5 ms·
The iPhone is only valuable because of developers. If they all coordinated together, they could get apple to change. Imagine all the apps breaking one day…
by mensetmanusman 5y ago
The iPhone is only valuable because of developers. If they all coordinated together, they could get apple to change. Imagine all the apps breaking one day…
- lancesells 5y agoIt's a symbiotic relationship. They both serve each other. Things could always be better and Apple is not a good guy but I doubt any large app or organization is either.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- asperous 5y agoIf all apps go on strike, an app that crosses the picket line gets all the revenue in their market. This is related to the economic term "cartel", and why they are unstable in practice.
- Iolaum 5y agoin practice? Instead of posting anecdotal evidence of mine to the contrary, I ll ask the following. If cartels are unstable in practice, then why do states need competition authorities to punish price fixing, and similar practices? I 'd say cartel's are unstable in theory but not necessarily in practice.
- AtlasBarfed 5y agoYeah, I would argue that almost every market/segment in America is dominated by a cartel or monopoly. Even things like commodities have hidden cartels and monopolies. Oil may be a commodity, but the refining facilities are most certainly cartel-owned. Agriculture is seemingly not a cartel, but ADM and Cargill dominate certain aspects of the supply chain and processing. Instead I would argue that iterative game theory of free market economics would stabilize to a cartel or monopoly. Once one of the open competitors determines an advantage, and/or has substantial access to near-free capital (um, what's the interest rate of the last two decades?), then they can acquire their competitors. Then they can apply barriers to entry such as regulation and lockin contracts with equipment suppliers and the like. Look at the practices of Intel to lockout AMD. Look at how Microsoft exerted power on PC makers. Once you are big, you can influence the suppliers and distributors to lockout competitors. As long as size is an intimidator (and it almost always will be except to extreme examples of markets), it will be effective. The only time it helps is when it slows response until an upstart using an entirely different supply chain and technology (like Tesla) gains such a fundamental advantage they can't stamp it out.
- ronyfadel 5y agoThey'll need to go through Apple's approval process first. And if they mention breaking one day in any manner, could get rejected, or worse, booted off the store. Apple has developers by the neck.
- fyzix 5y agoMost of the useful apps has to connect to a server, let's say app devs stop serving requests for iOS, Apple would be pressured to come to the table because the iPhone is useless without apps.
- nomel 5y agoThis would take such a critical mass that it's silly to consider. Without some critical mass, the average consumer would see that the rest of their apps work fine, and probably just give the app a 1 star review "it keeps freezing".
- geodel 5y agoIndeed. If some random app does not work I, as a user, would call that app as crap and not Iphone.
- manquer 5y agoUnions are able to organize with similar power inbalance. Collective action is not impossible, just difficult. Nobody will a join a union just to strike ( a.k.a pull the apps) however making collective to better negotiate with someone with lot of control over your revenue (salary) is not inherently a dumb idea.
- nomel 5y agoI would naively claim that unions have power because they are physically localized, and represent similar people (income, standard of living, laws, etc), and create a very physically localized skill vacuum when they strike, that applies immediate and significant pressure. App Store developers are sprinkled all over the world, so not too much is consistent between them. Getting enough of these varied people to collectively pause their income, and allow their competitors to flourish, long enough for Apple to even notice/care, is probably much harder. I think it would be even harder to present the applications failure in a way that an average consumer would sympathize with or even understand.
- geodel 5y agoA large number of developers work for companies. They don't need to deal with Apple as their employers/clients take care of all that. On freelance side free apps do not see much issue and paid apps devs are not in position to organize worldwide to make Apple change policy in haste.
- jjtheblunt 5y agoI feel that's a knee-jerk assertion. Is no value assigned to the truly amazing custom silicon that sips power while efficiently supporting an instruction set that, in turn, supports developers external and internal? Is no value assigned to the work that goes into evolving with the wireless network standards? Those are internal people, generally with decade+ hardcore engineering backgrounds.
