10 ms·
San Francisco Is Sick
- noahtallen 5y agoI live in one of the west coast cities, and while I am fairly YIMBY and think new development is very important, I think the most impactful part of homelessness is not solved by the solution proposed by this article. My take is that there is no societal framework to help people who have extreme mental disorders which cause them to act very dangerously and erratically. I think many in west coast cities are feeling increasingly unsafe walking around, which is making stricter approaches more palatable to local governments. But I think that feeling of danger is caused by people who (even by no fault of their own!) are actually dangerous to be around for mental health reasons. I think this is a topic we obviously avoid discussing frequently. But I think it’s at the core of the homelessness crisis. Yes, absolutely we need cheap housing. Yes, we need good programs to help people get back on their feet. But we also need to do something about severe mental health issues. (Hell, and even “minor” mental health issues.) It is simply not humane to allow someone to be a danger to themselves and others. And it’s especially not humane to just delegate them to the streets — which will never be sanitary or safe. So at a point, we will need to figure out as a society how to help these people, if we really want our streets to be cleaner and safer. And that means putting someone in a clean, decent place with medication… but it also means forcing them to be there if they experience severe enough issues. This is a really difficult problem to talk about and solve in a humane way, but I don’t see how we get around it.
- zozbot234 5y agoHow about housing them, for a start? Living on a street or in a chaotic homeless encampment can't be good for mental health.
- nathanaldensr 5y agoFor many homeless, you have the causation exactly backward. Mental health issues have and will sometimes be innate and have nothing to do with one's housing situation.
- noahtallen 5y agoYes, of course that should be part of it! My point is that we do need to acknowledge that some people can’t live independently and also don’t have a support system, and a humane approach will need to help them too. Currently, if someone can’t live independently, their family gets them into a nursing home or hires a caretaker. If you don’t have that support system, our society won’t help you at all.
- BoumTAC 5y agoHis book is really great and I recommend reading it. https://www.amazon.com/San-Fransicko-Progressives-Ruin-Cities/dp/0063093626/ref=sr_1_1?keywords=san+fransicko&qid=1644568717 https://www.amazon.com/San-Fransicko-Progressives-Ruin-Citie...
- nickpp 5y ago> What were we getting for our high taxes? This is the crux of the problem and it all comes down to motivation. Politicians have exactly 2 priorities: being elected and being reelected. Every other concern is a very, very distant third. In a democracy people imagine that the politicians they voted will do a good job in order for you to vote them again. But in reality politicians have always found easier, faster shortcuts for that: populism and buying the votes directly with your tax money. SF administration has immense budgets that anywhere else in the world would solve a lot of (if not all) problems. But they preferred to focus their attention on populist issues of the day, like attacking businesses and corporations (the very same ones providing jobs and building housing), and various woke causes. The results speak for themselves.
- WalterGR 5y agoBut they preferred to focus their attention on populist issues of the day, like attacking businesses and corporations Do you mean attacking globalists?
- lordnacho 5y agoAs a European with a lot of family and friends in the Bay Area, I have to say the place really does seem very clearly in need of fixing. Forty years I've lived in the rest of the world, saw a lady who was demented walking around in the street once, waited around until police came to help her. Seen a handful of people in need of mental health help shouting out loud aggressively, but it doesn't happen much at all. Never seen anyone poop on the street. I went to SF to visit a relative for about 5 days just before covid, put together maybe I've been there a month, and I saw all these things more than in the rest of my life. It seemed to be a reliable daily occurrence that I'd meet a shouting person. I visited Twitter HQ at one point yet not far away there were homeless people with no shoes. I saw tent camps. Not far from where I tried VR goggles for the first time, a lady was so desperate to eat she barged into where I had finished eating to grab my leftovers. A lot is said here on HN about what is wrong, but I just gotta say it's not just some ordinary large city level of problem, I've been to plenty of large cities that did not feel like this.
- deepsun 5y agoSan Francisco has unprecedented rate of help and support for homeless people and people with mental health issues. It is naturally expected that the people in need would move to the city. Maybe "other large cities" do not provide such kind of support? And if they did, people in need would not flock to San Francisco?
- lordnacho 5y agoOne thing I hear quite often from people is that other cities ship their homeless to SF on a one way ticket. Is that actually true?
- Fatnino 5y agoOf course it's true. And the people getting shipped are only too happy to go. The climate here is much better for living on the street than in some other city where it snows in winter.
- WalterGR 5y ago