8 ms·
Yup. The kernel of truth behind Austrian theories of macroeconomics/the business cycle is that interest-rate based policy setting is inherently an unstable syst
by zozbot234 5y ago
Yup. The kernel of truth behind Austrian theories of macroeconomics/the business cycle is that interest-rate based policy setting is inherently an unstable system. If the central bank makes policy errors that fail to stabilize the underlying target (whether inflation, nominal income, exchange rates, whatever) the whole system starts spiraling away from that unstable equilibrium point, and the subsequently needed correction grows even larger. It's important that errors be promptly corrected, and expectations about future policy remain properly "anchored" to the right target.
- wolpoli 5y ago> It's important that errors be promptly corrected, and expectations about future policy remain properly "anchored" to the right target. It would be interesting to know if inflation expectation has become unanchored in the mind of the general public, because, ultimately, inflation expectation causes inflation.
- nine_k 5y agoI don't think that inflation is as easy to cause without a fresh supply of money. And you know who prints fiat money.
- HWR_14 5y ago> And you know who prints fiat money. I imagine you mean the fed, but I don't know what point you're making.
- wbsss4412 5y agoInflation is easily caused without a fresh supply of money. Destroy your productive capacity => inflation.
- baryphonic 5y agoNo, money really is essential. If you destroy your productive capacity but money supply remains the same (which is honestly a bit odd, since real prices are always relative), then you get substitution effects that don't affect the general price level, only the price levels in particular segments of the economy. (I would expect the prices of products, capital goods and human capital to increase, and the price of commodities and goods related to distribution to decrease). Put differently, you'll have less exchange and will shift what you spend on, but the price levels will not show much of a sustained general increase. The tricky part of inflation is that a lot of money exists on paper, and banks and even firms are more constrained by capital than we otherwise might wish to believe. (Though one good casualty of the pandemic has been the realization that banks are almost entirely unconstrained by reserve requirements, only by capital.) So when the money is sitting in some account bearing a small amount of interest at the Fed, that is low velocity and may not cause inflation. However, if that cash enters circulation (via, say, direct payments from the government), then suddenly the velocity is much higher, the money supply goes up and you have "too much money chasing too few goods." Inflation is really always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon.
- girafffe_i 5y ago> "I would expect the prices of products, capital goods and human capital to increase, and the price of commodities and goods related to distribution to decrease" If wages go up, that comes from the companies; does that mean trickle-down econ worked, starting from low interest rates?
- wbsss4412 5y ago> If you destroy your productive capacity but money supply remains the same (which is honestly a bit odd, since real prices are always relative), then you get substitution effects that don't affect the general price level, only the price levels in particular segments of the economy. Because the destruction of capacity somehow didn’t affect the substitutes? That’s magical thinking. There’s a shortage of new cars => used car prices skyrocket (alone this accounts for roughly ~1.5 points of the cpi increase). And no, it’s not simply because demand is higher for cars, new car sales are still below pre pandemic levels. > Inflation is really always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon. It can be one, and that is certainly a contributing factor here, but if you can see the obvious supply chain/shift in demand due to covid effects, then you’re just blinded by dogma.
- djur 5y ago"Who prints money?" and "who creates money?" are two different questions with two different answers.
- danaris 5y ago"Who can print money" and "who can introduce money into the economy" are not the same question. Obviously, only the federal government can change the rate of printing new dollars. But inflation of the monetary supply, in practice, is not merely about "how many dollars are in existence." It's about "how many dollars are circulating in the economy." Thus, given how much money has been hoarded by the very wealthy over the past 50 years, they have an unprecedented ability to cause inflation themselves simply by deciding to spend more of it.
- HarryHirsch 5y agothey have an unprecedented ability to cause inflation themselves simply by deciding to spend more of it They spend it in the stock market, that's where the inflation is. I remember a time when a P/E ratio of 12 was a signal that the company was highly valued, and a P/E ration of 15 was a signal of a bubble. Nowadays that number for Tesla is ~ 100! That's insane.
- danaris 5y agoWell, yes, exactly; that, and stuff like the cryptocurrency and NFT bubbles are very clear demonstrations of the excessive wealth accrued by the top few %.
- imtringued 5y agoNo, they completely miss the point. The fundamental problem with money is that you can delay your spending indefinitively thereby breaking the concept of supply and demand. Imagine an economy where you are self sufficient and sell but never buy anything ( cough germany). You keep accumulating more and more money and you could in theory spend it all, thereby cause a huge amount of inflation. That is the core of the deflation inflation paradox. There is never enough money in one part of the economy while the part with too much poses a threat that can deploy instantly without any warning. Selling and selling isn't a free market, it's not even a market.
- zozbot234 5y agoIt doesn't break the concept of supply and demand, because demand for money also exists. Money is an asset. When you accumulate it, it increases in value and the central bank+banking sector creates just enough of it to offset your demand. When you later spend it, it becomes a hot potato (the economic actor who got your money doesn't really want to keep it, she'll exchange it for something else) until the central bank drains it away. Or else it will just slosh around until prices rise enough to create enough demand for it in nominal terms.
- stale2002 5y ago> Imagine an economy where you are self sufficient and sell but never buy anything ( cough germany). > Selling and selling isn't a free market, it's not even a market. You are not describing much of a problem. What you are asking is "What if there was an entity, that provided the rest of the world with lots of goods and services, and the only think they accepted for that is green pieces of paper". That sounds pretty good to me. Someone never spending their green pieces of paper, is just doing the rest of the world a favor, by providing all those goods and services.
