3 ms·
Sabine is overly critical IMO. The distinction she is making is known to anyone who has spent a little bit of time thinking about fusion (hopefully that include
by whimsicalism 5y ago
Sabine is overly critical IMO. The distinction she is making is known to anyone who has spent a little bit of time thinking about fusion (hopefully that includes the grant writers) and projects like ITER are explicitly aiming for Q=10, not just "breakeven"
- numbsafari 5y agoWhich Q? Qtotal or Qplasma?
- marcyb5st 5y agoQplasma. Supposedly, with Qplasma > 20 Qtotal should also be > 1 with current magnet tech.
- kalium-xyz 5y agoITER is a bit too optimistic IMHO. For example I've always found the "UNLIMITED ENERGY" on their website a bit funny https://www.iter.org/ https://www.iter.org/
- jfengel 5y agoThat's kind of her thing. She is usually right, but also overly pessimistic in a way opposite from the popular press over-optimism. I get frustrated because it paints science in an undeserved negative light. It is at least truthful, in a way that most anti science writing is not. Mostly I find it unhelpful in that it points out problems without either explaining why they were reasonable or giving a real alternative.
- GenerocUsername 5y agoPopular 'i f#@cking love science's type science deserves to be painted in a negative light. IFLS pushers are motivated by money, clicks, and clout and to a large extent misinform the public.
- jfengel 5y agoAgreed. But there is blowback on the actual scientists doing the real work. I suppose you could say that they also get benefits from appealing to the IFLS crowd, so live and die by the same sword. I believe IFLS does more harm than good, but it's hard to be sure.
- willis936 5y agoIndeed. Her arguments made in the aforementioned video are slanted. There are many lies by omission that paint an inaccurate worldview for laypeople. It's incredible that the term "Lawson criterion" wasn't mentioned once.
- whimsicalism 5y agoSabine is not as "right" as many of her pop-sci fans seem to want. Most of her opinions about the direction of theoretical physics are not really falsifiable or "right."
- jfengel 5y agoThat's correct. That's sort of the point. Fundamental research is in kind of a slump right now, and it's hard to judge where (or whether) it should continue. I don't think much of her "just do something different, don't ask me what" approach.