signed, different friends of yours truly in the Big-C-City), but the unfortunate thing is that they tend to place wind turbines exactly in the conceptually opposite places - the middle of the wilderness, the "deliverance" places.
- raxxorrax 5y agoEnergy transport is difficult but there would be much better locations, especially for islands. This is just mismanagement.
- mdp2021 5y ago> better locations That is an inherent difficulty with wind turbines, because the most efficient places for wind tend to be the places of optimal sound broadcast. Though location wise, one big point would be: "Alongside the motorway? Ok, consistent. // In the middle of paradise? (...Speechless.)" To place wind turbines where busy infrastructure already is would facilitate energy transport.
- raxxorrax 5y agoI thought about offshore installations in this case. But it is still very expensive. Otherwise proximity to users would make sense too.
- wrp 5y agoHaving experienced extended exposure to the kind of low-frequency noise emitted by wind farms and its effect on psychological health, I feel it is not at all hyperbole to call it "torture." I'm afraid that even in most urban areas, the low-frequency noise would stand out from typical background noise and have noticeable health effects on the community. There is a growing literature on the health effects of low-frequency noise, and also on (mostly losing) battles of communities against nearby wind farms.
- lm28469 5y ago> I'm afraid that even in most urban areas, the low-frequency noise would stand out from typical background noise Especially since most cities get much quieter at night.
- raxxorrax 5y agoI believe it. Frequencies in that regions are known to cause discomfort. In my opinion they shouldn't be build anywhere near areas where people live.
- mdp2021 5y ago> they shouldn't be build anywhere near areas where people live Surely, that societies have a clear idea that noise pollution must be a concern would be duly and civilized - but, that territory impairing infrastructure is placed in the few quiet places remaining, is a special kind of madness in itself. Also considering that urban areas in many territories already are a huge compromise in terms of quiet, so you will want to keep the few unpolluted places remaining as a reserve...
- BoxOfRain 5y agoCertainly not my area of expertise but would it be possible to arrange the turbines in such a manner the phase of the sound waves they're generating cancels out the harmful infrasound?
- csdvrx 5y ago> I feel it is not at all hyperbole to call it "torture." Unfortunately, the topic of windmills is getting politized, and complaining against the negative effects is now being ridiculed and tried to antivaxxing and luddism. > > There is a growing literature on the health effects of low-frequency noise, and also on (mostly losing) battles of communities against nearby wind farms. If even Trump couldn't prevent a wind farm near one of his Scottish properties, it's indeed mostly battles being lost: https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/joe-biden-just-brought-up-donald-trump-s-obsession-with-windmills/ar-AATHOA https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/joe-biden-just-broug... While nimbism may play a large role, the negative health effects reported by many people like you should not be neglected. And I just don't understand why the damage to the wildlife is almost never mentionned.
- rjsw 5y agoWhere would be better? I think the Aegean Sea is quite deep so it wouldn't be possible to attach wind turbines to the seabed.
- throw0101a 5y agoFloating turbines are possible: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Floating_wind_turbine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Floating_wind_turbine
- cinntaile 5y agoThese are mostly in the prototype phase.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dogma1138 5y agoI’m not sure if there are better actually solution. A single wind turbine near a farmhouse brings out some warm ecofuture vibes however right now it seems more likely that what we will get is every hill top and the horizon near ever beach polluted with turbines. Off shore wind farms are a nice idea until they block your entire view of the sea. Wind should be a small scale solution for remote locations. It doesn’t seem to me that any implementation of it on an industrial scale can be achieved without an environmental disaster of a different kind. Small Nuclear Reactors and fusion really can’t come fast enough.
- theshrike79 5y agoInfrasounds are weird. They are hard to measure correctly with off the shelf equipment that's usually used for noise complaints and they affect people very differently. Some people don't notice a constant infrasound at all, others start getting a "dreamy" feeling and a constant feeling of ... something weird. Both of which are really hard to quantify and measure. There are even studies that kinda sorta link "haunting" with sources of infrasound.
- PretzelPirate 5y agoI really wish this article included a recording of the sounds. I have no idea what they sound like and if it would bother me. I personally love the look of wind farms, but maybe the noise would make me equally as upset as the people in the article.
- goodpoint 5y agoHere's a video with a recording of sound intensity of wind generators (not infrasounds tho) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zKgN2G9d0dc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zKgN2G9d0dc
- mdp2021 5y ago> would make me equally as upset You may be unable to tell in advance. There comes a point in which you break and what was "not even perceived", not just "tolerable", before, becomes unbearable later. You have to consider the constant exposure, and the fluctuation of your resistance, and consider the effect of the burden in the times of lower resistance. The issue is not with the stress of the weight lifted when you are vigorous, but that which will be when you will be weak.
