12 ms·
Tesla FSD beta crashes into object [video]
- acchow 5y agoThe right turn at 4:45, I have no idea how I as a human could be expected to know where to drive the car.
- Tempest1981 5y agoAgreed, and at 6:30, more train track confusion. And LIDAR wouldn't have helped on either of these.
- acchow 5y agoI've rewatched the right turn at 6:30 a few times and I'm still not really certain where a driver is supposed to go.
- tomcam 5y agoRelevant moment: https://youtu.be/sbSDsbDQjSU&t=208 https://youtu.be/sbSDsbDQjSU&t=208
- KingMachiavelli 5y agoAs someone who has never driven is San Jose or the bay area, it certainly seems much better than a novice driver in a extremely complicated road layout. The streets have not only tram/train lanes but tram specific signals, keep clear areas,etc. Not to mention a mixture of bike and park lanes. Never driven a Tesla personally but I'd be pretty confident FSD could handle the 50 mile commute to my friends place that is just interstate, highways, and a roundabout. My only real complaint in the video is how aggressive it seems but I think that's configurable. Perhaps they should limit the FSD speed/aggressiveness to the specific drivers own capability in the area.
- consumer451 5y agoTangential question: Which goal is more difficult technically, FSD or Mars Settlement? As in, which one just needs money and time versus true technical invention?
- tim333 5y agoMars is going to be tricky.
- paulus_magnus2 5y agoThe immediate goal of FSD is NOT to drive perfectly, the goal (MVP) is to drive safer than the average human. Most probably the type of accidents the FSD MVP will be having is different than a human would and vice versa. There are 60k testers [0] of FSD and only 1 accident since September. OK, not really average drivers but that's one accident for 15k years of (some) driving. Probably FSD is already safer than most drivers. Although FSD is not yet complete as it cannot handle some situations at all and hands over to the human. [0] https://seekingalpha.com/article/4482970-teslas-ace-in-the-hole-60000-fsd-beta-testers https://seekingalpha.com/article/4482970-teslas-ace-in-the-h...
- rvz 5y agoCrash starts from the 3:26 mark: [0]. Had they not intervened, the damage would have been much worse. Further in the video, it has repeatedly become confused in trying to drive through the pylons - again the driver intervenes. This is just one of the many reasons why FSD is not only putting drivers at risk, but it is really turning its customers into real-life crash dummies. A more accurate re-brand of this product should be something more like 'Fools Self Driving' than 'Full Self Driving', given the false advertising and lack of safety features for these drivers using the product. [0] https://youtu.be/sbSDsbDQjSU?t=206 https://youtu.be/sbSDsbDQjSU?t=206
- xeromal 5y agoThanks for the timestamp!
- pcurve 5y agoIt's interesting how those green pylons were completely invisible to the car's sensor. If you look at dashboard LCD 4:30, the car seems too slow to register them as objects or misses it completely. 4:42 it makes a right onto tram track. And again at 6:24 Jesus.
- bradfa 5y agoAs a human, I had a hard time seeing the green pylons when watching the video. Local to me pylons are always bright orange and easy to see. My brain is not looking for dark colored narrow barriers so it doesn’t surprise me that FSD doesn’t see them either. I imagine I’d have a hard time driving those roads in bad weather or at night and maybe even under the lighting during the video.
- colanderman 5y agoThe car doesn't even see an orange pylon, with bright reflective tape, at 7:24. Or for that matter, the lane markings -- after the driver pulls the car back into the lane, in continues to try driving through the parking spaces and shoulder. This car can't even see orange pylons and lane markings. That's not even passable for a student driver on a closed course.
- jmacd 5y agoI've owned 3 teslas. On each of them I have chosen not to pre-pay $10,000 CAD in order to get access to FSD when it is available. 2 of those cars I owned and sold before FSD was even available. I would not have had the ability to take that license with me to the new car I purchased. I'm surprised this practice hasn't been investigated by any state justice or commerce dept (I'm not sure which it should be in the US?) as many consumers were sold something that was never provided.
- yumraj 5y ago> I'm surprised this practice hasn't been investigated by any state justice or commerce dept ... I'm not sure there's a way to regulate consumer stupidity. People are conned into losing money everyday, not all of those cons are crimes.
