5 ms·
My government has just spent 2 years - a pretty significant percentage of a lifetime - working to keep me from travelling more than 5km from my home and made it
by roenxi 5y ago
My government has just spent 2 years - a pretty significant percentage of a lifetime - working to keep me from travelling more than 5km from my home and made it illegal for me to see my friends. And I'm not even going to have a sympathetic audience if I try to claim this is against my wishes or wellbeing.
Run me through, in simple terms, how much worse it could get? I suppose they aren't trying to kill me, which is a nice minimum standard? These people have no respect for my rights. They don't think my rights rate on the scale of their objectives. And they want to spy on my mail - possibly to figure out from my phone if I've gone 6km from my home? I would quite like strong encryption by default and a weak government, please.
- robbiep 5y agoWhilst you’re entitled to your opinion, it wasn’t 2 years, it was 6 months of not travelling to the regions in NSW: the rights that were protected were the rights to preservation of life as evidenced by the significantly lower excess mortality in Australia. You obviously value these things differently to me, and it’s hard to have this argument without conflating the other aspects of our federal government that I think we would absolutely agree with, but a once in several generations pandemic is a good reason to do something drastic
- radicalbyte 5y agoMy government has restricted travel in order to stop a pandemic virus spreading to the point where hospitals are overwhelmed and we start seeing 10% of the population dying instead of 0.5%. Thankfully they have also implemented a nationwide vaccination scheme and a vaccination pass which is accepted pretty much anywhere worldwide.
- roenxi 5y agoWith benefit of hindsight, turns out there was never a risk of 10% of the population dying. The disease isn't that deadly, even if the hospital system did give out (and the numbers I've been looking at seem to suggest that the risk of the hospital system giving out was oversold - it didn't look fun but it also didn't seem to buckle enough to justify the authoritarian response in my eyes). If I were being uncharitable towards people who basically put me under a form of house arrest - which I am - I might note that the government will only revoke my rights in a way justified by your poor grasp of the figures some of the time. Which is hardly comforting when people argue that strong governments will somehow protect me from a threat that only emanates from government. This "strong governments protect rights" argument is weak. Nobody has ever threatened my rights as profoundly as my strong government. Maybe "rights" is too strong a word, they're only applicable for about 90-95% of the time. "Privileges which only get stripped when they feel it is a good idea" is a mouthful though. The dust hasn't even settled enough to tell if the interventions worked. Anyway, they shouldn't be reading my mail. These people clearly don't represent the interests of a big chunk of the population. And me.
- alsetmusic 5y ago> even if the hospital system did give out (and the numbers I've been looking at seem to suggest that the risk of the hospital system giving out was oversold - it didn't look fun but it also didn't seem to buckle enough to justify the authoritarian response in my eyes). My elderly father fell in December and broke his hip. Luckily, he got a bed. A month later, when he fell again in January, there were no beds available. Luckily, he didn’t need one as the fall was more mild. But had he needed a bed, there were none at all. Nothing was oversold. If we just allowed a free-for-all, the system would buckle and break.
- heavyset_go 5y ago> With benefit of hindsight, turns out there was never a risk of 10% of the population dying. There's a 10-fold increase in deaths when those with COVID can't get the medical care they need.
- roenxi 5y agoCountries are reporting in-practice death rates as high at 0.6%, worst case, slight outlier [0]. So even if it were possible for somehow no-one to get medical care (which is difficult to see happening, it takes a while for a wave to burn through and most people don't catch it so there is a lot of potential to beef up the response short-term) and the death rate multiplied 10-fold (which is also open to challenge, depends on a lot of factors and assumptions about how effectively community care could be provided) it still wouldn't reach 10%. That 0.6% might even be a country where the hospital system fell apart, I don't know what healthcare looks like in Peru. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/COVID-19_pandemic_death_rates_by_country#Table_of_total_cases,_deaths,_and_death_rates_by_country https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/COVID-19_pandemic_death_rates_...
- radicalbyte 5y agoThe USA has 900k covid deaths from 74M cases. The real number of cases are likely to be double that, but it's still a very high rate - from the richest country in the world.