- theshrike79 5y agoIt's like tinnitus. It's bearable when you get a mild case from a concert and then it goes away. But when it sticks and you're at your second decade of 24/7 eeeeeeeeeee in your ear, at times it gets to you really bad and you just want to claw your eardrums off.
- mrjangles 5y agoAnd tell me, what do you think would happen if they started building wind turbines in the middle of cities? There is no reason you couldn't fill Central Park in New York with them. Maybe put one on top of every building? You could have thousands of huge turbines powering every city. I wonder why no one ever seems to suggest that?
- mdp2021 5y ago(First of all, Sean, I am glad you are still with us and I plan to see your last television appearance in a few hours, as it will be broadcast tonight. You will remain unforgotten, Mr. Jangles, or should I call you "Ron".) There may be a misunderstanding there, if my reference to people minimizing the idea of the impact of noise because they live in the screams already, is taken as a suggestion that wind turbines should be placed on every roof. The messages were, (1), that noise is a problem even if you think it does not bother you, and, (2), if you had unpolluted places and you ruin them, you destroy your alternatives left. Noise pollution should be fought, period. The expression «It may be a minor inconvenience for those who live in some metropolitan areas» was rhetoric, as in "Some people used to noisy environment may tend to minimize the issue [but that kind of infrastructure is often placed there where living things go look for quiet]".
- pjc50 5y agoYears ago, there was a bit of a fad for small turbines on roofs. However, wind turbine cost efficiency scales positively with size. They also "shade" nearby turbines from the airflow, and the presence of buildings and ground clutter further reduces the efficiency. You may have noticed that it's not as windy in Central Park (or any other park) as it is on the Atlantic coast. So the optimal wind turbine is (a) extremely large and (b) at sea or near the coast. You get things like this with 100m blades: https://www.ge.com/renewableenergy/wind-energy/offshore-wind/haliade-x-offshore-turbine https://www.ge.com/renewableenergy/wind-energy/offshore-wind... There is also a little bit of a safety issue. The possibility of losing a 100m blade or part thereof is low, but you wouldn't want that in a city. (I appreciate the "I don't want that near me" view, but that means that person wants it near someone else? Or some other solution that nobody wants to be near either?)
- Kalanos 5y agothis is the kind of arrogance that got us into this mess
- logicalmonster 5y agoPerhaps this is a very dumb question, but how have people around the world living on smaller islands gotten their electricity in recent decades? Are they connected to the mainland's electrical grid, do they run their central own central power generator, or do individuals just use gas/solar power if they need electricity? I don't know about other nations with many islands, but in Greece's case, there are loads of small islands ranging from just a few people to hundreds to tens of thousands, so it probably makes a centralized infrastructure very hard.
- wildzzz 5y agoPower usually comes from fossil fuels on islands like this. Even a group of islands as large as Hawaii used 73% fossil fuels in 2017. Small, poor islands are going to almost entirely run off of fossil fuels since investment in energy infrastructure is expensive.
- jdrc 5y agoOil. The islands have been early adopters of renewables (they are ideally fit) . Solar water heaters are common since many decades. No gas infrastructure
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Steltek 5y agoWhat is the difference between wind turbines and highways or utility poles festooned with cables? It seems to me that the key thing is that the latter were installed a long time ago and acceptance is baked into life. But if you think about it, utility poles with cables running everywhere are a more invasive eye sore. And listing all the problems with highways here would certainly hit the character limit. There's a lot surrounding us in modern life that if you step back, you might see a problem. Wind turbines are new so they're under the microscope. But if they've enabled Greece to cut its coal power substantially, they're certainly worth it.
- mdp2021 5y ago> they're certainly worth it You think that people speak of torture lightly? > What is the difference between wind turbines and ... utility poles festooned with cables If you turn, you do not see the poles, but you hear the turbines. > What is the difference between wind turbines and highways 1) Not many people seem to have called highways "unbearable". 2) Some linear segments of highways run into the wilderness, spoiling an area according to the distance to a line. Some clusters of wind turbines are placed in the wilderness as a cloud of broadcasters, spoiling an area according to the distance to an area. 3) There are little alternatives to highways. Edit: and: > There's a lot surrounding us in modern life that if you step back, you might see a problem So let us encourage the public to see evident problems immediately, instead of "discovering" them later, post facto.
- acdha 5y ago> You think that people speak of torture lightly? Yes. It’s easy to find people who claim, for example, that’s it’s torture to wear a mask during the pandemic. This is especially common with NIMBYs who are trying to make their case sound more persuasive than “I don’t like change”. That’s not to say that there aren’t valid complaints here but it’s important to remember the selection bias: people who don’t mind don’t seek out reporters to tell their story. There’s a long history of this — I’m reminded of the various “electro-sensitivity” hoaxes involving complaints about cell towers starting months before they were even powered on — so the first thing you’d want to ask is how broadly shared these concerns are, followed by the trade offs (living next to a windmill beats living next to a coal power plant, for example), and putting it in perspective (windmills kill birds, but so do windows and fossil fuel plants - both at much greater rates).
