5 ms·
Of course. We treat females like they are a marginalized minority. My son’s school has a “Girls Can Code” program. All collateral features women and girls. (Bo
by Spooky23 5y ago
Of course. We treat females like they are a marginalized minority.
My son’s school has a “Girls Can Code” program. All collateral features women and girls. (Boys are welcome though)
I worked at a place where a C-level executive hosted company endorsed dinners at her home for female managers to mentor them for executive roles.
If I setup a boys club for computers at school or hosted a men’s IT society at work, that wouldn’t end well.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Jtsummers 5y ago> If I setup a boys club for computers at school or hosted a men’s IT society at work, that wouldn’t end well. Maybe not, but nearly every <Subject> Users Group I've attended may as well have been a men's IT society for all the women I've seen attend, despite specific outreach efforts to get them there.
- jimbokun 5y agoAre you implying that women were banned or explicitly discouraged from attending those groups? EDIT: my bad, think I got you confused with a different comment.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mjevans 5y agoWhile I share your first hand observations here, I'll note that (from my limited perspective) there was nothing obviously catering to non-females or any particular gender in these groups. Many of the groups I've attended also had 'professional standards'. So what is the discrepancy? What has changed and what is being done differently between the groups where 'boys' can optionally attend and ones that 'girls' appear to self select against attendance? We should reach for a world that doesn't require discrimination.
- jms55 5y ago1. Women aren't going to want to join a group where they're the minority 2. Given a brand new group with 0 members yet, it's still likely that women will avoid it, because of their past experiences with 1. putting them off joining groups in general 3. Women are less common than men in general in CS. Any group that accepts the average person will statistically end up with more men than women. The groups that "advertise" to women avoid these problems, which is why they tend to work. I agree that we shouldn't need specialized groups, but I haven't seen any other solution, at least in the immediate term. Likely society will improve simply due to the passing of time, and in 50 years from now and it won't be a problem anymore.
- skinkestek 5y agoProbably. But why should small boys be punished and denied opportunities because of that? Also, this has been even broader: Around here, until recently girls got extra points even on studies were they were massively over-represented (in addition to being generally over-represented in higher education.) Just recently boys started to get extra points when applying for Engineering degrees in Chemistry or in Nursing.)
- Jtsummers 5y agoI don't know where "around here" is or even what "girls got extra points even on studies where they were massively over-represented" means. Are you talking about grades? "points" towards college admissions?
- skinkestek 5y agoAround here is Norway were I have spent most of my adult life (save a few weeks at work in other countries.) I'm not a native English speaker and while I get my points across I struggle with the school system. Sorry for that. Point is, around here when you apply for higher education you get a standardized score based on: - how good your grades were. - being over a certain age - having extra maths/physics/chemistry classes - being a girl (at least in STEM) - etc Recently, but only recently they have finally started to add extra points for boys applying for BSc nurse studies.
- e4e78a06 5y agoAt least in the US, most schools practice either explicitly or implicitly (through adjusted admissions criteria) affirmative action towards women for STEM subjects. That's the case even for subjects like Biology where the gender ratio is already balanced or tipped towards women. One obvious example of this is the fact that CMU admits 50% women into its CS program, even though their applicant pool and similar caliber schools have around a 20-30% ratio. So if you believe that women and men in the applicant pool are equally qualified, women have a 2x higher chance of getting in. That's just basic statistics.
- 5y ago
- micromacrofoot 5y agowomen have been marginalized for most of modern history, so it's not like it's a false assumption... I guess maybe you could make an argument for over-correction? but a lot of women would disagree. >If I setup a boys club for computers at school or hosted a men’s IT society at work, that wouldn’t end well. That's because most computer clubs and IT societies are already primarily men. It's kind of the default, which is why women-only groups are seen as transformative. If you want to look at it in a different way, you probably wouldn't have a problem setting up a group that teaches miners IT
- idealmedtech 5y agoI believe it's reactionary attitudes like these (why can't we have a special club?) that make tech so hostile to women in the first place. If they feel better in a space that specifically caters to women, and if by them feeling better, they actually learn the skills, why should they not have those spaces? These are not mutually exclusive things!
