4 ms·
Tinc Is Not Catan
- nmeofthestate 5y agoTinc is not working
- sugaroverflow 5y agoYeah, sadly :( I tried to join a few times, but the game crashes when you join a lobby.
- aiisjustanif 5y agoSame
- Jiejeing 5y agoI clicked expecting some broken analogy between https://tinc-vpn.org/ https://tinc-vpn.org/ and the Catan board game, but instead it is a Catan implementation. Fair enough.
- tromp 5y agoYeah, strange to name it identical to the somewhat obscure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tinc_(protocol) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tinc_(protocol) when they had a free choice of any first letter. I'd have gone with zinc ( short for Zinc Is Not Catan), which is at least a word.
- neogodless 5y agoI would've liked Brick Really Isn't Catan, K?
- cooperadymas 5y agoReminds me of the time that guy named his online bookstore after a rainforest in South America. Or was it named after a river? Maybe a tribe of people? I can't remember. I'm all for a good naming conflict, but no one is mistaking a board game for a networking protocol. I feel everyone always finds something to complain about a name. Let's examine the *INC name space. A, E, I, U, X - don't really work Binc - why did you name it identically to a book foundation? C, K - you dirty old boy, you! Dinc - dual income no children, huh? Finc - how contemptible! Ginc - taken Hinc - not bad, although urban dictionary tells me it's Latin slang for lesbian, so some language major or 1600 year old European is going to might raise a red flag here Jinc - there's a website, it looks important Linc - this name space is so crowded already! Minc - just some USDA thing, not too bad Ninc - another book thing, eh? Oinc - lol, I kind of like it. Too bad Catan doesn't have bacon. P, R, S - all crowded Vinc - actually pretty well open here Winc - do you want to compete with the Internet's #1 way to wine? Maybe they should join forces? Nah, Catan is more of a beer game. Yinc - there's stuff here, but not too shabby Zinc - as you pointed out, it's a thing already, which is the same logic you used against tinc Point being, naming is hard, and nothing is unique, and it doesn't really help anyone to complain about names unless there's a really valid conflict, like, say, they came out with a new network protocol and named it tync or invented some new miracle element named zink and there's actual room for confusion.
- jrm4 5y agowinsoc. Winsoc Is Not Settlers of Catan. That way you throwback both to the old name of the game AND the old internet thing, but spelled different. Eh, maybe I'm salty because I use the everliving heck out of Tinc-the-vpn-thing. :)
- mxmilkiib 5y agoThere Is No Cabal
- rileyphone 5y agoI’m currently building a web version of a board game (Scoville, super fun) with a friend. We decided to use bordgame.io as it handles most of the multiplayer state transitions and has a pretty impressive selection of games done with it (https://github.com/philihp/fields-of-arle https://github.com/philihp/fields-of-arle, https://github.com/hwabis/forbidden-desert https://github.com/hwabis/forbidden-desert, https://github.com/mbrinkl/santorini https://github.com/mbrinkl/santorini). A lot of board games have some sort of web version as AFAIK copyright doesn’t extend to the rules and systems, just the names and art (we called ours “Capsaicin” to be cute). Maybe there’s a greater thought about the effectiveness of building and prototyping something that can be constructed from paper and mediated by humans, and only introducing computers once a design is more or less finalized.
- fsn4dN69ey 5y agoWhy not on boardgamearena? They already have a developer program where licenses are made available by developers and there's tens of thousands of users.
- captn3m0 5y agoBGA doesn’t have all the licenses and you have to get approval before you can work on a game (they might have changed this since), and the BGA framework is an ancient mix of no-framework PHP with ExtJS. Much easier to just submit to freeboardgames.io or host your own instance.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rubinlinux 5y ago"We Noticed You Were Using a Browser Other Than Chrome..." PLEASE don't do this. PLEASE.
- alekratz 5y agoWith firefox's market share of about 10%, the "we don't support firefox" message is basically announcing "our website is useless to 1 in 10 people". Very frustrating.
- smorgusofborg 5y ago10%? All the statistics I've seen recently put firefox bellow 5% and often well bellow like 3-4%. Given that is less common than colorblindness, colorblindness is not all that well handled on the web, and not handling a disability is an actual legal liability..
- leppr 5y agoBut then you wouldn't post your product in the "vision impaired community forums" for example. I'd be curious to see the actual stats, but HN surely has a high percentage of Firefox users compared with the general tech-naive population.
- smorgusofborg 5y agoThis isn't a "show HN" so most likely the author is not the poster. HN is also probably more color blind than average, so the poster should have checked multiple browsers and then the palettes before finding it interesting enough to post? I get the idea that it would be nice if the web were different, but I think that is a personal responsibility to choose for yourself or try to address yourself by submitting a PR that makes the repo better.
- fguerraz 5y agoYep. That's sad. But I understand that ironing out all the issues on all browsers is very resource demanding...
- apoland 5y agoCan't wait to give this a try when its working. One of my family's favorite board games.
- malermeister 5y agoPlease don't give me a popup saying my browser is bad when I'm using the only major free as in freedom Browser, Firefox.
- genpfault 5y agoTinc isn't Tinc[1] either. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tinc_(protocol) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tinc_(protocol)
- TheArcane 5y ago> For the best user experience, please use Chrome as your web browser. Oof
- stakkur 5y agoFolks, stop making Chrome a soft dependency for your software. I'm only one data point, but when I visit a site and see that, I immediately close it and move on.
- remram 5y agoThen you get to enter a username, click "join", and immediately get put back on the front page with the same message.
- jerojasro 5y agoLet's assume that this project merely clones the game mechanics and uses scans of its artwork, and all it does is providing a software version of the game, available at no cost. With those assumptions in mind, would it be OK from a legal/copyright POV to release such an adaptation to the general public?
- AndrewDucker 5y agoThat artwork is definitely copyright. Making that available will get you shut down very quickly
- ThalesX 5y agoNooo, I was having so much fun playing with player whack and at one point about 80% on the way through it just disconnected. Awful bug for me, but also congratulations on making a great not Catan! It really had me involved.