- JoeAltmaier 5y agoSeem overheated. "Can't even sleep for the noise" has to be a lie - they haven't died from lack of sleep, which would happen surely? No, they make noise, and they're resented, and any excuse is made to slang them.
- mdp2021 5y ago> has to be a lie - they haven't died from lack of sleep It does not work like that. This close acquaintance of mine had an accident, and he spent every night in years not really sleeping, but bearing attention to the damages borne in the accident, which remained too loud to allow his conscience to go in normal sleep. He spent his nights listening to the pain. People would guess a largely wrong age looking at him, or would say he looked horribly - but he survives today.
- wrp 5y agoThat is a good analogy. It is very similar to dealing with chronic pain that prevents you from ever getting a good sleep.
- JoeAltmaier 5y agoExactly. Pain is a real problem. Billions of people live with a constant background of city noise. These folks on the island have a new noise, to be sure. And some resent it, that's clear. And they may even get themselves worked up over it. But billions don't do those things and live a good life. Because noise is something our minds are exquisitely adapted to filtering. Unlike pain or hunger, our brains ignore sounds all the time, all day long, everywhere we go. So I think, again, that the 'windmills make sound' argument is specious.
- mdp2021 5y ago< noise is something our minds are exquisitely adapted to filtering. Unlike pain or hunger, our brains ignore sounds all the time No, Mr. Altmaier. In that story, I wrote pain and I meant noise (and I wrote it that way because the poster's point was about sleep). You have no idea. You must have no experience. The filter you are talking about works only on good health, and it bears stress during functioning, and it has limits. If you were under the physical weight of a heap of rugby players on top of you, your body resists, but do you think it would be healthy? And do you think your body would resist forever? The human system has a tolerance like flexible solids: under some load they adapt with elasticity, under some more they accumulate microfractures, under some they break. Millions of people live in degraded conditions and they just ignore them: it does not mean that they live «a good life» - they do not live a healthy life. They may manage to keep themself contented - through sheer tolerance, which oftentimes passes through dumbing down their perception. The human system is given feedback features to know what is healthy and what is to be avoided. If you believe that people are impermeable to noise, just go to watch somebody subject to protraced stimula and see them react - after one second, or one minute, or one hour...
- hirundo 5y agoThe light pollution is also a problem. 17 years ago I bought a lot in a rural subdivision and have lived there ever since. I consulted a light pollution map before buying here, as I'm an amateur astronomer. This is one of the darkest areas in the lower 48 states. I can just about read by the Milky Way on a clear night. I had my pick of the new subdivision when I bought here, and just barely chose to live on the East side, overlooking state land, instead of the West side, with a view of BLM land. Just this year a large wind farm has been built on that BLM land. The nearest turbine is over five miles away, so you can't hear them. But each one has a bright red light at the top, I guess to warn aircraft. Even so far away, with about 20 of those lamps visible it destroys the night darkness, not just for sensitive astronomy, but even for a good night's sleep. I just feel lucky that I'm on the other side of the subdivision and can't see them. That was a close escape. But a few lights are encroaching on my previously pristine view in the far distance as civilization approaches. But I probably have a few years left of dark nights, unlike my West-side neighbors.
- sandos 5y ago"Even so far away, with about 20 of those lamps visible it destroys the night darkness, not just for sensitive astronomy, but even for a good night's sleep." I don't get this _at all_. I happen to live in Sweden, you know the dark, cold place. We have extremely short summer nights, and I can guarantee you that the SUN is so much brighter than your puny lights that its just silly. Nobody (well, almost) complains about that here. There are even many different solutions to, you know, block light from coming indoors. Or are you really sleeping outdoors? It just sounds so much like hyperbole.
- hirundo 5y agoI sleep much better in real dark. I used to work night shifts, so have years of experience struggling to sleep with too much light. I never did adjust well to it. Now I probably take it too far, taping over the power light on the phone next to my bed, etc. But I know I sleep better with the blinds down even just to filter out the light from a full moon. No doubt for a lot of people light isn't a problem with sleep at all, particularly for younger people.
- Tepix 5y agoConsider me sceptical. In the the Netherlands, in the rich city of Noordwijk, some people claimed that the tourists would stay away before the placement of wind turbines near the coast. The wind turbines came. The tourists stayed. Didn't Trump sign some laws that would prevent wind turbines near his Florida property? #NIMBY
- mdp2021 5y ago> The tourists stayed Mr. Tepix, people accept situations and practices you would never believe. And with your comment you were not even referring to Average Joe, Median Jack and Typical Maude, not even Random Randall: your mention was exactly of Selected Sam. "Those who remained, remained". "Meant was, in the same amount": the pool is vast. ...Can you believe this very post received anonymous mark of downvotes, Mr. Tepix? When you lay your consideration on people, record their wild behaviour for something that teaches you about people, not about norm.
