27 ms·
An update on AirTag and unwanted tracking
- darkwizard42 5y agoThese feel like welcome changes. Don't think it addresses all the past concerns.
- tssva 5y agoIt addresses none of the key past concerns. Specifically the ability for the devices to operate with their speakers disabled and no effective means for non-iPhone users to detect they are being tracked. The Android app Apple released is basically useless since it requires manual scanning.
- dwaite 5y ago> The Android app Apple released is basically useless since it requires manual scanning. It is better than nothing. The limitation on background scanning is likely due to Android + diverse hardware not providing a low-power way to do such a thing. The more effort Apple takes to bind an Apple ID to a real world identity, the more consequence comes from abuse of a tag. The alerting serves to make that consequence more likely.
- Gigachad 5y agoMostly all seem ok. The only one that makes me a little sad is the precision finding tool will make it easier for thieves to spot tags on bikes.
- darkwizard42 5y agoYeah, but the original purpose was for keeping track of your own stuff, not as a deterrent for theft. For your bike, I would recommend something from here: https://www.cyclingweekly.com/group-tests/find-your-stolen-bike-with-a-gps-tracker-165579 https://www.cyclingweekly.com/group-tests/find-your-stolen-b...
- micromacrofoot 5y agoI'm not always a fan of Apple's decisions, but short of pulling AirTags off the shelves and scrapping the product entirely, they've gone far beyond any of their competition (Tile) with this stuff. Ultimately, maybe we're better off just losing things sometimes.
- unethical_ban 5y agoExactly - this seems like the kind of thing where the only way to really mitigate its abuse is to not have it at all. "Your scientists were so preoccupied with whether or not they could, they didn’t stop to think if they should." - Dr. Ian Malcolm
- quantified 5y agoLet’s see how hard it is to neuter the sound generation within the AirTag itself. If it’s silent itself, an Android or no-device trackee is vulnerable. There is not much tech that lacks unpreventable malicious use. Needs to be expected for pretty much anything.
- zingplex 5y agoWould it be possible to design the device to detect if the speaker has been tampered with? Perhaps having some sort of microphone on board to detect whether the speaker is functional would work.
- nomel 5y agoThis could be put into the speaker driver, to do something like an impedance measurement, to verify that something that looks like a speaker coil is still present. If you wanted to make something hard to defeat, you could measure the capacitance between the coil and case, as a deflection measumerent, to verify that coil was actually moving in a way that it should be. Both would probably add a relatively large amount of power consumption, completely change the design, and add a bunch of cost, where nobody would be interested anymore.
- Syonyk 5y ago
- mperham 5y agoI get an alert every time I ride my wife’s bicycle. It would be nice to be able to mark her tags as ok to be near me.
- closetohome 5y agoBeing able to share AirTags via a family iCloud account seems to be a pretty commonly requested feature. It does seem a little silly that I can track every device attached to the account but not AirTags.
- ssully 5y agoEven outside of family. I would buy an airtag for my dog for when my friend watches them. It'd be nice to drop off my dog and "share airtag with this user" so they can have a resource in case my dog got lost.
- dwaite 5y agoI suspect they are working on it, but the crypto is privacy-preserving enough to make centralized authorization management hard. Specifically, you get a cryptographic secret when you pair the key, it broadcasts as a bluetooth beacon with encrypted messages based on that secret and current time, that get reported up to an Apple service. When you want to see your accessories, your device will compute the encrypted messages at appropriate times and have apple search for them. However, there's no network push to an AirTag available to tell it to rotate keys. You could grant more people to see a tag by sharing the secret - but you then could not remove that permission without physically resetting the tag. I suspect the solution will eventually be having derived keys from the secret and date, and date-based "leases" for permissions - I share the current key to allowed peers. That would mean revocation might be represented in the UX immediately, and take a day (or some other time period) to actually start to fail cryptographically.
- olliej 5y agoI do think it should be possible to share encryption keys (ignore this MAC alas doesn’t work because the MACs and randomized and rotate fairly frequently when in the vicinity of an owner’s devices)
- seltzered_ 5y ago"We plan to update our unwanted tracking alert system to notify users earlier that an unknown AirTag or Find My network accessory may be traveling with them." How does this work if one doesn't own an iPhone?
- cyral 5y agoThere is an Android app which allows Android users to see the same notifications.
- Gys 5y agohttps://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.apple.trackerdetect https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.apple.trac... With 100.000+ installs it seems only a very small percentage of Android users is aware or cares
- teruakohatu 5y agoLook at the reviews. It doesn't seem to work. It requires manual scanning and does not work in the background.
- bigmattystyles 5y agoYea, but philosophically, you shouldn't have to opt in (to opt out) - if I don't want to any part of apple's ecosystem, this forces me to actively opt out.
