5 ms·
"Telegram is favoured by Jihadists" "Telegram is Russian Spying" "Telegram has extremely weak crypto" "Telegram is used by pedophiles" "Telegram is used by
by dijit 5y ago
"Telegram is favoured by Jihadists"
"Telegram is Russian Spying"
"Telegram has extremely weak crypto"
"Telegram is used by pedophiles"
"Telegram is used by far-right terrorists"
.... Use Signal!
sigh
The amount of times people bash on telegram is becoming painful.
But lets take a logical argument; NSA has made it's mission in backdooring basically everything.
We know from the Snowden revalations that their technical capability in 2008 (he only exposed info on things that were already old, his intent was to show illegal surveillance not capability remember) was such that they had some kind of access to every conceivable device on the planet and the majority of communication that went through the US.
I don't think their technical capability got significantly worse in that time. So, if Telegrams private crypto code is backdoored or weak: well, NSA have it. No doubt should remain in anyones mind about that.
Telegram is hosted on Google Cloud, which is under the juristiction of USA. Google cloud claims to not have access to client data, but I think it's not outside the realm of possibility that something could exist between the TLS terminators and the telegram communication relays.
Maybe I'm wrong here entirely, but two things cannot be true at the same time:
1) Telegram is weak, NSA has access
2) Telegram is strong, NSA does not have acces
If telegram was strong: NSA would do everything in it's power to push users to more controlled platforms.
If telegram was weak: Jan 6th and Jihadi terrorists wouldn't use it.
Addendum: all of these same complaints (save: weak crypto) can be used against Signal.
---
I don't think this is a good justification for not using telegram, you wont be labelled alt-right or a terrorist or a pedophile.
These same arguments come out time and time again about Tor too. It's pitiful, honestly.
- Krasnol 5y ago> Addendum: all of these same complaints (save: weak crypto) can be used against Signal. Better and E2E crypto is the main argument for Signal though. This is a significant difference between those two. You can't just ignore it if you build up such a case.
- thrown_22 5y ago
- fennecfoxen 5y ago> If telegram was weak: Jan 6th and Jihadi terrorists wouldn't use it. The Jan 6 dudes ("terrorists" and/or otherwise) put their ugly mugs all over Facebook, Twitter, Parler, and the public Internet. I wouldn't exactly take opsec advice from that lot.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 8note 5y agoSome Jan 6 folks did. Presumably not all of them did
- noxer 5y agoThe whole Jan 6 thing is a complete joke. Many people outside the USA can not even understand why this is still a thing people talk about, compare it to terrorism and even to the 9/11 attacks. Its completely insane. I remember 9/11 from outside USA. It "broke" the normal way people lived their life. Jan 6 on the other hand did nothing, no one cared. Only US propaganda media made a huge deal out of it. And they keep talking about the 768 (an more) people who have been charged as if they where charged for terrorism or something. Most of them simply got charged for entering a restricted building. Comparing this to a terrorist attack that took the life of 3000 people and injured at least 6000 other is grotesque and disgusting.
- selfhoster11 5y agoThat's because Jan 6 turned into a failed, and very incompetently executed attempt at a coup. 9/11 may have been devastating in many ways, but Jan 6 was an attack at the very structure of the American democracy. They tried to install a leader of the country who wasn't actually the one elected by the majority. If they succeeded, it would be a major blow to American credibility and founding story of a "democratic nation by the people, for the people".
- noxer 5y ago
- anothernewdude 5y ago> If telegram was weak: Jan 6th and Jihadi terrorists wouldn't use it. Pretty sure the intelligence people have a policy to maintain their ability to see their shit rather than blowing their load. In fact there's probably an evolutionary aspect to the jihadi thing.
- EGreg 5y agoTelegram and Signal are the best we have out of CENTRALIZED solutions. Both are founded by anarchists who like end-to-end encryption and user empowerment. One accuses the other of being less secure and easily backdoored by governments… but the actual problem is — they are both centralized. We don’t even need to resort to conspiracy theories — all Germany would have to do to ban Telegram is make Apple take it out of its app store. And it is coming close to that. Telegram’s Durov also openly said that they respect countries’ laws and censor certain people because to be kicked out of the app stores in that country is worse. What is the decentralized alternative? It takes a lot of work and immunity from the profit motive, to build a viable alternative. Moxie is famously skeptical of decentralization, but it is essential — not just for privacy, but more broadly — for user empowerment and control. If you want to know what the decentralized solutions look like, lease read my answer to Moxie https://community.intercoin.org/t/web3-moxie-signal-telegram-and-why-decentralization-matters/ https://community.intercoin.org/t/web3-moxie-signal-telegram...
- dane-pgp 5y agoA shorter (and less Web 3-focused) response to Marlinspike's claims in ‘The ecosystem is moving’ is this post by Daniel Gultsch, the maintainer of the "Conversations" XMPP client: https://gultsch.de/objection.html https://gultsch.de/objection.html
- ratsmack 5y ago>... founded by anarchists ... That's reaching deep... seriously?
- EGreg 5y agoIt’s based… no ?
- int_19h 5y agoMarlinspike is a self-described anarchist: https://theanarchistlibrary.org/category/author/moxie-marlinspike https://theanarchistlibrary.org/category/author/moxie-marlin... Durov seems to be more of a right libertarian type. Whether this qualifies as "anarchist" or not depends on who you ask.
- thematrixturtle 5y ago> Telegram is hosted on Google Cloud Source? Back when Russia was playing IP whack-a-mole, they were using at least AWS, Google and Azure. https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-43797176 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-43797176 Not that this really affects the thrust of your argument, since all 3 are US entities, but it seems unlikely that there's a single place you could tap for access to everything.
