4 ms·
> That’s in part because urine is rich in nutrients that, instead of polluting water bodies, could go towards fertilizing crops or feed into industrial processe
by mschuster91 5y ago
> That’s in part because urine is rich in nutrients that, instead of polluting water bodies, could go towards fertilizing crops or feed into industrial processes.
Huh? We're already producing way too much fertilizer from farm animals, which leads to the situation that countries like the Netherlands [1] and Germany [2] experience a massive oversupply of dung that has to be shipped sometimes hundreds of kilometers because otherwise the fields near the dung sources get way too much nutrients or the dung runoff fucks up river ecosystems.
How about using what we actually have right now in abundance instead of building highly complex systems designed to capture tiny amounts of human urine?!
[1]: https://www.noord360.eu/2021/02/10/guelletourismus-warum-deutschland-hunderttausende-tonnen-guelle-aus-den-niederlanden-importiert/ https://www.noord360.eu/2021/02/10/guelletourismus-warum-deu...
[2]: https://sz-magazin.sueddeutsche.de/deutschland/drecksgeschaeft-82696 https://sz-magazin.sueddeutsche.de/deutschland/drecksgeschae...
- manueldp 5y agoNPR Planet Money Episode[1] has interesting details around Phosphorous mines in Morocco, [1] https://www.npr.org/transcripts/581149776 https://www.npr.org/transcripts/581149776
- hiptobecubic 5y agoWe could also stop producing so much dung...
- dumbfounder 5y agoYou jest, but I have thought about this. If we all take fiber pills and probiotics will that reduce waste, and also toilet paper consumption? Should we be introducing these things into the water supply like fluoride? (the answer is no, but would be an interesting exercise to see what impact it could have)
- tazjin 5y ago> Should we be introducing these things into the water supply like fluoride? Absolutely not. Not all types of diets need fiber for your digestive system to function properly.
- fortran77 5y agoMost people in the US -- 66% over eat. Eat less, poop less.
- Scoundreller 5y agoIt’s not just a US problem. Obesity is going up everywhere. Even in pets.
- p1mrx 5y agoLet's stop putting sugar in water; that should solve most of the problem.
- mschuster91 5y agoThe "sugar in water" is not a problem, rather a symptom: it is a very effective and cheap way to get calories into a human. Way too many people lack a combination of access to fresh groceries (they live in "food deserts" [1]), enough money to afford these groceries [2], enough time to cook healthy food [3], or skills to cook food [4] - and most often these issues collide in poor and otherwise disadvantaged people... which again are at the highest risk of malnutrition, obesity and associated other health problems. The thing to tackle is poverty because it sits at the root of all of these issues, not making sugary drinks more expensive - all this does is punish the poor people yet again for being poor! [1]: https://www.aecf.org/blog/exploring-americas-food-deserts https://www.aecf.org/blog/exploring-americas-food-deserts [2]: https://www.nationalgeographic.com/foodfeatures/hunger/ https://www.nationalgeographic.com/foodfeatures/hunger/ [3]: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-economy-multiple-jobs-idUSKBN2AH2PI https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-economy-multiple-jobs... [4]: https://www.huffpost.com/entry/cooking-survey_n_955600 https://www.huffpost.com/entry/cooking-survey_n_955600
- p1mrx 5y agoI don't think we should ban cheap sugar, just keep it in solid form. The human brain never evolved in an environment where thirst leads to calories. If you split soda into water and candy, then at least candy intake is visible and controllable.
- openknot 5y ago>If we all take fiber pills and probiotics will that reduce waste, and also toilet paper consumption? The problems I see are unintended consequences [0] of the policy. Perverse results could include additional environmental costs to producing and delivering fiber pills and probiotics (there would still be costs if added to the water). Unexpected drawbacks could include side effects from the fiber and probiotics delivered in this way (especially for people with unusual gut microbiomes, or defects in the production of fiber and probiotic supplements), and civil unrest from people who oppose the mandatory additions to the tap water (which may ultimately result in changes in the nation's political power). [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unintended_consequences https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unintended_consequences
- dpark 5y ago> If we all take fiber pills and probiotics will that reduce waste Fiber pills do not reduce waste. They increase it. That is the point of fiber. It increases stool. Fiber is also known as “bulk”. > Should we be introducing these things into the water supply like fluoride? This is like asking if we should put protein into the water supply. You can’t just dump a bunch of psyllium husk into the water supply. It won’t make it through the water supply and come out of the tap on customers’ homes. It will just gunk up the city pipes, pumps, etc. If it did somehow work it would make the water supply disgusting to drink and unusable for many domestic purposes.
