5 ms·
Teachers are paid quite poorly, expected to do a ton of work, beyond their purview, unsupported by their administration, and regulated like crazy. It's a labor
by ChrisMarshallNY 5y ago
Teachers are paid quite poorly, expected to do a ton of work, beyond their purview, unsupported by their administration, and regulated like crazy.
It's a labor of love. People become teachers because they love the idea of being in that profession.
Unfortunately, governments, corporations, parents, and even students, see this as carte blanche to pay them even worse, and yank all support from them.
IT is a crazy field. People make a lot of money here, and we are used to being given a fairly free rein. Most folks in IT like their jobs, don't question whether or not we made the right life choices, are valued by our employers and customers, and, on top of that, we make great money.
Night and day. It's fairly hard for people to understand what teachers face.
I know quite a few.
Despite all the crying about teaching jobs being open, it's actually really difficult for teachers to find work; especially work that doesn't involve a two-hours-each-way commute, to teach in neglected urban schools, while being paid far too little to live near their work.
It's a tough gig.
- credit_guy 5y ago> Teachers are paid quite poorly, expected to do a ton of work, beyond their purview, unsupported by their administration, and regulated like crazy. Everyone can claim the same. Very few people will claim they are paid too well, or they don't have to do thing that don't exactly fit their job description, or their administration/management does not provide them the support they deserve, etc. Oh, and regulation? Lots and lots of trades have to deal with unreasonable regulation, don't ask me how I know. Here's the thing. This is a free country. Nobody's putting a gun at anyone's head and asking them to be a teacher. The teacher job may suck from some points of view, but it probably is quite ok from other points of view (like vacation, maternity leave, maybe benefits, etc). One way or another millions of people decide to be teachers. In the end, I like to tell people: 98% of jobs suck 98% of the time. If you manage to make your job suck only 90% of the time, you're having 5 times more fun than the average worker out there. If your name is Feynman, then probably your job sucks 0% of the time. But your name is not Feynman.
- ergocoder 5y agoThe craziest part is that most teachers are doubled as law enforcement. If students bully or assault each other? just call the police. Why would we even call teachers to resolve this kind of conflict? Teachers should only teach... not discipline or punishing kids. We should have separate roles for this.
- quantified 5y agoThere is a bit of “parent in absentia” needed for the grownups who look after the students. And the kids can do crazy things. Calling the police is definitely not the right way to handle things in a lot of kid situations.
- ergocoder 5y ago> And the kids can do crazy things. Exactly why we should involve law enforcement. Kids especially teenagers can be dangerous. Teachers who have almost no training on how to handle violent situation should not be required to handle this. Not to mention, teachers also have absolutely no authority to do anything.
- quantified 5y agoDo you have kids who’ve needed steering? If Bobby cuts one of Suzy’s pigtails, you perp-walking him and printing him, throwing him juvie for 60 days? Of course there’s the possibility of criminal behavior, but most of it is better served long-term by other means. I am speaking from looking a a couple of generations of influence here, both sides of the perpetration fence. There are infractions that need police, but the majority are best handled without. The original comment on this thread conflated bullying and violence with all discipline of all kinds (did not nuance between them). Cops don’t care about bullying anyway, it’s not against the law.
- ergocoder 5y ago> Bobby cuts one of Suzy’s pigtails Yeah, if adult go around with scissor cutting people's hair? That is fucked up. > you perp-walking him and printing him, throwing him juvie for 60 days You came up with a strong punishment just to support your argument. The punishment could be a warning as well unless it is repeated offender. The punishment could be fining a parent. Instead of coming up with a better solution like this, we let teachers handle it. This is why bullying is not often resolved. This is why school has the strange zero tolerance policy. They don't even care about justice. They just want the problem to go away.