- AlexandrB 5y agoAll customers are stupid relative to the manufacturer/retailer because they're not privy to internal company information regarding the product they're buying. That's why consumer protection laws exist.
- yumraj 5y agoI agree. However, consumers putting down $10,000 for a promised feature with no firm deadline and severe restrictions on the said feature's portability are in a league of their own when it comes to stupidity. Or, perhaps they are more akin to an Investor ..
- bink 5y agoMany types of fraud only exist because people are "stupid". They're still illegal.
- jmacd 5y agoConsumer stupidity is one of the key elements of many frauds.
- 5y ago
- saiya-jin 5y agofeels like the last 20% of this will take much more than 80% of the whole delivery time
- RupertHandjob 5y ago5% will take more time than the 95%. There is zero chance that they can make it work with their potato cameras. Tesla will not stop selling this scam thought, too many dumb people with too much money.
- sydthrowaway 5y agoA century from now, Musk’s ability to get to people to PAY to beta test with their lives will be studied in business schools across the world.
- avrionov 5y agoThey should start studying him right now.
- consumer451 5y ago> They should start studying him right now. Not only Musk. I would love to see a brain imaging study of humans as their net worth gains orders of magnitude. I have seen and felt the effects myself to a very limited extent. I have heard Elon and others say in regards to the internet: "We are not evolved to handle this much information, and this much choice." My intuition leads me to believe that the same could be said for having an absurdly large net worth. We just aren't evolved for it and one's behavior changes in weird ways. disclaimer: While I am pointing fingers, it is at our entire species, not "billionaires."
- tim333 5y agoIt'll be interesting looking back whether the Musk FSD stuff cost lives or saved them. I'm guessing saved but I we'll see.
- ChuckNorris89 5y agoIt's already documented: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dkix4UzEbjU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dkix4UzEbjU
- amelius 5y agoAn additional problem is that pedestrians, cyclists, etc. also pay for it.
- PinguTS 5y agoSad truth.
- colde 5y agoIt's really strange to me, that we allow this sort of beta testing on public roads. The car is doing multiple things in this video that is problematic with the driver being slow to react in order to see what it ends up doing. This should not be something that is allowed on public roads by end-users, but rather on closed tracks by specialists. If they want to test it out on public roads, run the analysis and look at whenever it diverges from the drivers decisionmaking instead.
- mindslight 5y agoThis isn't even beta testing, it's closer to development. The driving shown in the video is that of a drunk or texting driver. For at least half of those turns it couldn't even pick a line and stick to it, instead swerving haphazardly as it became more aware of where the lane was. Never mind the constant turns into bus only lanes. I'd love to see municipalities start writing tickets on all the well-documented violations in these videos, citing Tesla itself as the driver.
- Salgat 5y agoAs long as the accident rate isn't worse than human driving, I only see this as a good thing towards future safety.
- CheezeIt 5y agoEvery day you slow down FSD development with this kind of safetyism, a hundred people die in car accidents (in the USA).
- ChuckNorris89 5y agoSo, for the sake of progress, we should let FSD also kill people because people die at the wheel anyway?
- CheezeIt 5y agoYes, exactly!
- aeturnum 5y agoWatching FSD driving feels like watching one of my side projects mostly work - it's impressive that it works at all and it's exciting and it would be wildly unethical pass off to someone without the access and ability to tweak it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 34679 5y agoIf it can't see the pylons, I wonder if it would see a toddler?
- glonq 5y agopro tip: if there are FSD Teslas around, do not dress your toddler in a green jacket with horizontal white stripes.
- kehrin 5y agoI hope Tesla isn't testing that in production.
- steelframe 5y agoNo need when it can be tested on the public in Beta.
- amelius 5y ago> Full Self Driving Beta 10.10 version 2021.44.30.15 How often do these version number increment? Was he using a version that was tested for more than a couple of months? If not, how can that be justified?
- Volundr 5y agoIn addition to the fact that we shouldn't be testing this stuff on public roads, it's baffling to me that anyone wants to use this in it's current state. To me this seems so much more stressful than driving the car myself. Having to maintain constant vigilance of what's going on around me as with normal driving, but with the additional complexity of having to keep second guessing what that car is going to do about it as well seems so much worse to me than just driving the car.