- cyral 5y agoWhat about Tile and other AirTag competitors? None of them even have an app to alert you to unwanted trackers at all.
- bigmattystyles 5y agoNo love for them either - but your retort is pure whatabout-ism - it doesn't address my core complaint.
- ungoogled 5y agoI'm sure they're frustrated that people keep using AirTags as tracking devices rather than local thing-finders, but I think there are good reasons for that. Local trackers have been around for a long time. I had a "TV remote finder" years ago that you'd stick to a TV remote (or keys), and it would beep when activated by a second device. More recently, Tiles work pretty well, assuming you don't need direction finding. Personally I don't regularly lose anything large enough to benefit from an AirTag. I need it for things like individual AirPods. But a small device with a worldwide range and no subscription fee that I can attach to a car or suitcase? That's a novel capability. I have one in both cars and my electric skateboard.
- badwolf 5y ago> "TV remote finder" I was sorely disappointed when they announced the new Apple TV remote, and it didn't have airtag built into it.
- rootusrootus 5y agoI want to see AirTags built into all mobile Apple devices. iPhone, iPad, remotes. With it's own rechargeable battery, it would be really useful when my silly kid forgets where he left his iPad.
- kylehotchkiss 5y agoThe find my network is supposed to be that already - Apple devices even ping when turned off. Try opening “find my” and clicking devices. If you all share a family account, their iPad should display its location.
- rootusrootus 5y agoIt only lasts as long as the battery does, plus 24 hours (as in, the location will be visible for 24 hours but won't update after the battery is dead; after 24 hours Apple hides the last known location). Even then, it is unreliable. The last time my son misplaced his iPad (a week ago), after I put it back on the charger it didn't start beeping (I had told it to make a sound via Find My) until about 12 hours after it was turned back on. Simultaneously I got the notification that it had been found. Not too impressive, IMO. An AirTag, though, would have its own rechargeable battery and would be able to locate the iPad for a year after it got lost. In my ideal implementation it would work just like a regular AirTag, the only difference being a circuit to keep the battery charged, and being embedded inside the case of the iPad.
- karaterobot 5y ago> In an upcoming software update, every user setting up their AirTag for the first time will see a message that clearly states that AirTag is meant to track their own belongings, that using AirTag to track people without consent is a crime in many regions around the world That really should do it. I mean, in the unlikely event that a message to first time users doesn't solve the problem of people being stalked using AirTags, go ahead and keep working on the other updates. Belt and suspenders. But my guess is, it won't be necessary. They should consider adding a message for iPhone users to tell their friends with Android phones that they "should be really careful not to get tracked by AirTags, because there's no way they'd know about it". /s
- theshrike79 5y agoThey can just install an app if they're worried about being tracked by AirTags: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.apple.trackerdetect&hl=en&gl=US https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.apple.trac... Just remember to add the Tile app too, it does the same thing.
- nomel 5y agoDon't forget the Samsung SmartTag app!
- Melatonic 5y agoWont run in the background though - you have to actively think to use it each time your worried about being stalked.
- theshrike79 5y agoThere are other apps that run on the background, that's just the official Apple one.
- post_break 5y agoJust keep nerfing it Apple. They made the beeps louder with this new update too. So every time my wife borrows keys, my car, etc it's gonna go nuts. I guess I'm going to have to rip the speaker coils out of all of them at this point.
- r00fus 5y agoTBH sharing keys is a nightmare even without airTags. Honestly recommend each spouse gets their own key to each vehicle. Once my wife had her keys stolen and we made do for a year sharing my car key and it was hell (because both of us prefer the EV to the minivan). I don't track keys but I track my wallet and my wife does not need or ever ask for that.
- 6sp 5y agoLuckily keys are on the way out. Between a August Smart Lock and a Tesla I haven’t carried keys in years and I don’t miss that nightmare.
- pavel_lishin 5y agoHow are fobs different in this scenario?
- r00fus 5y agoYou can drive your Tesla using your smartphone app or other devices.
- zht 5y agounless if their servers go down, in which case you can't unlock your car
- KennyBlanken 5y agoOr the cellular network goes down, which happens about once a year during a bad winter storm.
- isoprophlex 5y agoAre airtags still useful for eg. tracking a stolen bike? Or will it now alert the thief within minutes that the bike contains a tracker?
- mmastrac 5y agoI don't think you can simultaneously limit unwanted tracking and still track thieves surreptitiously. Basically both are "unwanted tracking" by the "victim".
- dwaite 5y agoThere are details not exposed outside of NDA, but my suspicion is that there is a requirement that MAC rotation happen more slowly, like every 15 minutes, and it is a bluetooth MAC and the actual GPS/cell based 'movement' which together trigger an alert. If a bike's Find My support randomized its MAC on every broadcast, it may very well not be possible to tell that it is not a new device each time. That might not be allowed per the licensing agreement, and that might be something that Apple has heuristics to detect and alert on.
