10 ms·
Safari: Point to specific bugs and missing support that frustrate you
- falcolas 5y agoThe lack of RES when browsing Reddit. But that's more about the developers' choice to discontinue support than Safari (which, as I recall, was about the lead time of getting extension approval, not the browser itself). Overall, as a user of Safari, I appreciate that it lags behind the bleeding edge. Stability, battery life, and privacy are important things to me.
- theshrike79 5y agoI still have Chrome installed on my work laptop. I only use it for the dev tools and never really browse outside of localhost. =)
- vehemenz 5y agoI use a handful of Tampermonkey scripts to get some of RES's functionality. It's not ideal, but it's good enough for me. YMMV
- falcolas 5y agoAny chance those Tampermonkey scripts are available to others?
- vehemenz 5y agoHere's a few: https://greasyfork.org/en/scripts/41065-reddit-auto-load-more-comments https://greasyfork.org/en/scripts/41065-reddit-auto-load-mor... https://greasyfork.org/en/scripts/40897-old-reddit-please https://greasyfork.org/en/scripts/40897-old-reddit-please https://greasyfork.org/en/scripts/433321-comment-expander-for-reddit https://greasyfork.org/en/scripts/433321-comment-expander-fo...
- simion314 5y ago>Overall, as a user of Safari, I appreciate that it lags behind the bleeding edge. Stability, battery life, and privacy are important things to me. Some features could help with that like https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/HTMLImageElement/loading https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/HTMLImageEl... , if Safari is always behind 1 year or two then you always lose battery and bandwidth, so yeah Safari devs are not chasing efficiency if they would then they would have been the first not the last to implement this. Also try to search for "broken/not working in Safari" and you will see is not all about some nightmarish privacy invading APIs.
- falcolas 5y agoBoth are fair points. And yet at the end of the day, it's Chrome that spins my fans up, not Safari. It's Chrome that's pushing FLOC and its replacement, not Safari.
- dmitriid 5y ago> they would then they would have been the first not the last to implement this. Look at it this way, too: It's quite possible that before you get to performance savings by implementing `loading`, you may have a list of things a mile long that are higher on the priority. So, you solve those first. > Also try to search for "broken/not working in Safari" and you will see mostly people who develop and test on nothing but Chrome.
- simion314 5y ago>mostly people who develop and test on nothing but Chrome. Most developers can't test on Safari , I use Ff for dev (my colleagues use Chrome) nobody owns a Mac to test on it and there are Safari only issues or cool features that work in Ff and Chrome but not in Safari.
- mesofile 5y agoFYI, it seems that RES is being EOL'd [0]. The linked announcement describes how the contributing developers have dwindled down to only two people. I am curious how this situation will evolve, or if it will, since I also dislike using Reddit without the enhancement suite. Edit: link to HN discussion from last week [1] [0] https://www.reddit.com/r/RESAnnouncements/comments/sh83gx/announcement_life_of_reddit_enhancement_suite/ https://www.reddit.com/r/RESAnnouncements/comments/sh83gx/an... [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30157233 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30157233
- falcolas 5y agoThis makes me unaccountably sad. And yet, it also feels inevitable, with all the changes to the UX. Bah.
- easton 5y agoUblock Origin is missing certain blocking APIs, but those were closed as wontfix I thought?
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoAs a user, I really don't care that Apple broke something intentionally, only that it doesn't work.
- draw_down 5y ago
- vehemenz 5y agoSafari needs a way to actively sync tabs between iCloud devices. I'm not sure how it syncs now, but it does not work correctly. On desktop Safari, I have tabs from my phone that I visited six months ago. The only solution to sync them correctly, as far as I know, is to log in/out of iCloud on each device. Edit: this works - rm ~/Library/Safari/CloudTabs*
- tomaskafka 5y agoThat's just a subset of general iCloud syncing problems - I have these kind of problems with iCloud Drive, Notes, Podcasts, Music ...
- btmoore 5y agoTab groups are super reliable. It's strange that device syncing broke right around the same time that tab groups came out.
- vehemenz 5y agoIndeed they are. Thanks for clarifying that. I use a group called "Phone" to work around the syncing problems I've had.
- jghn 5y agoI found tab groups to be the opposite of super reliable until I read the workaround was to disable device synching. Pro: Tab groups are now super reliable Con: I no longer have device synching
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- vehemenz 5y agoEdit 2: Now my tab groups are not syncing correctly. I have a tab open in one of my groups, and it keeps re-opening no matter how many times. Apple really needs to dogfood their own browser if they want to get serious about fixing these bugs.