- jimbokun 5y agoNow try proposing a space that caters to men and helps them learn and feel better.
- vharuck 5y agoNot to be flippant, but have you seen somebody try this and fail or be stopped? What would be the purpose of the group? Why would it need to cater to men? These aren't rhetorical questions. I'm genuinely asking.
- tsol 5y ago>If they feel better in a space that specifically caters to women, and if by them feeling better, they actually learn the skills This can't apply to men? I believe there were such clubs and they were considered sexist in the past. I don't see why it's so strange an idea that men might like a club where they can be catered to and taught in a way that works for them.
- skinkestek 5y ago> Not to be flippant, but have you seen somebody try this and fail or be stopped? What would be the purpose of the group? I've not tried that exact thing but I have tried twice carefully to bring attention to mens day at work. I stopped doing it and I probably won't do it again; it's just a simple way to get some mockery thrown at oneself even at the generally very civil place where I work.
- rightbyte 5y agoMaking a support club for men probably has the same problem as trying to start a UFO or vaccines scepticism book club - since it is taboo you will have a hard time attracting sane members.
- NylaTheWolf 5y agoThe "Girls Who Code" program was created because of the discrimination and bias women face in the tech industry (not to mention other workplaces and areas of life). Also, the existence of woman managers doesn't suddenly mean that sexism doesn't exist in the industry. I'd imagine that many woman managers have faced a lot of prejudice throughout their careers. And there's probably a large amount of women who want to get into technology, but are intimidated by the space and fear potential sexism. Also, the reason that running a "boys club for computers" or a "men's IT society" wouldn't end well is because men already make up a large portion of the tech space and, like I said, there's a lot of gender bias in the tech world. This comment comes off as you using anecdotal evidence to disprove the marginalization women face.
- beiller 5y agoYour comment does totally make sense. But I also wonder, would a "Men's Teachers Club" for example have the same level of acceptance?
- anotherman554 5y agoI don't know if a men's teaching club would be accepted, but I can tell you I've been told by a female school teacher looking for work that it's much easier to get hired as a male because high school administrators are desperate for more male role models to help struggling male students given the lack of male staff in high schools.
- beiller 5y agoIt's easier to get hired as a male teacher because university and teaching school grads demographically skew female. There is less supply of male teachers ultimately which causes the high demand for male teachers is what I've heard.
- tstrimple 5y agoMen's teacher support groups exist. Men's nursing support groups exist. Men's breast cancer support groups exist. Men's support groups in general exist. If you find a place in society where men are underrepresented, there is probably a support group for men in that space.
- bell-cot 5y agoSpecial "Help $Gender enter $Field_Where_Gender_Is_Rare" stuff makes sense, if (for whatever reason) it seems that having some fields highly gender-skewed is undesirable. And whatever the PC / ideological reaction, programs aimed the other way sound like a waste of resources. Or maybe there are a bunch of "convince women that nursing is a career for them, too", "day care workers shouldn't all be men", "ladies can become receptionists", etc. programs that I'm not aware of.
- lph 5y ago> hosted a men’s IT society at work Maybe, just maybe, the point of those events for women has something to do with the fact that everything else in the tech world is a de-facto boys' club. My current team at work: 6 men. Previous team at a different company: 27 men, 3 women. The team before that: 5 men. The team before that: 10 men, 2 women. I guess we can debate "marginalized", but women are unquestionably a minority in tech. (I am also a man, fwiw)
- jimbokun 5y agoSo were those teams trying to exclude women? Or just no (or few) women that wanted to be part of those teams? Right now, tech companies are desperate to hire anyone qualified. Are you saying they are deliberately excluding women from consideration? From what I've seen, all the tech employers are desperate to hire and promote women, and there are just very few women interested.