- dawnerd 5y agoEveryone is blaming FSD but this driver is just as responsible. Earlier he let the car fly through a red light.
- olliej 5y agoEven if you buy the known nonsense of the human driver being expected to pay 100%attention at all times and be able to instantaneously take control why are you blaming the driver? It’s called full self driving: even rudimentary crash avoidance from 10+ years could avoid this
- Casteil 5y ago"Just as responsible"... for not being able to instantaneously react to the car abruptly steering itself into a bollard at the last second?
- dawnerd 5y agoIt wasn’t abrupt… they even say right after they didn’t think it would actually hit. They should have disengaged the moment it started to take the turn wrong. Not let it try to fix itself.
- leokennis 5y agoSo what does the “F” in FSD stand for? Also, what does the “S” mean?
- AlexandrB 5y agoThe car does a right turn on a red without stopping. I wouldn't call that "flying through a red". It's closer to the "rolling stop" behavior. I'm guessing he didn't see any cross traffic in that lane and just let it go.
- akmarinov 5y agoThese guys must now construct additional pylons
- olliej 5y agoAnd that’s why I play Terran
- mattlondon 5y agoKinda worrying that someone who was paying so much attention to what the car was doing that they were actually giving a running commentary still wasn't able to react quickly enough to prevent an accident. Lucky it was a plastic bollard and not someone's leg or baby carriage.
- bink 5y agoThe driver watches as his car runs a red light and then swerves into bollards, but still allows it to come within a couple of feet of pedestrians standing in the bollards later on. I can't believe people trust their cars not to kill people.
- ogjunkyard 5y agoThe removal of radar has got to be a hindrance to getting autonomous driving working well for Tesla. Cross-comparison between multiple forms of environment surveillance (Vision, Radar, LIDAR, etc.) has to be in place for autonomous driving to work reliably IMO. This much has been stated by multiple non-Tesla AI organizations and leaders. I think Tesla may be using the price of FSD as a way to dissuade people from buying it, while enabling it to be a funding mechanism for continued work on autonomous driving. As evident in this video, FSD is often acting like a nervous student driver by being unable to confidently make decisions on the path to take, running through red lights, driving unpredictably at slow speeds, and more. This is probably due to the fact that there is ONLY cameras being used to inform FSD, which can suffer from contrast issues. I've seen videos in the past where Tesla camera input is in black/white/grayscale for processing. It seems like if you converted the video to B&W, the pylon and the road are similar darkness/color, so I'm not surprised this had issues. Tesla Autopilot was suffering from issues with contrast all the way back in 2016 when Autopilot failed to detect a semi crossing a highway in Florida which lead to the death of the Tesla driver. This was due to the white trailer against a bright sky. Ultimately, as a consumer and former Tesla owner, I don't feel confident in Tesla's ability to get autonomous driving working well at a human-capable level, let alone the "10x safer" bar they've set for themselves.
- TooKool4This 5y agoThis video shows a lot of other ,,interesting" issues with the current FSD implementation. The collision with the pylon is in fact the least interesting thing. - 2.20: Taking a left turn with a trajectory into the opposite lane. The youtuber's camera clearly was adjusting exposure from underneath the overpass and I wonder if the car's cameras had the same issues. - 2.40: Right on red without stopping. I wonder if this is related to the stop sign rolling stop issues - 3.30: Collision with pylon. It seems like the perception system didn't pick up the pylon at all (or if it did, its not rendering on the screen) - 5.10: Some weird funky trajectory and then pulling into the sunken curb/sidewalk on the right turn - 6.28: Trying to drive down the railroad tracks I gave up after the above. Despite Tesla's (Elon) insistence that FSD will be safer than human drivers soon enough (1 year), there is very little evidence to support that. At the very least if we are going to allow beta testing on roads then Tesla should be forced to submit their FSD incident data to the CA DMV like the rest of car manufacturers that are testing AVs.
