7 ms·
I keep hearing from people who think nuclear's a bad idea that "France is ramping down its reliance on nuclear power, so what does that tell you?" I wonder whe
by robertlagrant 5y ago
I keep hearing from people who think nuclear's a bad idea that "France is ramping down its reliance on nuclear power, so what does that tell you?"
I wonder whether any will change their minds based on this news.
- rdtsc 5y ago> I keep hearing from people who think nuclear's a bad idea that "France is ramping down its reliance on nuclear power, so what does that tell you?" A cynical person might even imagine French infiltrators behind the scenes supporting anti-nuclear sentiments in neighboring countries in order to eventually sell them electricity. Energy independence and energy costs have started wars before, so it would just be pocket change spent for a future "investment".
- polotics 5y agoThe word you're looking for is "paranoid", not cynical I think. Reasonably, to drop CO2 emissions by 5% each year, ie. to have a change of keeping climate drift below 2°C avg, these reactors won't even be enough for French energy needs...
- cjbgkagh 5y agoCynical is indeed the correct word.
- anonporridge 5y ago"Only the paranoid survive."
- 323 5y agoOr Russian infiltrators. Isn't it funny how after deciding to get rid of nuclear reactors Germany suddenly realized that it needs to build a gas pipeline to Russia to cover it's energy needs. The former German chancellor, Gerhard Schröder is now chairman of Russian energy company Rosneft, and was a strong advocate of the Nord Stream pipeline project.
- freeflight 5y ago> Or Russian infiltrators. Isn't it funny how after deciding to get rid of nuclear reactors Germany suddenly realized that it needs to build a gas pipeline to Russia to cover it's energy needs. It's not funny, it's bluntly wrong. The German nuclear phase-out was precedented by the EEG, the first green electricity feed-in tariff scheme in the world [0]. It was part of the Energiekonsensgespräche that went on in the 90s, and ultimately resulted in ratifying the nuclear phase-out in 2002 [1] where nuclear would be replaced with renewables subsidized trough the EEG. It's particularly wrong in the context of Germany using most of its gas not for electricity production, but rather for industrial and chemical production, and household utilities, only 14% of German gas is used for electricity generation [2]. Nuclear fission reactors would do nothing for that, they don't help with high temperature smelting were gases need to be injected, as it's for exampled needed for metal alloys that go into all those cars Germany manufactures. They only way nuclear fission could help there is by using nuclear energy to electrolyze hydrogen, and use that as natural gas replacement. But renewables can very much do the same, without creating very complicated waste, while also fixing what's currently holding renewables back the most; Storage [3] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_Renewable_Energy_Sources_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_Renewable_Energy_Source... [1] https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomkonsens https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomkonsens [2] https://de.statista.com/statistik/daten/studie/37985/umfrage/verbrauch-von-erdgas-in-deutschland-nach-abnehmergruppen-2009/ https://de.statista.com/statistik/daten/studie/37985/umfrage... [3] https://www.euractiv.com/section/energy/news/dutch-pin-hopes-on-hydrogen-valley-to-revive-declining-gas-region/ https://www.euractiv.com/section/energy/news/dutch-pin-hopes...
- mrDmrTmrJ 5y agoYour citation #2 shows Household, Power Supply, and District Heating to total 52% of natural gas usage. Nuclear power can take over both for electric power supply and for home and district heat via electric heat pumps - which can be 250-350% efficient[0]. So, over 50% of German natural gas usage can be replaced by nuclear electrical power, based on the citations you provided :) [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coefficient_of_performance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coefficient_of_performance
- Krasnol 5y agoYou have to be joking... France just had to turn off 3 of their rotting reactors[0] and they lowered their estimates for this year to 295-315 TWh[1]. They're desperate, it's election year and they failed to come up with a diversified energy plan for the future. Luckily the recent taxonomy decision may help to avoid sharp tax rises to finance this backward and hilariously expensive[2] strategy but those EU funds won't run forever. Expensive times coming up for the French taxpayers. Why would you need conspiracies when the failure is so clear in front of you? [0] https://then24.com/2022/02/08/three-nuclear-reactors-shut-down-for-checks-following-suspicions-of-corrosion/ https://then24.com/2022/02/08/three-nuclear-reactors-shut-do... [1] https://www.edf.fr/sites/default/files/epresspack/2447/5c9aa66cd253dc8deb73da5ac2b429d5.pdf https://www.edf.fr/sites/default/files/epresspack/2447/5c9aa... [2] https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/edf-announces-new-delay-higher-costs-flamanville-3-reactor-2022-01-12/ https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/edf-announces-new-de...
- B1FF_PSUVM 5y ago> Why would you need conspiracies Sense of purpose. Mere incompetence is disheartening.