- cuddlecake 5y agoIn another tweet[0], Jen Simmons asks the question: > Do we really want to live in a 95% Chromium browser world? That would be a horrible future for the web. We need more voices, not fewer. It's difficult to become a voice for Safari, if Safari is hiding behind a hefty price tag. Debugging Safari issues on Linux or Windows machines make it easy to grow a disliking for the browser. There are ways to do it effectively, of course, but no simple or pleasant ones. [0]: https://twitter.com/jensimmons/status/1490747578526404608 https://twitter.com/jensimmons/status/1490747578526404608
- tantalor 5y ago> there seems to be an angry pocket of men Nice, very respectful and fair minded. Definitely going to encourage an honest discussion now.
- CoastalCoder 5y agoIf we can agree to just ignore that part, I think there's still a good discussion to be had.
- Steltek 5y agoI dunno, she sounds pretty combative and started the thread acting aggrieved. It's not a great look for a "developer evangelist". There's a good discussion here but maybe it shouldn't involve her.
- 015a 5y agoI feel it's difficult to have good discussion if that's the stance their developer evangelist approaches this topic from. Not only is it tacitly offensive to men, but it marginalizes the women who develop for Safari and have experienced all the same frustrating issues the men have.
- HWR_14 5y agoI'll say your statement seems strictly worse than the one you are quoting. She had a valid point and a way of characterizing those making the other point that doesn't even seem insulting. You, on the other hand, want to devolve the conversation entirely into irrelevancy. It's not likely your post will change her tweet, but hopefully this post can salvage this part of the thread. To that end: Chrome seems to currently be in a more dominant position than IE ever was. Even Microsoft was unable to build a competing browser, and they threw real resources at it. The only thing that is holding the line is Safari (I use Firefox, but its a rounding error). I think it's vitally important we don't let Google keep leveraging their control until they own the entire internet. AMP seems to have imploded, which is good, but it won't matter if for 99% of the people it's opening Chrome or Chromium, going to Google and typing in where they want to go.
- rado 5y agov15 performance degradation – what happened?
- sebastien_b 5y ago- Lack of proper support for PWAs (this alone would likely take care of most complaints/scrutiny about AppStore monopoly). Especially since WebKit is forced onto any browser for iOS (there's no other choice for developers). - Lack of proper support for real extensions; the most recent versions have basically neutered extensions for Safari to the point of being useless - as I say: "if it doesn't run uBlock Origin, it's not a real browser"; this is mostly why I've moved to Firefox as my main browser now.
- dmitriid 5y ago> Lack of proper support for PWAs As always: what is "proper support" as there's literally no such thing as a PWA standard. There are dozens (if not more) standards that everyone picks and choses from to call their own selection "the one true PWA standard". And the "no proper support" usually boils down to "no push notifications".
- sebastien_b 5y agoBeing on par with what other popular browsers implement.
- dmitriid 5y ago> Being on par with what other popular browsers implement. 1. There are no "other popular browsers". There's the dominant Chrome. There's Safari. There's Mozilla which is rapidly declining into obscurity. Maybe there's MS Edge? 2. What's on par? Define this "on par" Example: Safari doesn't implement "Add to home screen". Neither does Firefox. Is this on par enough? Same for Background Sync API etc. So. What is this "proper PWA support" you're talking about?
- the_other 5y ago> Safari doesn't implement "Add to home screen". Apple invented "Add to home screen" (from what I recall).
- 5y ago
- carlycue 5y agoIt's alarming how insular the Safari team is at Apple. They legit think it's the best browser. To gather some data, I quickly skimmed through 20 MacBook unboxings by regular people on YouTube and the first thing they do is download Chrome. Every single one of them. Google would've taken over the iPhone and iPad as well because regular everyday people want and like Chrome but Apple's anticompetitive practices are not letting people access it.
- dmitriid 5y ago> It's alarming how insular the Safari team is at Apple. Do not confuse "not wanting to spend spending billions of money on advertisement and having dozens of talking heads" with "being insular" > They legit think it's the best browser. Quotation needed > To gather some data, I quickly skimmed through You skimmed through videos of people who've been subjected to continuous and relentless advertisement campaign across multiple properties that has been going on for over a decade. > because regular everyday people want and like Chrome They've been told they want and like Chrome. Continuously. As another data point: Google's Apps regularly "forget" my choice to use a browser and once a month or so propose I open external links in Chrome. Subject a "regular user" to such behaviour long enough, and they will "want Chrome".
- whywhywhywhy 5y ago>Quotation needed I mean, read the tweet it's passive aggressive.