- varenc 5y agoI believe an AirTag stops randomizing some broadcast identifier when it’s separated from its owner. The AirTag by itself has no location awareness. But when an iDevice sees the same separated AirTag at multiple locations it fires the alert.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- troupe 5y agoWell now the airtags give the thief a way to locate the airtag and remove it--in addition to telling them that the air tag is there.
- DenisM 5y agoDestroy the speaker and hide the device inside a tire, steerer tube, or other such place? I mean the thief will get notified, but what are they going to do? Dismount tires, disassemble steering assembly, remove the grips, undo the saddle, bottle mount, Garmin mount, bash guard, lights, etc? This all takes time and skill, it can’t be done on the spot and if they dragged the bike home or to a fence they have already disclosed the location.
- Syonyk 5y ago> ...and we condemn in the strongest possible terms any malicious use of our products. Then subject them to malicious users before releasing them to see what sort of ideas they can come up with in a few days, and mitigate those before general release. Go schedule a room at Defcon, give people AirTags, and see what they do. If they neutralized your mitigations in an hour, well... other people can figure that out too. That the speakers are so easy to disable... well, yeah, you should have figured that out before release. I'm a bit concerned about Apple's internal ability to reason about malicious actors. This is the second time in recent history they've released a shiny something, only to discover it torn to shreds in very short order by people. The whole CSAM hashing algorithm being as weak as it was to manipulation should not have been a surprise to them - but it sure seems like the system was designed without considering that the first hashing algorithm was trivial to intentionally collide. "Buy an iPhone to prevent people from tracking you, and if you want to see where the tracker is, buy a really new one!" is some sort of sales pitch, certainly, though this new set of things sounds so prone to false positives and annoyance that I'm not sure how long it will be until people just turn the whole thing off (if that's an option). It's a neat concept, but doesn't seem to have survived contact with reality and humans very well.
- throwntoday 5y agoTo what extent is any hardware manufacturer responsible for malicious usage of their product in your opinion? Surely you don't believe that all bases can be covered no matter how simple the product prior to launch. I credit Apple for making a best effort at launch and continuing security and support for much longer than the industry standard in their products. But realistically there is no way to launch something flawless as you seem to be suggesting.
- CamperBob2 5y agoYou're both right; it's an interesting question. Something that can't be used maliciously is probably not useful for much of anything at all. OTOH, when the potential for harm is far greater than the potential for good, as it arguably is here, that calls for extra discretion on the part of the developers.
- writeslowly 5y ago> We hope this starts an industry trend for others to also provide these sorts of proactive warnings in their products. I guess they're hoping Tile (or whoever else) will feel obligated to create similar nerfs or annoyances on their trackers? I thought this was interesting because this is one time vertical integration (having a huge network of iPhones) is putting an Apple product at a competitive disadvantage
- eternityforest 5y agoThis kind of scares me. Privacy first tech groups seem to be getting more vocal about trying to change the whole industry. I hope someday we have a fully open global tracking network, not affected by Apple an Mozilla and all the rest who seem to want to destroy any technology that can be used to invade privacy, regardless of how many legitimate uses it has.
- olliej 5y agoCan you give examples?
- eternityforest 5y agoBattery Status API, Ambient Light are the two big Mozilla examples I know, but I suspect the list may be fairly long. I believe they are also against web bluetooth and serial. Apple has some permission stuff that apparently degrades Tile on their platforms IIRC.
- olliej 5y agoThere is no reason for any of those to be exposed to the web. For web specs you can't just think "I could do this cool thing", you have to say "what can a random popup ad do with this". Our experience with WebGL shows permission dialogs are a bad experience, and people will also click "yes" to make them go away. Most users report "would you like notifications" from websites as being spam/annoying.
- todd8 5y agoI like the functionality of the AirTags so I don't want them nerfed, but I can think of no way to fix their fundamental problem of being such easy to use stalking devices. Chefs knives are great for cooking and are inexpensive and easy to purchase; they can be very dangerous weapons in the wrong hands so we make it against the law to use them in that manner. Maybe that's the best we can do with AirTags.
- sixothree 5y agoWhat's different from a thief stealing my bag and carrying it around in their car versus me putting an airtag in the exact same location without them knowing? If a thief has my bag I definitely don't want them knowing they're being tracked. Maybe I don't quite understand something about this announcement.
- dharmab 5y agoWere AirTags ever marketed as theft recovery devices? Or only as a lost and found system?
- sixothree 5y agoFor the user, there's little difference.
- tshaddox 5y agoIt’s honestly pretty silly to expect to track down thieves because they stole something with a tracking device in it. Are you really going to chase a thief and confront them? Do you really think the police are going to do it for you?
- w0mbat 5y agoIt is entirely reasonable to expect the police to recover stolen high value items whose location is known. Particuarly if the items were obtained with violence or weapons.