- bryanlarsen 5y ago> has to be shipped sometimes hundreds of kilometers That's not very far, we used to ship guano halfway around the world. We don't produce near enough manure to fertilize all of our fields. Certainly we should use the manure we do produce, but it certainly isn't close to enough.
- hetspookjee 5y agoThe complete insane thing from the Netherlands is is that almost 25% of the drilled up gas beneath Groningen, and is causing earthquakes on a regular basis, is actually used to create fertiliser from. As far as I understand that is done because the yield from synthetic fertiliser is higher than from animal dung so unless I’m missing something we’re actually trying to get rid of a lot of the dung by exporting it as well. Though I’m not entirely sure what happens with all the excess dung. I believe most of the organic dung is not yielding enough to be economically feasible and thus gets exported.
- contravariant 5y agoIt's probably worth pointing out that the component that's overabundant in the Netherlands (nitrogen) is only part of what can be recovered from urine. In particular there's a chronic lack of phosphorus.
- the-dude 5y agoIt is not overabundant, just abundant. We do have an overabundance of Natura 2000 lots.
- pvaldes 5y agoIf what you are proposing is to dump it in the natural areas, this is not a valid idea. Not all ecosystems admit an excess of nitrogen. Many rare species of wildflowers would be quickly replaced by nettles, elder and other common species and vanish.
- jcranberry 5y agoFinish reading the article. >According to Simha’s estimates, humans produce enough urine to replace about one-quarter of current nitrogen and phosphorus fertilizers worldwide; it also contains potassium and many micronutrients (see ‘What’s in urine’). On top of that, not flushing urine down the drain could save vast amounts of water and reduce some of the strain on ageing and overloaded sewer systems. >In a study[1] that modelled wastewater-management systems in three US states, she and her colleagues compared conventional wastewater systems with hypothetical ones that divert urine and use the recovered nutrients to replace synthetic fertilizers*. They projected that communities with urine diversion could lower their overall greenhouse-gas emissions by up to 47%, energy consumption by up to 41%, freshwater use by about half, and nutrient pollution from the wastewater by up to 64%, depending on the technologies used. [1] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=33319997 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&d...
- mschuster91 5y ago> to replace synthetic fertilizers That synthetic is the key. Replacing it makes sense - but why replace current wastewater systems at an enormous price tag with "tech magic" when we could simply use existing supplies of animal dung? > and reduce some of the strain on ageing and overloaded sewer systems. ETA: Actually, sewer systems are more strained by not enough wastewater flowing through them - they were designed to the load of many decades ago, prior to the invention of water-saving toilets, showers and other appliances. Now, there is not enough water let in, and the sewage doesn't get swept away - the result is smelly [1]. [1]: https://taz.de/Wasserverbrauch-in-Deutschland/!5032936/ https://taz.de/Wasserverbrauch-in-Deutschland/!5032936/
- scythe 5y agoI don't see how that addresses the GP's key point about the cost of replacing wastewater systems in literally every household. If I imagine, say, replacing all the walls in every house with modern insulated walls, windows with double-pane glass, roofs with solar panels, etc, a variety of environmental and economic objectives can be achieved. With regard to the very shiny "up to 47%" reduction in GHGE, this appears to be relative to the wastewater system, not the economy as a whole: >Urine diversion consistently provides improved environmental performance relative to the conventional system for each scenario for all impact categories, except AP, as shown in Figure 2 (see Table S17 for data plotted in this figure). Both diversion alternatives reduced the GWP, CED, freshwater use, and EP categories from anywhere between 24 and 63%. As a reality check, there are still tens of thousands of homes in the United States using lead pipes for drinking water. The current regulatory and economic climate has made it infeasible to replace infrastructure that literally poisons people. Any reform that proposes to alter the physical structure of the vast majority of existing residential buildings must necessarily be situated in the context of laws, costs and politics that define what is possible for those buildings, and compared in terms of realistic costs and impact to the scores of other proposals to do similar things. This is a painful and depressing reality that anyone who has studied American urban development for more than a few months comes to understand.
- leethargo 5y agoMy understanding was not that we have too much manure, but that it's too concentrated. If it were more evenly distributed, it would not cause the same problems with downstream water etc.
- polskibus 5y agoDo you have a source in English?
- mschuster91 5y agoI'm German, unfortunately not (and I highly doubt that there would be a market for English news about local German dung market issues anyway).