- adventured 5y agoAnd it's well worth noting that the iPhone came first, not the wave of developers. Apple provided the platform and potential, they put in enormous resources and effort to make the iPhone work out, to deploy a phone in a new manner (bending the telecom providers to their will). What existed for developers before the iPhone (the languishing Windows desktop, much amazing)? If the developers are the primary, why'd they have to wait for Apple to make everything possible? It's because the developers are secondary. Apple is the primary, the key to it all.
- selectodude 5y agoI’m not sure how people don’t understand this. If certain apps stopped working on my iPhone, I wouldn’t get an android. I would just stop using that app.
- random314 5y agoThe argument is - what happens when all non apple apps stopped working on the iPhone
- kcplate 5y agoA straight up mental fantasy exercise with zero possibility of ever becoming reality so ultimately what good is going through the exercise? One, you would never get the complete boycott that it would require to have an impact—-very few app publishers relying on app profits would risk a profitable app just to prove the point, especially if the publisher is a publicly traded company. You would have to rely on activist super small (single dev or two) app studios for your strikers and, no offense to those smaller studios, those apps generally are not the ones that people will miss beyond a mild irritation. Two, for every app participating in the boycott, there would be a similar app that didn’t participate that could backfill. The non-participating apps would be well known within a day or two and would start displacing striking apps pretty much immediately.
- qzw 5y agoThat level of coordination among human beings has only been possible a handful of times in all of recorded history. And most cases involved wars or absolute autocrats, or both. Good luck forming any kind of an agreement between hundreds of thousands of independent companies and individuals across multiple countries. I can’t even get my wife to agree on what to order for lunch.
- bduerst 5y agoTragedy of the commons, in a triple sided market, prevents this. At the end of the day, these developers are still competing with each other, and rational actors will break from the coordination to profit off the users for themselves.
- nonameiguess 5y agoNot third party. You still have a pretty valuable device if you use nothing but apps provided by Apple.
- kelnos 5y agoValuable, yes. Clearly it was valuable enough back in 2007 before there was an App Store. But nowadays, would it be valuable enough? I doubt it.
- christophilus 5y agoWhat? I buy iPhones because they work, are simple, are supported for a long, long time, and aren't riddled with trackers, trojans, and whatever the heck Android generally has baked in. I have very few apps on my iPhone other than the ones that come pre-installed (by Apple, not by my cell provider). I'm sure I'm atypical, but I do wonder how much an app-developer rebellion would really affect folks. I can't imagine my wife or parents switching to Android even if all of the non-Apple apps were to disappear tomorrow.
- kelnos 5y ago> I can't imagine my wife or parents switching to Android even if all of the non-Apple apps were to disappear tomorrow. That seems surprising. Do your wife and parents not use Uber/Lyft/etc.? Do they not use any banking apps? Do they not use any social media apps? Yelp? Food delivery apps? Messaging apps aside from iMessage? Video streaming apps? And that's just from looking at one of my home screens! Do you really believe they'd be happy with a phone that suddenly couldn't do all that anymore? I very much doubt that.
- bhelkey 5y agoThe App Store supported over half a trillion dollars in billings and sales in 2019[1]. According to Satista, that is more than the global coffee market[2]. [1] https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2020/06/apples-app-store-ecosystem-facilitated-over-half-a-trillion-dollars-in-commerce-in-2019/ https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2020/06/apples-app-store-ecos... [2] https://www.statista.com/outlook/cmo/hot-drinks/coffee/worldwide#:~:text=Revenue%20in%20the%20Coffee%20segment,%2460.64%20are%20generated%20in%202022 https://www.statista.com/outlook/cmo/hot-drinks/coffee/world....
- Grustaf 5y agoThe original iPhone had quite a cult following, as did the iPod. People were flocking to them without any apps. It's because the iPhone was so cool that developers wanted to make apps for it. So it's pretty reductive to say that it's "only" valuable because of developers. Best regards, mac/iOS developer