- karpierz 5y agoThe issue isn't the first part; it's what happens when they cash in their green pieces of paper.
- hammock 5y agoTrue to form, since the Fed was created, each new crisis has been bigger and sooner than the last.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- zozbot234 5y agoWrong, actually. The 1980s and 1990s saw a huge improvement in macro-level stability. The late-2000s crisis was an outlier.
- colinmhayes 5y agoThis just isn't true. THe country was pretty much perpetually in economic crisis during the late 19th century, largely because of the lack of ability to perform monetary policy.
- gumby 5y agoApart from the comments talking about crises under the Fed, look at the 18th century where gold strikes (or the lack thereof) caused several more serious crises, with both inflation and deflation driving crises, due to the money supply being completely uncorrelated with economic activity.
- Spooky23 5y agoYes, it’s not like the good old days when you’d just hope JP Morgan was still in town to stave off depression.
- didericis 5y agoAustrian theories appeal to me/seem correct beyond just a kernel, but I’d consider myself an amateur/haven’t read enough to be confident about my opinion. Specifically, the emphasis on relative value seems correct, the emphasis on the importance of keeping pricing signals pure/unaffected by artificial monetary supply changes to effectively allocate resources seems correct, the argument that market incentives exist for keeping interest levels reasonable without centralization seem correct, and the argument that central banks are incentivized to mismanage monetary policy over time for political reasons seems correct. The counter arguments against Austrian ideas that seem most compelling to me are that having non centralized currencies leads to financial inefficiencies that outweigh any benefits of having market determined interest rates because of exchange friction, and that a lack of planned inflation and adoption of more hard currency would mean the velocity of money would be low and cause the economy to lock up. I’d be very interested in a book advocating the more traditional view in favor of central banking aimed specifically at Austrians and people like myself who find the Austrian arguments compelling. If anyone here has more economic knowledge and thinks I mischaracterized the arguments I found compelling, garbled them, or misattributed them, please correct me.
- quadrangle 5y agoAustrian economics is all anti-empirical say-so internally-consistent models that aren't tested against reality. Traditional economics is stuff that claims to be more empirical but fails to do so and focuses almost entirely on official stats and on its own versions of models that aren't tested against reality. The whole field of economics is overall messed up. It's insular, arrogant, and extremely resistant to outside criticism. And it's dangerous as economics claims are used to justify so much. Random amazing example: In https://www.npr.org/transcripts/980841456 https://www.npr.org/transcripts/980841456 and from "My question is, what is the M1 money supply, and the M2 money supply, for that matter?" last third of it, insanely clear and amazing. In short: Q: more money! does that mean inflation? check with this econ textbook author Author: oh, that's embarrassing, that chapter shouldn't be there Q: so what causes inflation? Author: people buying stuff more, demand going up (unless it's insane money supply like Venezuela or Zimbabwe level insane) Q: so why is the chapter in your textbook? Author: um, publisher said that if we don't say that more money means inflation then econ professors won't use our textbook. They learned that idea in their original studies, so they will only use a textbook that lets them teach it. But it's wrong, and we shouldn't have put it in the book.
- specialist 5y agoTangentially: > unstable equilibrium point Is anyone looking at economics thru the lenses of chaos theory (complex adaptive systems), control theory, or cybernetics? I've foraged a bit, no joy, but really don't know where to start looking. I only ask because... Anthropologist David Graeber's book Debt: The First 5000 Years muses about the fragility of market based systems. Like maybe capitalism contains the seeds of its own destruction. Hence the recurrence of debt forgiveness, jubilees, and revolutions throughout recorded history. Seen from this angle, it sure does seem like some kind of debt crisis always has a role in social upheaval. With economics simulations (modeling) attaining ever more fidelity, it occurred to me they'll inevitably hit "butterfly effect" type phenomenon. Further, what if Graeber is more than right. What if "capitalism" can never be stable? What if market equilibriums will always collapse? That insight would have huge impact on public policy. Instead of trying to keep things afloat indefinitely, we'd anticipate and plan ahead for the endless series of resets. Proactive instead of reactive. Because it sure does seem (to this noob) like crisis and resets are the norm. I'm not saying that real life is just a weirder instance of Dwarf Fortress. But given how hard it is to design stable and predictable closed world game economies, what hope do we have to do better with human economies?
- hackerfromthefu 5y agoPart of the problem is the crises occur infrequently and humans en masse tend to forget the past, in their emotions and actions if not in theory. Another part of the problem is the governments benefit from inflation and again short term the people in power benefitting from it are unlikely to be the same ones in power when the crises eventuates, ie the problems of money printing are externalities. But your central idea of planning ahead for the crises is actually refreshing and excellent, if it is possible to apply it. On a personal level, anticipating and timing the crises is a form of planning for it, to reduce financial leverage before the crisis and have cash available to buy assets cheap from those that didn't anticipate the crisis.
- jbay808 5y ago> economics thru the lenses of chaos theory, control theory, or cybernetics? I'm looking too. In my mind this is absolutely the way to look at the macroeconomic landscape, and as a control theorist, I don't like what I see, which is a widespread lack of respect for delayed responses and positive feedback loops. I'll evaluate what hope we have for stability once I see the control being executed sensibly.
- _lazlo 5y ago