7 ms·
I've never used a contact list for my "buddies." We just have each other added on Discord.
by charcircuit 5y ago
I've never used a contact list for my "buddies." We just have each other added on Discord.
- caslon 5y agoDiscord keeps your friend information on their servers. This is, like tptacek said, exactly what Signal is trying to prevent. If servers get seized by the Feds, they don't want to needlessly reveal who's contacting who for everyone. It's about storing as little personal information as they can.
- theamk 5y agoQuestion: do you use Signal? If yes, are you backing up/syncing your contact list? If yes, are you worried about Feds coming for your backup/sync provider?
- stjohnswarts 5y agoIsn't your contact list encrypted? I mean wouldn't they have to hack my password (good luck) to do that?
- crtasm 5y agoWhen you backup to/sync via Apple or Google? No.
- caslon 5y agoIf that happens, that's not a disastrous thing. That means one person reveals who they're talking to in general, not just on Signal. It doesn't mean that the millions of Signal users all lose that privacy. But no, I don't use Signal. I just think it's strange how some people can't seem to wrap their head around any of the rationale for this when it's the most transparent thing in the world. Do I like it? No, but it's ridiculous how some people pretend to be incapable of critical thinking in order to talk about how it's horrible. If something is actually horrible, being deliberately obtuse isn't needed.
- theamk 5y agoI don't think you are getting it -- I am not talking about single user. Whatsapp has 2 billion users, and they are pretty open that they upload entire user's phonebooks to Facebook-owned servers. We know Facebook is not worried much about privacy, so I am pretty sure that this data can be subpoenaed, sold and so on. If you care about privacy, you probably want to install something else, like Signal. But you know what happens if you cannot get all of your friends converted at once, so you keep Whatsapp around? It will keep sending your contact list changes to Facebook, just at it is designed to. Let me repeat this: you worry about metadata, so you want to chat to a friend via Signal. But the moment you add them, this is reported to all other apps including Facebook's Whatsapp. And there is no way to opt out of it. How can people not notice this? How can any company call themselves "privacy friendly" and do this stuff?
- caslon 5y agoNo one knows which app you're contacting them on. Send them a text message and suddenly your activity is cloaked. This isn't that hard.
- doc_gunthrop 5y agoNot only do they keep your friend information on their servers, they maintain a copy of every single message you've ever sent via Discord. Their service is the antithesis of private communications.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoCan you request deletion of these? I've never really thought about that before (I don't use discord that much anyway other than hoping on some channels occasionally to help beginners to rust and c++. I guess I'm not giving away too much there :)
- charcircuit 5y agoYes, you can.
- dylan604 5y agoAre you really going to request that deletion after every single sensitive conversation? That seems dumb. Also, are those deletions tracked? Like, do they say User A requested their conversation with User B and User C be deleted so that Mr Fed can still see that A B and C had that conversation? There's just so so many places to get tripped up by keeping data rather than just routing bits and never storing them.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoI was thinking more like "Hey discord, please delete all my old data from your databases, everything" not doing it after every "sensitive" conversation.
- charcircuit 5y ago>Are you really going to request that deletion after every single sensitive conversation? Just delete them manually then.
- vel0city 5y ago
- bogota 5y agoI can assure you that most people do use phone contact lists for their intended purpose. I’m not sure what your comment is trying to get at other than being argumentative for whatever reason.
- Talanes 5y agoDo you have data on that, or are you just asserting that your personal experience is more universal than their personal experience? I don't think they're totally off-base: I haven't used my phone contact list for personal contacts for most of the last decade. It's just a collection of work contacts that I don't trust enough to add anywhere I actually talk to people.
- jack_pp 5y agoI'm sorry but do you need data for common sense? Is WhatsApp one of the biggest messaging platforms where people don't talk to their close friends and family? You think discord or other mediums are more popular than iMessage and WhatsApp?
- Talanes 5y agoI mean, I guess I do? I'm legitimately unsure if I'm in some weird bubble where no one uses WhatsApp or you're in a bubble of unusually high usage. But it's been a small enough part of my life that I'm not even fully sure what the connection is. It uses your contact list as well?
- throwawayben 5y agoI assume you're in the US? As I understand it, it's less popular there. I'd say at least 95% of smart phone users in the UK use WhatsApp. I think that's probably true of the rest of Europe as well.
- Vinnl 5y agoSupposedly two billion users as of Feb 2020: https://web.archive.org/web/20200212142339/https://blog.whatsapp.com/10000666/Two-Billion-Users--Connecting-the-World-Privately https://web.archive.org/web/20200212142339/https://blog.what...
- mikepurvis 5y agoI haven't historically— multiple rounds of old flip phones and early Android devices with zero migration story made me wary of overly investing in anything on-device. However, the current wave of phone-number-tied messengers (WhatsApp, Signal) have definitely pushed me in that direction.
- tptacek 5y agoDiscord works by keeping a serverside database of which people are talking to which people, which is, to a serious adversary, the most valuable single piece of information the service can cough up. Discord is much, much more convenient than Signal, and that's good. The services have different goals.
- wolverine876 5y agoHow is Discord more convenient? I don't mean the question critically, but I wonder what a sophisticated user sees in Discord when Signal seems, to me, as convenient as texting and calling.
- scgtrp 5y agoOne big thing Signal is bad at for me is using from a computer. They have a desktop client, but it's just a weird thing that proxies through my phone in a sort of bizarre backwards self-hosting sort of way.
- wolverine876 5y agoExcellent point; agreed.
- haffenloher 5y agoIt does not proxy through your phone. After the initial setup, you can switch off your phone and the desktop client will work just fine.
- Yeroc 5y agoExcept (unless something has changed very recently) you can't backup/restore your chat history to a new desktop client... Security over general usability.
- pseudalopex 5y agoYou can back up. Not restore though. The database key is in the config file. How does it help security?