- 5y ago
- alkonaut 5y ago99% of the tracking notifications are given to my family members. It’s hilarious that you can’t “join” a family members tag so it can be shared within the family.
- jedberg 5y agoAre you on a shared iCloud account? This never happens to my wife and I but we’re on the same iCloud family account.
- Judson 5y agoInteresting. Just one data point, but my wife and I both have airtags on our keys. When I drive her car (and she's not in it), I get a notification about her keys traveling with me. We're on the same iCloud "family" account. I wonder if there’s something else that needs to happen?
- hackmiester 5y agoI would reach out to Apple about that. It’s not supposed to work that way.
- oarsinsync 5y ago“Okay, so what we’re going to try and do here, is reset and erase, and not restore from iCloud backup, so we can rule out this being something in your profile.”
- jedberg 5y agoWhen you go into "Find My", can you see your wife's devices and keys?
- Judson 5y agoI see all her other devices, but not keys. Now that I know how it should work, going to see if re-registering the keys changes things.
- c7DJTLrn 5y agoHilarious. In one statement they claim to prioritise privacy and then also explain why their product is not at all private and can practically be used against the owner by law enforcement. Apple don't care a jot about privacy. This became clear with the CSAM debacle. That's why I left their ecosystem, and I'm very happy with my new phone running GrapheneOS.
- paxys 5y ago"It’s why the Find My network is built with privacy in mind, uses end-to-end encryption..." "Apple can provide the paired account details in response to a subpoena or valid request from law enforcement" Hmm
- jackson1442 5y agoFrom my understanding, location is E2E but they still register the serial to your account.
- function_seven 5y agoBoth can be true. The actual pairing of tag to owner is encrypted in the communication of its whereabouts. Some stranger detecting an AirTag that you own is not able to determine that you own it. But also Apple can pair the serial number of the physical tag with the account that registered it. I think this requires the actual tag to be retrieved. The serial number isn't transmitted in the clear; it's gotta be read off the tag case. That's my understanding of it anyway.
- nomel 5y agoThe serial number, and last four digits of the owners phone number, is available to anyone that is within NFC range of the AirTag.
- ccouzens 5y agoEnd to end encryption has become a buzzword. It prevents identifying who an air tag is identifying its location to. It prevents identifying what air tags you're searching for. It is unclear to me how either property is useful to protecting someone from being tracked by someone else's air tags.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoThe location is end-to-end encrypted, Apple doesn't know where an item is at any given time, only the owner does. Who owns the tag (assuming someone has it in their possession) is not end-to-end encrypted.
- 5y ago
- warning26 5y agoHot take: There is no conceivable way to make Airtags safe, and they should be banned entirely. The problem is that by leveraging Apple devices to get worldwide geolocation and data service effectively for free, they make tracking trivially easy in a way that no other entity could.
- kingcharles 5y agoYou might as well say the same for any product that can be misused by criminals. I use crowbars to lift heavy objects, but they can also be easily used for leveraging open doors that I have no legal access to...
- jackson1442 5y agoShould all GPS trackers be banned then? The problem with AirTags is they're accessible; these problems have always existed with any kind of GPS tracking.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- warning26 5y agoGPS trackers require that you sign up for cell service, which is a non-trivial obstacle to overcome, and opens the user up to tracking by law enforcement. Thanks to Apple's usage of their own proprietary network, both difficulties are automatically negated.
- Closi 5y agoYou need to link your telephone number to use an AirTag indirectly - i.e. You need an AppleID to link the AirTag to, and you are required to provide a telephone number in order to create an AppleID (which is validated via SMS). In principle, Apple has the ability to match the AirTag to a phone number (if they do this or not, I don't know).
- 5y ago
- flawn 5y agoThe funny thing is that people just remove the speakers of that small thingy and hence it should just be banned as a whole
- jasongill 5y agoand as the article indicates, they are combating this exact issue by adding additional alerts on your device when an AirTag is traveling with you, as well as giving you the ability to use precision finding to locate the nearby AirTag in case you can't hear it.
- josephcsible 5y ago> New privacy warnings during AirTag setup: In an upcoming software update, every user setting up their AirTag for the first time will see a message that clearly states that AirTag is meant to track their own belongings, that using AirTag to track people without consent is a crime in many regions around the world, that AirTag is designed to be detected by victims, I expect that this will be about as effective as the antipiracy warning at the beginning of every movie is. > and that law enforcement can request identifying information about the owner of the AirTag. Haven't there been a lot of stories of victims going to police with an AirTag, but this not happening? > iPhone 11, iPhone 12, and iPhone 13 users will be able to use Precision Finding How convenient. Now you need a modern, expensive Apple product to protect yourself from stalkers.