- dijit 5y agoOof, called out, have an upvote, you're entirely right. Frankly I wasn't aware they were on all three, I was just on google cloud and got affected by these whack-a-mole shenanigans, and assumed it was exclusive. This is entirely my bad for not checking my assumptions and I apologise.
- countvonbalzac 5y agoRead the article - "Whether this is a good thing for the world is another question, one muddied by how poorly understood Telegram is, especially in the US. The vast majority of journalists still refer to it as an “encrypted messaging app.” This description unnerves many security experts, who warn that, unlike Signal or WhatsApp, Telegram is not end-to-end encrypted by default; that users must go out of their way to turn on the app's “secret chats” function (which few people actually do); and that only individual conversations, not those among groups, can be end-to-end encrypted. For the millions of people who use Telegram under repressive regimes, experts say, that confusion could be costly." Even if you make the argument that telegram CAN be encrypted (only in 1-1 chats) what ultimately matters is how people actually use it, and that is probably in an unencrypted manner.
- bmarquez 5y ago> what ultimately matters is how people actually use it, and that is probably in an unencrypted manner I've heard criticisms about Telegram's MTProto encryption on HN, but in my usage of Telegram nobody has ever turned on the secret chats mode enabling it anyway. Anyone privacy-conscious asks me to use Signal, Matrix, or even Threema. I have heard compliments about Telegram sticker packs though, if the other apps want more users they could consider making "cute stickers" :)
- discardedrefuse 5y ago> I have heard compliments about Telegram sticker packs though, if the other apps want more users they could consider making "cute stickers" :) You joke, but Telegram's clients have been innovating for years. Way ahead of the rest. Its packed with features and yet never feels bloated or slow. Frankly, its amazing.
- bmarquez 5y agoNot even a joke, I had a younger friend comment on the sticker cuteness and it never even crossed my mind that people would prefer messaging apps based on that. The Telegram client/feature set is great, and I hope Signal and competitors will improve their clients to match.
- charlieyu1 5y agoTelegram boardcasting phone number lead to arrest of Hong Kong protestors in 2019. I know it is fixed now, but a couple of years and a lot of people jailed too late. Most people I know would rather use Signal now.
- nirui 5y agoLet's be fair, Jihadi terrorists probably don't know which platform is actually secure for their terrorist operation (none of them is, actually). They could've used WeChat if they were able to register an account for themselves. It's simply not a good metric. It's the same reason why you don't want to measure someones kindness by comparing it with Adolf Hitler. "Oh I have such good neighbor, he is the completely opposite of Adolf Hitler", it just don't compare very well.
- lmm 5y ago> We know from the Snowden revalations that their technical capability in 2008 (he only exposed info on things that were already old, his intent was to show illegal surveillance not capability remember) was such that they had some kind of access to every conceivable device on the planet and the majority of communication that went through the US. We know they had access to every centralised provider's servers (including Google and any other company you care to name). We also know that they couldn't break post-DES cryptosystems when properly used - indeed NSA employees expressed considerable frustration about the fact that they couldn't break PGP-encrypted emails or chats and had to resort to metadata analysis, social engineering, hacking individual users and so on. > 1) Telegram is weak, NSA has access > 2) Telegram is strong, NSA does not have acces It's not a binary. Most attacks on cryptosystems reduce the amount of work it takes to break in rather than making it completely free. And even if the NSA theoretically has access, that doesn't mean they can predict an attack or will share that data with every contry/agency/company. We know the NSA was reading all unencrypted emails up until at least 2012 or so, yet there was plenty of crime committed and discussed over email during that period. (I'm no fan of Signal or the way it's marketed, quite the opposite, but I trust Telegram far less)
- trasz 5y ago>NSA was reading all unencrypted emails up until at least 2012 or so, yet there was plenty of crime NSA is not a law enforcement agency; they don’t care about crime.
- selcuka 5y ago> If telegram was weak: Jan 6th and Jihadi terrorists wouldn't use it. You must have missed this piece [1]: > The app was in fact secretly built by the FBI, and designed to allow law enforcement to tune into conversations between about 9,000 users scattered around Earth. [1] https://www.theregister.com/2021/06/08/operation_ironside_anom/ https://www.theregister.com/2021/06/08/operation_ironside_an...
- wolverine876 5y agoThe article doesn't discuss Telegram at all. How is it related?
- tomjakubowski 5y agoit shows that criminal groups aren't always going to pick the most secure option for communication
- wolverine876 5y agoIn the case of the article, they got caught in a honeypot. That seems like a different risk than choosing poorly made software.
- Brian_K_White 5y agoIt disproves the assertion.
- wolverine876 5y ago> If telegram was strong: NSA would do everything in it's power to push users to more controlled platforms. What power does the NSA have to influence those choices? When has it happened? Do you have evidence of it?
- N19PEDL2 5y agoSpeaking hypothetically: the NSA could push the US Government to ask Apple and Google to remove Telegram from their app stores. Without mobile apps, Telegram would die very quickly.
- alfiedotwtf 5y ago> I don't think their technical capability got significantly worse in that time I think that was probably around the same time more and more of the web moved from HTTP to HTTPS. Even webmail was accessed over plaintext for a long time, so I guess a lot of signal got worse while legal access got not only better but "integrated".
- alexb_ 5y agoTelegram makes it insanely easy to have a non-encrypted message, so the NSA definitely wants terrorists to use that. It also has central mass data collection. Of course the NSA wants people to use Telegram.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gerash 5y agoThe app itself in terms of features and UX quality is superior to Whatsapp. What I don't get is how is this funded.
- silvercove 5y agoPavel Durov was Russian's Zuckerberg until Putin chased him out.