5 ms·
>The only problem is: he now provides literally no value. He’s excluded by fiat the possibility of ever being useful in any way. He could be losslessly replaced
by bryanrasmussen 5y ago
>The only problem is: he now provides literally no value. He’s excluded by fiat the possibility of ever being useful in any way. He could be losslessly replaced by a rock with the words “THERE ARE NO ROBBERS” on it
except for the value of having a security guard visible so that 99% of the robbers who might conceivably want to rob a Pillow Mart decide to go rob Quilting Heaven down the road instead.
- PaulHoule 5y agoInstead of a rock you just need an inflatable security guard. What's frightening about all this is that this article has gotten 15 upvotes despite 100% of the comments so far being about what a pointless article this is.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoyeah I don't know I think people might spot the difference. But maybe most of these robbers have a method that says if you see anything like a security guard don't figure out if it is one just go rob somewhere that definitely doesn't have it because there's always somewhere else to rob - but maybe one of the groups of robbers is better than everyone else and they have a real robber mastermind in charge who determines the security guard is inflatable. Then it's on. on edit: added in missing two words that clarified meaning.
- MattGaiser 5y agoPeople mostly seem to object to the security guard example as missing a part of the analysis.
- PaulHoule 5y agoI suspect a lot of them are stopping when they see that when is bogus and aren't bothering to poke holes in the rest of them. Readers have their own heuristics, but that doesn't mean the rest of the examples aren't full of holes.
- ravi-delia 5y agoIt's really not about several examples of the same thing, but interrogating our intuitions around each one. I at least found I felt differently about different heuristics being replaced by rocks.
- moffkalast 5y agoSeems like the article writer has fallen for the very issue they're trying to portray, by writing so many examples that they've stopped thinking and just resorted to writing "PERSON CAN BE REPLACED WITH ROCK". If this isn't ironic then I don't know what is.
- PaulHoule 5y ago"Rationalism" is so ironic you might say it is an iron or at least made of iron.
- isleyaardvark 5y agoAll of them are missing a big part of the analysis, that it is often not a choice of “a rock” but of a person with a heuristic that works way less than 99.9% of the time. A security guard that constantly harasses shoppers, a “futurist” that buys into every new fad, the conspiracy theorist that believes everything on Facebook. Would anyone really think a weatherman that had say a 70% correct heuristic was good? Or go to a doctor like that?
- PaulHoule 5y agoI was thinking of that scene in Modern Times where Charlie Chaplin’s ‘Tramp’ gets hired as a security guard.
- sjg007 5y agoOr security cameras.. or a drone..
- soheil 5y agoAre you saying 15 votes isn't a lot? Also 100% of 2 comments is still 100% of the comments.
- PaulHoule 5y agoIt's a lot of votes for something for which the best analysis is something like "move along folks, nothing to see here..."
- PoignardAzur 5y agoPeople who agree upvote and have nothing more to say, people who disagree come to post their objections.
- epolanski 5y agoAlso, people upvote what they finf interesting rather than what they agree with.
- joe_the_user 5y agoI didn't unvote it and I think each of the example is missing subtle aspects. But I think it's interesting enough to discuss. The main thing is that are a whole lot of human activities where one can imagine completely rote activity could replace thinking. But in all of these, a deeper look shows to subtle factors actually require a human being to be present. It's a bit like self-driving cars. 90% of driving is really easy to get working. 99% is moderately hard. 100% looks like it won't arrive for quite a while.
- jekro9jdj 5y ago
- borroka 5y agoThe author is very popular among the tech/rationalist crowds (they are not the same crowd, to be clear), the topic is of interest for the same crowd, but the examples get a C-. It is challenging to write interesting and accurate pieces twice a week, and this is neither. That would be another heuristic.
- nabla9 5y agoSimple metaphors and examples always have holes in them. They exist to illuminate the point author is making. They are not the argument.
- thehappypm 5y agoYeah this was a particularly weak one though. The doctor example was much stronger.
- soheil 5y agoIt's not 99% of the robbers, you're exaggerating. Maybe at best you fool 5% of them, after all if they were that dumb to be fooled so easily they would have been caught by now. But now you have diminishing returns. Just like you, they know a security guard isn't effective, ... and down the game theory rabbit hole we go.
- wahern 5y agoA coworker and I were once stuck in an office building for an hour or two. We were working as consultants at a client's building and ended up working rather late. Not particularly late by software programmer standards, but clearly exceptionally late by the culture of the client company. At some point in the evening all the exit doors, including the front door, became armed, and this was conspicuously noted as when we packed up for the night and tried to exit to the parking lot, we realized we couldn't open the door without an alert being sent to the police (not just the security company). There should have been a guard at his station (desk, CCTVs, etc) in the entryway, but we found none. We waited for awhile. Then we walked up, down, and through every corridor and restroom of that 4-5 story building, multiple times, looking for the guard. When that failed, we called the security company to ask them if it was okay to open the door. They swore there was a guard on duty and asked us to wait a little longer in case he was doing rounds. Despite knowing that couldn't possibly be the case, we obligingly passed more time waiting in the entryway. Then we walked up, down, and around the building again, but this time splitting up and shouting. Nothing. Nobody. We go back down and inform the security company that we weren't going to wait any longer and that we'd be triggering the silent alarm as we left. And guess who exits the elevator just as we were about to open the door.... Apparently he had been sound asleep in a cozy nook somewhere in the upper floors--presumably in a conference room or more likely a private office, the former being something we inspected in passing (glass walls), the latter we didn't feel comfortable opening and entering, and both being the last place you'd expect to find a security guard. IIRC, he wouldn't admit it outright, but just played coy. We weren't mad. A little tired and frustrated because as consultants we still had to get in early the next morning, but that was mostly offset by the sheer absurdity of the situation, and by the fact that he seemed quite elderly. Anyhow, you may assume too much if you assume the security guard actually maintains some kind of useful presence. I guess these days it's more common to have electronic way stations to log a guard doing rounds. I dunno if this building had such measures (this was circa 2001-2002), but as the sole guard he probably was expected to spend most of his time, if not all of his time, manning the security desk, providing ample opportunity to be doing something else, instead.
- wheybags 5y agoThat security guard was performing the important function of allowing the management to legally tick the "we have a security guard" box on the insurance form.
- tshaddox 5y agoThat's true, but the (poorly expressed) analogy is specifically referring to the security guard's decision whether to leave his office and investigate a noise. Of course, the mere existence of the security guard in an office (if known to potential burglars) does likely provide some deterrent, but I think the analogy is referring specifically to cases where a burglar would make an attempt regardless of the burglar's knowledge of the existence of a security guard.