- Closi 5y ago> How convenient. Now you need a modern, expensive Apple product to protect yourself from stalkers. To be honest, this is more about technical capability than an intentional lock-out. If older phones simply don't have the hardware to do precision finding, what would you propose Apple does? No precision finding for anyone?
- Rayhem 5y agoDesign products so this isn't a problem in the first place.
- smilespray 5y agoWhat do you want, a time machine? You can still find the AirTag just fine, you just won't get the fancy "hot potato" animation and precision distance/direction that UWB offers.
- howinteresting 5y agoI'm pretty sure many modern Android devices have the required technical functionality including UWB. Airtags as global trackers should not exist. Finding things locally is a completely different use case.
- a-dub 5y agounwanted tracking should be an open standard.
- physhster 5y agoThe anti-stalker virtue signaling from Apple basically kills any chances of finding stolen belongings. AirTags only work for finding misplaced stuff, not stolen stuff because they will alert the thieves before you get a chance of recovery. This was never an issue with Tile.
- URSpider94 5y agoTile never gained enough market traction for it to be an issue. No use using a system to track your stolen goods that can't provide you with a location because there's no phone running the Tile app within hailing distance.
- concinds 5y agoAndroid users are still vulnerable, and these announcements do nothing to reduce that. All a stalker needs to do, is remove the speaker. To detect a rogue AirTag, an Android owner needs to: 1) know AirTags exist (many obviously don't) 2) go out of their way to install Apple's Android AirTag scanner app (only 100k-500k worldwide have done so according to Google Play stats) 3) manually open the scanner app and scan, since it doesn't scan passively in the background; and even then, it won't help you find the speaker-less AirTag, since it doesn't tell you proximity & direction. I continue to think Apple should have never released AirTags to the public, and should discontinue it. It's a very limited income stream, with limited use cases, and significantly increases the average person's risk of stalking. Practically all positive social media coverage of AirTags involves someone tracking a stolen stolen items (car, bike). Those use cases are dead, since thieves with iPhones will get alerts, and most thieves with Android will know to scan for AirTags. And since most lost items turn into stolen items after a few hours, that removes most use cases involving losing objects in public. That leaves "finding your keys within your home" as the only truly "officially supported" use case. Is that worth all the problems, and brand damage? People will argue that stalkers could always buy trackers, but Apple increased their availability, ease-of-acquisition and ease-of-use by orders of magnitude. AirTags are cheaper than competing GPS trackers, most of which require subscriptions. I remember seeing a chills-down-your-spine Apple Watch Series 7 TV ad, that featured beautiful remote nature landscapes, with the audio of 911 calls made from people's Apple Watches whose lives were saved by their Watch. Probably one of Apple's best and most impactful ad in the past decade. Compare that to AirTag's impact on Apple's brand. Why did Apple even bother?
- heavenlyblue 5y agoPolice in the UK does not follow up on requests to retrieve iPhones from FindMyPhone because the GPS tracking isn't exact enough to find the correct appartment. So for stolen items, it is also useless.
- phil21 5y ago> So for stolen items, it is also useless. It's not. I've recovered my phone after it was stolen by simply showing up to the house it wandered off to the next morning. I've done this a number of times for friends (perhaps not really the brightest idea in retrospect) and you'd be surprised at how many folks simply apologize and hand it over when confronted. If they refuse, at least you tried. Plenty of folks will take matters into their own hands for a $1,000 device that may be a source of their livelihood. Not everyone can simply walk away from that and absorb the loss.
- mjsweet 5y ago"We have successfully partnered with them (police) on cases where information we provided has been used to trace an AirTag back to the perpetrator, who was then apprehended and charged." Obviously each air tag is associated with an iCloud account, so this could be quite an effective move on Apples part.
- netsharc 5y agoA less charitable reading is "We've had at least 1 solid case of criminal use of the AirTag that lead to arrest and charge.".
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y agoWhy would that be less charitable? Many things can be abused criminally. Arrest and charges are how our society deals with it if someone does. Deterrence prevents crimes in many cases. Not all, but many.
- netsharc 5y agoIt's not common for many companies to admit that their product was used for crime, and here is one, in a PR piece about "We care sooo much about our users' safety!"
- nynx 5y agoI think the AirTag stuff will eventually be limited to localized areas where the tags are wirelessly powered.
- prpl 5y agoIf somebody steals your car/purse/whatever with an airtag on it, and that person has an iPhone, will they get notification that somebody is tracking them?
- rolobio 5y agoYes. "If a Find My network accessory that's separated from its owner is seen moving with you over time, this alert is displayed" https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT212227 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT212227
- barbazoo 5y agoOh so this is really only useful for tracking stolen items if whoever steals it doesn't have an iPhone or an Android with their app on it, I never realized that.
- FabHK 5y agoThe AirTags are explicitly designed to track lost items, not stolen items.