- bsaul 5y agoI’m surprised you’re happy about the pass. the only thing the pass does is insure the minority of people who didn’t want the vaccine are forced to be vaccinated. I suppose you didn’t have to be forced, so why do you care ?
- microtonal 5y agoso why do you care ? Because the people who didn't want to be vaccinated take up all the hospital and intensive care beds, leading to many postponed surgeries. E.g. in The Netherlands in October, unvaccinated people took 70% of the intensive care beds allocated to COVID patients, while only being ~16% of the 18+ population. [1] [1] https://www.rivm.nl/nieuws/ongevaccineerde-COVID-19-patiënten-in-het-ziekenhuis-bijna-20jaar-jonger-dan-gevaccineerde https://www.rivm.nl/nieuws/ongevaccineerde-COVID-19-patiënte...
- bsaul 5y agoWe had this statistic in france too, but it happens that ICU saturation occures every winter, for flu and such. it’s been on the headlines for almost a decade every year. Mostly due to population getting older, and hospitals poorer. I wonder if it isn’t the same everywhere.
- StanislavPetrov 5y agoHere in New York Andrew Cuomo spent the last decade closing hospitals and reducing hospital capacity at the behest of HMOs, for-profit hospitals, health insurance companies and associated banks and Wall Street investors. It is expensive to maintain hospitals and have enough spare hospital capacity in case of a crisis, and officials at the state and federal level chose profits over capacity. For the last 2 years, these same officials have telling us that we have no choice but to give up our freedoms, civil liberties and bodily autonomy because there aren't enough hospital beds. This was a manufactured crisis (even beyond the likely manufacturing of the virus in a CDC-funded Wuhan lab). 1975: U.S. population: 219 million Hospital beds: 1,465,828 Ratio: 1 bed per 149 people 2019: U.S. population: 334 million Hospital beds: 919,559 https://www.statista.com/statistics/185860/number-of-all-hospital-beds-in-the-us-since-2001/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/185860/number-of-all-hos...
- Bancakes 5y agoIt was never going to be 10%. The virus is too localized on the elderly, who isolate and vaccinate themselves well anyway.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- aprinsen 5y agoI'm probably making assumptions, so I'd like to clarify, which government prohibited travel to such a degree? In the my US Midwest jurisdiction, the truly restrictive lockdowns closed indoor business, and discouraged gathering, but to my knowledge it was never illegal to travel. And indoor gathering restrictions didn't last more than a few months in private spaces. Although, certain behaviors were strongly discouraged for quite a long time. I'm assuming based on your units you are not in the US, however.
- roenxi 5y agoAustralia. NSW to be specific since each state had its own response. But US law affects a lot of services I use. And I wish our government had taken a light-touch approach like yours. Dare I say I wish they'd adopted a philosophy of weak governance and respecting people's rights by letting them make their own choices.
- tut-urut-utut 5y ago
- roenxi 5y agoThat was pretty bizarre. Raging coronavirus pandemic, more cases than we could count, and we can't let Djokovic in because ... well, he didn't have COVID so I suppose we were worried he'd catch it here (ignore natural immunity because that must be misinformation!). Maybe they were worried it would impact his tennis career. It was outrageously petty; my theory is someone in immigration had a bet riding on Nadal, because that at least means they had a rational motive for their actions. It isn't a big deal in among all scary stuff going on but it was emblematic of the times. Bureaucratic. Pointless. Vindictive against scapegoats.
- CRConrad 5y ago> Bureaucratic. Pointless. Vindictive against scapegoats. Oh, so the law shouldn't be the same for everyone. Not making exceptions for celebrities is "bureaucratic, pointless, vindictive". That's one way of looking at it. Seems to be yours.
- ifdefdebug 5y agoSorry for you, but your country's democratic process is probably broken. In my country covid measures were always just the bare minimum to keep things running and lifted/alliveated as soon as possible.
- bsaul 5y agoYou’re the exception. Out of curiosity, what country is that ?
- dustimpact 5y agoIn switzerland there was no strict confinment, rather a strong recomendation to stay at home. The most that was imposed was closure of bars and non-essential shops, and restriction of private gatherings to 5 people. Work for home was mendatory unless you could not work from home. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/COVID-19_pandemic_in_Switzerland#Government_response https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/COVID-19_pandemic_in_Switzerla...