- pydry 5y agoThis happened in the UK too with Navitus Bay. Opposition to the project was astroturfed, probably by oil/gas/nuclear.
- sandos 5y agoThey really need to dismantle their old turbines, that's for sure. Re-powering can probably give much more power output but with a fraction of the current number of turbines. I'm not sure how large and modern turbines fare against older and smaller ones, I sadly get a feeling that they're not much better or maybe even worse. I think blade tip speed needs to be high for high efficiency and that sounds like it can be noisy.
- black_puppydog 5y agoI just had to check this and with a bit of clicking around and searching I think I found most of the areas the article is writing about. If you really want to, click this link: https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1fZE https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1fZE (but be gentle because I don't know how well the overpass APIs scale...) Here you can see the northernmost turbine in the area, the one also closest to Petries, mentioned in the caption of the top picture: https://i.imgur.com/8rBjHbp.png https://i.imgur.com/8rBjHbp.png That's here: http://umap.openstreetmap.fr/en/map/mesure-distance_315118#16/38.3647/24.1850 http://umap.openstreetmap.fr/en/map/mesure-distance_315118#1... That's just about 660m away from the next village. That's starting to be uncomfortably close in terms of noise indeed. Way to make sure you'll have justified opposition right there. *sigh* I'm not very sympathetic to the visual complaints -- car infrastructure already ruins many a landscape, I actually don't mind the turbines -- but the noise argument I agree with; proper distance (adapted to the geography) must be maintained. Edited to fix overpass link
- amatecha 5y agoI was curious about this subject and found a video[0] of a couple whose house is about the same distance (1600 feet or 487 meters)... In this case the turbine even casts a shadow on their home and property which is SUPER jarring. I'm not sure people realize but wind turbines are pretty darn loud (check at 2:55 in the video), that's exactly what they sound like at times. There's honestly zero excuse to build something that loud anywhere within audible range of peoples' homes. [0] https://invidious.snopyta.org/watch?v=f7DQ3SgSg0c https://invidious.snopyta.org/watch?v=f7DQ3SgSg0c
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pasabagi 5y agoHow does that compare in dB to a road? PS: checked it out myself, from some light googling: Road decibel levels are about 55 dB (averaged over a day) for about 30% of the EU population. Wind turbines are supposedly 43 decibels if they are within a few hundred meters of a house. I guess it probably varies a lot depending on the turbine in question.
- scientism 5y agoThere was a case in France about a couple who was awarded a compensation because of the noise of a windfarm close to their house. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/nov/08/french-couple-wins-legal-fight-wind-turbine-syndrome-windfarm-health https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/nov/08/french-couple-...
- Proven 5y ago
- Eric_WVGG 5y agoWould it be possible to use “active noise control” (reverse-amplitude sound waves) to cancel out the sound?
- rasz 5y agoYes, for one person/house. Everywhere else you would just amplify same noise by producing its copy out of phase.
- phoinix 5y ago
- V__ 5y agoMaybe someone who works with turbines can clear this up for me, but are these some cheap or old turbines? I have nether heard a turbine that loud in my life. I found the value of 105 db at the source for a modern turbine, which would mean at a distance of about 700m the noise would be negligible. Possibly Greece doesn't have high enough standards for turbines and this is the result of a lowest-bidder kind of scenario?
- musicale 5y agoThe unfortunate externality of pollution, noise or otherwise, is that one group of people (power customers, power company) with political or economic power benefits at the expense of a third party (local pollution victims.) It's disappointing that even if you manage to avoid the noise hellscapes of large cities, which perhaps might not be completely unexpected, you may still be stuck in a picturesque rural or small-town noise hellscape of loud wind farms that prevent you from sleeping at night. Basically noise becomes inescapable. (edit: moved to top level as intended)
- londons_explore 5y agoThe red flashing light on the top of wind turbines is ugly, distracting, and unnecessary in today's world. Sure, it's so that planes can see it at night. But planes flying at night also need to avoid mountains, and they have no flashing light. Just require planes to have updated maps, and turn the light off.
- schroeding 5y agoThese light, at least where I live, are mainly not meant for planes, but helicopters. For example, Military SAR / police / medical helicopters fly very low to the ground in cities. They often fly on sight, below any legal flight limit. Urban structures are all they need to avoid, and sometimes they must fly very close to them. As it's very hard to see a tall, unlighted structure at night before it's too late, this would be very difficult without any kind of signal lights from the structure itself.
- londons_explore 5y agoThe light could be designed to only come on if there is a helicopter nearby if it is really important for that.