- newsclues 5y agoCan probably track the iPhone that the AirTag notified. If apple and law enforcement (private?) want to…
- rootusrootus 5y agoNope, Apple can't tell you where an AirTag is nor can they tell you what iOS device relayed the location.
- newsclues 5y agoApple can track an iPhone and so can telcos
- diebeforei485 5y agoIt was a bit strange that they ever sent "unknown accessory detected" messages. They should say it's airpods. It was also strange that they told people by notification that an airtag was with them, but didn't let them search for it using precision finding. Why would they do that?
- madars 5y agoMight be useful: https://github.com/seemoo-lab/AirGuarg https://github.com/seemoo-lab/AirGuarg, a third-party Android app, can force an AirTag to make a sound even if Apple hasn't determined that tag has been following you (the BLE characteristic is unauthenticated: https://github.com/seemoo-lab/AirGuard/blob/main/app/src/main/java/de/seemoo/at_tracking_detection/util/ble/BluetoothLeService.kt#L234 https://github.com/seemoo-lab/AirGuard/blob/main/app/src/mai...) HN discussion: AirGuard: Protect yourself from being tracked by AirTags and Find My accessories (298 points, 150 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28577951 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28577951
- BeefWellington 5y agoThis works assuming the speaker hasn't been compromised by a would-be stalker.
- madars 5y agoYep. But there is also potential for civil disobedience / mischief there.
- Godel_unicode 5y agoThere's already a thriving market in muted airtags, a quick ebay search will get you there.
- LexGray 5y agoThere would be the hazard that you can no longer say it was an accidental stalking if you use a professionally tampered with device. Given that there are a lot of iPhones out there even if your device doesn’t detect it your friend may ask what is up. Then law enforcement can use the AirTag serial number to track back to the account it is linked to.
- milofeynman 5y agoSeems like it could be humorous to walk around a crowded stadium with a loop forcing everyone's airtags to go off
- muttantt 5y agoI have an AirTag that I dropped by mistake inside a taxi in another country over 6 months ago. It is still active, and still reporting up to the minute location to this day... Apple is really minimizing the real issue.
- sfifs 5y agoFirst apple creates a cheap spying tool that makes it simple to break the law and then "condems" its illegal usage. How is this any different from groups that sell hacking tools? If they were really concerned about privacy, they'd make set a higher bar to track things across their network - eg. Require Filing an official police complaint of the loss and submit the paperwork to get access to the tracking - win/win. You could still allow local Bluetooth tracking within range of the phone like Tile as that can conceivably be used only for personal items. Instead, they're pushing the responsibility of safeguarding from their spying tools back to people I'm sure they're going to be very soon be hit by a lawsuit from someone rich who doesn't really care about how much it costs to take them on. Their legal seems to have been asleep at the wheels.
- rootusrootus 5y ago> How is this any different from groups that sell hacking tools? You can use a hammer to break into a house. Still legal to buy and sell hammers.
- sprite 5y agoI recently had a car stolen and was able to recover it and police made an arrest because I had a Tile hidden in it. This wouldn’t be possible with AirTag notifications. On an unrelated note if you have any FCA vehicle thieves have a programmer that plugs into OBD2 that will delete yours keys from the car and pair theirs in under 2 minutes so they can crank the car and drive off. It’s not even the relay amplifier attack that affects a lot of other cars.
- randyrand 5y ago"Every AirTag has a unique serial number, and paired AirTags are associated with an Apple ID. Apple can provide the paired account details in response to a subpoena or valid request from law enforcement." For a company that 'values privacy', how do they think it's acceptable to only advertise this information now?
- supernova87a 5y agoEvery iPhone has a unique IMEI that can be provided to law enforcement based on a valid request. And everyone carries one in their pocket! They've never advertised this information. Are you also up in arms about that?
- askbjoernhansen 5y agoIf only there was a way to figure out what the website address is, maybe they indeed would have "advertised this information" ... https://www.apple.com/privacy/government-information-requests/ https://www.apple.com/privacy/government-information-request...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- randyrand 5y agoThis is not the kind of detail that should be buried in small font. Apple has a privacy report card for every app on their store, a whole “data linked to you” section. If that is necessary for apps, why is that not necessary for a product that literally can track you? It should not be buried.
- Wowfunhappy 5y ago> Every AirTag has a unique serial number, and paired AirTags are associated with an Apple ID. Apple can provide the paired account details in response to a subpoena or valid request from law enforcement. We have successfully partnered with them on cases where information we provided has been used to trace an AirTag back to the perpetrator, who was then apprehended and charged. This makes me wonder, could Apple go further? What if Apple put up a web page where anyone could type in the serial number of any AirTag they found, and instantly see the name and phone number of its owner? Apple could even print the website URL on the back of every future AirTag (albeit presumably in tiny print). I bet that would make stalkers think twice! And, I don't think there's any technical reason Apple couldn't do it, right? What I'm not sure about is whether this would be an invasion of the owner's privacy. But, if you're using AirTags to only track your own belongings, when would this ever come up? The owner's privacy seems less important than that of an unwitting victim, since the owner can choose to not buy an AirTag.
