3 ms·
I used to watch that get better in each release of Autodesk Inventor. A useful test is to model a bolt. Make a cylinder. Make a 2D cutting tool that has one th
by Animats 5y ago
I used to watch that get better in each release of Autodesk Inventor.
A useful test is to model a bolt. Make a cylinder. Make a 2D cutting tool that has one thread profile. Extrude the thread profile along a spiral. Subtract that from the cylinder. Now you have a threaded rod. Now make a 2D hexagon for the bolt head. Extrude. Union with cylinder. Now chamfer all edges of the bolt head. Also chamfer the end of the bolt.
Now take a close look at where the threads meet the bolt head, and where the threads meet the chamfer. If those are all correct, then you have a usable CSG CAD system for machined parts. Inventor started getting that right around 2012.
Admittedly, you don't usually model threads at that level of detail. Inventor has "cosmetic threads", which are just textures, which is what you use for ordinary bolts.
This is mostly an exercise for CAD operators. It's like whiteboarding for programmers. You sit the applicant down at a workstation, hand them a bolt and calipers, and say "model this". Sometimes you do need that kind of detail, because you're going to have a machine tool machine the thing.
- dekhn 5y agoFusion 360 handles this perfectly. In fact it has thread creation directly built in (both textured and modelled explicitly). I recently needed to make a nut for a specific thread, and did it by subtracting the thread from a volume. If you're careful you can inspect the results and see how to offset the thread slightly to move from a too-tight fit to a simple press fit.
- Animats 5y agoFusion 360 is the same CSG engine as Inventor. It just has fewer features and is tied to "the cloud". Inventor has pro features such as "would you like a finite element analysis of the weak points in that", and "Warning - gear tooth counts are not relatively prime and may result in uneven wear".
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Tossrock 5y agoFusion360 has FEA in the Simulation workspace.