- colanderman 5y ago2:20 is wild -- the street it's turning onto is clearly marked as a two-way in Google Maps [1] (which I understand provides the underlying data to Teslas). Why would the car think, no, it's best I turn onto the left side of this road? I'm also in awe of how fickle its predicted path is, especially when turning. Why commit to a new path for a tenth of a second and then change its mind again? This suggests to me it's placing way too high weight on poor quality telemetry. Heck, at 5:14 it can't even decide which street it wants to go down. Maybe it's just a UI thing (always displays the most likely path) and the underlying model is actually keeping both options open. At 6:45 it tries some insane passing maneuver -- I can't get over that one. Passing on the right, in a bus-only lane, planning to squeeze through the rapidly-closing gap of the car in front of it and a parked car, where there is currently a bicyclist. And it looks like the bicyclist is the only thing keeping it from doing that insane maneuver -- each time the bicyclist is occluded by the car in front (object permanence, hello?), it attempts to pass. I've lost count of the number of things this car doesn't understand, that it should to be on a road: * object permanence * reading basic text in simple print * logical connections between the map and road geometry * patience and commitment * understanding physics and geometry of other moving and non-moving vehicles * seeing stationary bright orange objects immediately in front of it [1] https://goo.gl/maps/EQfUnPrN52d9TVKPA https://goo.gl/maps/EQfUnPrN52d9TVKPA
- dogma1138 5y agoHonestly I don’t understand why Mobileye isn’t getting more attention this is one of their more recent unedited videos https://youtu.be/50NPqEla0CQ https://youtu.be/50NPqEla0CQ filmed in NYC city traffic… Intel is pushing them through an IPO and I’m pretty sure I’m going to put down a substantial investment out of all the players they seem the be the only ones that actually taking a serious evolutionary approach to consumer AVs. Their upcoming product stack shows an impressive strategy they aren’t trying to sell L4/5 as something that is just around the corner. They are still perfecting Level 2/3+ as a consumer targeted product (~$1000 OEM price) and focusing on full autonomy only for robotaxis where an OEM price of $10,000-20,0000 for the hardware won’t be an issue.
- folmar 5y agoThe traffic here seems well organized and very low. Look at this demo from RoboTaxi: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TFEvkmvIjVo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TFEvkmvIjVo
- stubish 5y agoThat is awesome. I think they are going to have to be more aggressive in this type of traffic, with pedestrians learning they can just wander in front of the car (the car can't deliberately not make eye contact and slowly move forward like a human driver can). I also like the situation at 3:48 where the oncoming human driver waves the car to overtake on the footpath, before realizing the driverless car is not going to do that and he has to back up quite a distance. Not sure what would happen there if there were more cars behind the oncoming car. Swerving towards the dog and giving it a scare at 3:10 seems a very human thing to do though, but I suspect it was probably avoiding something off camera.
- erulabs 5y agoI am a Tesla owner, and yes, I regret the purchase of FSD. I did and still do consider it a bit of an investment in a future I'd like to see, and I'm quite happy I also _actually invested_ in Tesla when I bought my model 3, but over the last 4 years I've learned something that has changed my mind considerably: AI does not step forward progressively. Normally, engineers spend ages improving things, testing, improving again. With AI, it's far more of a "let's just re-train this black-box on a totally different set of data, wind up with a totally different black-box, and see if its better!" The difference in driving quality and intelligence between even minor version updates is dramatic. I very intentionally _do not_ update my Tesla until the release is ~6 months old. This... sucks. I am still very bullish on Tesla and EVs, and on technology in general - unlike many I am not full of hate that this didn't work out, nor do I particularly think FSD is _dramatically_ more dangerous behind the wheel than say my grand father was before we convinced him to stop driving, but I do think I have more or less zero patience for AI engineers these days. The failure by Google and others to deliver even a moderately usable voice assistant is all the proof I need that FSD is _years_ away.
- mort96 5y agoYeah, I think most people who haven't worked with machine learning may not realize this, and it's extremely important. It can be pretty easy to reach 90%, but impossible to reach 95%. People tend to assume some sort of progression, where you just "iron out" the remaining quirks, but that only applies to traditional engineering. You can gather 100x the training data and build a model with 100x the number of nodes and get a 10% average improvement with some cases getting worse and others getting better. I think the current state of FSD is extremely impressive. There are clearly some extremely talented engineers working on that system. But my guess would be that it simply can't be incrementally improved until it's road-safe, in much the same way that GPT-3 is insanely impressive but can't be incrementally improved until it can write a whole human-quality novel. I suspect a new wave of radical rethinking of machine learning might be necessary, and that might be decades away.