- foolfoolz 5y agothis would violate privacy laws like gdpr
- x0x0 5y agoWhy and how? I'm quite familiar with gdpr, btw -- and I don't see how being able to look up a uuid or some other nonsequential identifier via a site to find the owner obviously violates it. There's a strong legitimate interest case for anyone in possession of a global tracking tag being able to find out the owner, I would think.
- Terry_Roll 5y agoYou dont know the circumstances for why an airtag is where it is, what if a parent sewed one into their kids clothes or bag or shoe, but got ripped out or something? Apple should know who possesses the airtags at the very least, and if an airtag is reported lost/stolen, that info could be conveyed back to the person who found it, but nothing more until Apple has then liased with the "owner" to find out what to do next. Obviously this can be automated to some degree.
- e-clinton 5y agoWhat’s missing is Family Support! My wife and I share keys. Where’s that use case?
- stefan_ 5y agoSo Apples response is the equivalent of a cookie popup? Throw a bunch of warnings in?
- only4here 5y agoThese Apple "updates" are just going to get crazier and crazier, aren't they?
- oxplot 5y agoThis is a great response - very happy to hear Apple's involvement with various groups to make things better. Some noteworthy bits: > we innovated with the first-ever proactive system to alert you of unwanted tracking If that's true, then Apple just raised the privacy bar and now Tile and other small players need to up their game to stay relevant. There is also lesson to learn here: whoever makes a tech/product popular is the one who gets the heat for all its shortcomings/problems. It doesn't matter how many existing small players were doing a horrible job for years. > As an iPhone user moves, Precision Finding fuses input from the camera, ARKit, accelerometer, and gyroscope to guide them to the AirTag This is something that's not appreciated. The UWB chip on the Airtag can only help iPhone know how far away it is from the tag. It's 3D modelling of the world through camera vision that helps triangulate and guide the user via live on-screen direction. Next time you think why we need tech X, just remember that you can't foresee what it'll enable in the future - (and before you comment "all AR stuff to find my keys faster?", re-read the previous sentence again).
- Kye 5y agoImagine: Bluetooth beacons for helping you find stuff in stores rather than for tracking your movements without permission.
- oxplot 5y agoCoins have flip sides :) But tech wise, I think UWB combined with AR is the tipping point for the application you mention. Bluetooth is unfortunately too coarse to be very useful in locating items. It's still useful in locating stores in a shopping mall though, and that we haven't seen yet.
- phire 5y ago> The UWB chip on the Airtag can only help iPhone know how far away it is from the tag. I thought the MMIO antenna array would have indicated a rough direction of the signal. But perhaps that isn't accurate enough to be useful? Since the distance is accurate to a few cm and the iphone is moving, it can use it's own calculated position from the computer vision data to apply multilateration to multiple UWB distance samples over time.
- camdenlock 5y agoSometimes I wonder if Apple has bitten off too much with this particular product. Not sure it’s worth it.
- NoImmatureAdHom 5y ago"We're working closely with the police on our pervasive, no-permission geo-tracking system" is a *terrible* fucking message to hear. It won't be long before they have tiny mics, too. And the little speakers they have, of course, can be disabled. We on HN should really band together to do something about this. There is already https://github.com/seemoo-lab/AirGuard https://github.com/seemoo-lab/AirGuard which is cool. What else could be done? I can think of some general directions: 1) Fill their network with noise somehow. If there are lots of tags, or tags pretending to be other tags, then information on which tag is where will be less valuable 2) Make something that forces existing tags to out themselves (should they have working speakers) 3) Jam their radio signals. Probably illegal in the U.S. under FCC rules, but perhaps there's a way to do it where you're not actually jamming, you're merely doing something else that causes them to not work. 4) Find some reliable way of identifying them via a wand, your phone, etc. 5) Apply political pressure to make this sort of thing illegal (especially for the authorities) 6) Make laws that say if you're using spectrum to build a mesh network, it has to be open to everyone
- wilde 5y agoAt what point do you go “you know, the low severity problem we’re solving (finding my keys) is probably not worth creating high severity problems like stalking and sexual assault?”