- moonchild 5y ago> I quickly skimmed through 20 MacBook unboxings by regular people on YouTube I am curious which videos you watched. The first four hits for 'macbook unboxing' on youtube for me are[0][1][2][3]. Of these, only 0 installs chrome; 1 does not seem to use a web browser at all, and 2 and 3 both use safari. 0. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qI6OvkcFES8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qI6OvkcFES8 1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D8oFSlBHo14 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D8oFSlBHo14 2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=00Zghbf4fwE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=00Zghbf4fwE 3. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SYHDmPvtWHA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SYHDmPvtWHA
- devwastaken 5y agoThis reads like a manager who has ignored feedback for years and when criticized expects a formatted list of every problem they ignored. I don't see any point in doing this on Twitter other than this dev wanting confirmation bias their product is good. Overwhelmingly only apple users whom like apple are going to be following apple employees and participate in their discussions. This by its nature excludes a significant amount of criticism. It's a poor forum for actual content. Take something that works on Chrome. Does it work on Safari? If not, fix it. There you go. I googled and found plenty of contemporary css bugs, js oddities/lack of support and feature differences.
- HWR_14 5y ago> Take something that works on Chrome. Does it work on Safari? If not, fix it. Why is Safari responsible for slavishly copying what Google developers dream up and shove in production? Does Safari not having FLOC indicate they are missing a vital feature?
- Steltek 5y agoA bit of a strawman, there's a big different in user benefit between certain CSS/JS features and FLOC. The web as a whole would be better if Safarai/iOS supported PWAs.
- Androider 5y agoThat thread has hundreds of legit replies with bugs (that are impossible to read on desktop Twitter from what I can tell). I saw a few cases of "I published an article about our challenges supporting Safari, the team reached out and then ghosted us", like http://blog.apps.npr.org/2021/08/31/joy-generator.html http://blog.apps.npr.org/2021/08/31/joy-generator.html. Search for Safari on that page... oof. Dear Safari team, the first step in fixing any problem is to admit that you have one. Please internally acknowledge that Safari has _lots_ of issues like these and has a reputation problem among web developers. It's not just people hating on Safari and being ignorant, I would love to support Safari better, but it's just so frustrating in practice and when filing bugs they seem to go into a black hole. I think a big problem is that bugs seemingly get duplicated into some internal system where there might be some discussion going on, but none of that is visible to the rest of the world and it creates that black hole perception and lack of back and forth discussion with the people who are reporting these issues.
- kevingadd 5y agoThe Safari team has always been pleasant to work with and they clearly care about the web, but something about their resourcing or schedules just stops them from delivering the best browser. They were great partners for the webassembly spec process, but they also frequently were unable to give any commitments or even talk about their perspective. Then more recently at my current gig we were basically unable to get our application to work in Safari - after a lot of debugging, I figured out that their wasm compiler had a bug that was producing massively bloated stack frames. In the end, getting that fixed required us to leverage personal contacts on the Safari team. Once we got in touch with someone they came up with a fix pretty quick! Back when I was still doing frontend work I frequently found that Safari had crippling bugs, but if you were able to work around the bugs it had good performance and a good feature set. I simply couldn't justify buying a Mac or an iPad to support a small % of the overall web audience. Bring back Windows Safari please :-( (Apple's patent/trademark battles with Khronos have also been a problem for WebGPU, but that would be a troubled standard even without them)
- ksec 5y ago
- bussyfumes 5y agoIt seems like they're getting what they asked for, people are posting a bunch of bugs. My personal pain point was when I figured out that Safari supports only a subset of the Date format standard (RFC which is a part of an ISO or something like that, basically there are some dates that only Safari can't parse). Now it's up to them to live up to the purpose of the thread, if it means anything.
- floatingatoll 5y agoThat’s a bug worth reporting to them on Twitter! Which dates, incidentally?
- bussyfumes 5y agoI no longer have access to send you the exact dates, but it was along the lines of what you can see here: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/63464398/new-date-returned-invalid-in-safari-but-chrome https://stackoverflow.com/questions/63464398/new-date-return... I just tried it in my Safari and it seems to give you an "Invalid Date" which it doesn't in Chrome. Not sure if it's a bug, maybe a design choice. Anyway, in my case I received dates from a backend and was supposed to visualize a chart with them and some supplementary data, so I had to parse them and at some point we learned that the chart was broken for users in Safari because they'd get "Invalid Date" after parsing.