- lph 5y agoNo, the teams weren't trying to exclude women. Not at all. They were representative of the company and the entire industry. There are very few women in tech. So then the question is why are very few women in tech? If you really dive into this, it's a chicken-and-egg problem: The fact that so few women are in tech makes the whole scene into sort of a frat house, which is often not a welcoming or kind environment to women, so women avoid it. A feedback loop. And one way you can try to combat that is by encouraging entry into the field. Et voilà: "Girls who code".
- jimbokun 5y ago> The fact that so few women are in tech makes the whole scene into sort of a frat house, which is often not a welcoming or kind environment to women I have had several jobs in tech. None of those work environments resembled a frat house. Maybe a few startups resemble a frat house, but is it really indicative of the industry as a whole?
- 5y ago
- tokamak-teapot 5y agoGirls and women are marginalised in the area of technology. This site in particular has hosted terabytes of discussion of this problem. If you look back at some of the stories about conferences and why codes of conduct have been set up, you will see at least part of the publicly visible part of this. This is why it’s perfectly socially acceptable to set up a specific group to give women and girls a chance to learn skills in an environment where they feel safe from sneering, lewd comments, and other such behaviour which is not conducive to learning, or simply having a good time. The article under discussion here is important, because boys and men face a great many difficulties in life, but the Venn diagram of difficulties faced by men and women has problems unique to each and problems shared by both. Complaining about people getting help in areas where they face a disproportionate struggle just seems unkind.
- mjevans 5y agoI believe what's rubbing many the wrong way is the obvious bias towards 'girls'. The name of the programs, the focus of resources based on being VAR rather than a need someone could be (E.G. how I similarly take mild offense at programs that happen to target 'RACE' rather than 'the POOR' (anyone impoverished, even if that happens to strongly correlate to various races in sadly common cases due to past discrimination)). So, hypothetically, what do you and others believe needs to change? How would a 'girls can code/tech/etc' look if it couldn't //market// towards girls or any other focus of discrimination? Other than perhaps types of being in the 'have nots' category which any body-type could qualify for?
- kkjjkgjjgg 5y agoWomen marginalized in technology was mostly bullshit abuse of statistics. It is just being assumed that fewer women has to be the result of discrimination. It is not.
- jimbokun 5y ago> This is why it’s perfectly socially acceptable to set up a specific group to give women and girls a chance to learn skills in an environment where they feel safe from sneering, lewd comments, and other such behaviour which is not conducive to learning, or simply having a good time. No. You just make it clear this is an environment where such behaviors are not tolerated. Also, it's not true that women and girls are incapable of sneering and lewd comments. You come across very much as the kind of person who believes boys are inherently deficient and deserve to fail, based on your assumptions about how boys will behave, and that they are incapable of behaving differently.
- jms55 5y agoMy CS lectures barely have any women. 1/10 students in a class of 200-300 are women. In more difficult/less mainstream classes (operating systems, networking, sometimes PL theory), it's 1/20. The game development club I'm in has 2 woman in it (including me) out of the ~20 people that regularly show up. This is in 2019-2022. My school also hosts a hackathon for women and underrepresented gender minorities every year (organized by a student org that rents out a building from the school for it). The hackathon is also open to high school students. Many people I've talked to there talk about how they only went into CS because someone they knew invited them to the hackathon, or have made friends and feel less alone in CS because of it. There's a real need for these groups. Whether men needs their own groups is a separate discussion that I have no real stance on.
- yes_really 5y ago> There's a real need for these groups. Whether men needs their own groups is a separate discussion that I have no real stance on. That doesn't imply there is a need for women-only groups. There can be a CS group for all genders and we just teach girls to stop being sexist and be part of that group (if they want to).
- NylaTheWolf 5y agoThis isn't "girls being sexist." Like other folks have explained[0][1][2][3][4], women often feel uncomfortable in spaces where they're the minority and might even have negative experiences in situations like that. And thus, they are put off by joining those groups in general. Groups that encourage women to join help women feel less intimidated by the idea of joining those groups. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30277540 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30277540 [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30278113 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30278113 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30276633 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30276633 [3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30299883 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30299883 [4] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30276633 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30276633