- Krssst 5y ago> they failed to come up with a diversified energy plan for the future Why diversify? If you have enough power when you need it without emitting CO2 I would think that would be enough. However, no new nuclear construction for that many years does look like a mistake as France looks like it is slightly increasing use of coal this winter: https://www.rfi.fr/en/france/20220112-france-fires-up-coal-power-in-policy-reversal-over-feared-nuclear-shortfall https://www.rfi.fr/en/france/20220112-france-fires-up-coal-p... If France had more NREs it would still face the same issues without adding considerable storage capabilities (any big country that does 80% NRE thanks to storage?)
- Krasnol 5y ago> Why diversify? If you have enough power when you need it without emitting CO2 I would think that would be enough. Ask that question next summer when the rivers get too hot again and they have too shut down.
- 99_00 5y agoSeems their mental model doesn't have predictive power.
- _ph_ 5y agoWell, France has 58 mostly old reactors and have 1 under construction and now announced 6 more. To keep their current level of nuclear production, they would have to build like 40 in the next 20-30 years.
- Bayart 5y agoNew plants are much more powerful than the older ones. But it's true that the relative share of nuclear is meant to go down.
- bjoli 5y agoI was under the impression that it is in the range of 1-2x per reactor. There are some old Swedish ones that are at 800mw, while the ones I believe the article refers to are in the ballpark of 1500mw.
- Bayart 5y agoOlder water pressure reactors in France are 900mw/1300mw, the EPR is 1650mw. I concede it's not as dramatic an increase as I made it sound. But it should also go hand in hand with longer uptimes and better safety.
- joe_the_user 5y agoFrance is the only country I know that's managed to make nuclear power work. Unfortunately, they haven't been able to export that expertise. Nuclear power plants are vast construction project. The construction and large-engineering industries combined are vastly corrupt in the US (look at the 3 billion dollars planning costs of the unbuilt high speed rail project in California, look at the Big Dig in Boston, etc). In an ideal world, nuclear might be great. In the existing US world, it seems like a disaster waiting to happen. Edit: found this text on the problems of standardization of nuclear power in the US. http://www.strategicstandards.com/files/NuclearEnergy.pdf http://www.strategicstandards.com/files/NuclearEnergy.pdf
- vimy 5y agoNot just France. 60 % of Belgian electricity is generated by nuclear power plants. Unfortunately the green party has decided to shut them down and replace them with gas plants to “save the climate”. Green stupidity knows no boundaries.
- theshrike79 5y agoI don't get this logic. How does 100% reliance on Russian natural gas save anyone from anything? =) The current hike in electricity pricing is pretty much solely based on the fact that way too much of Europe's electricity is produced with Russian natural gas...
- Manuel_D 5y agoUkraine and Slovakia both generate the majority of their electricity from nuclear [1]. South Korea and China area also building nuclear plants at a decent rate (though the former is adding a lot of fossil fuel capacity too). When the United States built nuclear plants at scale, in serial production, plant costs were also much lower. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_by_country https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_by_country
- Gwypaas 5y agoSouth Korea had a run in with a ton of faked documentation and is essentially out of the game [1]. China likes to keep a finger in the nuclear jar for diversification but the current investments are minuscule, even though they look large from an outside raw numbers perspective. [2] [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_South_Korea#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_South_Korea#H... [2]: https://www.iea.org/data-and-statistics/charts/average-annual-power-capacity-additions-in-china-in-the-announced-pledges-scenario-aps-2020-2060 https://www.iea.org/data-and-statistics/charts/average-annua...
- stubish 5y agoI don't think it will change any minds. Bringing a new power plant online in 15 years is irrelevant to just about everybody. Most people are concerned about switching to renewables right now. It might have interested people 20 years ago, maybe even 10.
- SECProto 5y ago> Bringing a new power plant online in 15 years is irrelevant to just about everybody. I mean, it's very relevant to the population of France, who are currently relying on a huge number of aging nuclear plants that will be retired in the coming few decades. I for one am hugely relieved to hear this news and hope it works out.
- enaaem 5y agoThe best time to invest in nuclear was 15 years ago. The second best time is now.
- jillesvangurp 5y agoThe question is how much of the capacity they are going to retire in the next few years is going to be replaced. It's a highly political issue in France and it's an election season. Nuclear from a cost perspective continues to be expensive; also for the French. And they will in any case continue to build out solar and wind as well. So, there's that. And finally, building nuclear plants is something the French do abroad too. So, it's actually something they export that generates jobs and revenue in that way. So, they would want to at least build a few plants to keep that going. And of course they also have military interests tied up with uranium enrichment. France is fiercely protective of its status as a nuclear power. But I think overall nuclear will be slowly declining proportionally in France; just like almost everywhere else. Unless something changes on the cost front. Which does not seem to be happening