- dmitriid 5y agoDates are weird in JS/browsers so I wouldn't be at all surprised if some browser was strictly adhering to a standard, and the other browser... also strictly adhering to a standard, but a different one. Or both being lax. Or one of them being lax. Or... Browsers are a mess, frankly :)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- OOvsuOO 5y agoI haven't really looked at the comments, quick search of "you tube". Nothing of my issue. On you tube the "homepage" or algorithm page, none of the thumbnails are working. The only thumbnail image that shows up is the Avert on the first top left area. I am on a brand new Mac M1 from 2021. It's only a few months old. Other stuff in YouTube works but the images don't come up. Hover now won't work either. Is Youtube aging on Safari? LOL.
- floatingatoll 5y agoIn the Safari menu, there may be a Feedback option that lets you report the broken site issue to them directly, without having to use Twitter. I’m not sure if it’s a developer thing or not, but if it’s not there, I imagine it’s present in the latest tech preview build.
- OOvsuOO 5y agoI don't use twitter. I found this quickly on duckgogo https://www.apple.com/feedback/safari.html https://www.apple.com/feedback/safari.html Doing that form. I figured out that my Mac doesn't have the latest OS. I'm running on 11.3.1 I thought it was supposed to "update" itself. I don't see any new OS updates on the App Store or whatever it's called. I think it's BS the updates just take up more memory space on the computer AND make the computer run slower. Our computers immediately depreciate like cars. I was able to make my older Mac Laptop from 2012 last 9 years and I am running on version 10. Now it's dying again. A clean install might fix it. I also had some upgrades to the hardware and fixes. Making your car and computer run as long as possible saves a lot of money. Buying the newest stuff is wow expensive.
- floatingatoll 5y agoWell, I’m glad my question helped you uncover the root cause, in any case.
- js2 5y agoHere's a fun bug that started with iOS 15. I have my phone set to automatically switch between light/dark mode with sunrise/sunset. In light mode, the Safari URL bar is supposed to use black text on a light grey background: https://ibb.co/vQGy1r7 https://ibb.co/vQGy1r7 In dark mode, the Safari URL bar is supposed to use white text on a dark grey background: https://ibb.co/87x119J https://ibb.co/87x119J Except, when my phone switches automatically to dark mode, the text color switches but not the background. So I get white text on a light grey background which is illegible: https://ibb.co/dJHT467 https://ibb.co/dJHT467 The only fix I've found is to force-kill Safari. But then at sunrise, I get the opposite problem: black text on a dark grey background, and I have to force-kill Safari again. I've been force-killing Safari twice a day on my phone since iOS 15 came out. :-( Manually toggling light/dark mode does not exhibit the problem, nor does it fix the problem when it's in this state. I have some possibly non-default accessibility settings: reduce motion on, button shapes on, on/off labels on, increase contrast on. Also in Safari: single tab, landscape tab bar off, allow website tinting off.
- floatingatoll 5y agoHave you filed this bug or reported it to the requested Twitter thread? If anything else, a link to your HN comment posted to them would be enough — and then they’d realize there’s bugs here to find.
- js2 5y agoI have.
- jfb 5y agoAs a user, I happily browse in Safari. I use Chrome for interacting with Google, but nothing else. I haven't noticed anything that I want to do that is prevented by my use of Safari. As a developer, I never touch the web, so. It comes down to: different people -- and organizations! -- have different priorities and respond to different incentives. Why it is so difficult for some to see that their particular way of seeing the world is subjective, and that some people in good faith can disagree? Oh right, the Internet is why.
- coldcode 5y agoAs a former iOS dev (retired, now doing MacOS/Web only) I also spend most of my time in Safari. Sure it has issues, but iCloud Private Relay is very nice, and iCloud Keychain is very convenient across all my Apple devices. Chrome might have fewer issues, but feeding the Google Ad engine is not a feature I care for much. I use it when something refuses to work in Safari, like for some reason paying my water bill online.
- Steltek 5y ago> As a developer, I never touch the web, so. Except Web developers are the target audience here? As an end user, you're not supposed to be work around Apple's bugs or lack of support. Users don't care how hard it is, what gross hacks hold up the world, or that Apple has a 30% rake; they only care whether the thing works as expected.
