6 ms·
Unfortunately the cloudflared software, while the source is available on GitHub, and there are pull requests open and accepted for it, is not under an open sour
by pabs3 5y ago
Unfortunately the cloudflared software, while the source is available on GitHub, and there are pull requests open and accepted for it, is not under an open source license, and the license it is under does not allow modifications, so any modifications (including the aformentioned pull requests) are contrary to the license and thus copyright law and thus illegal. The issue I filed about this is still waiting for action since October 2021.
https://github.com/cloudflare/cloudflared/issues/464 https://github.com/cloudflare/cloudflared/issues/464
- password4321 5y agoThanks for pointing this out as it does appear even taking the source and applying a pull request ones self does break the license. Just to clarify: many pull requests have been accepted and would thus from my perspective be covered by the license as having become part of the software. Caveat: did not dig deeply enough to check if it's mostly Cloudflare employees developing publicly, etc. Edit: worth mentioning here on HN customer support as well that 'opensource@cloudflare.com' is misconfigured.
- pabs3 5y agoPS: I note cloudflared uses some form of telemetry, although I have not looked at what data is transmitted and didn't try to remove it after seeing the above license. PPS: I wish cloudflared were split up into client and server instead of one binary for both, it would be easier to audit and understand that way. PPPS: I noted while auditing that cloudflared embeds its dependencies instead of depending on them and uses some golang libraries that are obsoleted.
- blibble 5y agohearing this I'm not sure I want cloudflared inside my network at all it's already vast... and telemetry always seems to be the thin end of the wedge a minimal version, not maintained by the company, under a proper open source license with no bullshit and a vastly smaller attack service would seem like a easy win... (and even better if it supported more service providers than just cloudflare... killing their lock-in)
- heliodor 5y agoBreaking a contract is not illegal. Seems to be a common misconception.
- pabs3 5y agoIts copyright law that is being broken here that makes it illegal, not breaking the license/contract.
- hashimotonomora 5y agoIn civil law countries it is. Also you can be sued for it.
- wjnc 5y agoPlease explain? I've googled your sentiment and have found some links but not many answers. Breaking a contract is just as illegal (~ against the law) as breaking the law? This follows trivially from contract law being a part of law. More substantive: Both contracts and laws proscribe actions. One can find remedy for breaking either via the legal system. (Obviously the severity of punishment can differ several orders of magnitude.) Only if you limit 'illegal' to criminal law you might be right in some jurisdictions.
- gmfawcett 5y ago> This follows trivially from contract law being a part of law That does not follow trivially. Contracts themselves are not articles of contract law.
- wjnc 5y agoContracts themselves are not articles of contract law. - This is true, but the concept of inheritance holds. 'Illegal' ~ 'against the law'. What is doing something against the law? Doing something the law states you are not allowed to do. So in practice under continental law (Napoleonic / Germanic) a law states "do X" or "leave Y" and doing the opposite is illegal. Then, if the law states "you must (under good faith) fulfill your contract" and you do not fulfill your contract ... that's illegal. A legally binding contract has the force of law for the signing parties.
- TownLake 5y agoHello from the Cloudflare team - thanks for the nudge. We're in the process of migrating away from the proprietary license to an Apache license. We'll update the GitHub issue too; should be wrapped up in the next couple of weeks but likely sooner.
- pabs3 5y agoExcellent, thanks for the update. Apache isn't what I would have chosen but is reasonable enough.
- pabs3 5y agoCould you also provide an update on this issue about the Cloudflare open source contact address? https://github.com/cloudflare/.github/issues/13 https://github.com/cloudflare/.github/issues/13
- mistrial9 5y agoeveryone believes that statement because?
- L3viathan 5y agoNo, pull requests are not illegal, at least when done on Github, because by posting code on Github (that you are allowed to post) you grant Github and its users certain rights: https://docs.github.com/en/github/site-policy/github-terms-of-service#5-license-grant-to-other-users https://docs.github.com/en/github/site-policy/github-terms-o... > By setting your repositories to be viewed publicly, you agree to allow others to view and "fork" your repositories (this means that others may make their own copies of Content from your repositories in repositories they control).
- pabs3 5y agoThat license doesn't allow modifications, which is what pull requests are. The forking thing is only about making copies, not modifications.
- cromka 5y agoI suppose you can modify the code, but not use it (compile) as such?
- pabs3 5y agoNeither copyright law nor the license allow modification, so probably not.
- password4321 5y agoUh, so I just realized how we are discussing how developers submitting pull requests to this project with this license are basically demonstrating publicly performance art style that they've broken copyright law. Or we give the benefit of the doubt and assume they are not testing their changes at all.
- flotzam 5y agoNot a lawyer, but it seems like it could be implied-in-fact that you're allowing people to submit pull requests if you publish on GitHub. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Implied-in-fact_contract https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Implied-in-fact_contract
- gz5 5y agoyou may be interested on zSSH then. apache v2. https://github.com/openziti-incubator https://github.com/openziti-incubator enables ssh without exposing sshd ports to the networks. disclosure: founder of company who builds products on OpenZiti open source