- Axsuul 5y agoIf there’s enough demand someone will eventually solve it
- schlowmo 5y agoI don't think that the timing of this has much to do with the following, but I find it an amusing coincidence: Just a month ago the German activist Lilith Wittmann used an airtag to corroborate the suspicion that a branch of the German government she (or anyone else who should) never heard about before called "Bundesservice Telekommunikation" (Federal service of telecommunication) is just a front for the Bundesamt für Verfassungsschutz (Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution, the federal domestic intelligence agency). Unfortunately I only found this [0] article in english quickly, a longer piece by herself in German can be found at [1]. [0] https://www.imore.com/german-woman-uses-airtag-find-government-arm-doesnt-exist https://www.imore.com/german-woman-uses-airtag-find-governme... [1] https://lilithwittmann.medium.com/bundesservice-telekommunikation-wie-ich-versehentlich-eine-tarnbeh%C3%B6rde-in-der-bundesverwaltung-a8823f308536 https://lilithwittmann.medium.com/bundesservice-telekommunik...
- iRomain 5y agoAnd yet still no update about sharing an airtag with my family...
- jtc331 5y agoNotably they hint at one of the problems but don’t discuss fixing it at all: it’s bizarre that AirTags can’t be shared with a family account. It’s irritating that if I grab my wife’s copy of the car key I get alerts about being tracked, and, conversely, it’s frustrating that she can’t locate my copy of the key when that’s the one that’s closest.
- johnwalkr 5y agoProbably deliberate since unconsented spouse tracking is probably the most common type of tracking. Maybe an icon and periodic notifications, similar to how the location service works could be a way to allow.
- adeelk93 5y agoThen it could be tied to the option on sharing location with a family member
- antihero 5y agoThat's pointless, my partner and I can see each others' phones anyway.
- jtc331 5y agoSibling comments have effectively pointed this out, but obviously it could be optimal per tag, and also given we already have Find My Friends access to each other it’s a completely meaningless objection. Point is it should be at minimum opt-in possible because without it it clearly misses the obvious connection to a selling point of Apple (family sharing).
- fortran77 5y agoThey could also make them not work if the speaker is removed.
- dainiusse 5y agoThe only real question is - can I explicitly disable airtag tracking on my iPhone
- josephcsible 5y agoAnd a follow-up if the answer is yes: can you still be notified that someone is using an AirTag to stalk you if you do so?
- atomicUpdate 5y agoYou can opt out of the Find My network: https://www.igeeksblog.com/how-find-my-network-work/ https://www.igeeksblog.com/how-find-my-network-work/
- cush 5y agoI’m curious why they don’t add a way to report and kill the AirTag’s signal if you’re being followed by one
- 0xdeadb00f 5y agoBecause then it becomes useless for it's intended use. Say someone put a tag inside their backpack, their backpack gets stolen. The person stealing it can then just open their App, see there's an airtag in the bag, report it and kill its signal.
- AtlasBarfed 5y agoAirTags last only one year and you can't replace the battery or recharge it? Is that right what I'm reading? I gave up on Tile for that reason about 3 years ago, although they may have added a replaceable / rechargable one. The Tiles were useful while they kept charge. Apple has a lot larger participant network as well than the tile network.
- azinman2 5y agoNot only can you replace the battery, part of the directions for dealing with an unknown AirTag that you found tracking you is to remove the battery.
- dawnerd 5y agoWhat is super annoying is getting the AirPods traveling with you notice when you’re around family that live in the same house or when you’re traveling on a plane or anywhere else crowded. It’s completely useless.
- kyledrake 5y agoI've heard of multiple people using airtags to prevent and successfully recover stolen vehicles and property after armed carjackings, and as dystopian as that feels, it seems to me far less invasive to society to narrowly target violent criminals than hiring more beat cops to randomly pull over (disproportionately innocent and disenfranchised) people over miniscule driving infractions to hunt for the actual criminals. I'm happy to see some actual numbers but it seems the devices have been used far more often to deter actual, serious crime than to cause it. Perhaps they should focus on improving the product for what it's actually good for and not nerf it's core functionality because of the extreme edge case of a few bad actors. Samsung has a similar product called SmartTag and it's also quite good from what I've seen, and on cursory glance seems to not be hyper focused on "fixing" this "problem".
- camillomiller 5y agoThat’s not how the media narrative works unfortunately. Source: I’m in media.
- hedora 5y agoYeah; I’d prefer it if the police could nerf it (by enabling notifications) to help out stalking victims, but thieves could not. Alternatively, if (with an actual warrant, and involvement of the airtag owner) the police could link location trajectories of any phones that travelled with the stolen airtag, that’d be nice. Not sure how to avoid abuse with that scheme.
- pcdoodle 5y agoI don't want this crowd source surveillance.
- ragazzina 5y agoTry not buying them.
- 0xdeadb00f 5y agoToo late for that. Look at how many people around you are using iPhones. They're all taking part in the FindMy network.
- ece 5y agoSome things should just be mandated to be cross-platform, and this seems like a good start. Phones scan for wifi and other BT devices, and this is just another BT device. There's an option for turning on a notification for open networks and authenticating to them, just give me a similar option for BT/UWB/whatever lost trackers.
- SaraPolson 5y ago[dead]