- Willamin 5y agoI recently discovered that Safari on both iOS and MacOS lack the ability to use a custom search engine. You're stuck with the few options Apple has hard-coded into the app. A few Safari extensions exist that try to skirt this limitation by watching your browsing for a Google, DDG, etc search. These extensions grab the query from those search engines then redirect your tab to your preferred custom search engine. Of all of the missing common features to implement, I feel like custom search engine is incredibly simple: * User entered string for search URL with some marker for "the query". * User entered string for the label of the search engine. * Option to edit/delete already entered custom engines. * In the search engine selector, also allow users to choose any custom engines. Sure, there are specs out there for making this a cleaner customer experience. For instance, OpenSearch lets web sites tell browsers if the website is a search engine, and what query string pattern should be used with it. But at the bare minimum, Safari (on iOS and MacOS) should implement the simpler "just enter a query string pattern" feature.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- favourable 5y agoDoes anyone use Safari exclusively for all their browsing? I've heard great things about DuckDuckGo's browser, Firefox Focus, (Vanilla) Firefox, Brave, Opera, etc. I try to minimize the apps I have installed, but when it comes to browsers, I like to have a fair amount of them installed, not because I especially like certain browsers, just that it minimizes the attack surface, and compartments browsing sessions, which is essential these days. I still leave a footprint, but having your browsing insulated from other browsing sessions is a good practice. Anyone else do this? Multiple browsers === Privacy win?
- mulander 5y ago> just that it minimizes the attack surface I stopped using multiple browser for exactly that purpose. It actually increases your attack surface. While compartmentalization of browsers helps somewhat against tracking you now have to keep all of them updated. RCE bug in one of them already compromises everything you have on your machine, so having multiple browsers just means the attacker can pick from a wider array of targets.
- favourable 5y agoI meant the attack surface of browsing sessions. Yes I agree, having multiple browsers increases the attack surface of the device, which is why I try to minimize the amount of apps installed. But browsers are an exception.
- dmitriid 5y ago> Does anyone use Safari exclusively for all their browsing? I do. Or I did. Google Cloud Console is unbearably slow and often broken (charts ugh) in Safari and marginally less so in Chrome. So I do all my browsing except GCP console in Safari.
- rcarmo 5y agoYep. Some Firefox on occasion.
- speedgoose 5y agoThe HTML5 video player using MediaSource is a mess on Safari. It’s not enabled on iPhone and quite broken on iPad and Mac. Like sending the wrong events, not starting again on the same video element, or returning no data when you use the api to extract an image from the video.
- arepublicadoceu 5y agoJesus, I feel like she's just like any support assistant from official support forums that I ever interacted with: User: > Can we get support for using any search engine we want? This is my biggest annoyance with Safari. I use it everyday, but being locked into a fixed set of engines sucks. Response: > You can change your default search engine. > On macOS, go to Safari > Preferences > Search. > On iOS, it’s Settings > Safari > Search Engine. > There are lots of cool things you can adjust in these preferences. ( Source: https://twitter.com/nesl247/status/1491069572950401024?s=20&t=scEUSerA7dX8Vbx4mGxSCQ https://twitter.com/nesl247/status/1491069572950401024?s=20&... ) If she can't even listen to the user question I have no hopes for improvements anytime soon.
- phillipseamore 5y agoI see some here are asking for Safari on Windows and Linux. You can get most of the way by just running Webkit builds on those platforms. BUT! That would only solve a small fraction of issues. Most of the issues my team has to work around are only with Safari on iOS and ipadOS. Plenty of those issues are so OS/hardware specific that they need to be debugged with actual devices since they can't even be reproduced in Xcode simulator. Those issues are mostly related to audio, webrtc and touch.
- edave64 5y agoAre there actually any Webkit browsers on Windows without having to build it myself?
- phillipseamore 5y agoIt's a bit complicated, but: https://build.webkit.org/#/builders/67 https://build.webkit.org/#/builders/67 Click the first Build # (9399 right now) Near the end of the list of build steps you'll see "transfer-to-s3" Click on that (step 12 right now) and you'll find the URL for the build on s3 (Right now: https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/archives.webkit.org/win-x86_64-release/289502.zip https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/archives.webkit.org/win-x...) You also need to have an (IIRC old) Itunes installed for some dependencies. Run MiniBrowser.exe when you've extracted the archive you downloaded from S3. If they change the builds (e.g. 67 isn't Win anymore) you'd look for "Apple-Win-10-Release-Build" on the Builders list.
- edave64 5y agoThanks. That works, but worse that actual Safari. Especially icon fonts seem broken. But better than nothing :)
- TingPing 5y agoA few, not general purpose but dev builds basically: https://fujii.github.io/2019/07/05/webkit-on-windows/ https://fujii.github.io/2019/07/05/webkit-on-windows/
- Angius 5y agoSeems fairly simple. Here's a step-by-step tutorial to solving Safari's issues, if some Apple developer finds their way here. You're free to use it, I don't even want any consultation fees. 1. Go to https://caniuse.com https://caniuse.com 2. Work through the list of features 3. Make red squares go green